An explanation ...
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
Why many of the same people who say there`s absolutely no need to use a jig in order to properly hone an edge, you just need to learn how to freehand are more than willing to lay down large sums of money for a Tormec and all it`s numerous (and expensive) jigs when all that machine does is grind?
Rough shaping and grinding freehand on a dry wheel is one of the first things a beginning WWer or machinist should be taught in any shop, right after they get sweeping the floor down to an art.
Hi Bob
Well I never tell other what they should do, but I am happy to explain a little more why I have come to prefer using a Tormek over a dry grinder.
It is interesting that you mention freehand honing, since this is one of the factors involved here. It is horses and courses - some methods are better suited for certain tasks and, if your aim is efficiency, then we are on the same page. My own preference is to freehand blades, and a hollow grind makes this easier. A hollow grind off a Tormek makes this easiest.
Ignore for the time being that the Tormek is an expensive machine (that is all relative and about priorities, not so?). Ignore also that the Tormek uses a jig to create an even hollow grind (that is a bonus and only a part of the big picture).
There are two features of a hollow grind that comes off a Tormek that are very difficult to duplicate on a dry grinder. The 8" wheel type is better than the 6" size in this regard, but even the 8" is not in the same country, never mind the same city, as the 10" wheeled Tormek.
The first is that one can safely grind all the way to the edge of the bevel. Try that on a dry grinder - no matter how careful you are - and you will burn the steel. And not just the little bit that Joel referred to. The benefit from preparing a hollow ground primary bevel this way is that honing the edge takes no more than a couple of strokes on two stones (it is possible to even get away with one stone, but it is still quicker on, say, a 1200 and a 13000, as I do). The resulting microbevel may be re-sharpened more times before re-grinding the hollow than if you were starting out with a lesser grind.
The benefits of this feature is more pronounced on harder steels, such as A2 and upward. While O1 and other "easy" steels are less of a sharpening challenge, if they are all you use, then this issue is not important for you. Obviously it is important to me (with a range of tough-to-hone steels for both chisels and planes).
The second feature of the Tormek hollow is that it is shallow. The 10" diameter does not exactly scoop out steel. Certainly not like a 6" wheel can do. The benefit here is that there is good support behind the bevel - which is important when you grind to the edge of the blade. I could - and do - hollow grind some of my laminated blades. The Tormek does not weaken the support for the hard steel. Apparently David Charlesworth does the same. So I am in good company. (There are some Japanese laminated blades I do not hollow grind, but that is because I prefer to treat them in the traditional manner).
Actually, I will add a third feature. This has to do with the "jig" that guides the blade across the wheel face. What it does is create a very straight and even grind. This also makes it possible to remove the most minimal amount of steel from the edge when you go to a stone to hone. I am reasonably skilled freehanding on a dry grinder, but the Tormek is a class ahead here.
This past Sunday I had a bunch of brand new blades to grind. All had flat primary bevels. There were 5 PM-V11 chisels and 5 PM-V11 blades. Plus, because I am starting a new project, a writing desk, one of my habits is to ensure that planes and chisels are all sharpened ahead. So I did a lot of sharpening. I hate sharpening. But now I am ready, and I also know that re-sharpening these blades will be a quick, fairly painless process. The ability to freehand a microbevel ensures that.
I must emphasise that this process is comfortable for me. It sets me up to work efficiently. Someone else will do it differently and prefer their own method. More power to their elbow. At the end of the day it is not about sharpening but what we do with the sharpened blade.
Regards from Perth
Derek