New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

Posts

plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#1

plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

Lars Parrington

i think you guys are going to get a kick out of this one. i chopped up some old blades from a thickness planer to use in a #4 hand plane. the blades were kindly donated by someone on this forum.

lots of pictures and an explanation of my reasoning on my website at the link below:


img

http://lllars.com/the_workshop/planer_plane_blades/index.php

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#2

question

Bill Tindall

they are typically M2 or M42 and not easily cut or made into other shapes. How did you cut the slot and cut to size? They will be robust in use.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#3

Re: question

Lars Parrington

i cut the blades to length using an angle grinder equipped with a cut-off wheel. i cleaned up the cuts a bit on the belt sander afterwards.

i didn't cut any slots in the blades themselves. i cut the slots in the fixture (blade holder thing) on the milling machine.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#4

Re: question Dremel

TomD

Amazing what you can do with a Dremel. I am not a big Dremel user, but the fiberglass strengthened cut-off wheels are amazing.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#5

Re: question Dremel

Lars Parrington

actually i meant a 4 1/2" angle grinder, though i see no reason why a dremel wouldn't work.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#6

Re: question Dremel

TomD

Thanks! My thought is that if people own a 4.5 they probably know it cuts metal, but a lot of people own a dremel and would hardly believe what it will cut. Though actually anything much over 1/8 might be a bit much.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#7

Re: question Dremel

Lars Parrington

yeah, i've always found dremel tools to be surprisingly useful given how cheaply they are made. i used mine just the other day to remake the groove in the back of a plow plane iron.

here's a photo of a cnc machine i built back in college, that was based around a dremel tool:


Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#8

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

You have a note on your blog about adding a bevel on the back of a plane blade to convert it to 50-55 degrees and you state that it increases the sharpness of the blade and will cause it to dull more quickly. Actually the converse is true. adding a 10 degree bevel to the back will make for a more obtuse angle and it is something I have done on my old lunch box planer for tough woods such as elm to make my blades last longer.

Robin

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#9

obtuse edges dull more quickly under abrasive load *LINK*

Lars Parrington

robin, you've hit upon a point which i am particularly interested in talking and learning more about. so, bear with me. i'm afraid this got a bit long.

first some nomenclature clarification:

what i actually wrote is that adding a 5 or 10 degree back bevel "increases the sharpness angle" of the iron. perhaps this is not the right terminology. by 'sharpness angle', i mean the angle formed between the two bevels at the tip of the blade. so, i think we are actually saying the same thing: adding a back bevel makes the sharpness angle more obtuse.

where we seem to disagree is in whether a more obtuse angle dulls more quickly. part of the problem is that we are talking about two different tools: a hand plane versus a thickness planer. consider the difference in the loads being placed on the blade, and what we consider to be 'sharp enough' for each tool:

a thickness planer will do satisfactory work with blade edges that are much duller than what many of us require in a handplane. the loads on a thickness planer blade might be more similar to those placed on a mortising chisel than a hand plane: they are subjected to repetitive impact loading, as the blades are continuously driven into the wood surface to a short depth. each cut makes a short and thick chip. on the other hand, a hand plane blade sees a relatively constant load, with a only a small amount of impact at the beginning of each stroke. the 'chip' is a thin and long shaving.

an acute edge subjected to the impact loading of a thickness planer would quickly dull by means other than abrasive wear, such as folding or chipping of the edge. this explains why a more obtuse angle seems to last longer. as the angle of the edge is made more obtuse, the blade edge becomes strong enough to resist folding and chipping, and abrasive wear becomes the primary mechansim of dulling. let's call this the transition point or transition angle.

because there is less impact load on a hand plane blade, it's transition angle will be lower (more acute) than that of the thickness planer blade.

abrasive wear essentially rounds over the sharp edge of the blade. so, now instead of a cutting edge, you have a cutting curve with a certain radius. imagine a given amount of abrasive wear removing a quantifiable volume of steel from the cutting edge. removing that same volume from a blade with a more obtuse edge will result in an edge with a larger radius of curvature. this is why i said that a more obtuse blade will dull more quickly.

it would seem that the ideal sharpening angle is the one that is slightly above the transition point. the transistion point for a hand plane blade seems to be around 30-35 degrees, depending on the specific characteristics of the blade material, the wood, and how the plane is used. the transition angle for a thickness planer is higher, perhaps around 45 degrees.

looking back, i've been pretty long winded on a topic i really don't know that much about. so, please don't think i'm trying to sound like an expert here. just trying to explain my understanding of the subject. i do think there are somewhat important ramifications for hand tool woodworkers here, and yet i haven't really seen this particular issue discussed anywhere else. it seems that most articles about back bevels gloss over or ignore this issue. i do have one reference i can point to, which is steve elliot's webpage where he shows some increase in hand plane edge life at more acute bevel angles:


http://www.bladetest.infillplane.com/html/bevel_angles.html

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#10

Re: Take this...  Seriously.

