New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Question about stringing sizer

Posts

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#26

Re: more tapers not

William Duffield

Maybe what I think I see is an optical illusion. There is definitely a much more pronounced taper at the top of the L-N cutter, which makes sense, even if hide glue makes tapered stringing and tapered grooves unnecessary. I am certainly not an expert on this art.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#27

Re: more tapers not

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I'll check the LN thicknesser with a feeler gauge later, and report.

Wiley

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#28

Re: more tapers not

Bill Tindall

The cutter is times taller than an 1/8 inch of stringing. The top is wider to be able to start a thicker string and then work it to the bottom as it thins.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#29

Garrett Tapers !

David Charlesworth

Garrett tapers both his groove and his stringing.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#30

Followup

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I checked the LN thicknesser and the straight-line cutter (that makes the channel). Both are Steve Latta's designs, as I understand it. The cutter is not a scratch with a ploughing tooth; it is a piece of saw steel with three crosscut teeth worked in it--it's a short saw!

The cutter makes a straight-sided channel, and the string thicknesser makes a straight string--I actually had to take the knives off and hold them to a reference square, because I kept thinking I saw a very slight taper. But no, it thicknesses to a straight string. The aperture is wider at the top so you can progressively thin the string to the point where it will enter the section that does the final sizing.

I have a couple more thoughts on the matter, down below Mr. Charlesworth's post.

Wiley

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#31

Re: Garrett Tapers !

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks for the information, David! Great to hear from you.

Couple of thoughts about the tapered string and groove approach. I had never done this operation at all before, or had any teaching, or even over the shoulder watching someone who knew what they were doing.

I had two main worries. Nothing to do with tapering or getting the string to fit the groove--that seemed to be, and was, not difficult to do. After all, you can dry test the string in the groove all you want!

The two problems I did worry about were (1) the thickness of the string for aesthetic purposes, and (2) whether the groove-ploughing operation would leave a perfect surface on the leg--because you're inlaying the final leg--scrape the glue off and apply finish.

To my eye, and this was a fairly dainty lady's worktable, a string thickness of about 42 thousandths looked right.

A far greater worry was what the ploughing might do to the leg surface. Because you can experiment all you want with the string thickness, but you only get one shot at grooving a near-final leg, and if you blow it, you get to go make another leg (or try to find some more color-matching 8/4 stock to make a leg). And I had a lot of work in each leg by the time I got to the stringing, because these legs had the therm foot. And each leg had 16 different strings to lay, since the front and side was being strung. So when it came time to plough the groove, I was glad that the cutter was tapered. Because the tapered cutter establishes the groove width and depth bit by bit, gradually widening the surface cut as it goes deeper. You're not dragging the plough over and over through the same-width surface cut, as you deepen the groove--with every new pass a chance to mung up the surface. Instead, every pass of the plough ever-so-slightly widens the surface cut. So you end up with a perfect surface cut, even though you may have made 25 or 50 passes (just guessing) of the cutter to get to depth.

Wiley

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#32

yet another professional non-taperer

Bill Tindall

Person that gave our club program tonight has an impressive pedigree including Williamsburg and he doesn't taper string. If it was tapered imagine the pain of keeping which edge was up straight on something 1/8" tall during trimming bending etc.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#33

Re: yet another professional non-taperer

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bill,

Am finding this all interesting. Do you know what these various pro's who do not taper are using to cut their channels? The guy last night? Will Neptune? We know Steve Latta uses his sawtooth design. Hack uses a tooth on a scratch stock.

Wiley

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#34

Re: yet another professional non-taperer

William Duffield

I have photos of Chuck Bender's tool for curved stringing grooves, but they're still in my camera, and it'll take me a while to process them, and I'm more than busy through the weekend. I'll post a new thread, with some of his critique of the L-N tool, early next week.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#35

Cutter/thicknesser combinations

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

That will be most useful, Sir Wm.!

Just one kinda sorta maybe related thought......We've waded into this taper vs. non-taper discussion. But that's not of the essence. These renowned woodworkers we're discussing, and their thousands of predecessors back in time, didn't start out thinking taper or non taper. They needed to do two operations--make a groove on a finished leg, and then make a string to fit the groove. The tools they use to do this are a combined decision--they have to work well together. Like steel and sharpening media, some combinations work together better than others.

So which combinations of tools are preferred? Mr. Latta uses a sawtooth cutter, which makes a rectangular channel, and his string thicknesser also makes a rectangular section string. A mini-router would also make a straight-sided channel. Mr. Hack teaches the scratch stock + tapered tooth--that necessarily makes a tapered channel, and if you look at Sir Wm.'s photo of Garrett's string thicknesser, all he has to do is tilt the scraper to get a taper on the string. And he can optimize the fit of the string to the channel.

Installing the string is not much of an issue, once you have a good dry fit. When you install the string in the channel, you're inserting it into a glue bed--I used hot hide, for example (cause the cleanup is so easy and leaves no trace to show up in the finish). The glue lubricates the install.

From my very limited experience, the groove cutting is the key operation, moreso than making the string, because you only get one try per finished leg, and also because there are cross-grain issues we haven't discussed yet. I suspect in most cases, it is the choice of groove cutter than has the most influence over the subsequent choice of string thicknesser and groove geometry. Just a thought.

Wiley

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#36

Re: yet another professional non-taperer

Bill Tindall

Neptune and Buddy Floyd each use standard veneer and slice it. Will selects a number drill bit that matches the veneer thickness and grinds it. Though in class he just ground a piece of band saw blade. Buddy uses scratch stock and scrapes veneer with card scraper as needed to adjust thickness. Headley shop uses scratch stock.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#37

A few notes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have done this kind of work occasionally over the last 30 years. I like a groove with straight sides and fairly deep so the inlay will not pop out. I would be surprised to see old work with a tapered groove. I use a scratch stock for portions with the grain, a knife and chisel cross grain, and gouges for curves. This might be hard for someone not skilled with a chisel or gouge. A scratch stock will not work very well for cross grain.

I like to cut my own veneer with a hand saw and plane to thickness. The thickness of the veneer (width of the stringing) should be scaled to the size and daintyness of the work, not just one size fits all. I often put a very small bevel on the stringing with a plane to help start it in the groove; I like it to be plenty snug.

Years ago one of my friends bought a tool made by Ulmia for cutting the grooves. It was like a panel gauge and the cutter had two knives and also a raker cutter to remove waste. There were shims along to adjust the width between knives. Also the beam could be set up like a beam compass for cutting arcs. These Ulmia tools were only in a few catalogs and maybe not in the last 20 years.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#38

Re: Question about stringing sizer

Richard Darjes

I'm coming late to the party, and I have no direct experience with the device I have seen, but there are instructions for making an adjustable thicknessing scraper in Robert Wearing's book "Woodwork Aids and Devices." In North America the book is published with the name "Making Woodwork Aids and Devices."

The scraping tool makes use of parts from a Record or Stanley 151 spokeshave.

You need the blade, the cap the two adjusting nuts and the threaded rods the nuts travel on.

Without the illustrations in the book it is difficult for me to describe how he suggests to build the supporting structure.

If you have access to the book, this could be another option.

The