We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Just about to finish my workbench. I have worked several sessions on flattening, and have gotten very close. Just how close to .000 do I need to get to before I can stop? I do have a section where a .005 feeler gauge will slide under the straight edge with resistance, and I think I probably should keep working at it. Am I correct in my presumption?
How big is the bench, how new is the wood, and how close are you to the window?
That's pretty darned flat. But if you just built the thing, it's going to move. If it's in direct sunlight, it'll probably move. When you drill dog holes, you'll expose end grain, and that strip of wood will go through a bit of re-adjustment, and it'll move.
My inclination is to call it done for now. Winter is coming. (I love saying that now...)
So, the air will chill and dry out. Your bench will adjust accordingly. Check the surface after Thxgiving, and Xmas. Flatten accordingly. (It'll be less work next time.)
Some time next spring I'm guessing things will start to settle out, and you'll have been using the bench for half a year. After that, I'd consider indulging my fussy side. In the meantime, you'll be dancing around the point of diminishing returns.
Wait until your efforts will be better rewarded. In the meantime... Build something new. You have a new bench that's ready to use.
Stuart.....there is a point of diminishing return/benefit to flattening and you are about there.....for an answer, a lot depends on how easy/difficult it would be for you to work this minor low spot out of your top and just how flat your top has to be for the work that will be done on it.....this is wood we are working not metal jet engine parts.....and in a year or so, the top might need another minor flattening.....I'd say use it as is and see if it is effecting your work or not.
James, the bench is just shy of 72" long, and a bit over 23" deep. It is 2 5/8" thick, made of southern yellow pine bought at the Depot. I stickered all the wood in the garage and let it sit for almost two years before I had the time (gumption) to start. I have marked out an area on the benchtop in three directions to highlight the low spot. It runs down the middle of the top for about 30 " and covers approximately 1/3 the depth, front to back. I feel like I'm SO close, but I don't want to screw it up!
Mine has an 1/8" hump down it middle where its 42" width has cupped during the last 35 years. If it ever prevents me from building stuff I will look into flatening it.
I don't think it is theoretically possible to keep a bench flat to 0.005" if the environment has humidity changes.
I really wouldn't worry about screwing anything up. The bench is very flat, but this is an ongoing process with workbenches. So, even if it was 'perfect,' this would change over time. Wood moves and adjusts to ambient conditions. You'll have to flatten it again, for sure.
And it's also important to remember that it's (just) a work bench... If it proves to live a good, useful life, the years will leave a series of scars, spills, coffee rings, etc, on the surface. Some of it may never fully come out. The criteria that I would use to judge success or failure are not laid out in terms of geometrical ideals, but in terms of usefulness instead. I do flatten my own bench periodically, because it makes for a decent reference surface, a good clamping surface, etc. But my ability to secure work, and productively perform various operations, is just as important, if not more so. If the bench holds your work securely and steadily, and in a way that's useful to you, you've succeeded.
As you continue to work and learn, keep a bench notebook handy. Jot down ideas for how you'd like to improve the bench, and improve your own process. Revisit that from time to time. Over time, some ideas may sound better and better... Or worse. Adjust your bench accordingly. Try not to Swiss-cheese the top just yet, that's the best up-front advice I can offer.
From the sounds of it, I'd stop, wipe some Danish oil on the surface, and move on to your next project.
I used to be pretty happy if I could get the big Oliver jointer that close to "flat" (beds co-planar in the case of a jointer). Anything less than 0.003" was simply not possible, 0.005" was fine and vastly better than the 0.03" or so where we'd start to notice problems.
I've never even worried much about it with any of the 4 benches I've had over the years. If it needs to be flatter than it is, you'll find out when you do whatever thing it is that requires super flat. I'm betting you'll never find such a task, I sure haven't.
Congratulations!! For that flatness, you can check/clamp drawers and cabinet doors for flatness. One thought: I have found having one square and plumb front corner a very good thing.
