New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

How would you saw the lid for this box?

Posts

Re: How would you saw the lid for this box?

#26

How I would reach a decision.......

Bill Tindall

.....for what little that might be worth.

If I wanted a box and the box was the focus of the effort I would part it on a table saw like a typical jewelry box and forget the angle thing.

If the focus was more on learning a new skill or seeing if I could "do it" and make the result work, then I would saw the angle after the box was glued up.

I would do it on a jigged sled on the table saw with a very thin blade, but that is because I can't saw straight with a hand saw. Or, I might consider parting it with a small router bit and a fence attached to the box. If my hand sawing was up the the task (it isn't) then I might do it that way.

What ever the result skillful hand planing can fix the result as needed.

Re: How would you saw the lid for this box?

#27

Re: How would you saw the lid for this box?

William Duffield

I just thought of something. There is a way to do it, using hot melt glue blocks, instead of wedges and clamps. After cutting two opposing faces, glue them back together with glue blocks on the outside. Just make sure the temp glue blocks don't interfere with the table saw fence. Then saw the other two faces. Finally, remove and clean up the glue blocks.

Re: How would you saw the lid for this box?

#28

Re: Update

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Holy Cow! That's more gorgeous than I first saw!

The first problem is that the angled cut line passes through the loose join. So to preserve the angled cut, you either have to relocate the angled cut, or else fix the join. I don't think you would want to leave an unsound join in such an amazing box.

You can make a quite good repair by picking out a 1/8" blade for your LV hand router and a 1/8" chisel that matches; ver-r-r-y carefully-y-y knife in a 1/8" channel (i would fence this knifing, as it would have to be truly on the money); dig out the channel with the router, finishing the ends with the chisel, as you cannot ding the pin board edge; then glue in a grain-matched strip that is tight enough you have to lightly hammer it in, using a water-based glue that will expand the grain slightly so it looks "growed together". Then proceed.

There is the conceptual option of sawing the box apart on the angle, then fixing the join from the inside; but it would be hell to try to get at it from the inside.

Everything considered, I come to these facts and recommendations :) :

1. You have a most beautiful box.

2. Saw it apart with table saw right down the middle of the join line, and now you have a perfectly sound and beautiful box. Hinge it.

3. Enjoy what you made!

4. Continue with the rest of your life. There is much more to do and think about.

Wiley

Re: How would you saw the lid for this box?

#29

Cyanoacrylate joints

Bill Tindall

I have had no success repairing a crack to original wood strength by wicking this glue into it. Furthermore, this adhesive is not permanent. It was never designed for gluing wood permanently and it doesn't ( it was intended for aircraft canopies but that is another story).

Re: How would you saw the lid for this box?

#30

Re: Update

David Charlesworth

If I understand correctly, the join would surely have to be one plane, or it won't be possible to plane it?

David

Re: How would you saw the lid for this box?

#31

Re: Cyanoacrylate joints

TomD

I am cautious about this stuff. I just had a major project fail on the crack repair front, not really a surprise, but I have had success before.

However, most modern guitars, or for a while there, have a lot of Cyano in them. There are major structural parts like the binding that get cyanoed, and it is used a lot in repairs. There is maybe a trend to hide glue for the moment. Guitars unlike violins, perhaps, have a problem with longevity, and they have also had lots of perishable material put in them like ivoroid and sprayed finish so there is a history of making them out of junk, an openness to unproven materials.

Obviously there is a lot of cyano work in turning

Re: How would you saw the lid for this box?

#32

Fixing the join

James Watriss

Get the cut made first. You're going to fit bracketed for blades and plane inside the box, they can be designed to reinforce the join, and since it's hide glue, it'll be easily fixable anyway.

I say, pattern routing or hand saw against a guide block.

Re: How would you saw the lid for this box?

#33

Re: Fixing the join

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

(insert sound of hand wacking my forehead)

Of course! - the inside of the side is planned to be lined with a holder for the 8 blades, 4 on each side of the box. Glueing that to the side will reinforce the side where the glued join has failed. Back on track. I'll post pics next weekend.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: How would you saw the lid for this box?

#34

;-)


Re: How would you saw the lid for this box?

#35

Too late now

Lars Parrington

but, I think this is a good idea, so I'll mention it anyway. I would have mostly made the cuts before glue-up. Cut a kerf just less than half-way through the thickness from each side of each board. Leave just enough material that the boards won't break apart by accident. Glue the box up, and then finish the cuts with a utility knife. In this way you could have had the front and back square with the sides at an angle.

I suppose it would also work to cut kerfs all the way through the boards thickness, but not full length. Cut a few inches in from each edge of each board, leaving a few inches at the center of each board uncut until after assembly. Those last few inches could easily be cut with the tip of a handsaw.

Both methods would essentially allow you to do the cutting before assembly, while still insuring a perfect fit between top and bottom.