New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

wraping a retangle with mitered strips

Posts

wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#1

wraping a retangle with mitered strips

BillTindall

It is a common building task to need to wrap molding or trim around something retangular- table top, molding on case furniture, etc. What strategy do you all use to ensure perfect length of these pieces to get perfect meters, especially on th elast joint to be made?

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#2

I am not very good

Ron Harper

I have never had a whole lot of luck with this right off the saw. I cut the last piece a smidge long and shoot to fit

Ron

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#3

If possible

John in NM

I make a little bit of a rabbet to give me some wiggle room.

If not possible to do the rabbet, I just cut one side of the miter on each piece, then mark off the inside of the other end using a chisel against the rectangular piece and just sneak up on the mark with a shooting board.

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#4

Re: If possible

don stephan

Start with at least one extra piece, and if you end up a smidge short, plane a bit off the inside edge.

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

Jack Guzman from Maine

I always make these pieces slightly large and fine tune to fit. Norm however,takes a measurement,cuts and applies the piece like there was nothing to it. I've never been that accurate.---Jack

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#6

Architectural practice

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

In architectural trim work, where the molding sections are longer than common in furniture, the last piece is often cut a hair long and snapped into place. Important in this is choosing a long section to do this with - you want as much length as possible to accommodate the smidgen of extra length.

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#7

try kerfing in the last corner


Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#8

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

TomD

As far as the length is concerned I use the strategy where the first three pieces are like a C on the rectangular piece, and the ends of the outer pieces are a distance apart equal to the OAL of the 4th piece. So all you do is cut one end on the forth piece, turn it around backward and align the cut end, and then mark the other end from the outside of the molding. This work well, but it is like dovetails and a lot of other things, you have to have the feel for how much to leave of the pencil line, so to speak.

Actually it can be easier to hold the oversize fourth piece and scribe both ends. It is hard to get a perfect fit with one hand trying to align the first cut end to one of the mitres. If you don't cut the first end of the fourth piece then both ends of it will rest against the mitred ends, and they will be like a giant calliper giving you your OAL. It depends what makes you happier, cutting two joints to a line, or having one in the bag, but a bit of a three hander taking off the lines.

A third option is to hold the uncut fourth piece against the ends of the other two pieces in the orientation it will have when put in place. Tick the ends, carry those marks to the outside then mark the angle from the outside back to the inside, to get the cuts.

If the mitre is too floppy to accurately take the measurement, take something stiff like a level, and put masking tape on it, so that if it is held up to the open mitre ends, they can be scribed to the tape, and you can use that measurement to make your fourth piece.

It gets more complicated if anything at all is not square, or if any of the moldings have little cut-aways, that make it impossible to really accurately project a line. That would not really affect measuring the fourth piece, but it might affect the fit of the two it meets.

So to really dumb it down, cut two small piece of molding, and fit those perfectly, make any adjustments on these. Then either use another piece of stock to mark the distance apart the two fit pieces are, or if you don't have four hands, you can scribe the but ends of the small pieces on the work, and then with all that info you have what you need to assemble a piece that will just drop in.

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#9

Some advice from SAPFM years ago

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

The main challenge I see is a set of joints that will not open up over time. There are various ways to get a trial and error or measured fit, which have been spelled out in this thread.

Some years ago, I was making my first cockbeaded drawers, and asked for advice on SAPFM. One of the things suggested, was how to fit the little end pieces, which are mitered to matching miters on the full-width top and bottom beads. It's a similar problem to what you have raised, except on a smaller scale.

Anyway, what was suggested was to get the top and bottom beads in place and mitered. And then miter the end pieces, such that they were ever so slightly longer, and ever so slightly more acute than the complementary angle on the full-width beads. For example, to generalize this, let's say the long-side frame pieces are mitered at exactly 45 degrees on your shooting board or chisel jig. Glue them down. Then the short-side pieces would be mitered at slightly less, say 44 or 44-1/2 degrees, and made ever so slightly long. Then shave them on the shooting board, slice by slice, until you can just press them to fit. What will happen is that they are ever so slightly sprung, and are tighter at the outside than at the heel. You are pressurizing the outside of the join, as the heel of the join seats against the panel. The idea is that slight movement over time will not cause the joint to open.

You could get the needed 'acuteness' by shimming your shooting board with a Post It note or somesuch to achieve slightly less than 45 degrees. Apply glue and clamp.

It happens I am in process of applying a 5/8" T&G frame around a Baltic birch ply core for a desk top, and then a 1/8" thick band (of the appearance wood) around that. (Then the appearance top veneer will cover both the 5/8" frame and the 1/8" band.) Both the 5/8" frame, which provides a glue surface, and the 1/8" band will need to be mitered in the manner you suggest. I'll take photos of how I make out.

I think this notion of the slightly sprung joint--the outside of the joint under pressure--is what Bill Houghton was speaking about, up above in this thread.

