New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

Posts

Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#1

Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

Ron Harper

I tried this this morning. 2 Hock plane irons. 4 Stanley 40 chisels. 3 Chas Buck paring chisels.

Long story very short. It works just like he says it does. I used my oil stones , soft Arkansas, hard black Arkansas, and my hard black translucent. Stropped with green stuff on leather. Tried to imitate what you can see on the video. Wicked sharp. Certainly as sharp as I ever got with my 8000 grit King stone, or the dozen or so grits I used in scary sharp. I certainly did not time it, but it does seem quicker to me, and I expect it will get quicker as I do more of it.

As a side note, some of my recently acquired Chas Buck chisels that had not been used had the vertical camber on the edges. Somebody had been using this method a long time ago. Sellers does not claim it other than it is ho he was taught


http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=a6ykVzL2VAM

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#2

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Ron,

Would appreciate if you would keep us apprised how this method works over time.

It strikes me that the critical thing about it, is that you need a very aggressive first stone (soft Arkansas for you, diamond for him), in order to quickly restore the original geometry to the chisel with each new sharpening. In other words, it seems intuitive that the risk is that the convexity will keep increasing over time with new sharpenings. If you can keep that from happening, with vigorous action on the first stone, why should it not work?

Please let us know how you make out with this over time!

Wiley .... who has indeed seen a lot of convex bevels on old arn

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#3

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method

CStanford

Good stuff. Glad you emphasized what I think is/was an often overlooked point when that video first hit the internet - this was how he was taught to hone as an apprentice - which of course implies that's how it was done in the professional shop in which he was employed.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#4

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method

Darren Brewster

It strikes me that the critical thing about it, is that you need a very aggressive first stone (soft Arkansas for you, diamond for him), in order to quickly restore the original geometry to the chisel with each new sharpening. In other words, it seems intuitive that the risk is that the convexity will keep increasing over time with new sharpenings. If you can keep that from happening, with vigorous action on the first stone, why should it not work?

This does seem to be the most important thing to remember when using this method. Although with practice and careful sharpening, you can keep the bevel from increasing very much, but I think that is some very serious muscle memory.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#5

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method

Patrick Gibbons

I learned this method from Paul in courses in Texas. It does work quite well over time. It is very quick. Every step is important. He has stated outright that it's how craftsmen sharpened for a long time before him. The camber is achieved very easily without much effort. One's natural movement will make it. If things get too out of whack, one can always use a guide to reestablish a known angle. With practice this is less likely. Because sharpening is fast this way, one tends to sharpen more often. Sharpening more often makes a chisel's balance, feel, finish and handle ergonomics more important than how long it will hold an edge. While the steel's quality is important, it becomes less so because the chisel is sharpened before the edge quality is problematic. Initial shaping is a different and longer process.

I have read others state that they have found old chisels in the wild that exhibit this technique. I have not. I've found a lot of chisels in the wild with back bevels and other signs of abuse. I think sharpening has always been a problem for many.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#6

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method

CStanford

While it is admittedly a small sample, every old chisel I've ever bought had a convex bevel, and all the old chisels I've ever bought were British brands.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#7

How he was taught

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I suffered through the entire video and nowhere does he say this is how he was taught. There is no evidence that deliberate convexity is a historic or traditional method and there is lots of evidence to the contrary.

There is a feeling that a beginner ought to produce professional results right away, at least after an all day workshop, and if he doesn't, it must be that he isn't using the right trick. If this video helps some not to be ashamed that their bevels are noticeably convex, it is a good thing.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#8

We must be seeing different history


Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#9

Re: How he was taught

Marhk

I suggest: Go back to the Chris Schwarz blog where he released preliminary data about the blade edges in the Studley Chest.

http://blog.lostartpress.com/2012/11/08/the-cutting-edges-of-h-o-studley/

They are mostly all sharpened with a convex bevel.

It has always been my contention that any hand sharpened blade (no guide) will have by nature some degree of convexity. A human can't absolutely hold a blade to a flat bevel - nor did the old guys try to. Sellers' technique simply accepts that fact. I wish someone would do a more quantitative evaluation of edge life vs. bevel shape. My perception is that sharpness can quickly be achieved with hand sharpening (and per Sellers' technique accepting the convexity - but not necessarily trying to achieve it). The jury is out on edge life. There may be a friction-heat effect that degrades the convex bevel faster.

I surely agree that (as I have said before) the key to the hand sharpening technique is to quickly "find" the edge by starting at a coarse stone - also as taught by Sellers. It's satisfying to quickly resharpen without a jig. I most times do that but in reality the Charlesworth guide and micro bevel technique is probably faster until the bevel wears down and you come to the regrind step which does take a while.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#10

Studley probably a quack too

Ron Harper

:D :D

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#11

Hollow grinds and bevels

Bill Tindall

I think it may indeed be possible to not make a convex bevel when sharpening a hollow ground bevel on a very flat abrasive surface. At least on the cast iron plate or the fine fixed diamond plate I think I can feel the bevel sucked onto the surface where it seems to be securely registered. The engagement of two perfectly flat surfaces, in our case abrasive and bevel, should result in attraction, especially if there is a wetting liquid between them.

