New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

Posts

Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#1

Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

Scott in Douglassville

Hi, all -

I'm redeveloping my interest in learning to dovetail. I have an old Atkins 10" backsaw that I had Tom Law file rip 14 PPI years ago, and it works fine, but leaves a fairly rough cut. I'm wondering if the roughness is attributable to technique, or PPI, or some combination. Past experience with sawing then paring wasn't great - I'd like a smooth saw cut to avoid chisel work. Would it be worthwhile/reasonable/possible to have that guy in Chicago (forget his name) file this thing to 19 PPI like the Gramercy?

FWIW, I have a Japanese dozukime, but like the ergonomics, and handle, better with the Western saw.

Thoughts?

Thanks,

Scott

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#2

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

John Pappas

I look forward to what others may say, but personally I don't thing going from 14PPI to 19PPI would be a game changer. I am happy with my 14PPI saw.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#3

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

Ron in Sterling, CT

Hi Scott,

Leaving a rough cut sounds like either to much set, or a burr on the side of the teeth leftover from the sharpening/filing. Have you tried passing a fine stone ever so lightly over the side of the teeth?

My 2 cents.

Ron

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#4

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

Patrick Gibbons

I'm not sure why roughness of the cut surface is a problem. If your pins and tails fit tightly then they will glue up well and no one will ever know the difference. Stoning the teeth lightly will help as someone pointed out. I've got a saw filed at 11 or 12 ppi and it leaves a very smooth surface. So your ppi are probably not a problem.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#5

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

TomD

Particularly with softer woods, pine-cherry, the rough surface will usually knit to itself well enough.

For technique it may not be a huge factor, but sure it can have an effect. The saw can dart around a bit, or blow out little fibers. In saw technique the keys are to get the saw gliding on the surface of the wood, under it's own weight, concentrate on being smooth with a regular tempo. Keep an eye on the top of the kerf, and try to keep the saw parallel in it. Before you address the board hold the saw out over the board with your eyes closed, then open them. If your saw is not at the correct angle, then you can adjust your feet so that the saw falls cleanly on the saw line. Practice a bunch of parallel lines, freehand on the end of a board. Just let the saw fall. A little practice may be all it takes. I believe in sawing freehand practice lines because people tend to get all cramped up, at first, when trying to keep the saw on the line.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#6

flawed assumption

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I use a 12 point saw. You will have a hell of a time fitting a glass smooth cut. The roughness enables some wiggle room to get things to slip together that are not perfect. Don't fret any lack of strength of the massive glue surface of dovetails. The only time a perfect fit is essential is edge gluing.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#7

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have a 10 inch 14 point saw. I tried it dovetailing this evening on white pine , poplar, and cherry, all 1/4 inch stuff and actually was surprised how smooth the surface was. Usually I do this kind of work kind of unconsciously and never bother to look at the surface.

Without actually trying the saw or watching you work, it is difficult to know just whether there is a problem or what might be the cause, but my gut reaction is that there is too much set, that the saw has too much freedom to wiggle in the cut and make an uneven surface. You might want to get together with someone and have them try your saw.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#8

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

CStanford

That saw is perfect for dovetailing. Don't worry about what you perceive as 'roughness.' Aim to split the line to the waste side with no need to sneak up to it with a chisel. At any rate, the sawn surfaces with that saw DO NOT need smoothing with a chisel.

The only thing you need is probably practice. You don't need a dozuki, you don't need a different western saw. What you have is, again, perfect.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#9

testing the set

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I just did a test to confirm the set, or lack of it, on a LN saw. I sawed a kerf about 2" deep in a 3/8" thick stick. then I stuck the end of the saw (just the saw plate no teeth) into this kerf. It was snug and I could not wiggle the saw plate. bottom line, there is little to no set in these teeth. One might argue what amount of set is best, but this test reveals the amount of set that a lot of people are using successfully as a result of buying the popular LN saw.

No set means the saw will track in the direction it is started, for better or worse. Most find this tracking beneficial in sawing dovetails. Set results in a wider kerf that enables the direction of the saw to be altered as the cut advances, for better or worse. Hence, Scott, you may find that your accuracy of tracking a scribe line is affected, for better or worse, by set.

