New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

What's a #1 worth?

Posts

What's a #1 worth?

#1

Ellis Walentine

What's a #1 worth?

Ellis Walentine

I had an inquiry today from a fellow who found a #1 Stanley in a bunch of tools he inherited. I didn't know what to tell him....

Ellis

Re: What's a #1 worth?

#2

Re: What's a #1 worth?

Stuart Hough

Ellis,

I have watched them on ebay go for everything between $250 for a base casting covered in rust, all the way to $1250 for one in great shape. I even saw one with a "Buy it now" price of $2250 for a " mint, pristine, never-been-used" unit with the original box and papers that looked like it was freshly cast. It's kinda crazy the way collectors slobber over them. (Having said that...I can go to about $650 for the right user-grade unit :) )

Re: What's a #1 worth?

#3

Ellis Walentine

Photos of the plane

Ellis Walentine




Re: What's a #1 worth?

#4

Re: What's a #1 worth?

steve mackay

I keep a pretty good watch on Da'Bay. Stuart's right. 2,000 or better shinny w/ box. This week 950 tarnished "user". Colectors would nit-pick this one down to 650 or seven. But, as we all know . . . put it in front of the right two pepole on Da'Bay . . . CAT FIGHT !

Re: What's a #1 worth?

#5

Re: What's a #1 worth?

Gary Ascher

I am the owner of this plane. I am a retired wood patternmaker.

As an apprentice many years ago I found this plane in the shape it is in.

I put it with the other planes I had been collecting and I never did use it.

I have not cleaned it up yet. Just blew the sawdust off that has been there for 40 years.

Thanks for all the information.

This picture might help the dating of it.

Re: What's a #1 worth?

#6

Plane date and type *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hello Gary,

Welcome! Down below is a link to Josh Clark's pages on Stanley Bailey plane types and dates. As he explains, type studies are not bulletproof, in that there were 'in-between' types and occasionally even today something will surface that hasn't been seen before. But the probabilities are on your side--the one you have is probably a known type that can be identified by comparing its features with those on the various charts.

Suggest you first try the 'One Page Plane Dating Flowchart', to get the hang of it. Then if need be, or if you like the hunt, go to the more detailed ones.

Wiley


Josh Clark's Stanley Bailey Type Study Pages

Re: What's a #1 worth?

#7

Re: Plane date and type

Gary Ascher

Thanks Wiley,

I used that site a few days ago and what I found it was a Type 1.

Not understanding everything I wasnt certain so I posted here.

I did the flow chart again and it still seems its a Type 1.

Thanks ,

Gary

Re: What's a #1 worth?

#8

Ran across a post on Craigs List

DizD

Hilton Head Island SC last Friday- Asking $1600. Looks to be in great condition.

Re: What's a #1 worth?

#9

Fad ? . . .

steve mackay

I'm wondering if the "Metro-Yuppies" have lost interest in "Things Planes". So the days of the 2K and up #1 might be over. They seem to be moving on to vintage Johnny Deeres and vintage bumper cars that they motorize. Good for me though. I'm still hunting my #8 "C" at rust prices !

Re: What's a #1 worth?

#10

Moses Yoder

Re: Plane date and type

Moses Yoder

I am not sure the #1 fits in with standard #4 plane dating. I notice for instance the lever cap is solid on the back side, but don't know enough about #1 planes to say if they aren't all like that. That would also apply to the adjuster nut; I believe the nut on the #1 plane was solid long after the others were hollow. The iron logo is very early though, it could be a type 1 #1. If it were mine of course I wouldn't sell it, I would die of starvation first and pass it on to my children. If you do sell it on ebay make sure to get photos with plenty of light on a white background. Photograph the bed as you have but show the whole thing, a good photo of the adjuster nut and iron and the plane overall from 4 or 5 different angles.

Re: What's a #1 worth?

#11

Re: Fad ? . . .

Michael Brady

I would value the plane in the photo at about $750. #1 rear totes come at a pretty dear price and that plane needs one. I wouldn't clean that plane, by the way. It will do nothing for its value if you are planning on selling it, and could lower the value if done incorrectly. I'm kind of sorry I sold mine, but it made a bunch of useful tools possible for me to own. They are shelf queens.

Re: What's a #1 worth?

#12

Ellis Walentine

Different totes...

Ellis Walentine

... for different folks? I have grafted horns on totes in the past and you'd never know they weren't original. (Collectors would, I guess.) But, is a repaired item generally of lower value than one repaired from original parts?

Ellis