The knife people have thoroughly researched convex bevels and seem to like them and claim more robustness. I have been quizzed by knife makers as to why woodworkers don't use them. Yet another research topic to be explored. Probably someone that was good at grant writing could make a good living researching these topics.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#12

Re: How he was taught

James Watriss

It's very possible for humans to make perfectly flat bevels. I've seen a number of Japanese, or Japanese-trained, woodworkers do it on a regular basis. It is a skill, for sure, and definitely the result of training and practice. But the skill isn't THAT hard to learn, and it's how I was taught to sharpen my Japanese chisels.

Hollow grind freehand is much easier, learned that at NBSS.

Brings to mind the old saying... 'Those who say something can't be done, should get out of the way of the people who are actually doing it.'

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#13

Re: Hollow grinds and bevels

david weaver

Robustness is only the product of having a more blunt final angle.

It's novel for someone who absolutely can't have a grinder. For anyone who can, it makes no sense to me other than just doing something to play.

The edge will be no better, and it will take longer to do it.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#14

Re: How he was taught

david weaver

It's not terribly difficult to hone a very flat bevel on a chisel, even without a guide. The only exception to that being very narrow chisels.

If someone *wanted* to do that without a grinder on western chisels (which leaves me wondering why they would), side sharpening or anything close to it )working askew) makes it pretty easy to do it. Any convexity goes across the width of the bevel, but because most anything 3/8ths or wider doesn't rock much, there's little of it.

Unless it's for play, I don't know why anyone would want to go without a grinder, the exception being if you actually depended on the convex bevel to moderate something.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#15

Re: How he was taught

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I use a grinder for everything with the exception of the narrow chisels, say 1/4" and under. The narrow ones don't get ground down because it's way too easy for me to muck them up, especially a 1/8" Berg. Not too many of those around.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#16

Do they have to be wrong?

Ron Harper

Does someone who does things in a different manner have to be wrong? There are lot of folks who want to learn how a master craftsman does things. Can he not tell them without having his sanity or methods questioned? I think the quality of the work produced by those methods should weigh the most in evaluating the methods.

If you want to cut dovetails with a chainsaw, it is OK by me, if your dovetails are good. I may choose another method. Does not mean you must be wrong.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#17

Something else to consider

Ron Harper

I believe that very few of those whom we would honor with the term Master Craftsman care much about metallurgy, or the theory of perfect edge attainment. They want a wicked sharp edge, and they want it very quickly. Many of them have chosen different paths to achieve this. They all have one thing in common. They work and they work very well. They do not have the time or need to seek perfection. They are too busy making gorgeous things from wood.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#18

Question for Patrick

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Patrick,

Thanks for relating your personal knowledge of Paul Sellers' methods. Right now, we're talking about his method for chisels; how does he recommend sharpening plane irons, say, ordinary bench plane irons?

Thanks, Wiley

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#19

we have several master craftsmen on this board

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Warren is one of them. It would be good to pay attention to what he says, too.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#20

Re: we have several master craftsmen on this board

Ron Harper

He made a statement that is demonstrably incorrect. There are many examples that point to the reality that a lot of folks honed convex bevels into their edge tools. Studley is just one of many.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#21

Re: Do they have to be wrong?

david weaver

I guess it depends on what your objective is. There's always another way to do something, and I understand the objective if either no grinder is available (though I'd rather just hand grind a long shallow primary bevel and make the fine work at a secondary angle), or if riding a curved bevel is wanted.

But if it's just sharpening plane irons to plane and chisels to chop, it just seems like a slower way to get results that likely incorporate a more blunt final angle (which in the case of a plane iron, is exactly what happens when they wear).

Certainly, if someone enjoys it and is pleased with the results, by all means, do it.

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#22

Re: sharp and fast..

david weaver

..I think sharp and fast probably is perfection, isn't it?

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#23

Re: Question for Patrick *LINK*

Ron Harper

Wiley,

I am not Patrick. But this will answer


http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=vvTcReENk9g

Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#24

Pretty darn close David


Re: Experiment and review Sellers honing method *LINK*

#25

Re: Do they have to be wrong?

Ron Harper

We had a misunderstanding a while back, and I really do not want to prolong this apparent disagreement, but yesterday I pared end grain cherry with my chisels, and I cannot imagine needing a better result. This morning I used my planes and they left shimmering finish in cherry.

Take an old chisel and try it just once.

Ron