New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

Posts

Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#1

Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

Bill Tindall

I have had the belly to the bench in earnest of late finishing up the drawers. The recent discussions of benches got me to thinking, and there is plenty of time for that while tediously whittling away dovetail waste, and made me realize that the details of the bench will fundamentally determine how one does woodworking.

For those that have built furniture for some years and then built the bench of their dreams this fact needs little consideration. These people will probably know what features they like and require, or don't. For those where the bench is the first furniture project,realize that its details will, for better or worse, force you to do common furniture building tasks to accommodate the bench design and fixtures. If a bench is built according to the standards of some long ago period one may be constrained to adapt the techniques of the period, which may be the whole idea, or not.

I will use my "unconventional" bench as an example. I do not in any way mean to sell its features but rather to use them as examples of how a bench's features determine how furniture is made.

My bench has lots of acreage; it is 43" wide. As a result it accommodates the tools I am working with as well as what I am working on. A narrow bench will require some other place to put tools in use- shelves, chest, etc.

My bench, for historical reasons, has a quick release vise on each end. Because the vise opening can be quickly adjusted and it opens wide I fasten stuff in the vise that a traditional bench would fasten other ways on the top. I support long stuff between the vises, for example while breaking down 12' longer into cuttings because I don't have the front peg holes like would be found on a traditional bench.

Personally, I could not live without a quick release vise because of the many ways I use a vise. Other styles of benches must conveniently accomplish these tasks some other way because it is tedious screwing a traditional vise in and out even 2" never mind 10". I worked a bit in a shop with a traditional vise and I was ready to slit my wrists after a bit. I noted that its owner replaced it with a quick release, maybe as a result of my complaining.

One fundamental difference between today and 1720 is the availability of cheap and handy clamps. I built my bench with a huge overhang to accommodate my huge collection of clamps. Because my bench lacks most of the holding features of traditional benches I must use clamps for fixing parts to the bench. For example,



my version of the Moxom vise consists of the quick release vise and two clamps. I suffer no loss of capability or convenience. A traditional Roubo bench with its thick top would not enable handy sized F style clamps to be used for clamping parts. This bench would employ other means to accomplish fixing parts to the bench, perhaps better, perhaps not.

My bench would be near useless for planing large panels. It is too wide. And I have no means of fixing long stock for surface planing or molding. But, I don't do either of these tasks, either because I can't due to bench limitations, or don't want to so the bench wasn't made with this capability (chicken-egg, egg-chicken).

My bench is cupped up about 1/8". I have an old oak "library desk" in the shop where I do final assembly. It is flat, or sufficiently so. So I never fretted the lack of flatness of the bench. I am probably not skilled and or patient enough to flatten it anyway so I accommodate the needs for an assembly surface some other way.

So, should the furniture maker make some before building the bench of their dreams? Or, is the bench design irrelevant for the furniture builder will adapt to what ever features the bench has? Don't know. But I do know that the bench will determine the details of how one makes furniture, so at least consider this fact before chasing the bench fashion of the day.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#2

Thanks Bill, very interesting points to consider.


Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#3

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

roger lance

Bench design does have a real influence on what type of work you do and the way you are able to do that work. But there are a multitude of other factors which may influence your bench design (I'll not try to list them all here). One which had a significant impact on me was shop size and lay out. I originally wanted a free standing bench that I could work around on all four sides but all the shop layout solutions I devised indicated that a bench against a wall was going to give me the optimal use of floor space and the length of that wall helped determine the length of the bench. I liked Shaker style benches for hand tool storage, Record metal face vises, and old school tail vises for clamping between dogs. So I played with those parameters until I came up with a solution.....


In addition, I also built an assembly table that I can get glue, water, and stain on and not particularly worry. It also gives me added storage and a flat clamping surface.....


The two are partners in making things and are but one solution to the need for a bench.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#4

Re: Coincidences, or Not?

William Duffield

I have the same quick release vise as yours, and the same Jorgensen hand screws, and before I installed the Moxon/Benchcrafted knockoff on my meta-bench, I used the same method as you for holding dovetails while sawing. One minor difference: I used another handscrew instead of the big F-clamp to hold down the right side of the "moxon".

Also, the same double square, the same Pilot marking pen and same dovetail saw. The pen is not a coincidence: Your recommendation on that from several years ago was spot-on.

The meta-bench now also solves the problem of holding stock vertically on the front face of the bench. But I solved that problem a long time ago with a specially designed board jack. My bench top floats, it has a wide overhang all around, my frame has upper and lower stretchers, and the rear jaw of the face vise is proud of the front of the bench.


