Hand Tool Chat topic suggestions
Stephen Shepherd
Does anyone have suggestions for our weekly Hand Tool Chat?
Stephen
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Hand Tool Chat topic suggestions
Stephen Shepherd
Does anyone have suggestions for our weekly Hand Tool Chat?
Stephen
Small Marking Tools - Knives and Gauges
david weaver
Bringing this up out of self interest, because I'm having a spat elsewhere about whether these are items any craftsman should make themselves.
They (ornate craftsman made knives and marking tools) seem to be one of the tool types that has blossomed with the trade of servicing the gentleman woodworker, but some of the easiest and cheapest to make tools at the same time.
A contrarian view
Bill Tindall
My Blue Spruce marking knife, a gift from its maker, must be the perfect marking device. I can not imagine any improvement to its utility and apparently Derek can't either(see his display of similar knives earlier).
If I already knew what size and shape the various parts had to be to make the "perfect" knife and I happened to have on hand a lathe, brass ferrule material and some heat treated steel for the blade I certainly could make one. However, by the time I optimized the variables and rounded up the parts and made it I could have made substantial progress on a piece of furniture. I'd rather be making furniture.
Sounds like...
John in NM
The makings for a lively discussion 
Unfortunately I have no opinion as such, and could only drag the debate down by agreeing with everyone 
Re: A contrarian view
david weaver
I have a similar BS marking knife, someone gave it to me as a gift. It's very nicely made.
It is, however, functionally no better than a knife that I can make in 15 minutes (like a lot of us, I have a couple of junk saws around that are dying to be used).
I think items like that are nice gifty kinds of things for people to give to woodworkers, but there seems to be the notion among novices that folks need to buy marking tools, and that often includes tropical wood handles, brass ferrules, etc.
a piece of scrap wood with a kerf, affixed to a piece of scrap saw (which is ideal because it can be filed to shape) with epoxy is its equal in use. If anything, the saw tip might tend to round a little bit with some use, which, to me, makes the knife a little nicer to use.
Re: You could make it more exciting by..
david weaver
...agreeing with someone, and then agreeing with someone who says something the opposite, only to agree then with someone else who has a different opposing view.
Certainly, you could make everyone upset by appearing to agree with them and then appearing to agree against them 
(Message Deleted by Poster)
(Message Deleted by Poster)
I suppose you are the reason that.....
Bill Tindall
........I have only ever found one at the FL flea markets. Indeed a wonderful divider.
Re: A contrarian view
Bill Tindall
If you bring Bridge City Tools into the discussion you will have me on your side.

Can I redeem myself with these stringing tools? I may add some friction tape to the groove scraper to cover up the teeth. Had I not happened to have on hand a piece of band saw blade of proper thickness, or if I was already ordering from them I likely would have bought these tools from Lee Valley. It illustrates that depending on the impediments of time, materials, money and skills we may or may not choose to make our tools. Where we buy them from could indicate extravagance.
Re: A restatement...
david weaver
..I should clarify that it's not like I don't appreciate the quality of the BS marking knife, it is a really nice knife. The guy who bought mine bought two, and I thought it was very thoughtful for him to have given it to me. I use it because it was a gift, and because it is nice to use.
At any rate, I have a soft spot for tools made from hacksaw blades, recipro saw blades, etc.
George Wilson was describing to me his distaste for low quality bread knives, so he made one out of a high speed steel reciprocating saw blade, with large very sharp serrations. I can't remember how long he said he's had without sharpening, something like 20 years, and it's still sticky sharp.
I have a used up recipro saw blade waiting to be turned into a parting tool for the lathe. Maybe I'll suggest the topic be "tools made from shop scraps" so we aren't all harping on marking knives.
Re: REVISED suggestion - tools from shop scrap..
david weaver
..could be anything, shop supply, or whatever, that's made from shop scrap.
Turning tools, marking tools, chisels, etc.
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Funny...
Tony-Memphis
I had an idea for a new shop made tool this weekend. We have a lot of Hallmark ornaments that have to be plugged in twinkle light string sockets. Removing those small buggers can be a real challenge and is tough on the thumbnail. So, I thought about using a piece of spring steel, piece of old bs blade, etc. to make a bulb remover. Mount it in short fat handle.... The shape of the business end is just a radius close to the radius of the lip on the bulb.
I like making handy little purpose-built tools. I've made a few and evena couple of turning tools.
Tony
lathe parting tools
Bill Tindall
Don't know what your steel is but if it is not robust it will not make a durable parting tool. I have made numerous lathe tools from machine tool steel blanks. These M2 blanks hold up well in turning. The lathe cut-off tools can be readily mounted in a wood lathe tool handle and they work just dandy for parting wood. The 1/4 x 1/4 and similar bits make bedans and skews.
this is mine
Bruce, a MN Galoot
design lifted straight from Patrick Leach, who got it from someplace else. The blade is hard enough that I can use it for other cutting duties, too. Flats on either side keep it mostly from rolling off the bench.
Padauk, brass pipe for a ferrule and an old, cut-up plane blade:

Re: lathe parting tools
david weaver
They are some sort of unidentifiable HSS, for the full thickness of the blades. Probably something like M2.
If they don't work out, I have a set of jointer blades that might make a nice parting tool, but I want something really narrow.
Right on, right on, rappin rhymin Dave !
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Too bad Soul Train is off the air !!
Oh man.. Why did you post the pic
I'm with you, David
Patrick Gibbons
I find myself using my Case pen bladed knife a lot to mark out. I was using the coping blade on my whittler pocket knife but I can't seem to find the knife anymore.
Have we found something to agree on?
Re: Have we found something to agree on?
david weaver
Uh oh...Twice we've agreed with no disagreements between...If we can't argue, what will we talk about? 
Re: Have we found something to agree on?
Ron Harper
This is an alarming trend 