New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Hold Downs

Posts

Hold Downs

#1

Hold Downs

William Duffield

A few years ago, I wrote an article for WoodCentral on versatile hold down clamps.

http://www.woodcentral.com/cgi-bin/readarticle.pl?dir=jigs&file=articles_144.shtml

Mine are Purpleheart, but Woodpeckers and others make hold downs in aluminum that work on the same principal.

Originally, I thought that the best way to use these was to drill half inch holes in the bench top and install threaded inserts. However, threaded inserts are a bit of a pain to install, especially when you might need them all over the place. They also work using T-bolts in T-track, but here the issue is the amount of force you can apply to the screws holding the T-track down.

More recently, I built a meta-bench, with what some have determined to be way too many dog holes. I thought it might be a useful idea to be able to mount stock between dogs on the front of the meta-banch, so I drilled a series of dog holes along the front edge of the top, carefully aligning them with the row of dog holes I had already drilled in the top of the bench. I also put a matching hole in the side of the front vise chop.


If you are a turner, you already have a saddle square like this one. I have three, in different sizes, and I've been toying with the idea of grinding one leg down to 6° so I could use it as a dovetail marking gauge. It would still work with the rule as a center finder.


Be careful how deeply you drill the holes in the side, or you will be drilling and tapping a hole in the end of your dog so you can extract it.

For holding work to the front or top of this bench, I have migrated to using Grammercy holdfasts or a Moxon vise. While hammered-down holdfasts and two wheeled vise jaws are both very effective for holding work to the top or front of a bench, they’re not the only alternative.

After installing the dog holes, the proverbial light bulb turned on, and I implemented this idea. It makes better use of some of the superfluous dog holes.


I drilled a hole in the side of a Veritas Bench Pup, using a v-block, and tapped it to match the threads of my hold downs. 1/4-20 UNC or 5/16-18 UNC both work. These are 5/16".


The dogs can be inserted in either the horizontal or the vertical dog holes.



Re: Hold Downs

#2

Re: Hold Downs

James Watriss

Great execution, but WOW that bench looks like Swiss cheese!

:-)

Re: Hold Downs

#3

Many ways to defur. felines

rononkokomo

Thanks for sharing this clever solution

Re: Hold Downs

#4

Re: Hold Downs

TomD

I need one of those, which is why I need full scale picks. I can't bring myself to drill holes in my bench, but I think I could build one where the whole thing was holes. That's cool. And there are a lot of clamping options.

Re: Hold Downs

#5

Re: Many ways to defur. felines

Jim Ritter

Thanks for sharing that William. It was nice chatting with you last night. That hold down was featured in WoodSmith mag it I remember correctly. I wonder if those wedge things from the bicycle handle bars that we talked about would work to secure the bolt for a hold down in a regular dog hole?

Re: Hold Downs

#6

Re: Many ways to defur. felines

William Duffield

I wouldn't be surprised if that's where I first saw my holddowns. August Home (Shop Notes and Woodsmith) is an invaluable resource for those starting out in woodworking, and you can find an index of everything they've ever published, and buy a copy.

It's been half a century since I've taken that part of a bicycle apart, so I have no idea what the diameter might be. Thinking about the modern ones that Lee Valley offers, however, I imagine lots of sharp edges and lots of pressure down in the dog holes, which I can imagine would play a lot more havoc with your bench top than the Grammercy holdfasts. At about $30 something a pair, they are a real bargain, and you can immediately apply them to holding wherever you can drill a 3/4" hole in a hunk of hardwood.

The vise chat was interesting. Too bad we didn't have time to delve more deeply into more of the fascinating vises that are out there. Maybe Stephen will suggest a reprise of the topic. I got there a little late. Did you post the pic of the hand screw carver's vise? I really liked that idea, and may try to adapt it to my PanaVise, with a smaller hand screw, of course.

Re: Hold Downs

#7

Yep

rononkokomo

That's where I saw them. I actually made some. Where in the world are they :)

Re: Hold Downs

#8

Re: Many ways to defur. felines

Jim Ritter

Yea that was my photo. As a boat builder I'm always trying to figure out how to hold odd things. Nothing is square. And it is all different dimensions. You've got some good ideas too I see. I would defiantly like to revisit that vise chat.

