New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Help me choose a spokeshave

Posts

Help me choose a spokeshave

#1

Help me choose a spokeshave

Tony Wilkins

Wanting a spokeshave to help clean up a curve on my current project (The straight edge from Jim Tolpin's New Traditional woodwork). I've done some looking but still haven't decided. I was thinking of a wooden one since I prefer wooden planes but I'm not so sure on a spokeshave I wouldn't want something just a bit heavier. I thought about a kit but then I'd have to buy some more tools to build the kit lol. All I know for sure is want a flat soled.

So metal there's the LV low angle, the 'regular' LV, and the LN boggs. For wooden ones, I've narrowed it down - I think - to the Dave's Shaves and the Woodjoy models. Don't really have a way of trying any of them that I can see.

So can anybody help me sort out which would suit me better?

BTW - haven't been able to get down to the basement to work but hopefully I'll get stronger after going to inpatient neuro rehab I'll be going into soon.

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

Jack Guzman from Maine

Contact Dave at Dave's shaves. I'm sure he can set you on the right path. He's very knowledgeable on spokeshaves and his tools are well made.Most wooden shaves are low angle. They work differently than a typical metal bodied shave.A metal bodied shave works similar to a handplane.Any of the shaves you mentioned are excellent.You have to find the style you need.I have alot of different shaves. I make windsor chairs and that requires much spokeshave use. My favorites are a veritas low angle and a stanley 151. These two shaves perform almost any function I need done.---Jack

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#3

I hate to say this about an LV tool

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

but their low angle shave is not among their best tools, at least in my hands. I find setting the cutting iron a little frustrating; and it's held in entirely by being clamped in place by the blade locking bolts (what they call the "blade stem"). If you work with enthusiasm or hit a hard spot, you can slide the cutting iron right out of the tool.

I should be clear that I've used it only a little; perhaps with more practice, I could make it work. But I find myself going back to my Stanley 52, which fits just fine in my hands.

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#4

I agree

Bill Tindall

I sold the one I owned and was glad to be rid of it. However, the newer shaves with the wooden handles are most satisfactory and I recommend them.

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#5

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave *LINK*

Hank Knight

Take a look at the new (relatively new) Lie-Nielsen #81 Razor Shave - link below. I have an original Stanley 85, a kissing cousin to the 81. It was my favorite spokeshave, but has seen better days. LOML gave me a new LN 81 for my birthday in July. Shipping from LN was delayed for a while, don't know why. It finally arrived several of weeks ago. It's an almost perfect copy of the Stanley and it sports LN's customary excellent fit and finish. I'm back in business. Great shave.

Hank


LN #81 Razor Shave

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#6

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

Tony Wilkins

Thanks for all the ideas. Went back to Dave's FAQ and it was good reading. I want eventually to try my hand at chair making (especially Welsh stick chairs). It seems like ultimately I might want both kinds as they seem to function a little differently.

If I'm reading sources right, the wood shaves are more like a step up from drawknives where the metal version for the most part are like handled smoothing planes.

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#7

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tony

Don't rule out a vintage Stanley #53. They come up on eBay. This is a metal shave with an adjustable mouth. It allows one to rapidly move from a thick to a finish cut.

If you are looking at woodies, include HNT Gordon on your list. These are Australian-made with a Japanese-Malaysian influenced design. They have high cutting angles, and are the shaves I turn to with interlocked grain. They look large and bulky, but are very comfortable and have excellent control. There is a review here:

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolReviews/THE%20HNT%20GORDON%20SPOKESHAVES.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#8

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

Tony Wilkins

Thanks. I'd noticed that earlier when I was searching about Derek. I was just going back and searching around on your site when I came back over and found your response in fact. One of the reasons I wasn't as keen on the vintage Stanleys was the look of the handles. With the nerve damage to my hands they didn't look comfortable. The HNT's, now that I go back and look at them, might be a really good solution for my hand situation. Does HNT send to America very readily?

