You didn't go nearly far enough...
Denis Chenard in Ottawa
Somehow, something's bugging me here...
Here we are, in a hand tool forum, discussing the merits of Mac vs. Windows...
We're hand tool enthusiasts, right? We could all use tailed routers to do our dovetails instead of the traditional hand-tool way. We could use tenoning jigs, mortisers and dado blades to make our joinery. We could send our table tops to be thickness-sanded on a Timesaver.
But we don't.
Then why are we discussing the merits of "power tools"?
Macs are like a Festool Domino. Impeccably made, does the work, but you'll end up paying an arm and a leg for it... Windows is like a mortiser/tenoning jig approach, it will work, you pay less but that's still a fair amount of dough, and you need to make adjustments to get good results. And you are limited by the tool characteristics (blade width, router bit size, etc.).
Why not go the "hand tool" route?
Linux is like a saw and chisel approach. It's dirt cheap (actually free), you can tweak it any way you want (admittedly some of the tweaking requires expertise, but we're talking special cases here), and it will do anything the other operating systems do, just not with the same software (usually not an issue). Instead of paying for MS Office you can use OpenOffice or LibreOffice (all free) and it will work 99%+ of the time. Some of the best picture and video editing software is Linux-based BTW (and free).
Five years ago, I would probably not have made this suggestion. Linux has many "distributions" (i.e. a specific software package and "eye candy", based on what you want to do), which can make a choice daunting for the newbie; hardware support could be iffy, and the installation process could be intimidating. Nowadays, all you need to do is pop the CD (or USB stick) in the computer, boot from there, and answer four or five questions (your name, the name you want for the machine, password, where are you located (time zone), whether you want to erase the hard disk and install anew or install side-to-side with your current installation (try that with Windows!), and that's about it!
Oh, did I mention that Linux is much faster/more efficient than Windows or Mac? The old machine that you are ready to throw to the trash can be revived into a useful computer by installing Linux.
And did I mention that, because of its architecture, Linux is virus-proof? One less piece of software to pay for, and which will not hog resources.
Although I have a laptop and a netbook that came with Windows installed on them, I almost never (read: once a year?) log on to it. I installed Linux side by side (so I can use either), but am running Linux almost exclusively.
You can even try Linux without committing! Download a "live" installation from your favorite distribution, burn it to a CD/DVD, pop it in your machine, and it will boot without touching anything on your computer. It is much slower because it reads from the optical drive, so it is not indicative of the performance once installed. But it allows to try without commitment, if you decide not to install, shut down the computer, remove the disk/USB key, and reboot to where you were before.
If it sounds like preaching, I guess it does :-)
Think of it, by not having to buy another computer and software, that's more money that can be directed to buying tools! Think about that...
Cheers,
DC