New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Truing grinding wheel

Posts

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#26

Re: Crowning wheel eliminates problem & is better

TomD

With a grinder, you dont eventually need Joel. Eventually you can make pretty much anything. But chips would be a good reason to have a grinder, hooking scrapers, or getting flea market finds cutting a few minutes after you walk through the door.

There was an interesting passage in The Joiner and Cabinet Maker book about the apprentice Thomas, that Joel brought to light, and Chris published. A hand tool environment back in 1839. At one point Thomas is instructed to take a look at a power grindstone when he gets a chance, that one of their vendors had. Even almost 200 years ago a power grindstone had it's appeal to people working in a hand tool shop, even though they had a big wheel that could be hand turned, all their own.

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#27

Re: Crowning wheel eliminates problem & is better

david weaver

The coarser diamond pastes, especially if used on mild steel, are bad news on japanese tools.

Found that out by experience, not thinking one time.

diamond hones are fine, but the loose diamonds love the backer on chisels, especially if it's wrought iron.

I absolutely agree with both of your comments:

1) the grinder is the last power tool that would leave my shop, tied with the bandsaw. I could live without everything else

2) if an edge is burnt, and probably most people will burn a corner here or there, there's no great need to go through the arduous task of grinding off lots of metal to remove it unless it proves to be needed. It rarely does. A person whose eyes bother them (i.e., they don't like the look of the blue) can just hone the blue color off on a polish stone.

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#28

Not harsh

Ron Harper

You were direct. I did ask a question and you gave a straightforward response.

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#29

Can somne explain to me...

Bob Hackett

Why many of the same people who say there`s absolutely no need to use a jig in order to properly hone an edge, you just need to learn how to freehand are more than willing to lay down large sums of money for a Tormec and all it`s numerous (and expensive) jigs when all that machine does is grind? :D

Rough shaping and grinding freehand on a dry wheel is one of the first things a beginning WWer or machinist should be taught in any shop, right after they get sweeping the floor down to an art.

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#30

An explanation ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Why many of the same people who say there`s absolutely no need to use a jig in order to properly hone an edge, you just need to learn how to freehand are more than willing to lay down large sums of money for a Tormec and all it`s numerous (and expensive) jigs when all that machine does is grind?

Rough shaping and grinding freehand on a dry wheel is one of the first things a beginning WWer or machinist should be taught in any shop, right after they get sweeping the floor down to an art.

Hi Bob

Well I never tell other what they should do, but I am happy to explain a little more why I have come to prefer using a Tormek over a dry grinder.

It is interesting that you mention freehand honing, since this is one of the factors involved here. It is horses and courses - some methods are better suited for certain tasks and, if your aim is efficiency, then we are on the same page. My own preference is to freehand blades, and a hollow grind makes this easier. A hollow grind off a Tormek makes this easiest.

Ignore for the time being that the Tormek is an expensive machine (that is all relative and about priorities, not so?). Ignore also that the Tormek uses a jig to create an even hollow grind (that is a bonus and only a part of the big picture).

There are two features of a hollow grind that comes off a Tormek that are very difficult to duplicate on a dry grinder. The 8" wheel type is better than the 6" size in this regard, but even the 8" is not in the same country, never mind the same city, as the 10" wheeled Tormek.

The first is that one can safely grind all the way to the edge of the bevel. Try that on a dry grinder - no matter how careful you are - and you will burn the steel. And not just the little bit that Joel referred to. The benefit from preparing a hollow ground primary bevel this way is that honing the edge takes no more than a couple of strokes on two stones (it is possible to even get away with one stone, but it is still quicker on, say, a 1200 and a 13000, as I do). The resulting microbevel may be re-sharpened more times before re-grinding the hollow than if you were starting out with a lesser grind.

The benefits of this feature is more pronounced on harder steels, such as A2 and upward. While O1 and other "easy" steels are less of a sharpening challenge, if they are all you use, then this issue is not important for you. Obviously it is important to me (with a range of tough-to-hone steels for both chisels and planes).