Wiley

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#10

handy for inside corners

BillTindall

not applicable to wrapping a retangle

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#11

what is a retangle?


Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#12

Shooting board, low angle plane

James Watriss

This really is where the rubber meets the road, Bill. When set properly, a good plane, whether bevel up or down, can take off a thou (or less) at a time. That's better than most power tools can manage, or at least, better than they can do without a high degree of jiggery. And hand planes don't have the tear out issues that whirling toothy tooling does.

I try to keep my operations efficient in the shop. I use planes because it's easier to be reliably accurate when these sorts of details come up. If I'm doing a lot of miters, I might cut the pieces slightly over-length in the machine room to save time, and just trim to fit with the plane. But even that doesn't save too much time.

Cut an extra piece of molding or two, 'just in case.' But with a little bit of patience, and a 'good enough' shooting board, there's no reason you should have a problem here.

And yes, I mean 'good enough' on the shooting board. It's easier to shim to a perfect angle with masking tape than it is to build anything out of wood that will cut an immaculate 45 all the time. Small moldings are one thing, and they're pretty easy, really. The hairiest miters I ever had to shoot were wide fields of veneer that were surrounding a chess board. The inside edges had to match the board, the miters had to be straight, and the width of the miter meant that any gaps would be amplified. And the shooting board was well-used... worn down, and beaten up. Shimming with masking tape made it a very simple operation.

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#13

That would be a rectangle that you can't 'c'


Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#14

clarification

BillTindall

I would like to hear more detail from James.

TomD, who ever you are, summarized the problem in detail, and provided some alternatives for accomplishing the required steps, all with their advantages and disadvantages. The question is....what approach do you all actually use?

By saw we can cut the mitered stick end to length and angle accurately, or not quite. James described how by shooting board we can adjust both the angle and length in tiny increments. Wiley described one strategy for doing the short ends, glossing over the task of getting the long ends of perfect length and angle and installed accurately.

To summarize the challenge--Eight mitered cuts must be made on the ends of 4 sticks. Particularly on a case, or drawer which has been adjusted for an opening, the angles may be slightly different from 45 degrees. The lengths can be transferred, more or less accurately, from the piece to be wrapped.

As an example here is what I do for wrapping three sides of a case molding. Note sure what is best for 4 sides.

I start by cutting the two short pieces (that go on the case side), and the long front piece, a bit longer than required. I cut make 4- 45 degree miter cuts, two on the long piece and one the end of each short piece.

Starting on one corner, lets say the right corner I test fit the miter. If not perfect, and it rarely is, I adjust with shooting board, as James described. I have a whole collection of shims to micro-adjust the angle.

Then I test fit the other corner, leaving the pieces long, but making note of what adjustment needs to be made on this miter to get the angle perfect. At this point the miter angles of the first (right) corner are perfect and the shooting board(or saw) set up to achieve the perfect angle on the left corner.

At this point I bring the miter of the right corner together and nail on the side (short) piece, leaving its extra length hanging out the back of the case to be trimmed later.

Next, by trial, I trim the left miter of the front piece to make this piece fit the proper length. The miter angle will be right because I have left the saw or shooting board adjusted for this joint. When the length is perfect the left miter will close up and I can nail on the front piece and then the left side piece.

Finally the overhang of the side pieces is trimmed, in place, flush with the back of the case side.

This approach is tedious but reliable for wrapping 3 sides, but is incomplete for wrapping the 4th side. It has the advantage of being able to empirically fit each joint and perfection is only limited by the care in shaving off smidgens on the shooting board.

The approach Wiley describes relies on cutting, and attaching, the two long sides perfectly. TomD describes the perils associated with this step. It must be measured perfectly and attached perfectly. If the piece is cut too long or short or it slips a few thousandths of an inch on installation you're screwed. I really do not see how to accomplish this feat when it is done but occasionally.

Then holding these pieces in position I nail on the short side piece, leaving it sticking long out the back to be trimmed square later.

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#15

You're over thinking this, Bill

James Watriss

Trust me, you are.

Cut 5 or 6 pieces of stock, all to the longer length. (extra, to be safe.)

Make the front piece and back pieces first. If you over-shoot, you can turn a long piece into a short piece. (pun not intended, but Philologically curious, now that I think about it...)

Clamp on front and back pieces.

Shoot the first side piece. Take small shavings, one or two at a time. If you prepped as described, you have 3 or 4 chances to get 2 pieces made. You're going to over-shoot one in your zeal, I promise. But it's no more difficult than driving in the middle of the road. Don't worry or try too hard, just do it.

Gentle, small adjustments, easy does it. And if you're optimally adjusted to take really thin shavings, any gap from overshooting will be filled by glue or finish anyway.

15 minutes spent on this particular job will teach you more about how fussy to be than any more time spent in here will.

I thus banish you to the shop. Go, do work. And learn in the doing.

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#16

Re: clarification

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

I didn't go into the long piecess because I thought Tom had described exhaustively the whole thing, and there wasn't much left to say. That's why I focused on getting the joints in compression on the outside corners.

