New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

Posts

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#26

Re: Historical perspective

TomD

"It is well to poke into antique furniture and see the standards of the day. Dovetails were an effective way to hold things together not a fashion statement, and they were often made accordingly. The ability to make flauntable dovetails can be a goal, but it is not an essential goal to making furniture that works and looks good. At the point you are at for making a serviceable joint I would be making stuff and not fretting my dovetail precision."

- The thing is correct is faster than bad. The shortest line between two points is straight, not wiggly with tear-out. I learned this while collating documents, and even earlier when tier flies for pocket money. Thread wraps that are not neat and don't hold anything to the hook, and probably make subsequent success less likely, are not "going fast". From documents I learned you could go slow, and you could go too fast. There is a sweat spot that is as fast a you can go, but it will be faster than most people, and faster than people who don't try.

- Fashions change, which is certainly something they understood historically.

- They may have been doing something right, like elaborate veneer work, proportioning, carving, or molding. So just picking the worst joint at the back of a drawer, and promoting it to the front of a Krenov, may have it's limitation. Most eras have something that needs to be right.

-People also have a capacity for great ugliness/craptasticness. The US is possibly the richest place ever, and yet very few people have a decent pair of shoes. They virtually don't even make the right cows, or tan the resulting skins. I remember skirting this mall in a very affluent suburb, on the way to Florida one time, and seeing these mastodons in sweats waddling from their cars to stores. One look and you could tell they were not getting the right food, or decent clothes. They were wearing clothes a mid-century person would have been ashamed to wear to the factory, or to climb a mountain in.

- Stuff survives for all kinds of reason. My daughter can trash anything, I can leave china lying all over the floor of my shop and never break any of it. Sometimes the stuff that lasts was just lucky. The stuff that may have been nicer may have seen more use and is now long since gone. The other piece may have spent all it's time in the attic, until someone proclaimed it a classic.