As can be seen, the board jack has an upper bracket that hooks over the back of the upper stretcher, a rabbet on a lower bracket that rides on the top front of the lower stretcher, and it extends up the front face of the bench top and is the same thickness at the top as the rear vise chop.

Yeah, I know, too many dog holes, especially when you consider the dog sitting on top of the bench, which has four different offsets from the center of the dowel. To adjust the height support, I just rotate it 90° or 180°. Also, it's only 3/4" thick red oak, so I can't use a holdfast in it.

I'll reiterate Bill's idea: I am not recommending you build your bench like this one. I'm just showing how a little ingenuity can overcome serious problems, and maybe allow you to spend your time making furniture instead of building new and better benches (or tool boxes) every few months, like the Schwarz does :) .

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#5

Assembly bench & back bench

Steve Elliott

Most of my woodworking has been done in commercial shops where someone else set up the work stations. Your combination of a taller bench against a wall and a lower bench for assembly is the most common configuration, and in my opinion the most useful.

The taller bench has vises and is good for close-up work, either with hand tools or with a sander. It puts the workpiece at a convenient distance and with good lighting it helps get the piece in good final shape for assembly.

The lower bench is good for setting up a router table, which would be too high if clamped to the tall bench. It also lets one or more workers clamp up a larger piece quickly. Unlike the tall bench, the assembly bench doesn't need a great deal of mass (which is needed for, say, mortising with a chisel).

Your shop setup does a number of things well: storage, work surfaces, flexibility. It also looks great. Nice job!

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#6

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

TomD

"The recent discussions of benches got me to thinking, and there is plenty of time for that while tediously whittling away dovetail waste, and made me realize that the details of the bench will fundamentally determine how one does woodworking."

There is some truth in that, but for the most part a bench is a piece of wood on top of trestles, with possibly a vise or some other fixtures accommodated, it really shouldn't grab you by the you know whats. In particular, while power tool guys may have fancy benches for the same kind of reasons that a fan has a t-shirt from a stones concert, there does not seem to be a real power tool bench. While stationary tools do not require a bench for their functions, there are dozens of power hand tools that require a 3rd hand, possibly in order to retain the attachment of the other two hands. But we do not have that kind of thing. Point being, the bench argument is already clear of the major rift in woodworking, the power vs hand thing, so whether one uses both or only one, the bench is not a casualty in any of those tensions.

"For those that have built furniture for some years and then built the bench of their dreams this fact needs little consideration. These people will probably know what features they like and require, or don't. For those where the bench is the first furniture project,realize that its details will, for better or worse, force you to do common furniture building tasks to accommodate the bench design and fixtures. If a bench is built according to the standards of some long ago period one may be constrained to adapt the techniques of the period, which may be the whole idea, or not."

Again, partly true. If the Roubo was an architectural bench, then maybe it should not be in every cabinet shop in stout little shorty version. But given that a bench is just a board on some trestles, people are free to fall into line with pretty much any fancy without loosing anything too great in the way of functionality. The biggest problem to early bench building is probably getting the size wrong, that is a little hard to deal with later, particularly length, and most popular designs are too short. But people seem to like making benches, it is easy and fast and enormously satisfying, and cheap if you lay in the wood for 2.0 shortly after completing 1.0.

" A narrow bench will require some other place to put tools in use- shelves, chest, etc."

Yeah, and with a narrow bench on can actually reach the wall than most home benches are against and get at the neatly racked tools.

"My bench, for historical reasons, has a quick release vise on each end."

"Personally, I could not live without a quick release vise because of the many ways I use a vise."

Can't argue too much with that, though it is the feature I use the least on my Tucker vise which has both a pedal and a hand release. As with our dovetailing, most work is one turn to the left, one turn to the right, and actually sub quick release granularity of adjustment. One thing I ponder about the quick release, and other super feature vises, whether they need to be on the bench at all. I would like to have room for a vise pedestal.

" Other styles of benches must conveniently accomplish these tasks some other way because it is tedious screwing a traditional vise in and out even 2" never mind 10". I worked a bit in a shop with a traditional vise and I was ready to slit my wrists after a bit. I noted that its owner replaced it with a quick release, maybe as a result of my complaining."

That is a bit of an extreme though. It does happen, but unless your job is manufacturing 2x5x10 blocks, probably not all that often. Anyway, very few modern workers use wooden screw vises. I would not discount them, but they are not that common. And there are quick release screws for all the conventional vise forms, so it isn't as though one couldn't have a Klauzs all tricked out with quick releases.

