New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Marking Knife

Posts

Marking Knife

#1

Robert Tutsky

Marking Knife

Robert Tutsky

Lately I've been into this ergonomic thing and realizing I needed a marking knife I thought I would make one.


The handle is maple and the blade is 1/16" thick 01 tool steel. In the past I made a bunch of them out of hacksaw blades. Could make one in less than an hour and had them laying all about the shop. This one I spent more time on paying more attention to the handle. The handle was whittled into a rough shape then rasps and sandpaper to smooth it out. BLO and shellac rubbed out with steel wool is the final finish. It came out feeling comfortable and positive in my hand.

The beveled edge has the tendency to push the blade into a straight edge so I back beveled the reverse edge just a tad. Now the blade won't chew up a ruler or try square.

I didn't feel it necessary to pin the blade as past experience showed me that using epoxy to mount the blade was sufficient.

Re: Marking Knife

#2

I really like that


Re: Marking Knife

#3

Re: Marking Knife

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Nice looking knife. I have an ergonmic marking knife I made 20 years ago mounted the same way and it is holding up just fine. When I shaped mine I kept holding it in my hand to feel for any uncomfortable pressure points and would then carve a bit more and re check. I think once you get a tool so suited to your hand it is almost an extension of your hand.

Robin

Re: Marking Knife

#4

That's a good one

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I made one, similar in shape and intent, a couple years ago, with the blade epoxied in place plus a ferrule at the connection point. It's stayed without budging at all, although I was highly tempted to pin it in place. No need.

Nice job!

Re: Marking Knife

#5

Ellis Walentine

Ergonomics

Ellis Walentine

If you really want to get a custom-ergonomic fit, try rolling up a piece of modeling clay and then pretending it is a marking knife handle. You can then approximate the form of the handle in wood, based on the clay model.

Ellis

Re: Marking Knife

#6

Re: Ergonomics

TomD

True, but it is amazing how often that is tried and does not work out well. Many activities I have been involved in have gone through that phase and come out somewhere else. Basically we are applying force to tools, and that force comes from somewhere, so pushing along bone lines, or hanging off stuff (finger grip on spoke shaves). Generally accommodating the whole hand is not necessarily the right approach.

Archery is one sport where I really got into this, and is very similar to pushing a plane. The ideal grip looks a bit like a deck of cards. The typical modern grip looks more ergonomic. But really only succeeds in selling bows in stores, and can be literally unshootable.

Ergonomics, is undoubtedly an advanced technical concept, but it often gets applied in accordance with incorrect assumptions. Like that a comfortable hand filling grip is more effective. My approach would probably be closer to a pen. But it would not look like there was a lot of value add.

My main concern with marking knives is that they do not cut many fingertip off that encroaches the line. :)