While I'm at it - dang it Derek, now you have me looking at their dado plane as well ;)

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#9

you are right on handles

Bill Tindall

The Stanley handles are no less an ergonomic failure as the shoulder plane. The metal mouthed LV with its wooden handles are comfy.

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#10

Maybe a matter of grip

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Thanks to a Foine Wouldworking article some years back, I learned to hold the Stanley-type spokeshaves by gripping the body between thumb and index finger and using the handles to keep the other fingers from flopping around. This grip increases sensitivity in sensing where the cutting edge is on the work, and I find it quite comfortable.

Naturally, everyone's mileage varies; this is my experience, maybe not yours.

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#11

Re: Get the video

TomD

I love the 5 LV shaves I have. The low angle one is fine, but that would be the one to lose in favour of a wooden one if you wanted to. My favourite design is the smallish Boggs that LV produced before the design skipped to LN. So I am guessing I would like the LN ones best of all. Particularly if you like wooden planes, then you are comfortable with the superior tap adjust system, and that is how the boggs work. There are other designs like the Kuntz that work that way also, but they are cheap, and not worth the money. The LV ones are bigger, and as such you might be more comfortable with them in the hand. With the curvatures, there is something to be said for owning a variety, as they are perfect fot different edge treatments. Though my Kuntz snapped in the frame, I none the less miss it's particular shape.

If you are going with the grain, get the high angle type.

Since your need is not immediate, I would get the Boggs video, you will learn something from it. Not everyone will have his need, but at least you will gain an insight into his approach to the tool. Since both the LN and LV are in part or in whole based on the Boggs design, it would be money well spent.

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#12

Re: Get the video

William Duffield

One important observation about the L-N Boggs shave: It is for finish work only. You cannot open the mouth wide enough to hog off a lot of material in a hurry, so if you choose the L-N, you will need another shave for the rough work.

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#13

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

Darren Brewster

How does the LN or the Stanley it is based on compare to a wooden spokeshave? I assume this is bevel up too? What does the brass part do? Is it more for fine cuts, or can it hog off wood too? Colour me inexperienced an confused by all the options.

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#14

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave *LINK*

Hank Knight

The brass sole allows you to adjust the depth of cut. It also serves as a wear plate to keep the sole from dishing from repeated use. You can set one side of the shave for a thick cut and the other for a fine cut. This allows you to choose the depth of cut by simply moving the shave from one side to the other - and anything in between. It's a very comforttable shave to use and is very sensitive in the hand. Here's a thread from the archives about the shave before it was introduced for sale:


Lie-Nilesen #81 spokeshave Archive thread

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#15

Re: Get the video

TomD

Which does lead perfectly to the buy both the LN, and the LV, since the LV are coarse, though they have those stopgaps.

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#16

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

Most people don't belive me when I tell them what my favorite spoke shave is, but I have about 10 shaves and my favorite is the one made by x-acto. They are very small and are cast out of a white metal. the blade is about 3/4' wide and it is a bit tricky the set the blade with the slotted screw. But the small size gives you increadable control. I usually start with a larger shave, but almost always end up finishing with one of my three x-acto spoke shaves. They are out of production but they do show up on ebay or at garage sales and usually for under $10 Pay attention to the sole as they come in flat and curved bottom versions.

Robin

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#17

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

Larry Barrett

Tony, if a 'tool event' occurs within an hour or two of where you are, and LV and/or LN are there, you should go and try out the tools they will have on display. And if there is a woodworkers club in your neck of the woods, you could ask around for spokeshaves to try out. That would be the best way to find something you are comfortable with. If you find a style you like, and it is modeled on an older vintage tool, the vintage ones are often available on *bay or from tool dealers, and are very affordable.

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#18

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#19

How do these compare with the bronze shaves... *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

...that lots of folks sell? The link to Lee Valley's offering is below, but I've seen what I assume are identical shaves from other makers.


http://www.leevalley.com/us/wood/page.aspx?p=32681&cat=1,50230&ap=1

Re: Help me choose a spokeshave

#20

David Barnett

The bronzes are okay, but I prefer the X-ACTO