New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

Posts

Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#1

Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

James Watriss

It's occurred to me recently that I've been WWing for 9 years... And I'm still fussing over my tools. Sharpening and tuning up Bailey planes has moved on to ripping apart infill planes, I'm looking at other tools with an ever more critical eye, (My HNT Gordon try plane needs one of the abutments filed... It's twisted two lever cap wedges in half.) and on, and on, to ever higher levels of fussiness.

I won't even get into the incessant jig designing obsession...

At what point does the fully satisfied with the tools part kick in?

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#2

Nope. Not if you care


Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#3

Just think of all the skills and knowledge....

roger lance

you are developing due to your obsession/tweaking....if you are setting your mind to designing jigs, that's problem solving.....thats a capability that will do you well in the future.....not everyone has that ability.

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#4

Answer....

Bill Tindall

"At what point does the fully satisfied with the tools part kick in?"

Answer: when your clients are calling each day asking when their XXX will be delivered and you need a new truck(or other).

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#5

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever

Brian from Monument

A way that I use to evaluate the tweaking of tools of any type is to ask one question.

Is the tweaking I am doing the result of a failure/shortcoming of the tool or a consideration for perfection by the one tool in the shop that may need an alignment correction?

In other words am I doing the tweaking because i like to tweak (obsessive tweaking disorder) or does the tool not perform correctly and I am seeking a higher level of performance.

A final consideration is is this a quest for the last 1 % of performance increase that will take lots of work to achieve.

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#6

craigd

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever

craigd

It stops when you have so many of the same type of tool, if the one you are using needs a tweak, you just grab another.

For example, today I was working on table leg beads and went through three planes to get the "perfect" one for the job.

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

easy answer

Jack Guzman from Maine

When all your tools are perfect.---Jack

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#8

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever

CStanford

I'll butcher the original verbiage of the Voltaire quote thusly:

"The perfect is the enemy of the good [enough]."

Sanity starts with getting rid of redundant tools. Then you move on from there.

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#9

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever

TomD

I've been at it 35 years and I haven't stopped yet. I think it depends what is driving the tweaking, other than the immediate task at hand.

- Back in the late 70s, we did idiotic stuff like flatten plane soles on plates of glass with sandpaper. Not because they weren't perfect, but because they were so bad they were unusable without heavy work. Today that is no longer necessary.

Another fool's errant from that time frame, was reconditioning antique tools of user quality. Today one could buy several brands new, or make them from scratch for about the same time and money.

So one hopes that will no longer be a burden.

- There is all the work it takes to set up a shop. If you want a lot of hand tools for different purposes this is somewhat inevitable. Admittedly there are a lot of tools today, that are not only not in need of a lot of work to get to the starting line, but come sharpened. I found out a few years back that people actually send their EDC knives back to the factory for sharpening. And there are some disposable tools also, I guess. So while there is always work fettling tools, today one can buy some of the tools ready to go. Though they are not always prepared to one's taste.

Now for the arguably sketchy stuff, or I guess for some people, the fun part.

- Endless fiddling with tools brought on by being obsessed with tools, constantly trying the latest greatest, but also stuff like tools of different cultures, or simply different style. The doers have no time for this, but the fiddlers are in their glory.

- And then there is reading "influential" blogs and buying all the marketed stuff. That can't ever come to an end, since it is essential to find something new to sell.

So it depends on your outlook, and what is leading you to play with the tools.

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#10

Sanity is a terrible condition


Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#11

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever

Hank Knight

"At what point does the fully satisfied with the tools part kick in?"

For me it was when I realized I liked building furniture more than I liked fooling around with tools. I went through a period when I had an almost insatiable appitite for tools, particularly old, classic ones; and I acquired a bunch of good quality hand tools. I "tweaked" all of them and got them working like they are supposed to work, and I learned how to get a very good edge on most any edge tool. Finally, a couple of years ago, I realized that I had enough tools to accomplish just about any woodworking task that came up. My tools were in really good shape and performed very well and I began to enjoy using them more than I enjoyed fooling with them. I no longer crave evey tool I see. I haven't bought a project tool in a long time. Sharpening is an ongoing activity, but I don't find myself thinking about how I can "tweak" a tool to get some minute and probably unnecessary improvement from it. Now I just really enjoy using my tools.

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#12

"The relentless pursuit of perfection"


Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#13

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever

eliot d

This post seems to be especially intelligent.

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#14

and Perfection is highly overrated


Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#15

Re: easy answer

Kevin French

But then you can't be using them, to get them ALL prefect that is.

WW'rs Catch 22?

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever end?

#16

Re: Side note: does this tool tweaking stuff ever

CStanford

Firmly fixed in my mind are photos of Alan Peters shooting drawer sides, taking those last bits of tissue to achieve the piston fit he was known for, with a Record No. 7.

For the final fitting of a masterpiece, the Master used a Record No. 7.

Maybe he spent 40+ hours tuning the thing. I don't know. I tend to doubt it.