New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Question about hammers

Posts

Question about hammers

#1

Question about hammers

Patrick Gibbons

Cross pein hammers, such as a Warrington pattern, are considered by many to be a cabinetmaker's hammer. I wonder if this is more of a British tradition. I've never seen them offered for sale in vintage catalogs of American manufacturers. I must admit my exposure to these catalogs is limited. I've also read in a bazillion places that the pein is for easily starting small nails. Honestly, have any of you ever tried this? It just doesn't work for me. I can't really believe this is what the pein is for. I have three Warringtons that I use often. This has more to do with them being the appropriate size. Any wisdom on the subject?

Re: Question about hammers

#2

Half my life . . .

steve mackay

I've looked for years and years for an Eastwing, leather handle, English pattern, 16 oz. . I know they made them. I saw them (when I didn't want one !). One day. In a dark & dank junk store. Covered with rust (sorry . . . "patina") I shall be rewarded.

Re: Question about hammers

#3

yes indeed

Bill Tindall

I have a very small version of this hammer. Just yesterday I started some tiny short brads with the wedgy part. But if the brads are 1/2" I use tweezers to hold them if the location is awkward.

Re: Question about hammers

#4

Re: Question about hammers

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

The hammer I use in the shop is a 10oz continental pattern and I rarely use the cross peen end. Back when I was an apprentice I tried getting used to starting small finish nails with the cross peen end but it was a technique that just never took with me.

Robin

Re: Question about hammers

#5

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Question about hammers

Stephen Shepherd

Patrick,

I got my first one as an apprentice 40 years ago and have always had several around my shop. I use it as advertised to start small brads and finish cut nails, once you get the method right it works, if not it pinches.

As for them being English, aren't we all? About 56% of the Utah Pioneers were from the UK, so plenty of old ones around out here. There is a toolbox in a local museum that has a Warrington pattern hammer, dating from the 1860's.

Mercer lists similar cross pein as riveting hammers.

Stephen

Re: Question about hammers

#6

Re: Question about hammers

TomD

I agree about their working as advertised, as others have said. I was told that with hammers when you want to hit flat things, you use rounded end hammers, and when you want to hit round things, you use a flat hammer. Japanese chisel hammers have one flat an one domed end. It's not always true but it makes sense if you think about it. If you have a chisel with a domed butt, then when hit with a flat hammer face it will push the chisel in the direction of swing because the ball of the handle and the flat of the hammer contact at only one point. If you were hitting with a round hammer on a round head it could skid apart. If you are hitting a flat head nail like a 16 penny, then you need a shallow dome to the face to deal with any hammer presentation errors, with the radius of the swing determining the working range for the dome of the hammer head.

The anti-hammer in this case is the carver's mallet which has a cross-sectional radius to maximize alignment errors, and is flat in the direction of the swing. But they work, and I guess they were easy to make on a lathe. I hated the type though, due to my upbringing, but now I use the urethane versions a lot, and the plasticity of the head makes up for a lot of issues I was told would be a problem.

Of course there is more than one kind of tack hammer. Some tacks are longer, some shorter, and some fit in odd spaces. So if the cross peen does not suit the tack in hand, it may be a job that requires one of the other types.

The thing about these hammers is that as cross peen hammers they are obviously derived from designs that have nothing to do with driving tacks. This style is designed for moving metal, and very similar hammers are used in sheet metal and blacksmithing. In fact one version of tack hammer that has a cross peen on it, and is more commonly used on the continent, is just a scaled down version of a common blacksmith hammer. The other oddity is the extent to which tacks are really used in cabinetmaking. This is a subject of discussion, but maybe we have these derivative hammers because tacks aren't an important enough mater to deserve a characteristic hammer of their own. Though that seems hardly likely where upholstery is concerned.