Getting down to cases, you brought up problems of marking, cutting, and attaching:

"The approach Wiley describes relies on cutting, and attaching, the two long sides perfectly. TomD describes the perils associated with this step. It must be measured perfectly and attached perfectly. If the piece is cut too long or short or it slips a few thousandths of an inch on installation you're screwed...."

Marking. The long sides are first of all a marking problem. On critical marks, I believe in fixing in place--clamping--the piece to be marked. For example, on dovetails, when transferring the tail board marks to the pin board, I fix the pin board vertically in a vise, and clamp the tail board down onto it. So nothing moves while marking.

Same thing here: You can either clamp a long piece onto whatever panel or frame it will go on, and mark the heel of the miters in the clamps--with a fine knife mark. Or you can take a longish rule and put stops on it, like these,

http://www.leevalley.com/US/Wood/page.aspx?p=53825&cat=1,43513

and get transferrable precision that way. I prefer to make fine small knife marks at the inside corner of the miter. When that marked piece is mitered, you are going to saw cut and then shoot, to the middle of the mark. Or like Tom said, if you have a different marking scheme, then you know your own scheme, and know whether you're splitting the mark or taking the mark. I like to split it, and leave a little, so there's a witness.

Slipping. You also mentioned any slip on installation is fatal (if left til the glue sets up). So true. So let's say now we've sawn and shot a long piece, leaving ever so slight a witness where the heel of the miter meets the panel or case side. First, clamp the piece back up where it will go to make sure there's been no mistake--if there has, start over, but this really should not happen if the piece was marked in the clamps in the first place. Bear in mind, the miter angle on the long pieces (in this approach) are not critical. They're in the ballpark of 45, but on the long pieces you have a free choice. All the 'error' will be accounted for and taken up by the short piece miters, which won't be cut until the long pieces are actually fixed in place. At which point, the whole thing is right in front of you, and you're marking from the final positions of the long pieces.

But back to the long pieces 'slipping' in glue up. Now if the pieces are to be nailed, it's easy. You have the long piece clamped to the case for final fit--if it's right, then put a couple of nails into it. No glue yet, but the nail holes give you exact registration. Apply glue to both surfaces, use the nail holes for registration, set the nails, clamp, and you're good. When both long pieces are done this way, mark the short pieces directly off them, and prepare them. Sneak up on the fit, one thou at a time.

Now suppose the strips to be applied will not be nailed. You have the long piece in the clamps for final fit. It's good. Now clamp a long ruler, or a milled edge level (we want something straight), right beneath and up against your strip to be glued. That gives you vertical registration and support. Reinforce your witness marks at either end at this point--so you can clearly see where the heels of the miters join the case (or whatever it is). Apply glue to both surfaces, place the strip upon the support, get initial tack, line up one of the witness marks, quick clamp it, check the other end, make any final adjustment, and clamp.

_____

The above is a pretty complicated situation involving a case which is not easily handled. In my own situation, I will be gluing edge banding to a 38"x 18" frame, the vertical registration will be a sheet of marine ply with wax paper on it, and the whole thing is reachable and seeable. So much less busy a procedure, not requiring the fixing of vertical supports.

_____

Bill, I freely confess I may not understand the problem you're raising. My frame of reference is for a fairly simple mold or band or edging strip. Perhaps a large complex crown molding or some such requires a match-up precision at the corners that I am not taking into account.

Wiley

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#17

Re: clarification

TomD

I actually use all and every. I guess if I was doing the one piece over and over, I would come up with an optimal solution. I don't like moulding, or any nailed parts on furniture, so most of my problems of this type come in trim carpentry, and there there is rarely a straight line or square corner to work with. So I look at what I see, and what scraps or tools I have with me, and then I just do something. I like cutting crown moulding or trim by hand just for the practice, obviously a serious mitre saw would make more sense, but jumping in and doing cuts freehand and no shooting, is how one grows.

Probably given the sweat you put into this, you might be best suited to the 2 pieces and measure the gap approach. If all the parts to date are really clean, you can use pieces cut from a minimal dimension batten stock to get the base length and any angle variance, then just cut it. That said, if you have some nice wood, and say some hand stuck moulding, then there is nothing wrong with mocking up full scale in some wood like poplar. There is nothing like a full size piece. Then just replicate that piece.

Another option would be to use those go bar slides to make a full length calliper. That way you could get a full length measurement automatically. One could use a small bevel gage like the LV to check and transfer any angle anomalies.

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=32585&cat=1,43513,43553

http://www.leevalley.com/en/wood/page.aspx?p=32593&cat=1,42936,50298,43508

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#18

Coping?

jack curtis

Why wouldn't you treat the case like a wall and cope those joints?

Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#19

they are outside joints


Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#20

Oh, yeah, my bad. Sorry.


Re: wraping a retangle with mitered strips

#21

Shave, fit, shave, fit ... Start over.