TomD

I never worry about sounding like an expert here...

So imagine you have two planes, both having the blade set at 45 degrees. One has a real blade of say 3/16" and the other has an imaginary blade of the same size, except it is almost 0" thick With me so far? Ok so when we sharpen the imaginary blade that is 0" thick we essential scrape it into metal slivers that are the length of the blade, because the stone grit pattern cuts right through the blade leaving only the long slivers. Essentially, if we could use this blade, it would be like a toothing blade, but with teeth as deep as the blade is long. This would leave a very rigged surface in the wood, and be essentially a very rough plane blade edge. Of course it would only work on imaginary wood.

Now lets imagine the other plane has a 40 degree bevel with the blade set at 45. This would limit the scratch pattern to almost the height of the grit last fully used to sharpen the bevel plus whatever intersections there might be with the scratches on the back of the blade. This would appear to the user to yield a wonderful sharp plane, and a tremendous surface, and yet the edge would last and last due to the smaller fingers of metal at the edge, and the greater support to the edge from the bevel coming down to within a 5 degree angle of the surface being planed.

I have one plane that is pretty similar to that, and it is great, but if it were not a fat blade it would be difficult to sharpen without a jig.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#11

interesting point, but not relevant

Lars Parrington

if i understand correctly, you are saying that a scratch of a given depth on the wood-facing side of the blade appears to the wood to grow deeper as the clearance angle of the blade increases. those scratches leave behind ridges and valleys in the wood surface. a blade with a greater clearance angle would leave behind taller ridges, or effectively a rougher surface. seems logical enough to me. i did a quick calculation and got that for a given scratch depth, a 15deg clearance angle would create ridges 1.3 times as high as a blade with 5 deg clearance.

unfortunately, i don't see how this scratch pattern relates to the edge staying sharp over time. you say that "the edge would last and last due to the smaller fingers of metal at the edge...", but you don't explain why.

you also say that a low clearance angle blade would last longer due to greater support behind the edge. however, it seems to me that the blade edge would only need additional support if it were failing by some mechanism other than abrasive wear.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#12

Re: obtuse edges dull more quickly under abrasive

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Believe it or not most power planers have an angle of incident, or the angle the blade is at when it makes contact at the lowest point of the blade arc of about 35*. If you turn the power off with the board still in the planer and then raise the power head to remove it you will see that each chip starts with the blade at this angle and then transitions up towards the surface. So in practice the working angle of a power planer blade and a hand plane blade are very similar.

there may indeed be a slight difference in how an edge with a back bevel wears as opposed to one without but the biggest difference is the amount of force required to push the blade with the back bevel is much greater than the blade without, hence you need to reduce the depth of the cut. I can imagine how this grater force could lead one to believe the blade is not lasting as long

The only hand plane I have added a bevel to the back of the blade is a small spoke shave that I used on some highly figured walnut. It seemed to me that the edge held up about the same possibly even a bit longer if I compare the amount of parts shaped .

Just to clarify the angle that a plane blade is sharpened to has little effect to how well it cuts. The only purpose of the angle is to allow for clearance of the work. It doesn’t matter if the blade clears the work by 2* or by 10 * it has no effect on the smoothness of the cut. With that in mind the optimum angle to sharpen a plane blade is one that allows for the most amount of metal to back up the cutting edge. This makes for a stronger edge and in that vein adding a bevel to the back of the bade provides even more metal backing up the cutting edge which makes it even stronger. This should result in longer blade life.

I suppose a case could be made that by increasing the angle of incidence the edge incurs more abrasive wear, but that is another can of worms.

Robin

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#13

Re: but not relevant, I will settle for correct.

TomD

" if i understand correctly, you are saying that a scratch of a given depth on the wood-facing side of the blade appears to the wood to grow deeper as the clearance angle of the blade increases. those scratches leave behind ridges and valleys in the wood surface."

Right, though it is the bedding angle, the bevel angle, and it is the effect of both the grooves on the bevel and the back because points of accidental intersection are going to be more pronounced.

" a blade with a greater clearance angle would leave behind taller ridges, or effectively a rougher surface."

Good reading, you must be readily able to see things in 3D

"unfortunately, i don't see howeve this scratch pattern relates to the edge staying sharp over time. you say that "the edge would last and last due to the smaller fingers of metal at the edge...", but you don't explain why."

Yeah, smaller could be a problem since I guess one could interpret that as either the more needle like projections , or smaller meaning the projection is less, so yeah that could be confusing as written.

"you also say that a low clearance angle blade would last longer due to greater support behind the edge. however, it seems to me that the blade edge would only need additional support if it were failing by some mechanism other than abrasive wear."

Abrasive or adhesive, etc... I leave that up to the guys with the vinyl pockets. But if the edge geometry was such that there was less material at the edge to wear off? Just sounds like work is being done somehow, and more work is still more. The more obtuse the bevel, the lesser the effect of serrations, the more material.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#14

Re: obtuse edges dull more quickly under abrasive

david weaver

With that last part, are we talking about hand planes or are we talking about machine planers?