The second feature of the Tormek hollow is that it is shallow. The 10" diameter does not exactly scoop out steel. Certainly not like a 6" wheel can do. The benefit here is that there is good support behind the bevel - which is important when you grind to the edge of the blade. I could - and do - hollow grind some of my laminated blades. The Tormek does not weaken the support for the hard steel. Apparently David Charlesworth does the same. So I am in good company. (There are some Japanese laminated blades I do not hollow grind, but that is because I prefer to treat them in the traditional manner).

Actually, I will add a third feature. This has to do with the "jig" that guides the blade across the wheel face. What it does is create a very straight and even grind. This also makes it possible to remove the most minimal amount of steel from the edge when you go to a stone to hone. I am reasonably skilled freehanding on a dry grinder, but the Tormek is a class ahead here.

This past Sunday I had a bunch of brand new blades to grind. All had flat primary bevels. There were 5 PM-V11 chisels and 5 PM-V11 blades. Plus, because I am starting a new project, a writing desk, one of my habits is to ensure that planes and chisels are all sharpened ahead. So I did a lot of sharpening. I hate sharpening. But now I am ready, and I also know that re-sharpening these blades will be a quick, fairly painless process. The ability to freehand a microbevel ensures that.

I must emphasise that this process is comfortable for me. It sets me up to work efficiently. Someone else will do it differently and prefer their own method. More power to their elbow. At the end of the day it is not about sharpening but what we do with the sharpened blade.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#31

Re: Can somne explain to me...

TomD

99% of the time I freehand both power, and hand sharpening. I am not anti-jig. I think there are applications where they are necesarry, more efficient, function as training wheels. My favorite thing about jigs is that if one bought them along the way, at the very worst, one can use them to get back to zero if the attempts at freehanding go wrong.

But I freehand because it can be necesarry. You are not going to grind a dagger with a jig, unless you really get into the tooling, you probably are just as well off not grinding a camber with a jig. Freehand is normally more efficient. Freehand is usually more difficult to learn, so one might as well use all opportunities one has to pracitce it.

So maybe it isn't the same people who do one thing with a jig, and the other without.

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#32

Re: Crowning wheel eliminates problem & is better

TomD

I know they don't hollow grind bevels/bezels, but they sell a load of grinders, grinding wheels, they sure grind super surfacers, and I am hard put to believe they don't grind a lot of their tools in production as they have score marks and wheel patterns all over them. Flat bezels can just mean they side grind or band grind.

I'm a big believer in the sincerity of the Japanese tools, and get pretty angry when people dismiss them as flim flam. But the idea they do everything by hand, as you know, is not correct. Anyone who makes a wild machine with two hyperactive chisels for roughing out plane bodies, can't be walking past the grinders...

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#33

Reason 2 is irrelevant.....

Bill Tindall

....at least in my hands. I have never encountered any weakness created by the hollow grind from a something less than 7" wheel. If the steel is so flimsy that the flat created in edge refinement after grinding is not sufficient support I would judge the steel to be poor for woodworking application. Personally I have never seen any fracture back to the hollow which would suggest that the hollow contributed.

This weakening argument likely dissuades many from trying and then gaining the benefits from hollow grinding. Does anyone have any data to support the claim of weakening?

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#34

Amen.


Re: Truing grinding wheel

#35

Re: An explanation ...

Joel Moskowitz

"The first is that one can safely grind all the way to the edge of the bevel. Try that on a dry grinder - no matter how careful you are - and you will burn the steel."

Derek,

I do this all the time. I don't consider a tool done on the grinder unless I have a wire burr from the grinding. It's not brain surgery - it's just practice and even before I knew what I know now and had much worse technique the problem was never being able to establish a hollow grind without burning to a 1/64" to the cutting edge. The problem was that last 64th. Now it isn't.

But even if you go to the 64th and stop - honing is about the same amount of work. Unless you have ground back the edge and need to reestablish the original bevel.

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#36

Re: The puzzlement of the Tormek *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

I bought a Tormek a coupla three years ago. Already had a 6" Baldor 1800rpm grinder with Joel's I-hardness 60grit 3X blue wheel. Which I learned how to use mainly from your instruction. And still use it, though I haven't crowned the wheel. I would encourage anyone wanting to try hollow-grinding to start with a dry grinder or belt sander (though my Craftsman handheld belt sander is probably making 95db)--cause it's cheaper and you prolly already have the unit, and you don't need a Tormek in any event.

