New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

Posts

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#26

The key to his method

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks Ron,

I was curious whether he recommends the same treatment of plane irons as chisels. And he does--identical, I believe. I thought he might differ on plane irons, due to the potential issue of rapid loss of clearance with the convex bevel.

I believe there are two keys to his method:

Key 1: Starting at 30 degrees. Not more. He allows no 'starting creep'. By that, I mean to locate the edge, a beginner might start cheating up to 33, 35, 38, 40 in successive sharpenings, right up to a baffling loss of clearance. But Sellers is locked in on 30. He manages this by using very coarse starting stones.

Key 2: He starts with 200g diamond, if I heard him correctly. Then 800g was it?, then 1200g diamond. Lots of people would start at 800g or 1200g, but he is starting at 200g! By starting at 200g, and reinforcing that with the middle diamond stone, he is absolutely erasing the previous session's wear--all of it--in order to be certain he is back to virgin steel at 30 degrees.

If his irons were examined under a scope, you would find deep scorings from the diamond, which the stropping with CrO will scarcely touch. So I would say, not a refined edge, but definitely a sharp and serviceable one.

His method has the great virtue of erasing all traces of previous wear, which I suspect is the main problem when beginners (not you!) have trouble getting a sharp edge. Indeed, I imagine after the 200g or possibly the 800g diamond, he has the rough equivalent of a machine ground edge.

Thanks for sharing!

Wiley

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#27

Re: The key to his method

Patrick Gibbons

This is an issue that always raises a discussion and I'm not wanting to prolong it. I just wanted to share what I have learned and experienced. In class Paul related how by free handing one could start the chisel at approximately 25 degrees. It might actually be 24 or 27, etc. A convex bevel is stronger because there is more metal. The natural inclination is to lower the handle on the end of the stroke. Convexity is a consequence of sharpening, though it may be quite little.

Diamond plates as they break in become less course. While I've never looped a chisel edge, my edges have always been very polished after the green goop. My personal comparison has been with oil stones and charged leather, and scary sharp using four to six different grits of very fine abrasion. I've never used water stones. The three methods I've used have not shown any significant advantage over the other two in sharpness. But speed is another issue. Paul's method is fast and the edge life is as long as the other two methods.

I have a grinder which I have never used. I've feared burning an edge. It takes up space and requires another plug. I just never got into the habit of using it and so it sits under a cabinet with the dust bunnies and spiders.

I said I have never found a chisel in the wild with a convex bevel. Mostly I have run into carpenters chisels that have been abused. My experience in this matter is very limited and an argument from silence is not very convincing. I have seen quite a few stones that are dished lengthwise. A convex bevel is easier on a stone like this and the tool is perfectly serviceable.

To me a convex bevel replaces a honed micro bevel and does it quickly and easily with the same results. I've never had the angle of my bevel increase with each successive sharpening as some have suggested. It's just a cheap, quick and effective way to sharpen and get on with it. Of course we all have our rituals and preferences. Chacun a son gout.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#28

Re: Do they have to be wrong?

david weaver

I can't remember who I've disagreed with so much, but just the same would rather not.

I did try the method, coincidentally, on a set of nice marples chisels that I found for cheap on ebay. It works, but it does create an edge less keen than a controlled bevel and it takes longer than grinding and using a stone or two stones.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#29

My mileage is different. Peace Brother


Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#30

Re: The key to his method

TomD

"I said I have never found a chisel in the wild with a convex bevel. Mostly I have run into carpenters chisels that have been abused. My experience in this matter is very limited and an argument from silence is not very convincing."

Those pig sticker mortise chisels that were all the rage a few years back, not to mention a few centuries, they have very marked convexity, almost like a ball socket for prying. Then there are the other tools like drawknives, some carving tools, axes, and various knives, like bowies.

"To me a convex bevel replaces a honed micro bevel and does it quickly and easily with the same results. I've never had the angle of my bevel increase with each successive sharpening as some have suggested. It's just a cheap, quick and effective way to sharpen and get on with it."

Just seems to me that this method involves the micro bevel sharpening effect, and then about 30 degrees of rotational nonsense that achieves little, unless one is sharpening the tools that aren't bench chisels in the list above. Method obviously works, but his version is expensive, time consuming, some skill required, and he is applying it to soft chisels you can almost sharpen on your pants. I was very interested to see how he does it, because it is probably deeply rooted. I don't know how Granddad, who was a Joiner in Belfast, sharpened his tools, but it may have looked a lot like that.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#31

Re: Do they have to be wrong?

