New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Question about stringing sizer

Posts

Question about stringing sizer

#1

Question about stringing sizer

Bill Tindall

I am not inclined to pay LN a fortune for a stringing sizer. Does anyone have a picture of one that is readily made and works well? Specifically, I need advice on how to make the cutter adjustable, ie the adjusting mechanism/blade attachment.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#2

Re: Question about stringing sizer

TomD

This kind of thing:

http://www.frets.com/FretsPages/Museum/SpecialItems/GezaBurghardt/GezaViews/geza01.jpg

This one uses spring load, but might even work with hand pressure. a spacer under the blade migh also work in place of the screw.

http://www.rdebey.com/purfscra.htm

Oh! yes, yes, yes!

http://leedsguitar.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/P1040124-e1291580295583.jpg

http://leedsguitar.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/90-purfling-trimmer-parts.jpg

http://www.mikeouds.com/messageboard/files.php?pid=46411&aid=7023

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#3

Re: Question about stringing sizer

William Duffield

You mean this thing?

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/viewimage.php?product_id=10521

Why can't you make one? It's a block of wood, a couple of scraper blades (made from excess bandsaw blade stock) or whatever 1095 or better carbon steel you have laying around, thee end ground at a very small angle off perpendicular, a hook turned and burnished in the typical manor, two screws to grossly adjust the width of the stringing, and some way to hold it perpendicular to your bench. I might be tempted to use a Festool clamp, since they happen to be handily laying around in my shop, but making it a bit longer and clamping it in whatever vise you have handy should work just as well. The small angle allows you to pull the stringing through one or more times until it just wedges in your groove, and then you push it in and glue it with some hot liquid horse butt. The only functional thing I don't understand about the L-N tool (one of which I had in my hand today) is how it continues to function in the long term without abrading a groove in the side of the wooden fence. If you want, I could get some more detailed photos of it tomorrow, and discuss my concerns with someone I know who is an expert in this art.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#4

Re: Question about stringing sizer

TomD

A really simple version works this way. You make your hooked scraper blade with a taper to the outboard side. You concoct a simple adjustment so it can be set to a single gap against a feeler shim. When you run the banding it starts cutting in the wider slot where the taper is, and eventually cuts to a uniform thickness in the straight section which is a uniform gap across the fence. With a deal like this, setting to say 40 thou, will not necessarily get you that dimension, but with a little playing around you will find out which feeler, will give you the right cut. Worst case you have to make an estimate on that every time you sharpen.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#5

these answers are missing the mark

Bill Tindall

to repeat: "Specifically, I need advice on how to make the cutter adjustable, ie. the adjusting mechanism/blade attachment."

A slotted piece of steel is the easy solution to the afixing part of construction but I don't know how to make slots in a band saw blade or piece of tool steel.

I have seen several of these home made devices but can not recall the blade/scraper attachment technique. I doubt they relied on a slotted cutter.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#6

Re: these answers are missing the mark

TomD

I don't think you are expressing yourself clearly. Do you want to know how a thicknesser of this type might be make adjustable, in which case there are plenty of examples in my post, or are you only asking how the LN version itself is made adjustable. In that case I haven't seen one, but if it does not require an enormous range it would only need holes somewhat larger than the bolts. Seems the versions that uses a plane or a part of a plane, not to mention the Berghard, version are a lot easier to make and would have a lot more adjustment built into them.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#7

Re: these answers are missing the mark

Wade Mackey

If you go to Amazon and look for "sheet metal hole punch" you will see a number of tools for punching the slot (a series of holes) into the piece of band saw blade. I have several home stringing tools and they were all made this way.

Wade

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#8

Re: these answers are missing the mark

TomD

Cool, that said how much adjustment is needed? For a given size of banding?

