New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Guess the woods?

Posts

Guess the woods?

#1

Guess the woods?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Here are a few marking knifes I made for Christmas gifts. Three are Australian, one is Indonesian, and the other two are from central Africa.



Too easy? :)

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Guess the woods?

#2

Stephen Shepherd

One of them is not a wood.


Re: Guess the woods?

#3

Re: Guess the woods?

Mark Hennebury

one Palm, two Wenge, maybe one Imbuia, dont know the others.

Mark

Re: Guess the woods?

#4

Re: Guess the woods?

david weaver

one (possibly two) is she oak.

Re: Guess the woods?

#5

Its a grass.....but you don't smoke it !


Re: Guess the woods?

#6

Re: Guess the woods?

Bruce McCrory

I threw out some names on another forum Derek posted the same to. Kinda fun trying to figure 'em out.

Someone is splitting wood hairs, regarding Phyla. On the same note, Balsa is technically (by convention) a hardwood.

I think one, if not two, are duplicates--and makes this a sneaky, tricky question, especially when OZ has a bazzillion Euc's. and just as many names for each species, and cross overs over cross overs. Plus, I think they change figure based on micro-climate, too. Chase down some lacewood, please?

The only wood I have fondled from Australia is Jarrah, which these are not.

Re: Guess the woods?

#7

Re: Guess the woods?

William Duffield

Four of them are pretty obvious. The two in the middle are Millettia laurentii. The two below are an Allocasuarina sp. and Normanbya normanbyi (which is in the Arecaceae family). At least one of the others (if not both) might be Acacia melanoxylon.

Re: Guess the woods?

#8

Yes. Indubitably conspicuous.     


Re: Guess the woods?

#9

Answers

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Good identifications by some.

Here are the woods again ..


From the top down:

Macassar Ebony (Diospyros celebica, from Indonesia) - this turns wonderfully. Tight grain.

Rock She-Oak (Allocasuarina huegeliana, from Western Ausralia) - another that is tight grained and turns sweetly.

Two in Wenge (Millettia laurentii, from the Congo) - you need a really sharp edge for this wood. It begins to break out at soon as the edge goes.

West Australian She-Oak (Allocasuarina fraseriana), another from the She-oak family (Casuarinacece) - turns well, hard and interlocked grain.

Black Palm (Normanya normanbyi, typically from tropical Asia or Africa, but this piece was from North Queensland in Australia) - this was a total bugger to turn. Some argue it is a grass not a wood, and its fibrous nature makes it nearly impossible to turn without the sharpest edge. This knife was #3, with the two preceding attempts exploding on me. Finally finished it with sandpaper.

Regards from Perth

Derek