TomD

"I did try the method, coincidentally, on a set of nice marples chisels that I found for cheap on ebay. It works, but it does create an edge less keen than a controlled bevel and it takes longer than grinding and using a stone or two stones."

Like all tests, the big problem is the lack of 30 years practice with the method. I laugh at all those tests in FWW, where some guy often a newbie is trying to evaluate stones or chisels based on some casual exposure, and mishmash of techniques. And then once one has the 30 years experience, one is so biased one can't make a reasonable judgement either.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#32

Re: Something else to consider

TomD

As you point out MCs know less about tools that some others. Like a great race car driver, knows what he needs in a car, but that does not dispense with the efforts of a whole host of experts who actually design and build the vehicles. Sometimes it is outright amateurs who come up with the goods. Interesting to look at the modern technique with pistols. It did not come from officialdom, but a relatively small group of amateurs who were playing around with shooting techniques on the week end.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#33

Re: Do they have to be wrong?

david weaver

Fortunately, we do have the benefit of watching sellers do the method with a chisel, once with talking and once without.

It takes less time to use a grinder and one or two stones. If he can work his chisel edges to be the same angle I work mine (the grinder determines that for me...with a little persuasion to the tool rest), sharpness will probably be similar. But if I assume that it would take me as long to do his method as it does for him to do it, I'd still be taking longer to sharpen.

I do, however, agree that the magazine articles are just about useless unless they can expose something that is clearly a quality issue. Several years ago, the LN chisels were described as being the best chisels, but at the same time, they were suggesting that they should be sharpened at 30 degrees. So many people I know bought chisels due to a magazine review (and I mean before any LN chisels were ever in magazine articles). These supposed reviews are always based on something like driving a chisel into something abusive to wear it at an accelerated rate.

There was an article not too long ago where the conclusion in a test was that barr chisels didn't hold their edges very well. At the same time, there was an experienced woodworker who mentioned that they liked barr chisels because they allowed them to do some large number of drawers and joinery before resharpening. Those two things came out at almost exactly the same time.

The sharpening stone test was goofy, too. It makes little difference what stones someone gets if they want to learn to use them...*especially* if they have a grinder so that the stones are basically doing very little.

It seems like other than here, most of the experienced users in the forums have moved on. I think I know why.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#34

Thirty years experience

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Can anyone tell me the cutting angle of these chisels?




img

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#35

Re: Thirty years experience *LINK*

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Barr Quarton makes some pretty good framing chisels, and he uses much the same technique as Sellers. The attached video, starting at about 5:30, shows how he does it, slowed down from Sellers so you get a better idea of the angles and the rocking motion.

Barr tools are pretty good. I've used his timber framing chisels and I was impressed, and maybe there is something about a framing chisel that requires that type of edge, but I just don't get it. When you take a good look at the time spent on the very cutting edge, it's just a fraction of the total time spent sharpening, and it doesn't seem to be enough to refine that edge. Am I missing something?


Barr Quarton

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#36

The proof

Ron Harper

Is what the chisel does in the hands of the user?

It really seems ludicrous to me to tell Paul Sellers that he doesnt know how to hone.

It is almost as silly as the pins. Vs. tails debate. When he sees the joint. The client/ recipient of the work will never ponder whether tails or pins were cut first.

Lots of ways to remove hair from a feline.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#37

Re: The key to his method

Patrick Gibbons

I don't get where you think it's expensive, time consuming and only good for chisels soft enough to sharpen on your pants. Not my experience at all.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#38

Don't think you will shsrpen these on your jeans  *LINK*


http://m.youtube.com/#/watch?feature=plcp&v=x_dLA_DkePQ

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#39

Re: The key to his method

TomD

I wouldn't necessarily say the method is those things, but his demo is. He uses three diamond stones, and literally more green compound than I have used in 20 years; he sharpens fairly thoroughly on four surfaces, as one would expect to have to do given that each sharpening starts at 200 grit; And the chisels he uses are one step up from plasticine, but not to say the method would not work on any other chisels, and as it seems to be traditional, then it must have worked one trad chisels also.