Re: Hold Downs

#9

Re: Many ways to defur. felines

William Duffield

I see in the background, you also have a Zyliss. One of those is also on my list of things to get a grip on.


This one is not mine, nor is the work-mutt.

Re: Hold Downs

#10

Re: Many ways to defur. felines

Jim Ritter

Yup I'm a fan of that Zyliss vise. The bench I just finished was designed around the dimensions of that vise. I've got a bunch of them. Often use them in pairs to hold oars for varnishing, just clamp them to the same 2x4 clamped in the workmutt.

Re: Hold Downs

#11

Re: Handlebar stems

TomD

Typically these are 1", or 1.125, or 1.25. Basically road bikes, MTBs, or Tandems.

The system has been largely replaced with so called threadless stems. Threadless refers to the kind of stem that works with a threadless steering tube and headset. It does not refer to the construction of the stem.

Re: Hold Downs

#12

craigd

Re: Handlebar stems

craigd

Typically these are 1", or 1.125, or 1.25

Old school quill stems are 22.2mm (7/8") and if you get a wedged one, they will expand to about 1" (I just measured). I have a bunch of 1" quills but I don't think they were made for very long. 1.25"? Was that a Gary Fisher thing?

Re: Hold Downs

#13

Re: Handlebar stems

TomD

Good catch, I copied the wrong column. My only current bike has a quill stem so I guess I should know better. I only have the frame prep tools for modern forks though.

The 1.25 is tandem, if they used oversized tubes. Or a single like a Bike Friday where the main triangle is just a single oversized boom tube. So it might be there for more bearing surface, or it might be there just to smooth the tubing fit. One can fit a fat tube to a standard head tube size if one doesn't mind tapering the tube. There are even larger sizes, for maybe monoshocks. All of which is severely OT this discussion. I, as you can tell, am no expert on this stuff. The tools are so expensive I try to keep everything I make to 1.125. My set may include the 1" also. Can't recall.

Re: Hold Downs

#14

late to the party and puzzled

Bill Tindall

I just figured out this hole arrangement and was left bewildered. If I was faced holding down the piece in Figure 5 I would either grab it in my vise or afix it to the bench with two "f" style clamps which would be very much less in the way, provide more clamp force and be faster to install. While the multitude of holes, pivoting hold down points etc. is creative I have not grasped the benefit over more straight forward solutions to immobilizing something on the bench.

I just had a vise on my slab bench for many years and never failed to be able to hold all that was needed holding. Later I added a row of holes behind the vise dog with are occasionally handy. But it is rare that some combination of F clamps and the vise doesn't hold anything that I need held. I will add that I do very little hand surface planing or jointing, and no carving, and maybe this colors my bench needs. But for my needs a huge selection of F style clamps and a quick action vise accomplishes almost all my needs to hold something. Add a couple of those left and right hand thread wooden screw clamps and I have never found it inconvenient to hold anything I have encountered.

If one is contemplating all this bench paraphernalia because that is what was on some bench in 1720, I would point out that in 1720 quick action vises and handy steel clamps were not available. It may well be that with modern clamping and vise choices some of the 1720 paraphernalia is unnecessary, or even inferior, unless historical conditions are desired.

Re: Hold Downs

#15

Re: It seemed like a good idea at the time

William Duffield

Your assessment is completely valid, and if someone were starting from scratch, I couldn't agree with you more. To begin to understand why I ever implemented this Rube Goldberg solution, you have to reflect on its history, in my shop.

I have had the holddowns since before I can recollect that anyone offered them commercially. For the intended applications, these work well when implemented in beech, rock maple, purpleheart, jarrah, etc., are much less expensive than the equivalent De-Sta-Co or Bessey toggle clamps, and are easy to build. Their advantage over the commercially available toggles is that you only need one threaded insert to attach them to whatever jig you are building, and you can install the TI anywhere you want it in a hunk of hardwood or BB ply or MDF that is a half inch or better thick. That jig, of course, is NOT the Loxiliary meta-bench, which doesn't y et harbor any threaded inserts.

