obtuse edges dull more quickly under abrasive load *LINK*
Lars Parrington
robin, you've hit upon a point which i am particularly interested in talking and learning more about. so, bear with me. i'm afraid this got a bit long.
first some nomenclature clarification:
what i actually wrote is that adding a 5 or 10 degree back bevel "increases the sharpness angle" of the iron. perhaps this is not the right terminology. by 'sharpness angle', i mean the angle formed between the two bevels at the tip of the blade. so, i think we are actually saying the same thing: adding a back bevel makes the sharpness angle more obtuse.
where we seem to disagree is in whether a more obtuse angle dulls more quickly. part of the problem is that we are talking about two different tools: a hand plane versus a thickness planer. consider the difference in the loads being placed on the blade, and what we consider to be 'sharp enough' for each tool:
a thickness planer will do satisfactory work with blade edges that are much duller than what many of us require in a handplane. the loads on a thickness planer blade might be more similar to those placed on a mortising chisel than a hand plane: they are subjected to repetitive impact loading, as the blades are continuously driven into the wood surface to a short depth. each cut makes a short and thick chip. on the other hand, a hand plane blade sees a relatively constant load, with a only a small amount of impact at the beginning of each stroke. the 'chip' is a thin and long shaving.
an acute edge subjected to the impact loading of a thickness planer would quickly dull by means other than abrasive wear, such as folding or chipping of the edge. this explains why a more obtuse angle seems to last longer. as the angle of the edge is made more obtuse, the blade edge becomes strong enough to resist folding and chipping, and abrasive wear becomes the primary mechansim of dulling. let's call this the transition point or transition angle.
because there is less impact load on a hand plane blade, it's transition angle will be lower (more acute) than that of the thickness planer blade.
abrasive wear essentially rounds over the sharp edge of the blade. so, now instead of a cutting edge, you have a cutting curve with a certain radius. imagine a given amount of abrasive wear removing a quantifiable volume of steel from the cutting edge. removing that same volume from a blade with a more obtuse edge will result in an edge with a larger radius of curvature. this is why i said that a more obtuse blade will dull more quickly.
it would seem that the ideal sharpening angle is the one that is slightly above the transition point. the transistion point for a hand plane blade seems to be around 30-35 degrees, depending on the specific characteristics of the blade material, the wood, and how the plane is used. the transition angle for a thickness planer is higher, perhaps around 45 degrees.
looking back, i've been pretty long winded on a topic i really don't know that much about. so, please don't think i'm trying to sound like an expert here. just trying to explain my understanding of the subject. i do think there are somewhat important ramifications for hand tool woodworkers here, and yet i haven't really seen this particular issue discussed anywhere else. it seems that most articles about back bevels gloss over or ignore this issue. i do have one reference i can point to, which is steve elliot's webpage where he shows some increase in hand plane edge life at more acute bevel angles:
http://www.bladetest.infillplane.com/html/bevel_angles.html