I suppose it depends on what that particular video is trying to say. It seems hard to believe it is trying to sell cheap, or fast, just the method and it succeeds at that. Since virtually no western videos are trying to sell sharpens rock hard chisels, why worry about that.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#40

Re: Thirty years experience - More plasticine

TomD

I have a couple of Barr timber framing chisels, a drawknife, and the Beckwurst chisels (I think he now uses LN). The drawknife is my favourite of new manufacture, and the chisels are also my favourite. That said, one of the chisel ferules split and they are all about as soft a Blue Chip. I just really like them, not too sure why. I'm not sure I would go to him for advice though, good blacksmith, but the tool side is a little lacking on metallurgy, and therefore the sharpening advice is moot. His O1 heat treat, at the time, was less than my first efforts. Great chisel for anything south of maple, say cherry, mahog, pine, walnut. The nice woods.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#41

Re: Do they have to be wrong?

TomD

+1 David

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#42

Re: The proof

TomD

He very obviously knows what he is doing. I think FK said it best when he said the expert knows exactly what to do next. This means not only finding a method that works in the abstract, but finding one that works with everthing in your environment and culture, and with all the stuff you make. An integration is key. I think this is why experts and newbies on forums often clash, because there is always the latest greatest method, but there can be all kinds of meaningless to most people details that bind an expert to a method.

Culture is a huge part of this. Most of today's experts are loners, while in the past they were part of a culture. I always wear hearing protection when driving nails, or mowing the lawn. Try that when you are working with other guys, they don't like it for various macho and communications reasons.

Basically Sellers method can be broken down into two parts. 1) is the stuff he uses to achieve the goal, without going into it, nobody agrees on any of that stuff, and you will never sell everyone on using 3 diamond stones and green compound, for good reasons as well as other; 2) The method only makes sense if you have some reason for wanting convex bevels. There is a continuum from hollow to convex, that some people are perched on. Then to boot, there are micro bevels, and their combination with the basic grind. And then there are some people who could care less. So yeah it works, but nobody will be convinced on any of it. It isn't some magic sauce or pixie dust, it is a bunch of subcategories that nobody will ever agree on. The issue isn't that the method doesn't work, it is that they all work.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#43

Looks to me like . . .

Steve Elliott

If your question is about the bevel angle at the tip of the chisel, it looks to me like it must be at least 45 degrees. I don't know of any use I'd put a chisel to that would require that large an angle. Smaller bevel angles would take less force to make a cut and would have a longer working life before rehoning.

I think the honing technique used to produce those edges matters less than the angle at the tip.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#44

Re: Looks to me like . . .

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thanks, Steve. When I watched the sharpening video it seemed like he was well into the 40 degree range at the beginning of his stroke on the stones and also the end of the stroke on the strop. I looked for pictures of the bevel and these seem to confirm a rather blunt edge.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#45

another flaw for this chisel

Bill Tindall

I haven't followed this discussion until I noted Warren's chisel picture. What an alarming bluntness. I never miss an Elliot post which suggests, without reading all that came before, that someone is advocating a chisel with a 45 degree bevel!?!

When we "chop" to a base line, for example when preparing dovetails, the force pushing the chisel away from the base line(bad) and into the finished piece is some geometric function of the bevel angle (likely tangent but its too early to think about geometric functions). More is bad or at least problematic. When sharpening for these tasks the goal should be to prepare the bevel at an angle as small as the chisel's steel will allow. To say another way, the steel and the task it is put to determines the angle to sharpen. A sharpening technique is chosen to reliably and conveniently achieve this angle. I keep a bench grinder and tool rest set up for this task as does every professional shop I have been in, but this is certainly not the only way.

Someone sharpening at 45 degrees must have discovered that the combination of their steel and task can't hold up at a more typical angle of 30 degrees or less. Must be weak steel or a more strenuous task than I encounter in my work.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#46

Re: Looks to me like . . .

david weaver

I don't know what the final angle is, but it's blunt enough that the few times users of the method have described their experience, there is always talk about how strong the edge is.

I'm sure a 35-40 degree final angle would create an edge that seemed a lot more durable when abused than one that was sharpened at 25.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#47

Wow

Ron Harper

I learned an important lesson. Nobody is doing this right, except you , of course. :D

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#48

Re: Do they have to be wrong?

James Watriss

Yes! This is the internet. They have to be wrong.

Silly N00b.

[/sarcasm]

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#49

Re: another flaw for this chisel

TomD

I completely agree about obtuse angles creating a peculiar side force, but a) the quantity is lower, at 90 degrees it would be 0, and b) part of the problem is just that western chisels do not align the input force. Japanese chisels have the handle angled so the effect is more to spilt the difference like an axe entering wood.