Bought the Tormek because I was setting up a second work area, and in a small space. Decided on Tormek because of its small footprint. In Derek's photo below, the Tormek has about 2/3 the footprint of his dry grinder. No water in the immediate area--I just bring a pitcher of water to fill the Tormek reservoir. Water is not an issue, and when it comes time to dump the grindings out of the reservoir, I wouldn't put those down a sink anyway. Tormek makes no mess outside its footprint, which is useful IMO.

I've grown to like Tormek, though I still use the Baldor when I'm in its area. The main thing I like about Tormek is that I can grind a 1/8 to 1/4" chisel to a primary burr at a 25 degree bevel, while peacefully contemplating the flock of bushtits in the nearby crabapple tree. A blissful moment, I assure you. Without worrying about whether I'm going to change the temper from 61 to 57.

There's a link below to tempering colors. Note that when blue/purple starts to appear, there has at least been a transient somewhere north of 500F running across the steel. In the low 400's Fahrenheit, W1 (straight high carbon), O1, and A2 are all RC60-61. At 500F, W1 is at 59 (not a bad showing!), but O1 has dropped to 57, and A2 to 56 (A2 stays at RC56 til you get to 1000F). And at 500F, you're not even in the blue/purple range yet. With Tormek, these things don't go through my mind--I'm just immersed in my neighborhood goings-on.

There is some mention below about grinding to a burr being almost the same as stopping 1/64" short. If I'm grinding, I want a primary burr so I know I'm down to fresh steel, and have ground some wear off the blade back, too. So there's no worn steel hiding out at the end of the blade. If I stop 1/64" short, I still need to get out the 1000 stone or equal, and get to a burr. But if I've ground to a burr, I can start on just about any stone--8000 Shapton or a natural stone that is thereabouts.

One other thing I have come to like about Tormek: it makes a really long, low bevel, terminating at 20 degrees or so. I like those.

Wiley


Tempering colors

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#37

Does this mean you free-hand grind daggers?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Even the knife sites I frequent talk about using jigs a fair amount :D

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#38

Re: An explanation ...

RobertHarrison

I agree with you, Joel. I grind right to the burr every time. I prefer to do it outside with a hand grinder which makes it easy to work fast and not burn the steel. There is also better light and better air outside. We have outdoor workbenches outside where we repair tractors,etc. The hand grinder is essentially portable. I have a powered grinder, a water cooled powered wheel grinder and a large, floor standing belt sander machine inside. All can be used, but nine times out of ten, unless there is a foot and a half of snow out there, I take the hand grinder outside to grind a new bevel on a chisel or plane blade and I go right to the burr with it. If I don't grind all the way to the burr, the only reason not to is to try to not waste steel.

To each his own.

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#39

Re: An explanation ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I grind right to the burr every time. I prefer to do it outside with a hand grinder which makes it easy to work fast and not burn the steel.

Hi Robert

Would you use your high speed dry grinder to do this?

Joel, I replied early on to your comments, then deleted my post, as I wanted to give time to others to respond as well. Only Wiley did so, and in a separate thread. His view accords exactly with mine: the advantage of the Tormek is that it gets you to the edge of a bevel safely.

I read earlier your comments about not worrying too much if the blade is burned a little, however I am mindful that the blue/purple/dark brown is at a high enough temperature to lower the hardness of the steel, even if it does this just a little. Perhaps not as much as one fears, but enough to lower the edge holding of that blade. Yes? No?

I am also capable of grinding to the edge of the blade with my high speed grinder, and the combination of a 3X and cambered wheel (both which I got from you) makes the task so much easier and safer. But still not nearly as safe and stress-free as when done on a Tormek. At least for me. Even if I get there without any apparent colour changes, I still remained concerned that the temper has been altered by the action of the friction-heat on the thin edge.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#40

Re: An explanation ...

joel moskowitz

one important point:

when I say a little burn isn't a big deal I don't mean that's typical or should be encouraged, just that once in awhile it might happen and it's not a big deal and certainly the tradeoff in speed between being safe with a tormek, and working at this very very slight risk is substantial.