If you have a drill press and a 3/4" Forstner bit (a FAMAG BorMax is even better), dog holes are as easy to turn out as doughnut holes. Dog holes are a pretty generic concept, applicable to wood or brass bench dogs, hold fasts, work lights, and temporary holding of a wide variety of tools.


They work with end vises and face vises, and they secure stock on the top or front of the bench, and they work with holdfasts.

So, how much work does it take, beyond a small leap of the imagination, to take all this stuff that's already collecting spiderwebs all over the shop: the hold downs; a couple of bench pups; the drill press and a v-block and and a tap, and significantly increase your work holding options?

I still prefer Grammercy holdfasts, a deadblow mallet, and some Jorgensen handscrews, but no matter what tools you suggest, you will always find someone who doesn't want to spend anything on tools. There are as many woodworkers out there who brag about how little they spend on tools as there are those who brag about how much they spend on tools (and then there are the collectors, who couldn't use any of the historical artifacts they hoard if their life depended on it). Therefore, I offered this alternative, because it performs the intended functions, the incremental cost (in the environment in which it was invented, anyway) was totally insignificant, and its development was interesting.

Re: Hold Downs

#16

Re: late to the party and puzzled

TomD

Well he did refer to preferred alternatives as "they’re not the only alternative." After which he suggested some home made fittings. I think a fair number of people would say the hold downs William prefers are faster and less squirrelly than your F clamps.

Re: Hold Downs

#17

Re: late to the party and puzzled

William Duffield

That's why I retitled it "Stupid Dog Trick" when I reposted the info on the Messages forum (less than an hour after I posted here). Curiously, so far I've gotten over a hundred more views over there than here, but only one comment. I'm not sure what that says about what draws people to the Messages forum, but it seems to me that it is a lot less about serious woodworking than what draws people to the Hand Tools forum.

Re: Hold Downs

#18

It`s more about working with your mind

Bob Hackett

At least for me it is.

One of the things that drew me to blacksmithing was the ability to look at metal as potential. If I had a forge, simple tools and time then I could make just about anything I needed from a lump of the appropriate metal. That same thought process spilled over into woodworking.

If you live in or near a city and have a substantial bank account then it`s probably quicker and easier for you to run out and buy whatever you need. I know a lot of people with huge shops filled with an overabundance of expensive tools who`s first response to a new project is; "what new tools do I need to buy to make this"? These are the people who visit my shop frequently and many times leave substantial amounts of cash on my bench because I know how to make unique and shiny tools that will impress their buddies. May the Gods bless these merry gentlemen and keep them coming back.

The folks I most like to visit are the ones who can look at something, deconstruct that project down to the least amount of effort and steps needed to complete it, then go out into the woods or the scrap pile, quickly drag whatever they need back into the shop and get to work.

I find those folks have a far better understanding of the materials they`re working with, engage in more finesse and less overkill, and worry far less about rules, boundries and limitations. They don`t so much look at projects in terms of tools and materials. They look at what surrounds them and ask themselves "How can I make do with this"? I also find these types of folks care a whole lot less about straight lines and square corners, they prefer fair curves, user friendly corners and edges and a more organic look and feel in the projects they make.

William`s toggles and " The Holey Bench" may seem overly complicated when you have a wall full of clamps hanging in your suburban shop. When you live over an hour away from the nearest WWing store andyou factor in the drive, time away from the shop, catching a meal on the road, the fact that WWing shop may actually be sold out of what you need even after you called to be sure they had it, and various other unforeseen things those toggles and the system that holds them to that bench begin to seem like a downright elegant and a simple fix using what is available with very little time wasted.

Re: Hold Downs

#19

Re: It`s more about working with your mind

roger lance

Bob....I agree....one of the major reasons I've involved myself with WW was the freedom to use my mind. If you have worked in a large organization, you know that you will be limited to some small part of a project and that your ideas will probably not be used....you will be over-ruled. But in your own shop, all decisions are yours.....you are free to problem solve, create, and implement from start to finish. Keeping your mind active and challenged as we age is a vital thing to do....just like the body. Sometimes, I get it right....sometimes not....but the important thing is that it is my own creative effort....whether others like it or not is no longer the point.