New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Sawing quandary

Posts

Sawing quandary

#1

Sawing quandary

Ron Harper

I mentioned here a week or so back that as a guy who has gone way over to the neander way of working wood, i needed some improvement in hand sawing. Pleased to report that I have seen some. Particularly with the larger saws. Cutting square now and very close to plumb with my D 8 s. with the joinery saws not so much. The issue is plumb, especially with my small dovetail saw. No brand mentioned but it is an icon among Galoots, so the trouble ain't the quality of the tool. I have a Grove and Sons tenon saw that I can do a lot better with. I get very close to plumb. But with a dozuki or ryoba it is not an issue for me. I am aware that until you see my attempts at sawing to a line, you are guessing, but any guesses? . Should i cut my dovetails with my tenon saw, or ryoba? Should I continue to work on it and talk to you again after Thanksgiving?

Ron a Kokomo Galoot

Sent from Xfinity Connect Mobile App

Re: Sawing quandary

#2

Re: Sawing quandry

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The trouble could be with the tool. If you take your dovetail saw and cut down at the end of a board the full depth of the saw, a saw that cuts crooked will leave a slight arc for a kerf, and may not even be able to cut the full depth without binding.

If on the other hand the saw cuts easily and straight, but at an angle, not straight down, the problem is with you.

Note that adjustments to the direction you are cutting must come early, in the first 1/8 inch or so. It is not reasonable to cut 1/2 inch down and then try to change direction.

Re: Sawing quandary

#3

Stick with what works

James Watriss

This isn't the Olympics, you won't be judged on form.

There's no such thing as cheating in woodworking; if you have a method that works, you're doing something right.

Don't sweat the small stuff... But listen to Warren, too. He's a pretty smart guy.

Re: Sawing quandary

#4

Thanks, I learned something here.


Re: Sawing quandary

#5

Do you saw on two lines?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

When I learned to saw on two lines, the accuracy of my sawing improved a lot.

By this I mean alternating sawing on two adjacent faces of your stock. For instance, if you're sawing a tenon, saw a shallow cut across the end for a bit, then swing the saw around and saw a shallow cut along the length of the tenon, alternating this until you've got kerfs that will guide your cut.

I recently cut miters across nominal 12" boards (11-1/4" actual) for frieze boards on the chimney on the current remodel. I marked both faces and both edges of the boards, and was coming out the end of the cut on the lines.

But it takes practice - I spent my early years making cuts that looked like I'd made them from 20 feet away, with my eyes shut.

Re: Sawing quandary

#6

Re: Sawing quandary

TomD

I agree with Warren on correction. The main difference between coarse saws and joinery saws, in this application, is the set of the teeth. I try to get them on line before I sink beyond the depth of the teeth. I start trying to get the saw to glide initially, then I work hard on getting it on line. if you sink it much beyond the depth of the teeth before you are online, it will be a struggle from that point on.

However, this problem is relatively obvious because you have the sense you are struggling, and the saw is binding.

One thing I often get people to do as an exercise is to just saw drops without a line. There is something about a line that gets the sawing tense. Just make practice cuts in a row, no line get the saw dropping, watch the side of the blade, and see that it is a consistent space from the side of the kerf, and consistant across the top. Once you get the saw dropping it is a lot easier to saw with a line.

Basic is to stand in address to the cut in a good free position, then close your eyes, and kinda feel the position, maybe make a few cuts in the air. Now open your eyes, if the saw is not in the right place in relation to your line, adjust your feet till it is. Do not saw in a cramped position

Re: Sawing quandary

#7

Jack Guzman from Maine

Stance

Jack Guzman from Maine

One thing you may have going on could be your stance. You could be used to holding your saw a certain way.Using a saw with a different hang and not compensating with your stance could throw you off. Just something to think about.---Jack

Re: Sawing quandary

#8

Re: Sawing quandary

Patrick Gibbons

I have found with my own sawing that it is often a case of perception. After finishing a cut that I knew was straight, a reference with a square proved me wrong. I now try to mark square on my stock before cutting as much as is practical. If your saw goes where you want it to go then you don't have a problem sawing. You just need to lay out your path to follow.

Re: Sawing quandary

#9

Re: Sawing quandary

Patrick Gibbons

I also want to mention that I have found it easier to judge a square cut with a longer saw. The dovetail saw, because of its size, will often be off.

Re: Sawing quandary

#10

Re: Sawing quandary

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

The mechanical considerations have been covered already, and mighty well too.

One thing that helped me was a change in mindset. This was some years ago. I had gotten all the mechanical advice about starting the cut right, stance, and so forth. The advice was all sound, and all necessary. But still my results were hit or miss. Two good, one off; three good, one off. (This was all Japanese saws, but still it may apply.)

There came a time when it came to me, that I was hoping for a good outcome. Doing what I'm supposed to do, and I hope this time it works. Maybe the probabilities will get better as I practice.

It came to me suddenly that I have to make my own luck. Don't wait to see whether the saw will fall down the tenon cheek line; make it go there. Angle the saw and saw down that line right now--don't wait for luck. As someone put it to me about that time (it was John McDonald, some will remember him from Badger Pond), you're sawing your own miter box. I had to think about that a lot, but never forgot it. I still think, 'make your own luck', when starting a cut.