The longest lasting edge a user will be able to get with a hand plane blade is the smallest angle that can be used without having chipout problems. I think Steve did some study work to find that this was about 32 degrees with A2.

If the edge is more blunt than that, then it has already been ground at an angle that is similar to a phase of the worn angle in a plane that was sharpened at a narrower angle, and will wear to the point that it is undesirable to use in fewer strokes.

Not that any of it is terribly critical, but if someone wants to maximize how much time they have with a plane before they need to resharpen, they will want to use a strategy similar to what Steve used with the A2 and find the lowest total angle that doesn't have chipout problems.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#15

Re: I should've read what Lars wrote first..

david weaver

..I pretty much said what he said, except he said all of it better.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#16

wahoo!!  someone agrees with me!


Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#17

brain fart

Lars Parrington

when i wrote above about the action of a thickness planer being similar to a mortising chisel i was a bit confused. for some reason i was picturing the head of the planer rotating in the opposite direction to what it actually does, even though i knew better.

so, i now agree with you that the blades of both plane and planer approach the wood at similar angles. however, i don't think that changes the rest of my previous arguments. it still seems to me that the thickness planer blades are subjected to higher loads and much more impact loads. although certainly those loads are much less than they would be if you ran the head backwards**.

**it's kind of neat to think about running a thickness planer's head backwards. there would be no tearout. but, can you imagine trying to pound a 12" wide chisel into the surface of a piece of wood. each cut would be like that. you would need a big motor.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#18

Loss of clearance

Steve Elliott

The main reason a hand plane blade stops cutting well is loss of clearance behind the blade, which makes it difficult to keep the blade in the cut. That's the most important reason to look for the smallest bevel angle that won't chip or fold over.

This post is short because I'm texting from a new smartphone while on break at work. Learning to text is a hand skill too.

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#19

To illustrate Steve's point

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi All,

Here is a sketch of two irons, A and B. Let's say they're both bevel-down, and let's say they're the same steel. Both bedded at 50 degrees, which is the attack angle, or cutting angle:


Blade A is sharpened at 30 degrees, that's its included angle; Blade B at 38 degrees. Therefore, A has clearance of 20 degrees, and B has clearance of 12 degrees.

The diagram is drawn to show a limiting clearance at 7 degrees, roughly following Leonard Lee's estimate. Our story would remain the same if some other limiting clearance were selected--the 7 degrees will do for purposes of illustration.

The yellow area is the metal loss from each blade, before the blade reaches its 'allowed' 7 degrees clearance. The yellow area will be gone, and the hand-drawn green line outlines the geometry of the worn blade.

The key point is that Blade A at 30 degrees, has to lose roughly twice as much metal as Blade B at 38 degrees, before it reaches 7 degrees clearance. That's just the geometry of the situation. The picture would be about the same if we had picked 5 degrees clearance, or some other figure.

In principle, Blade A should win the endurance planing contest against Blade B. But. The caveat is that the steel has to be tough enough so that it won't start breaking down and experiencing accelerated chipping or other wear at 30 degrees! If it does, Blade A could in fact lose steel faster than Blade B, and Blade B could win the race, just because Blade A couldn't take the load.

Wiley

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#20

Re: brain fart

Mark Hennebury

Hi all, Thickness planer blades don't take as much impact as you might think as the knife contacts the wood and picks up a shaving the shaving gets thicker as it progresses through rotation of the cutterhead and the movement of the wood past the cutterhead. So the shaving starts of at virtually no thickness, kind of a soft start if you like.

On the point of a planer running backwards; It is in many cases the best way to cut wood, it is referred to climb cutting.

It is not used nearly enough.

It has the blade cutting down into the wood, so it gives a great finish without tearout.

Most machines are not designed to handle climb cutting, most tool geometry is not designed for climb cutting, but that doesn't mean it doesn't work or that machines and tools couldn't be made to use climb cutting.

Climb cutting requires slightly different tool geometry to be safe and efficient.

Climb cutting Requires good feed control, this can be achieved on machines like shapers etc with a power feeder.

Climb cutting makes a different shape of shaving starting of with thicker and finishing smaller, so the opposite of standard upcutting as in a planer.

Climb cutting in a planer may best with a helical head arrangement to more evenly distribute the force.

Just because things are done one way doesn't mean that they cant be done better a different way. A lot of woodworking tooling and machinery is done certain way because of the limitations of the past and the ingrained acceptance of those methods as "the way".

Mark

Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#21

excellent diagram! worth > 1000 words


Re: plane irons made of thickness planer blades *LINK*

#22

Re: To illustrate Steve's point

TomD

That is an interesting point, though way too many other factors. For instance, if you overlay the idea of the grooving that sharpening cause, that alone would make B a lot better bet. I have a plane with a clearance angle of five degrees, and it is really good. I however has a beding angle of 35 degree. So whatever the reasons for any of it, I don't think these are major issues.