"One fundamental difference between today and 1720 is the availability of cheap and handy clamps. I built my bench with a huge overhang to accommodate my huge collection of clamps. Because my bench lacks most of the holding features of traditional benches I must use clamps for fixing parts to the bench."

Yeah... This is your way of saying that while you believe passionately in quick release vises, you also believe passionately in slow to adjust vises that have to be built every time you use them... OK...

"For example,my version of the Moxom vise consists of the quick release vise and two clamps. I suffer no loss of capability or convenience."

Busted! Yeah you do, though probably not capacity. I think though that you have a good approach to your work. I see zero reason to believe that the older classic 2 vise benches have been superseded by "flexible" designs. But what has changed is the fact that in modern shops many of us span ten trades. If you watch FK work drawers in his shop at 20 minutes, per, I don't think it is the vise that slow him down, but he isn't building trimarans, bicycles, toys hay rakes, etc... So one might need a little more flexibility in a home shop. But here is where the argument falls through. Even assuming one takes on all furniture tasks on the same bench, it rarely needs to be any longer than ceiling height, and if you find conventional benches too restrictive in size between the vises all you need to do is add a foot or two, at far less cost than 43" depth.

"A traditional Roubo bench with its thick top would not enable handy sized F style clamps to be used for clamping parts. This bench would employ other means to accomplish fixing parts to the bench, perhaps better, perhaps not."

I don't know about a Roubo, most of them are not all that thick in their modern versions, but I have benches 4+ inches thick, and have no problem with clamping. Plush you have hold downs, and holes to fixture through, dogs to grab between, I seen nothing you can do I can't do better.

"So, should the furniture maker make some before building the bench of their dreams? Or, is the bench design irrelevant for the furniture builder will adapt to what ever features the bench has? Don't know. But I do know that the bench will determine the details of how one makes furniture, so at least consider this fact before chasing the bench fashion of the day."

Definitely bench first, you can't use most hand tools properly without some degree of bench capability, or shaving horse, etc... There is a reason in boxing why they don't let you put the guy in the corner and pummel him, but it is perfectly fine to trap your opponent in cabinetmaking. I don't think the bench design is irrelevant, but for the most part people are doing cabinetmaking with tools of the 19th century era, so benches from that trade, and that period should serve. I don't really buy that the bench determines the details of how you make furniture, unless by details you mean stuff like using clamps versus vises, but that is the details of the bench, not the furniture.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#7

Re: Assembly bench & back bench +1

TomD

I think the bench is massive and it needs to be at a height were muscle and weight can be flung at it, that is probably lowish, but it depends on your tools, handles on planes etc... Then there is a low assembly table. The third height is the dovetail chopping height, for quick work on drawers and so forth. A height adjustably bench would be nice, but probably bench top fixtures, etc... are more practical for most. Or the Joinery bench fad.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#8

Adaptability is key

Ron Harper

We change. Our benches will need to accommodate to our changes, or we will need to build another. Schwarz and many others have said a bench is simply a holding device to hold stock secure while you do what you need to do it. If your bench does that. It is a good bench. Other considerations are secondary. I just in the past couple of days moved my shop. No my work holding needs have not changed.. BUT.. I am not sure that I am going to find a storage solution for planes that I like without using some of the space under my new bench. I have spent some time today sketching ideas that combine a Roubo type construction with some drawers to store planes that will be used at that bench. I will not sacrifice the ability to use holdfasts. I can store a lot of planes in two runs of two drawers near the floor with a gap above them that permits holdfast usage. I now have a bench that will become a dedicated joinery station with Moxon vise, bench hooks, shooting board, etc. it will be 42 in high and against a wall. It is 7 ft long and 22 in wide and 3.5 in thick. My new bench will be 32 in tall 8 ft long by 2 ft wide by at least 4 in thick and used for planing and some assembly. Still have a couple of weeks to stew on the new bench as I cannot start on it till Nov 15 or so.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#9

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

James Watriss

I think it's a mix.

Most folks start with what they have on hand, or is provided to them. For me, that was a series of small, simple benches.

Over time, and with experience, I've come to see the merits in a variety of bench styles and appliances. Flat bench tops are mandatory for me, as references, and for surfaces to clamp laminations to while gluing. Similarly, Some procedures evolve over time, and the fixtures evolve with them. Or, they'll get to a point where I'm suddenly noticing aspects of various benches that I hadn't before.

I think my skills evolve side by side with my tools... See my thread on tool tweaking. I think it gets to the point where the vast majority of the procedural habit becomes static, and you tweak what you need in the bench over time as the needs demand.