One other thing John said that helped a lot. It was about how to see the cut. His point was not to scrinch down your eyes, focussing as hard as possible watching for the first little deviation from line. But rather it was to stand back slightly, breathe, and see the whole thing--the plane of the work stretching out beside and beyond on either side of the saw blade, the plane of the saw down through the work. You're looking at the whole picture, and taking in the essentials--the intersecting planes of the work and the saw.

Wiley

Re: Sawing quandary

#11

Excellent advice, Wiley


Re: Sawing quandary

#12

Agree,  Great Advice - Here's an analogy

Hank Knight

Most kids, when they learn to drive, focus on the road 15 or 20 feet in front of the car (I cartainly did). Their steering is erratic because they make tiny corrections to keep the car in line for 20 feet. As they gain confidence, their attention moves farther down the road. Think about your own driving. Your focus is 30, 40, 50 yards in front of the car - maybe further, depending on your speed. You almost unconsiously visualize the path the car will take over the distance and you smoothly guide the car down that path, with little attention to what's immediately in front of you. Sawing is the same.

Re: Sawing quandary

#13

Re: Here's an analogy

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Ah! "The car goes where the eyes go." (Garth Stein, The Art of Racing in the Rain) Guess that applies to handsaws as well.

Re: Sawing quandary

#14

Target fixation...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

You ought to see what that does to riding a motorcycle. Potholes are impossible to avoid if that's what you're looking at.

Re: Sawing quandary

#15

an interpretation

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

The way I interpreted John's method of viewing was this....

I'm looking at the larger picture so as to 'see' the planes. I want to abstract the planes from all the other objects in the field of view. If I scrunch down and look at the marks 'in the small', I can't see the planes anymore. What planes? The work has a horizontal plane, that you've made a mark on. And a vertical plane, that you've also made a mark on. The saw blade itself is a plane.

The two marks you've made join. There is only one plane in all the universe that passes through both those marks. You want your saw to be that plane. As Warren points out, you can't just start any old way and correct as you go--once the teeth are below the kerf line, you're about out of room to correct. Visualizing the correct plane is key to starting right. [*see below for exception] Incidentally you can identify and see that one correct plane by changing your position until the two marks line up in a straight line--this can be a check on your saw angle.

With Japanese saws at least, there is a further point to keeping the larger picture in mind. A dozuki or a smallish (under 240mm say) kataba has more flex in it than a comparable western saw. So you can actually pull the saw 'out of plane', and start sawing 'around the corner', with the blade in a curve. Easiest thing in the world. So with a Japanese saw, you have to be aware always to minimize the kerf pressure on either side of the blade. For me, the saw feel is a better guide to keeping the saw neutral in the kerf--this is one reason you need a relaxed grip--but the visual is a good help too.

___________

[*Exception to rule of starting with saw in correct plane (IMO): In sawing the tails of a dovetail joint, I picked up from Ian Kirby to make the first cut with the saw held plumb (dead vertical), because the most important thing is that this cut be square to the sides, so that all the tail cuts are parallel to each other and square. Even though this first sawcut will carry offline, it is into the waste and won't hurt. So, first sawcut plumb, then angle saw to pick up the correct plane of the tail.]

_______

Wiley....not meaning to run on so long

Re: Sawing quandary

#16

Re: an interpretation

William Duffield

I'll run on a little longer. The plane of the saw blade of which Wiley speaks must also pass through your wrist joint, your elbow joint and your shoulder joint. Otherwise, you will not be able to keep the saw plate in the plane. Again, the exception is when cutting tails, but in this case, after you have everything lined up to cut a vertical kerf, you need make only one small correction: twist your wrist to the angle of the tail. If you are having problems getting things aligned, move your feet. I usually find that I am in the best balance if this saw plate plane is also passing through the arch of my left foot (I'm left handed), and my right foot is pointing directly at the kerf. If you are having trouble verifying when everything is properly aligned, get a laser level, put it on a tripod, put it the other side of the board, turn it so it sweeps vertically, and align it with the kerf you want to cut. Now you can get your feet, saw, elbow and shoulder in the proper positions.

Rule number one for sawing, chopping, marking out, drilling, etc.: Move your feet.

Re: Sawing quandary

#17

Sawing, in this regard, is like shooting

Bob Hackett

A shooter would call this "natural point of aim". Easiest wat to get there is to get into position with your eyes closed. Once you`re settled in, open your eyes and see if your`re on target. If not you adjust your entire body (rather than cranking the rifle/saw around) and and check again. Soon this becomes ingrained in muscle memory and you just naturally set up this way.

The visualization of the plane well beyond the piece/target being sawn/shot as well as the visualization of the cut/ shot reaching a successful conclusion helps as well but unless you are initially set up in a relaxed, comfortable natural point of aim you are seriously narrowing your success rate and increasing your potential disappointment factor.

For me, at least 75% of successful sawing takes place well before the saw takes that first stroke.

Re: Sawing quandary

#18

Re: Sawing quandary

CStanford

Good advice and I would only add that most people can (would) saw just fine if they hadn't read how supposedly hard it is to do on woodworking forums. Overt steering of the saw is as likely to cause problems as trying to steer a golf ball. You just have to do the woodworking equivalent of letting the club swing itself, especially if the woodworker has a saw that he or she knows to be of adequate quality and in good tune.

I've probably already gotten more pedantic than I had intended but I also think the finer the saw the harder it is for the beginner to saw a straight line. I suggest using a joinery saw on the coarser end of the spectrum, relatively speaking.