Benches- chicken-egg; egg-chicken
Bill Tindall
I have had the belly to the bench in earnest of late finishing up the drawers. The recent discussions of benches got me to thinking, and there is plenty of time for that while tediously whittling away dovetail waste, and made me realize that the details of the bench will fundamentally determine how one does woodworking.
For those that have built furniture for some years and then built the bench of their dreams this fact needs little consideration. These people will probably know what features they like and require, or don't. For those where the bench is the first furniture project,realize that its details will, for better or worse, force you to do common furniture building tasks to accommodate the bench design and fixtures. If a bench is built according to the standards of some long ago period one may be constrained to adapt the techniques of the period, which may be the whole idea, or not.
I will use my "unconventional" bench as an example. I do not in any way mean to sell its features but rather to use them as examples of how a bench's features determine how furniture is made.
My bench has lots of acreage; it is 43" wide. As a result it accommodates the tools I am working with as well as what I am working on. A narrow bench will require some other place to put tools in use- shelves, chest, etc.
My bench, for historical reasons, has a quick release vise on each end. Because the vise opening can be quickly adjusted and it opens wide I fasten stuff in the vise that a traditional bench would fasten other ways on the top. I support long stuff between the vises, for example while breaking down 12' longer into cuttings because I don't have the front peg holes like would be found on a traditional bench.
Personally, I could not live without a quick release vise because of the many ways I use a vise. Other styles of benches must conveniently accomplish these tasks some other way because it is tedious screwing a traditional vise in and out even 2" never mind 10". I worked a bit in a shop with a traditional vise and I was ready to slit my wrists after a bit. I noted that its owner replaced it with a quick release, maybe as a result of my complaining.
One fundamental difference between today and 1720 is the availability of cheap and handy clamps. I built my bench with a huge overhang to accommodate my huge collection of clamps. Because my bench lacks most of the holding features of traditional benches I must use clamps for fixing parts to the bench. For example,
my version of the Moxom vise consists of the quick release vise and two clamps. I suffer no loss of capability or convenience. A traditional Roubo bench with its thick top would not enable handy sized F style clamps to be used for clamping parts. This bench would employ other means to accomplish fixing parts to the bench, perhaps better, perhaps not.
My bench would be near useless for planing large panels. It is too wide. And I have no means of fixing long stock for surface planing or molding. But, I don't do either of these tasks, either because I can't due to bench limitations, or don't want to so the bench wasn't made with this capability (chicken-egg, egg-chicken).
My bench is cupped up about 1/8". I have an old oak "library desk" in the shop where I do final assembly. It is flat, or sufficiently so. So I never fretted the lack of flatness of the bench. I am probably not skilled and or patient enough to flatten it anyway so I accommodate the needs for an assembly surface some other way.
So, should the furniture maker make some before building the bench of their dreams? Or, is the bench design irrelevant for the furniture builder will adapt to what ever features the bench has? Don't know. But I do know that the bench will determine the details of how one makes furniture, so at least consider this fact before chasing the bench fashion of the day.



.