But, I have no doubt that a skilled sawer could make just fine dovetails with an 8 point saw if the stock was thick enough. Once glue combines with the teeth marks the joint is going to lock up as well as a glass smooth cut, and some would argue better. The joint with some roughness will be easier to fit. So, don't fret the teeth marks if you are being successful tracking your scribe lines. You might consider "stoneing" away some set if the kerf is wandering as you try to track the scribe line.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#10

agree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If Tom knew it was going to be used as a dovetail saw it is no doubt perfect. Rumor had it that he did Lie Nielsen sharpening. Otherwise the set may be too great to make tracking easy, but that is a different issue.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

agree

Jack Guzman from Maine

When I decided to learn to cut my dovetails by hand the first guide I had was "the complete dovetail" .In it Ian Kirby teaches to draw a series of angled lines on a board edge and practice cutting them. It is a good exercise and really helps.What you cut with isn't very important,it is technique that matters.

I too have a dovetail saw that was filed by Tom Law. I find it cuts a little rough for the task.It doesn't affect the dovetails,just a little harder to saw with. I switch around sometimes when cutting dovetails. Sometimes I use a cheap japanese saw I keep by the bench . I also use a Lie-Nielsen saw or one made by Lee Valley.I've even cut them using a bandsaw,but I find that to take too much time setting up the angles.

My point us don't worry about your saw . Use one that is comfortable for you and practice your technique. Tage Frid cut dovetails with a large bow saw .---Jack

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#12

partially disagree

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I believe all parts of the saw are important, especially to a beginner. How it fits the hand will affect how difficult it is to control. Too much set will enable it to wander in the cut. Too coarse and the saw will be harder to start in a cut. Too fine a set and the increase in strokes can cause more wandering. In one class I taught a student could not get the hang of it. He tried a Japanese pull saw and did fine. I hated it and sold it to him.

For a beginner a quality saw with an optimum set and number and grind on the teeth will be easier to learn with. I have seen this fact confirmed numerous times.

Who knows what Tom was told before he sharpened the saw. The variables are kind of wood, crosscut or rip, thickness of wood. The requirement will lead to a much different sharpening (according to someone I met that makes saws). Maybe this saw was sharpened to cross cut thick softwood, to take an extreme example.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#13

Re: partially disagree - Hacksaw test

TomD

So there was that guy who wrote the book in which he showed that dovetails can be cut with a hacksaw. back in the pre-tools era of woodworking, a few years back. The blade can get painfully hot, since hacksaw set is not woodworking set.

So get a hacksaw either the fine eclipse saw, or a 16 point regular hacksaw, and try cutting some dovetails. If the Tom Law sharpened handsaw is less controllable than the hacksaw, you know you have a problem. Tom could sharpen a dovetail saw as well as anyone, so something odd is afoot if his saw will not pass this test.

The key thing with a hacksaw is that it is not a "good experience" as Iphones are said to be. But it will get the job done, will start, will cut straight, etc... That is why I suggested controllability as the test. Obviously the hacksaw blade needs to be pretty fresh.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#14

Coupla thoughts

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Scott and all,

Thought 1: Life's too short (and too long) to put up with a saw that's not sawing to suit you. Truly doesn't matter what others think--it has to suit you. Find someone to send it to, maybe that BadAxe guy or someone equal, and get a refiling. Or buy a new saw, if the out-the-door price for roundtrip shipping and filing is going to be about the same.

Thought 2: One test that a dovetail saw has to pass is: does it start the cut exactly where you put it down on the mark, or does it slip sideways (even a little).

Wiley

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#15

Bill...."E. TN." Did you move?


Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#16

no, always been here......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been trying ever since Ellis got the new software to restore my log in name to what it had historically been. " Edit" never worked for me. My WC account got miscombobulated and I had to start over which gave me the opportunity to restore an "address" with my name. Now everyone can rationalize my comments with the fact I am a "good old boy" from E. TN and discount accordingly.

Definitions (good for East TN)

Good ole Boy- if you are broke down on the side of the road he will stop and assist your plight.