One modern day hammer that is interesting is the piton hammer that has been developed for rock climbing, now a somewhat obsolete type. It is interesting how this type developed to be almost identical to blacksmith hammers since blacksmiths that climbed were the early developers. So one might conclude there is a bias in hammer design that separates design from pure function, unless the type has ample time to develop it's own character. Both nails, and climbing nails are somewhat transitional types, not having a long period of mass production. But that is getting beyond even speculation.

Re: Question about hammers

#7

But Tom, there are tack hammers...

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

One of my hammers has a brass head, with long peens* and inserted steel faces: one magnetic, one not. You stand the tack on the magnetic end, use that to "set" the tack in place, then spin the hammer around on the backstroke and use the non-magnetic end to set it. It's a marvel with carpet tacks (yes, some of us still tack our carpets down), and would probably be equally useful with upholstery tacks.

*looks a little like a pushme/pullyou anteater.

Re: Question about hammers

#8

Re: But Tom, there are tack hammers...

TomD

Sounds like everyone should have one!

Re: Question about hammers

#9

Re: Question about hammers

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

i just picked up the most expensive hammer I have ever owned.

A Stiletto TB15 Titanium hammer.This thing is a beast.I am currently working on a

refinery rehab project building scaffolding.Almost every piece we touch is metal and the main components get locked together by hammering a cup nut shut. I never thought after 27 years as a carpenter I would buy such an expensive hammer($200)...now I am just sad I didn't do it earlier.The hammer weighs 15 oz but has an impact like a 28 oz hammer.


Had I not gotten a bargain on a bulk order on Ebay I'd probably still not have one.

I know this really isn't relevant to the original post but a guy has to gloat when he can and it IS a hand tool : )

Re: Question about hammers

#10

Thank you for buying a California tool

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Not sure where production is, but the corporate HQ is in the California valley, in an area that needs the income - so thanks!

Re: Question about hammers

#11

Follow up

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Tom,

In addition to the hammer I mentioned, I've got another upholstery hammer of similar functional design. The brass hammer I described in my earlier post is to the right, here:


The magnetic face is the one to the right; the hammering face, to the left, is presumably larger because you no longer have the tack right there; it also distinguishes the hammering face from the magnetic face.

By the way, I've never tried removing the electrical tape to see if it's hiding a crack or just serving as a padded grip.

The hammer to the left uses a slightly different approach: the magnetic face (again, to the right) is a horseshoe magnet made by slitting the face back over most of the length of the poll (is that the right term? - the portion between face and where the handle attaches), with the slit getting wider behind the face. Alas, the magnet seems to have lost its magic. I have a friend at my old university, a professor of physics, who has offered to help me re-magnetize a few of my tools; I really need to get around to taking him to lunch, so he can take me to the lab's electromagnet afterward. It would be nice to catch up with him anyway.

This lost magic seems to be a common issue with this tack hammer design. One way to magnetize a tool is to clamp a magnet to it and strike it a firm blow, encouraging the iron atoms to align, thus creating the magnet field. Perhaps the repeated shock of driving tacks with the hammering end gets the iron atoms all agitated and mis-aligned.

When I was a kid, my father had a tack hammer of the design shown below. This shows the horseshoe magnet layout, to the right side. These are still pretty freely available (Stanley, Ace Hardware, etc.). I owned one of them at one time (the magnet on which had lost its magic, too), but donated it after I got the upholstery hammers, which are better designed and cooler.


img

Re: Question about hammers

#12

Re: Thank you for buying a California tool

TomD

I think it is a myth that Ti hammers hit above their weight. The Ti hammer craze hit at the same time that the Ti driver craze hit. If a Ti driver was worth 500 dollars (at the time a quantum increase in cost) then a Ti hammer had to be good also. Ti drivers, however were not lighter, not even by a gram than Steel or wood drivers, they were larger. Any performance increase there may have been was based on engineering more forgiveness, and a larger sweet spot. They are generally longer in the shaft which is a really upsetting factor in golf swing dynamics, and therefore, having a large head is hoped to make up for that increase in length, and come out better in the end.