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#9

Re: these answers are missing the mark

William Duffield

L-N's has two oversize slots and two screws with very wide heads, so it is easy enough to adjust theirs with a screwdriver. What they don't have is a microadjust screw to fine tune the width of the slot. They also have no mechanism to adjust the taper. The one I looked at today, which is the demo model that they carry around to events, shows lots of evidence of worn edge from pulling a lot of stringing across it.

If you wanted to make one like that without punching holes in the hardened steel, you could instead hold the blade down with two screws on either side.

I also like the idea from the Leedsguitar blog that Tom provided which uses a hunk of Stanley #78 rabbet plane to hold the blade in a wooden fixture in a gunstock vise. The disadvantages of the #78 are that it doesn't have a lateral adjuster for controlling the taper of the stringing and it's depth adjuster is a bit coarse and has a lot of backlash. You might want to adapt the idea to a salvaged frog and adjuster and blade mechanism from a flea market Bailey design bench plane. All you would need to do is bolt the frog to an appropriately shaped block of wood with a bit of steel wear plate, and regrind the blade to a scraper profile.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#10

No drill solution

Bob Hackett

Take a hardwood block and excavate an area that is just slightly more shallow that the thickness of your intended blade material and a bit larger that the blade, enough to allow the blade to move thru the expected range of adjustment. (I`d us a section of a HSS planer blade but that just me). Toward the upper corner furthest away from where the cutting is taking place drill a hole and drive a pin in, this is your pivot point. Now drill two holes for pan head sheet metal screws to hold your blade in place in the recess. I use pan head sheet metal screws because the shank is not tapered like a wood screw and the threads are usually deeper, more like HD drywall screws with a wide head for a broader surface to hold the blade more securely securely. Use the same type of screw just above the cutting area as your adjuster. If you can`t put a screw in that area for strength reasons the I use a more remote screw and a slice of angle iron with one leg shortened to reach the edge of the blade in order to make adjustments.

I don`t do stringing but have used tools like this to thickness and shape things with thin cross section in materials ranging from hardwood to non-ferrous metals with excellent results. For some of these jobs I moved the tool over the material and other times I`ve clamped the tool in the vice and pulled the material through a hole in the tool.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#11

Re: Question about stringing sizer

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

Well, to be fair to Lie Nielsen, their thicknesser does not exactly cost a fortune. $65. I think that's an OK price, myself. And it's a good unit, like all things LN. I bought one when they came out, ironically after doing my string thicknessing the hard way, with plane, scraper, and micrometer.

Anyways....you can make something functionally similar yourself, all right. But you need to see it up close. Because the cutter prep is important. Thom described it correctly, with the cutter entrance opened up a little, so you can progressively thin the string. A picture is worth a thousand words:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8063421832/in/set-72157631713450111

The problem of making the thicknesser is that--if you start from scratch--you'll either have to start with unhardened steel and drill it unhardened, then harden it; or else do all the stuff ya gotta do to drill hardened steel; or else take the hardened steel to a local machinist for slotting. Bob offered a 'no drill' solution, which sounds good to me.

It strikes me that the truly simplest way is to use a slotted plane blade, or else a chisel plane directly as shown in one of Thom's links. If you use a plane blade, the letting-in is pretty simple--a big shallow rebate.

I'll mention one other thing, but of course you would think of it yourself. And that is, that the thicknesser will need to be adjustable enough to match the channel cut by your stringing router. For example, when I did my strings, I used a stringing router which my friend Konrad Sauer (a truly great craftsman!) was kind enough to make and send. Konrad had attended a class by a very well-known furniture maker, and he made me a router like the one they made in class. Here it is:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8063422865/in/set-72157631713450111/

and here is the other end, showing the threaded insert that the thumbscrew goes into:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/8063421627/in/set-72157631713450111/

That's an ordinary fragment of saw blade that he used to fashion the cutter. Now here's the point I want to get to: the stringing router blade has a slight taper to it. So when I made the strings, I scraper a slight taper into them also. Long story short: make sure the thicknesser has enough flexibility designed in to match your router.