Re: quick release... I hear you. But I LOVE my Emmert.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#10

Re: Adaptability is key

William Duffield

There is a solution to the under-bench-storage vs. holdfast usage dichotomy. Cut the bottom of the post off the holdfasts. Joel's are inexpensive enough (and easy enough to cut) that you can afford to have more than one pair, in different lengths, for different thicknesses of stock.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#11

Re: Another option

TomD

is go bars, then one does not have to do unspeakable things to the bench.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#12

Dovetail set up

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have never before seen such a Rube Goldberg dovetail set up. Hard to believe it could be called "convenient". It takes me two or three seconds to get a drawer side secured for dovetailing and three seconds to switch it to dovetail the other end. My big bench screw has only 2 threads per inch; it takes only a quarter turn to release or secure.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#13

Agree wholeheartedly

Ron Harper

Bill and others. With low benches. Build a Moxon vise. They are cheap to build with veneer press screws. They work quickly. They grip like grim death and they make cutting dovetails more comfortable. I also believe that causes better work. They are also wonderful for work on chair seats, cabinet doors, etc.

I have found that my sawing really has improved.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#14

Thanks William

Ron Harper

I had wondered about that. Is there a choke point, past which one does not travel?

I think my current design will solve my storage need, but, I will certainly keep pruning holdfasts as an option.

Ron

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#15

You need to study it more......

Bill Tindall

To release the drawer side the vise handle is rotated 1/2 turn and the wooden clamp screw is rotated 1/2 turn and the drawer side drops out. Repeat to install a new side. Not a burdensome task.

To install Mr. Goldberg one lays the wooden clamp on the bench, the jaw on the F clamp is slid up tight on the wooden clamp and the clamp handle tightened. Done. Reverse order to remove and store handily where clamps are stored. Nothing additional to make or store. All parts multitasking.

The additional clamps are a crutch. I clamp a scrap across the back scribe line to prevent over sawing the back scribe line. Someday I may build enough drawers at one time, or within a short time, that I may not find this crutch useful. But the last drawers I built were 6 months ago and those skills have become rusty.

By the way, someone disparaged my clamps. The F style clamps are mostly quick release; all mine are. I have a fine collection of C clamps which I rarely use any more because they are not quick release. I even have F clamps that can be secured one handed, courtesy of Lee Valley.

Now the vise. At some point the half blinds need to be worked on with the drawer front more of less flat. No doubt you have some handy way to fix the front to the bench. Because I have a quick release vise I have another way. I pull the vise out and capture the drawer front in the vise jaws at an ergonomically handy up-tilted angle and pare away.

Because my vise pulls out quickly to enable the capture of wide material I use the vise for this task. It is impractical to wind a threaded vise in and out 8' to work on a drawer face then an edge edge, so those with no-release vises adapt other ways of holding wide stuff.

My valid point is that a quick release vise enables its practical use for tasks others accomplish by other means. I rarely use a bench hook, maybe because I have a quick release vise. I have F clamps within an arms reach of the bench because I use them routinely for fixing stuff to the overhang of the bench. I am not advocating my approach is better. Not yielding that it is worse either. As lazy as I am I usually find the most efficient way to accomplish something within the bounds of my skills.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#16

Of course it works

Ron Harper

Just suggesting that there might be an easier way to do it.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#17

can't argue with success

Bill Tindall

Contrary to most folks I start a dovetail cut on the back edge of the vertically held drawer side. I have learned to lift the saw slightly to take some weight off the teeth and the cut therefore starts smoothly. Then I can drop the blade precisely across the top scribe line to start the cut for this orientation. I find getting the saw located precisely on the top scribe line more difficult than getting the vertical cut precise.

My approach would be difficult with the drawer located higher than I typically have it. On the other hand I may have adapted the more conventional front edge start if the drawer side was located higher.

Anyone ever seen Al Breed do a drawer? It will be an enlightening experience should you get the chance.

And another calibration, first hand from an English tradesman. Six drawers per day was the quota in the furniture factory- mahogany fronts, oak sides.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#18

Re: Another option

William Duffield

What is unspeakable? Surely not shortening a holdfast? Maybe putting storage cabinets under the bench? A bench is just a tool, and all tools are kits.