I appreciate the replies. I thought I was on the brink of being a bit OCD on this matter. Thanks for helping to keep me from falling over the edge! RELIEF!!!!! It's so sweet!
Biggest reason I asked is that in several videos and magazine articles I have seen or read all show the authors getting their top down to less than .003 from true flat so the bench can be used as a refernce point. I am building my first real workbench ( I have named it my FRW) and want to do it right the first time. My wife says I'm well past the requirement for being labelled anal about this, but what can I say. I apprecaiate all the responses, and am moving forward with bringing the legs into that magical state of coplanarity (if that's a word) with the front edge of the FRW, and then I'll drill a few dog holes and holdfast holes and start building something.
Did any of these sources ever say what the bench needed to be flat to 0.003"? If you apply these standards to furniture you will never get anything completed.
A stint of house carpentry may be a useful antidote for excessive precision obsession. The cabinet built flat to 0.003" is going to sit on a floor flat to 1/4", in favorable cases.
OK, then what's the holdup? If you had it to within 5 thou you didn't have much to go to get it to what you've been convinced is some 'magical' number of 3 thou or less or the thing is a piece of unuseable trash. If you need it that flat then go make it that flat. Have fun keeping it that way.
You're too close now to be asking questions about it on a woodworking forum. It's quite unnecessary, but you might as well finish the fool's errand you've sent yourself on (or that others have sent you on) if you've put this much work into it.
Freely admit to to the gruffness but the poster is 90+% of the way there. Might as well finish. I do appreciate that he recognizes a degree of absurdity in the thing, for it is, but he can't get back the time already invested.
And I would add, for more reasons than I have time at the moment to enumerate, you absolutely can consistently build projects to a higher level of accuracy than the benchtop upon which the component parts are processed. If this wasn't the absolute truth then NOBODY would ever get good work done.
If you think your benchtop needs to have the same level of accuracy as a machinist's straight edge, and that's essentially what you're talking about given the relatively size of a benchtop vs. a straightedge, then you have been horrifically mislead.
me if I inadvertantly touched a sensitive nerve. My intent was to solicit opinions from those more experienced and learned than me, I guess, to back up the gut feeling that I had "done good" so far. I am in complete agreement that I have the benchtop as close as is necessary, after reading all the posts. I still consider myself to be a neophyte, but want to do the best possible job I can on each project as I proceed along the path. I sincerely thank everyone for the benefit of their knowledge!
you've actually made a workbench (and flattened it).....you'd be surprised by the number of woodworkers who have not built a bench (much less flattened the thing).
Good question as measured by the responses! I agree with the consensus that you have it flat enough, but will add a couple of points that I think you have covered:
It won't ever be perfectly flat. Whatever "error" you have should be on one side--that of a concave surface. You don't want workpieces spinning on a high-point on your bench.
You also want to check for wind. Presuming you have checked flatness on multiple angles, including diagonal, this should not be a problem.
A couple of people here have mentioned level. I haven't found that to be a problem, but figure that if it ever is, shims under the feet or between the base and slab top (mine is a slab on trestle style) should fix that. And since the floor is not perfectly level, I didn't obsess over levelness of the top, since if it becomes an issue, the fix will depend on the floor it rests on.
You may be in for a pleasant surprise on the stability of your top. Mine is SYP as well, built of construction grade lumber that was sitting in my basement shop for a couple of years before the build. I flattened the top with my #8. A 4' straightedge shows it hollow everywhere, but if I put a dollar bill folded in half under the middle of the straightedge, it pivots on that, so the hollow if very small. After four years, I have had to tighten break-down joints in the base a couple of times, but have not had to re-flatten. This is in an unheated basement shop, surrounded on two sides by poured concrete and two sides by conditioned living area, in a four-season climate (Georgia).
I don't think levelness matters at all, however, if it were level, and making it level can be one of the easier things to do, you can then measure off the surface in useful ways, this is done on machine tools. For instance you level will tell you whether you have planed the piece parallel. I do not work this way on my bench but it would not be all that hard to do.