One other thing I should mention. Konrad said that the router tooth has to be fashioned quite precisely, with four sides square and real sharp, and the little tiny bottom has to be square and sharp also. Cause you're gonna use this thing in both directions, depending on how the grain lays. So although the tool can be any fragment of hardened steel, the prep is critical.

Wiley

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#12

Re: Question about stringing sizer

TomD

Another option is one I have a special bronze plane to do. You mill a slot into your plane so the blade cuts above or level with the surface being planed. But you don't need to mill anything you can just use tape, or glue blocks on and size them. The tunnel in the middle determines the cut. This method is very accurate as it is used to make bamboo fly rods. Only downside is the stock has to be planeable, or scraper planeable.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#13

Re: these answers are missing the mark

Wade Mackey

Since my banding is all the same thickness (width of another piece of band saw blade I use to scratch the opening), once I set the thicknesser, it does not change unless I have to sharpen it. I don't do that much, so I think its been sharpened once or twice.

If you want to see the L-N tools in action, look up "Steve Latta" on Amazon, he has two videos on stringing and inlay.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#14

simple solution

Bill Tindall

I have learned that there are simple and cheap solutions to string sizing. By now you should know that I am cheap and that I am satisfied with minimalist home made tools that just get the job done.

To that end here is a very simple solution to string sizing used on at least one professional shop.


It consists of a card scraper driven into a saw cut, adjustable by tapping one end or the other. To my astonishment I was able to easily adjust the string thickness in 0.001" increments. It took something less than 5 min to fabricate. The slight spring of the blade may offer some advantage in thickness control. I lucked out and the burr was near optimum for the first try. Burr angle will be critical on this sizer.


This is the tool used in the Mack Headley and Sons shop. My good fortune was that someone took this picture when Steve Hamilton gave a class in my shop last year, while I did not. The grabber on top is used to pull the string through the tool. The advantage of this tool is that it will deal with a rough sized string, taking it down in increments to a target thickness. A scraper or small slotted plane blade can be used for the cutter.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#15

Re: these answers are missing the mark

William Duffield

Minor detail: Steve Latta now has 4 DVDs in the Fundamentals of Inlay series produced by Lie-Nielsen:

- Making Ornamental Bandings

- Federal Table Leg

- Stringing, Line and Berry

- Paterae, Part I

The video on patarae has been released only very recently. At L-N's event at Hearne Hardwoods this weekend, it wasn't even on their price list yet.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#16

Re: Question about stringing sizer

William Duffield

Wiley, Have you any idea why Konrad put a threaded insert in each end of his scratch stock? I've seen the very well known furniture maker demonstrate his, and actually held one of the precious things in my hand.


Not only is this one, made by the man himself, tapped on only one end, but it doesn't even have a brass insert. The wood itself (probably cocobolo, but I'm not sure) is tapped into the end grain. Obviously, the thumb screw is also hand made.

Good news: While looking for my pictures of this tool, I also found several photos of Garrett's stringing sizing tool. It works more like Lee-Valley's than Lie-Nielsen's. I'll post those photos as soon as I can crop and size the originals.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#17

Re: these answers are missing the mark

wade mackey

I only have the first three. I'll have to put the last one on my Chrstmass list. I've taken three or four courses from Steve. He is an excellent teacher.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#18

Huh?

Bill Tindall

"Paterae, Part I" For those of us in the outback what is this topic about?

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#19

Re: these answers are missing the mark

William Duffield

I will agree wholeheartedly, Steve is an excellent teacher, and has been an inspiration to me. He will be hosting the 2013 SAPFM mid-year conference at Thaddeus Stevens, which I have no intention of missing. So far, I've only experienced his demonstrations and presentations, which are very useful, but a chance to watch him and then do what he is teaching in real time would be much more valuable. I haven't watched any of his videos yet. Right now, I'm working through building (and trying to improve on) the table saw jigs and fixtures he demonstrated at a local SAPFM meeting last month.