And then, there is the problem of the "cathedral" ceiling over my bench, not to mention the wooden dinghy that hangs up there, so go bars wouldn't work for me. Where they do work, however, they can be a very practical work holding strategy.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#19

Re: Thanks William

William Duffield

The holdfast needs to go all the way through the top. Otherwise the bottom edge of the holdfast will gouge the inside of the dog hole and wear it out. So, the minimum length depends on the thickness of the bench plus the thickness or the stock you are trying to hold down plus the thickness of any pad used to protect the work from the holdfast. Probably, the whole suggestion is too much bother to try to deal with.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#20

Re: Of course it works

William Duffield

Another way to do it is to lay an F-ckamp or a pipe clamp across the bench top turn the faces about 45° degrees to the vertical, and clamp the board to the front face of the bench top. It might be quicker than Bill's setup for one or two drawers. If you have a tool tray, clamp it to the front face of the tray, because the clamp would put too much pressure on the usually thin back board of the tray. Also, a shorter clamp will suffice.

The front boards of the Nicholson bench are thick enough to use a holdfast instead. Many other traditional bench designs, including the Roubo, use holes in the front legs for holdfasts.

An additional disadvantage of using clamps, instead of holdfasts or a Moxon, is that there is a lot more clamping hardware sticking out the front of the bench, that you have to walk around.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#21

Re: You need to study it more......

TomD

"To release the drawer side the vise handle is rotated 1/2 turn and the wooden clamp screw is rotated 1/2 turn and the drawer side drops out. Repeat to install a new side. Not a burdensome task."

Think of the hundred percent additional work you are doing compared to a double front screw like the Lee Valley!

"Now the vise. At some point the half blinds need to be worked on with the drawer front more of less flat. No "oubt you have some handy way to fix the front to the bench. Because I have a quick release vise I have another way. I pull the vise out and capture the drawer front in the vise jaws at an ergonomically handy up-tilted angle and pare away."

Not sure why you do that, but the Tucker vise has a handy feature where you can rotate the jaws so they are parallel to the floor, and then can't then at any angle, so you can have them fully adjusted for angle either parallel to the front of the bench, or perpendicular.

"Because my vise pulls out quickly to enable the capture of wide material I use the vise for this task. It is impractical to wind a threaded vise in and out 8' to work on a drawer face then an edge edge, so those with no-release vises adapt other ways of holding wide stuff."

8' is a bit much, but for more conventional openings, one can easily do them with a screw, and the older screws had a fair pitch to make it quicker. Quick release vises like the Record, exaggerate the time it takes because, given the release they have a finer pitch.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#22

Re: Another option

TomD

Drilling holes in my bench. I like your Swiss cheese bench, but I would not want to drill holes in my bench. And as you mention it, I do not much want to cut off expensive hooks, though I would probably make my own, in which case it would be OK.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#23

Re: can't argue with success

TomD

"Anyone ever seen Al Breed do a drawer? It will be an enlightening experience should you get the chance."

Is he another member of your woodworking club. I took the Rough Cuts video on making a shaker stool out of the library. And his segment on dovetails was noteworthy. I'd like to see it again, but what I mostly remember is that he used mini speciality benches to do the various steps. He had outfitted his shop in stations which is a production technique. Basically when you know you will do certain steps over an over, a general bench approach is less effective. So it is somewhat contrary to the approach of using clamps to scab everything together.

When building guitars which involves repeating many steps over and over, one way to expand production is to create a workstation for every single step, and either staff up or move from station to station. General furniture making, is a more diverse activity, but there are certain kinds of joint that warrant specialization for some.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#24

Re: Another option

William Duffield

There are certainly operational disadvantages to extra dog holes, but so far I don't notice any structural problems. Of course, the aesthetics of Swiss cheese are personal.

Small parts tend to fall through the dog holes. But, I think if I had even only one hole in my bench, small parts would roll three feet to fall through it.

When I need a brass bench dog, I have no idea which dog hole I put it in, and waste time searching for it.

Sometimes, I want to put the holdfast in a specific hole, but find that it is already occupied by a chisel, or a carving gouge, or a screwdriver, or an awl, or a marking gauge, or a file, or a striking knife, or something else I should have put away instead of dropping it in the closest convenient empty dog hole. And, I don't even know which chisel it is, because all the handles look the same, and I can't see the blade below the bench, like I can if it's hanging in the rack.

If I put a holdfast in a few of the dog holes, they interfere with the vise, and I can't open it, or I can't close it.

Re: Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken

#25

Interesting bench--Dominy workshop

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

A few years ago, Chris Schwartz took a photo of the Dominy workshop bench. From mid-1700's, East Hampton NY. Since relocated to Winterthur Museum in Delaware.

Here is Chris' text, with photo of bench at bottom of page:

http://blog.lostartpress.com/2007/10/24/the-dominy-workbench-under-glass/

Roubo heft; big twin-screw vise is integral.

FYI.

Wiley