On hammers, to breeze past the math, basically you have to increase swing velocity by a quantum that sounds small but is highly significant. It works out to be the same amount that distinguishes par golfers from PGA tour player averages (I did these number at the time this stuff came out), and PGA tour average from the long hitting champs on the tour. In other words it is not an amount you can just pour on, any more than I can just go out there and hit it as far as tour pro by jumping on it a little.

There may be differences, such as that you can jump on it a little because nails are not as hard to hit as golf balls (maybe); Lightening a hammer by a third does make some increased swing speed possible. Many hammerers, can't sink a framing nail in one swat anyway, so their idea of "the same" may be a matter of loosing count of the blows; Until not so long ago, in many parts of the country framing hammers were not the California style, and a 16 oz claw hammer was used, so a 15 ounce long handle hammer is more powerful. There is a difference between swingers and hitters. Basically swingers use the weight of the head. So if you swing, you are likely noticing that something is missing. If you hit, this hammer may suit you better, particularly if you believe it is the equal of a steel hammer.

Anyone who thinks a long shaft ti hammer of 15 ounces hits as hard as a 21 ounce steel hammer, needs to explain why a 15 ounce long shafted steel hammer would not work as well. Particularly when a lot of framers choke up on the shafts to regular length much of the time. There is no evidence I am aware of that Ti has some magic properties. Magic properties have been suggested for other materials, like beryllium (you guessed it, it is extra heavy), over the years, but normally they don't catch on.

Ti hammers are perfect for those who want to carry a hammer, but nail a lot with a gun. It is a lot lighter to carry, and it works pretty darn well. Ti hammers can spark when they hit grit, particularly noticeable at dusk. So if there is an explosive hazard in the area you work in, not a typical framing issue, but common in wreaking, it might be worth asking the manufacturer about any such risks.

I own two Ti hammers, a Stiletto and a Dalluge, and and would probably own more if there were more to try out. But the Ti versions of finish, roofing, and drywall, hammers do not sell around here.

Re: Question about hammers

#13

Another question about hammers

Patrick Gibbons

Nail hammers are hardened and are meant to be used with nails that are soft- not tempered. That means they shouldn't really be used with a nail set which is hardened. Ball pein hammers are softer and can be used with cold chisels. Should a woodworker's cross pein hammer be more like a nail hammer or a ball pein? I would assume it's a type of nail hammer. At least that's what I use them for.

Re: Question about hammers

#14

Mythbusters demolished this one

Bill Tindall

On one episode they tired every imaginable way to chip a nail hammer, old and new, and could not do it.

Re: Question about hammers

#15

I used to hear the same thing...

John in NM

about rock hammers... there was always one old professor lecturing the freshmen on not using a rock hammer (has a pointing end and a flat end) as a chisel and hitting it with another hammer. Never tried it, never worried about it, I figure if the hammer is going to shatter, hitting a nice chunk of granite would do as good a job as another hammer :D

I did once get hit by a piece of a splitting wedge that got hit by a glancing blow with a maul. It was either a mild steel wedge (homemade out of 2" rebar) or the aluminum sawing wedge that us dumb kids didn't know wasn't for splitting. So I would say that, personally, I find hitting soft metals with a hammer a bit more risky than hitting hard ones (the real wedges were fine, must have been hardened) :D

Re: Question about hammers

#16

When it comes right down to it

John in NM

Everyone I know (3 now, used to be 2 :D ) who has switched to a lighter framing hammer prefers it. I've not gone into the physics of it either, so I won't speculate about that.

But I don't think any professional framers are losing count of blows. I've met plenty of guys who claim to sink framing nails in one, and being both gullible and not really interested I simply believe them. Of course that belief is encouraged by knowing I can sink them in 2-3 most of the time, and I'm not all that good at it :D

Re: Question about hammers

#17

On the perils of splitting wedges

Bill Tindall

I am fastidious about keeping my splitting wedges from making a mushroom. I keep them ground. Never-the-less they can be dangerous.

