The key to his method
Wiley Horne--So. Calif.
Thanks Ron,
I was curious whether he recommends the same treatment of plane irons as chisels. And he does--identical, I believe. I thought he might differ on plane irons, due to the potential issue of rapid loss of clearance with the convex bevel.
I believe there are two keys to his method:
Key 1: Starting at 30 degrees. Not more. He allows no 'starting creep'. By that, I mean to locate the edge, a beginner might start cheating up to 33, 35, 38, 40 in successive sharpenings, right up to a baffling loss of clearance. But Sellers is locked in on 30. He manages this by using very coarse starting stones.
Key 2: He starts with 200g diamond, if I heard him correctly. Then 800g was it?, then 1200g diamond. Lots of people would start at 800g or 1200g, but he is starting at 200g! By starting at 200g, and reinforcing that with the middle diamond stone, he is absolutely erasing the previous session's wear--all of it--in order to be certain he is back to virgin steel at 30 degrees.
If his irons were examined under a scope, you would find deep scorings from the diamond, which the stropping with CrO will scarcely touch. So I would say, not a refined edge, but definitely a sharp and serviceable one.
His method has the great virtue of erasing all traces of previous wear, which I suspect is the main problem when beginners (not you!) have trouble getting a sharp edge. Indeed, I imagine after the 200g or possibly the 800g diamond, he has the rough equivalent of a machine ground edge.
Thanks for sharing!
Wiley