Red Neck- he will throw an empty beer bottle at you upon passing by

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#17

Re: Coupla thoughts

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Scott's complaint is that the saw cut isn't smooth. If by "not smooth" he means there are teeth marks and that is the only problem with his dovetails the better solution is to realize that tooth marks are an irrelevant issue.

Now if he can't saw a straight line with the saw, a different saw or different tooth grind could help substantially.

Maybe we need clarification of the problem.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#18

East Tennessee

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

is beautiful country! Bill will have to post some rhododendron and dogwood photos come April!

Wiley.....from North Carolina, long years ago

You might be a redneck if.....your primary car color is BondO.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#19

I wuz thinking (always dangerous)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

that if the set is too wide, or uneven, one of the things that happens is that the saw will have a tendency to slip sideways on starting. I do recall Scott's complaint was the sawn surface.

I can't stay out of saw threads, and sometimes talk too much in them. They're my favorite tool.

Wiley

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#20

Re: no, always been here......

david weaver

For some reason, I always figured you were in upstate new york. No clue why.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#22

*UPDATE*

Scott in Douglassville

Thanks, all, for the advice, suggestions, and opinions. I've been reading all of it, and put it to use today.

First, my concern was only roughness of the cut interfering with the fit of the joint. Did some practice in 3/4" maple the other day, and while they came together alright ("serviceable" comes to mind), they were far from fine furniture joints. My sawing, for whatever reason, is pretty good right now. I spent hours and hours practicing sawing years ago when I first tried the whole dovetailing thing. Guess some of it stuck.

So, today I cut a piece of 1/4" QS sycamore into two 2" wide strips. Laid out a couple tails and sawed them. I'm chopping waste now - never had any luck with sawing it, and I don't own a fret saw (was using a coping saw). Marked the pins with an X-acto knife, sawed them, and chopped. Fit was great, but the baseline fit was bad. Chopping error. Tried again. And again. And again. Had issues sawing past the baseline, chopping too far into the base, paring the pins, you name it. Each time a new problem, but was able to compensate the next iteration. Finally got this:


There's still a lot of room for improvement, obviously, but this took all of ten minutes from marking to gluing. Considering the extent of my total ineptitude, I'm fairly pleased.

All that said, I have terrible episodes of GAS, and last night sniped my way into a Richardson Bros. 8" dovetail saw. This this one is going to get filed to 16-18 PPI for comparison.

Anyway, this is fun. Was home sick today, and spent the bulk of the afternoon entertaining myself with a saw and chisel. Too cool.

Thanks for all the help.

Scottt

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#23

Historical perspective

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

It is well to poke into antique furniture and see the standards of the day. Dovetails were an effective way to hold things together not a fashion statement, and they were often made accordingly. The ability to make flauntable dovetails can be a goal, but it is not an essential goal to making furniture that works and looks good. At the point you are at for making a serviceable joint I would be making stuff and not fretting my dovetail precision.

I was in Grove Park Inn gallery recently. The quality of stuff there has gone up. I peeked in a drawer of what I considered the finest piece there in terms of design and execution. Exquisitly fit drawer. Noted a dovetail repair on it.

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#24

Nothing wrong with serviceable at all...

John in NM

In fact, I would rather see someone build 10 less than perfect pieces than never finish that one perfect one. We learn the most and the quickest by getting out there and trying, making mistakes, and figuring out how to avoid them next time. The dovetail is meant to hold the parts together as a box, your's does that so it is a success. The function is the meat, and any improvement of appearance is gravy (and who doesn't like gravy :D )

Re: Dovetail saw setup - suggestions?

#25

Re: *UPDATE*

William Duffield

14 tpi is a bit coarse for 1/4" stock. It should give you a much smoother cut (for what it's worth, since a little roughness helps a hide glued joint) on 1/2" or 3/4" thick stock. A fine tooth dovetail saw (e.g., 22 tpi or so), although it can be a challenge to sharpen, would provide a smoother cut on very thin stock.

Instead of retoothing that saw, you would probably be wise to get a second saw for dovetails in thin stock.