I was splitting some fence posts out of a locust log, straddle the log and with the wedge in the end to start the split. As far as I could tell I was hitting square and not with full strength on an old wedge, but one not mushroomed.

I felt something hit my thigh and felt the spot with my hand. It came up dripping with blood. To cut to the end, apparently a disc of metal spalled off the wedge. It was so thin and sharp, and at such high velocity, that it went through my light pants and through my thigh resulting in a cut that looked like a knife stab. Fortunately no major blood vessels were severed.

All I can think of is that the metal had become fatigued and weakened from years of pounding on it.

Re: Question about hammers

#18

Re: When it comes right down to it

TomD

I remember the original Larry Hahn review in FHB and it was pretty supportive of the 14 hits like 21 hoopla. Subsequently I think he may have changed his mind, as he wrote for publication in 2002:

"These days, most framers west of the Miss. prefer a 21 oz... Women friends in the trade tell me they like the Stiletto 14 oz..."

And doesn't that say in a couple of sentences what I, as usual wrote a book on.

That said, 10 years further down the line it does not surprise me at all that "pros" love them. we are in a world of nail guns, even factory floor production of one-off custom homes. I never said Ti hammers were bad hammers, just that 14 oz does not hit like 21. And it would be pretty strange if it did. We are also in a world of TV show pros who commonly carry very fancy hammers. There are also some good parallels in golf as to why that might be.

Re: Question about hammers

#19

Re: Mythbusters demolished this one

TomD

Probablt true. Clever dudes. That said, like everything else, if you know the subject, they often sound hopelessly out of depth. Which leads to their having to do follow up shows on the same topic. I have no opinion on the myth in this case.

Re: Question about hammers

#20

Re: On the perils of splitting wedges

TomD

At one point I was splitting some oak for chairs, and it really wasn't up to it a little twisted, and it rebounded a lot. I went back to my source material and noticed that he was splitting out by hitting an axe head with a wooden glutt. So I made one of those, and despite the stock I had on hand being much lighter than my sledge and wedge combo, it went right on through. More recently I had some experience where I picked up a sledge and wedge and it worked fine. Not sure what to make of any of this, but I wish I could get those metal wedges that have a socket into which one can insert a stout wooden tail. Maybe that would solve safety and dead blow issues.

I will note that a lot of hitting axes with wooden clubs, even accurately hitting the heads, is not that great for the handle fit.

Re: Question about hammers

#21

Agree

Bill Tindall

Sometimes their ignorance of the matter at hand leaves them out on a limb. The recent cannon ball through the town comes to mind. But in this case they bashed all sorts of hammers together. They even involved a blacksmith as I recall and even got some old hammers to see if they would respond different. I thought it one of the more through shows.

But the best show is the water heater through the roof. OMG!!!

Re: Question about hammers

#22

OT - Mythbusters

Steve Elliott

In one episode they tried and failed to split an arrow with another arrow (as in the old Robin Hood TV show). They found that the grain of the wood always trumped whatever scheme they used.

If they had prepared the arrow shafts by riving the wood they might have produced ones that would guide the incoming arrow all the way down the shaft.

Re: Question about hammers

#23

Re: OT - Mythbusters

R Payne

They revisited that one with rived arrows and still failed to split down the shaft. They concluded that the nock prevented splitting the shaft.

Re: Question about hammers

#24

Re: When it comes right down to it

Ron Hock

I suspect the primary difference between steel and titanium hammers has to do with titanium's greater modulus of elasticity. I think a lot of the effort of hammering is in the lifting of the hammer for the next blow. Titanium bounces more than steel so it is ready for the next swing with less effort. This could be why nobody uses dead-blow hammers for driving nails.

Re: Question about hammers

#25

Re: Thank you for buying a California tool

Andy Lincoln,in Dearborn MI

Bill,

You will be pleased to know I did not order just one hammer but

between two purchases I am up to 17 new hammers.Any way I can help the State of California

I will certainly try.If I could get guys interested in the Stiletto Nail Puller bet those would sell well also.