It will be interesting to compare and contrast Latta's methods on paterae to the presentation by Don Williams at this year's SAPFM mid-year conference.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#20

Re: Paterae

William Duffield

In this context, paterae are the typically oval marquetry decorative elements found on Federal period furniture, typically tables, and typically at the tops of legs, on aprons and on drawer fronts, and at the centers of table tops.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#21

Why two threaded inserts?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Sir Wm. et al,

Good question! It's just Konrad. He is probably the most thorough, non-corner-cutting, do a little more, think of the other guy first, perfect the design, add redundancy just in case against the unknown unknowns, kinda person I ever met. In my 70 years' experience, one of a kind. Same reason he put in the threaded inserts. This is a guy who tapes labels to the garbage cans when he puts them out, if there's something in there that the garbage guys may need to know about. He photographs his builds--and sends you the photos while he does the work--and keeps them archived in case you lose your set. Would you like the front bun like this, or like that--hard lines or soft lines?

Looking forward to the string thicknesser if you can find it!

Wiley

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#22

Re: Garrett Hack's stringing sizing tool

William Duffield

I took photos of this tool from all sides at the 2008 WW in the 18th Century Williamsburg conference. First the photos and descriptions, then a rather uninformed critique.


It's made from two pieces of beech, with a scraper blade, and two bolts and two wing nuts to hold the scraper.

It is held like a spokeshave, typically pulled, with the stringing placed below it on a piece of scrap, and guided through the narrow slot. When pulled, this is the back side.

I do not know the function of the hole in the middle of the clamp block, but it might have something to do with making the clearance shown a couple of photos down.


Pencil for scale.


The slot in the body is ramped (probably somewhere around 5°) to hold the scraper at an effective scraping angle.


View from the front face. 4" double square for scale.


View from the bottom.


For completeness, a view from the top side. Not much here that can't be deduced from the prior photos and descriptions.

From the photos of Wiley's scratch stock, it appears that Garrett tapers his slots and scrapes his stringing square. It appears that this also has to be done if you use the Lee Valley scraper. An alternate practice is to cut the slot with parallel sides, and taper the stringing. I think the second method (which is done by a couple of experts I know in Chester and Lancaster counties in Pennsylvania…but I still need a third opinion from Warren) makes more sense to me, because when you are done, the stringing is tight at the surface and still at a constant width. If you use a scraper like the Lie-Nielsen, or Bill Tindall's Q&D model, or the one fashioned from a hunk of a #78, you can start a little fat, test fit your first piece of stringing, and once you have found out where it fits, repeatedly pull all the rest of your stringing through the scraper, and stop pulling each piece when it gets to the same height as you finished up with the first one. Because of the taper, each time you pull it through, it drops down a little from the previous pass.

If you use a tapered string method, it does require more discipline in the construction and use of your groove cutting tools, especially the tools for cutting curved grooves.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#23

tapers...not

Bill Tindall

I have never seen a demo of stringing where either the slot or the stringing was tapered. Unless I messed this part Latta does not do it, ditto Headley shop, etc.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#24

Re: tapers...not

William Duffield

Well, then how do you explain the taper in Hack's scratch stock, or the taper in Lie-Nielsen's stringing trimmer? It's not much taper, maybe a degree or two, but it's there, and my understanding is it is efficacious. My understanding is that it is intentional.

OK, I will accede to the fact that a good dose of hide glue should make it totally inconsequential to the look of the finished product. I'll discuss it with Chuck Bender the next time I see him and see if I can get a clarification. We discussed the geometry of the different arc cutting tools this weekend, and I learned a bit about which ones work well, and which ones can be modified to work well.

Re: Question about stringing sizer

#25

more tapers not

Bill Tindall

Just heard from Will Neptune and he does not taper either. The stringing sizers can be tapered at the top to get the string started then not tapered at the bottom.