Re: clarification
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Hi Bill,
I didn't go into the long piecess because I thought Tom had described exhaustively the whole thing, and there wasn't much left to say. That's why I focused on getting the joints in compression on the outside corners.
Getting down to cases, you brought up problems of marking, cutting, and attaching:
"The approach Wiley describes relies on cutting, and attaching, the two long sides perfectly. TomD describes the perils associated with this step. It must be measured perfectly and attached perfectly. If the piece is cut too long or short or it slips a few thousandths of an inch on installation you're screwed...."
Marking. The long sides are first of all a marking problem. On critical marks, I believe in fixing in place--clamping--the piece to be marked. For example, on dovetails, when transferring the tail board marks to the pin board, I fix the pin board vertically in a vise, and clamp the tail board down onto it. So nothing moves while marking.
Same thing here: You can either clamp a long piece onto whatever panel or frame it will go on, and mark the heel of the miters in the clamps--with a fine knife mark. Or you can take a longish rule and put stops on it, like these,
http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=53825&cat=1,43513
and get transferrable precision that way. I prefer to make fine small knife marks at the inside corner of the miter. When that marked piece is mitered, you are going to saw cut and then shoot, to the middle of the mark. Or like Tom said, if you have a different marking scheme, then you know your own scheme, and know whether you're splitting the mark or taking the mark. I like to split it, and leave a little, so there's a witness.
Slipping. You also mentioned any slip on installation is fatal (if left til the glue sets up). So true. So let's say now we've sawn and shot a long piece, leaving ever so slight a witness where the heel of the miter meets the panel or case side. First, clamp the piece back up where it will go to make sure there's been no mistake--if there has, start over, but this really should not happen if the piece was marked in the clamps in the first place. Bear in mind, the miter angle on the long pieces (in this approach) are not critical. They're in the ballpark of 45, but on the long pieces you have a free choice. All the 'error' will be accounted for and taken up by the short piece miters, which won't be cut until the long pieces are actually fixed in place. At which point, the whole thing is right in front of you, and you're marking from the final positions of the long pieces.
But back to the long pieces 'slipping' in glue up. Now if the pieces are to be nailed, it's easy. You have the long piece clamped to the case for final fit--if it's right, then put a couple of nails into it. No glue yet, but the nail holes give you exact registration. Apply glue to both surfaces, use the nail holes for registration, set the nails, clamp, and you're good. When both long pieces are done this way, mark the short pieces directly off them, and prepare them. Sneak up on the fit, one thou at a time.
Now suppose the strips to be applied will not be nailed. You have the long piece in the clamps for final fit. It's good. Now clamp a long ruler, or a milled edge level (we want something straight), right beneath and up against your strip to be glued. That gives you vertical registration and support. Reinforce your witness marks at either end at this point--so you can clearly see where the heels of the miters join the case (or whatever it is). Apply glue to both surfaces, place the strip upon the support, get initial tack, line up one of the witness marks, quick clamp it, check the other end, make any final adjustment, and clamp.
_____
The above is a pretty complicated situation involving a case which is not easily handled. In my own situation, I will be gluing edge banding to a 38"x 18" frame, the vertical registration will be a sheet of marine ply with wax paper on it, and the whole thing is reachable and seeable. So much less busy a procedure, not requiring the fixing of vertical supports.
_____
Bill, I freely confess I may not understand the problem you're raising. My frame of reference is for a fairly simple mold or band or edging strip. Perhaps a large complex crown molding or some such requires a match-up precision at the corners that I am not taking into account.
Wiley