My blog on Tuesday is going to be a followup on my grinding article and the blade I ground for the blog took me less than a minute (excluding stops for pictures) and because of this quick time with no setup time to speak of I hollow grind everything and save substantial time honing and wear and tear on my stones. The actual additional metal wear is nil because the honing takes away the same amount of material I'm just removing the waste material in the middle of the bevel a lot faster.

For anyone who does not earn their living working in a shop whatever feels right to you and makes you want to work in the workshop is the way to go. For anyone who is trying to make a living at woodworking if you spend 10 minutes more at the sharpening process than someone else who spends 2 minutes you are at a competitive disadvantage which adds up.

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#41

This practice is common in commercial shops

Bill Tindall

"For anyone who does not earn their living working in a shop whatever feels right to you and makes you want to work in the workshop is the way to go."

That is a fine piece of wisdom. Presenting alternative ways of accomplishing a task is not a criticism of some other approach but rather additional information for the undecided.

I see a lot of hollow ground tools in commercial shops and a bench grinder in the corner to do it with. Not the only way, but a way to be considered if cheap and fast are important. What is important to communicate is that this approach can be successful with a modest amount of skill and practice. I recently taught someone how to use the bench grinder and they got it the first time on a thin Stanley blade, the hardest to do. They were cautious and slow (maybe 5 minutes to get it straight) but speed will come with practice and confidence.

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#42

Many paths up the mountain...

Bob Hackett

and they all lead to the same destination.

The only one who`s truly lost is the one who perpetually circles the base of the mountain insisting everyone else is taking the wrong road. :)

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#44

Re: Crowning wheel eliminates problem & is better *LINK*

joel moskowitz

I just published the blog I mentioned about this topic. It has some drawings and photos that might explain using a wheel camber a little better. The link is here:


More Thoughts On Grinding

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#45

Got one...

Tony - Memphis

I ordered teh new Tormek truing tool. I already had teh diamond, so I ordered the jig without the diamond. I tried it out tlast weekend and was impressed. It worked great and was pretty fast.

I got stuck with one the chrome shafted Tormeks (makes me feel like I got shafted!). The shaft rusted and the wheel is "permanently" attached. Tormek had their stateside dealer sell me a shaft at half price. That was decent of them as the unit is pretty old. I thnk I can save the wheel. They offered some advice on getting it off the old shaft. I hope like heck I can save it. A new one is $178. In spite of this, I still like the Tormek. After I trued up the wheel, I sharpened all of my turnig tools and a chisel in short order. Given the price, I can't justify it though. They have gone up somewhat since I got mine. I think I owuld invest in a slow wheel grinder and some good wheels. The Tormek jigs can be used on dry grinder too. I am going to set that up with my old non-threaded Tormek tool support that I reoplaced with a new threaded model. I'll use the dry grinder for hogging.

Tony

Re: Truing grinding wheel

#46

Re: Got one...

david weaver

Don't take the old wheel off the shaft unless you intend to switch wheels around all the time. You will likely break the wheel, and it doesn't matter if the shaft is stuck to the current wheel if you can use it. You can put the stainless arbor on when you've used up that stone. Otherwise, you're likely to end up breaking that wheel now before you get a chance to wear it out.

My first wheel froze hard to the shaft, I managed to get it off, probably because there was enough chrome plate stuck to the stone for it to break free from the arbor.

I switched my wheel to the black wheel believing it would be a better wheel to use than the aluminum oxide (it was actually worse to me, because it's not friable enough and only diamond truing or scuffing brings the surface back to fast cutting).

Anyway, I didn't realize that putting the black wheel on the shaft that was already nasty would mean I'd never get the wheel off without breaking it. Essentially, that's what happened. I, too, had the stainless steel shaft but I had to pay full price for it. I decided to give the machine to a friend, and had to take the wheel off to ship it. Despite getting the first one off successfully and spending an hour farting around with the second one, it finally broke after an hour or so of prying and turning, etc. Of course, as soon as it broke in half, both halves came right off.

So now I have an expensive broken black stone (that I kept) that's cleanly broken through and I ate the expense of the stainless shaft. Good riddance to all of it.