New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

OT - what are these guys thinking?

Posts

OT - what are these guys thinking?

#1

OT - what are these guys thinking?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I've been watching the development...or non-development...of a tree trimming project two streets over. Someone - must have been a professional, as I can't imagine an amateur doing this climbing - limbed three trees at the front corner of the lot on a house or business last Wednesday. The trunks have been like this ever since:


I'm up on the roof at the back of the house right now, trimming out the chimney on our remodel, so I can see this desecration every day. I wish they'd either finish cutting the trees down or use their time travel machine and undo what they've done.

Our town has a heritage tree ordinance - perhaps they're a heritage species, and the tree trimming firm involved failed to get clearance before beginning. Regardless, it's painful to look at these toothpicks.

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#2

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

Patrick Gibbons

Those trees look to be straight and tall. Are they pines? The drought here in Texas has left many trees standing in nearly the same shape. I would assume the project stopped in mid-progress. Your guess about heritage tree ordinances makes a lot of sense.

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#3

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

Stuart Johnson

Will the trees send out new limbs? If so it might be someone trying for a new look. When I grew up the streets were lined with Elms and from time to time the city would come through and top them off. In a year they would bush out again.

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#4

They do that here too...

John in NM

About the only deciduous tree we have here is a variety of elm, and the town maintenance crew will occasionally pollard them. Looks awful for a winter, then they start leafing out again. I always assumed it was done because the branches would get too heavy and split on their own, but I don't really know. Could be some just find it more attractive than a natural tree.

Bill's examples kind of look like cypress, I don't know if those will branch out again. I'm not sure they would have done such a complete job of stripping the limbs if they were just cutting them down, but then that may be the practice in urban areas where you need to use a crane.

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#5

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

Tony (Charleston, WV)

Just think of it as art, bad art, perhaps, but art. (This approach might prevent you from getting p--off every time you see it.)

HTH (but I doubt it will).

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#6

Don't know much about tree growth

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

or history or the French I took, for that matter; but the one time I cut all the needle-bearing limbs off a conifer, I kilt it dead.

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#7

Dale Lenz

I do know something about tree growth

Dale Lenz

And those "trees" are history! Geeez.

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#8

How about posting this on the noisy side?

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Tom Dunlap is an arborist but he doesn't post over here. I doubt he would approve of what was done, but maybe he could provide an explanation.

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#9

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

TomD

You seem to live in a nice neighbourhood. What are the solar panels for?

Only logical thing I can think of is that given that you have a tree ordinance, if it specifies only cutting down trees, then this approach will kill the tree, and if there is a view, provide access to it. Then once the trees die, it is a no-brainer that a permit would be offered to cut them down. I don't see any other convincing reason for turning them into tooth picks while they are still vertical. That would be a lot of work, and I don't see any encumbrances that would make this a necessary step. Still seems kinda strange that such a move would not be anticipated in your by-law. A deprivation of the means of life kind of deal.

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#10

The only other thing that comes to mind is that

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Pg&E has decided to run new overhead through the neighborhood without digging in new poles :D

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#11

Re: OT - tree trunks as art???


Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#12

That's only Phase 1 ...

Mike L

... Phase 2 involves cutting down the trees in the foreground so you'll have a view of the entire "improvement". It's probably being perpetrated by someone from SoCal making us (SoCal-ers) unwelcome in yet another area of the West.

Mike

p.s., those look like some biggish solar panels in the foreground. What are they powering?

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#13

Solar panels

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Our town water is from several wells, one of which is in a little park there across the street. The solar panels operate the well pump and equipment. It's my impression that the city would love to do this for all the wells; but not all of them have the necessary land for the panels.

Re: OT - what are these guys thinking?

#14

The explanation

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA


Apparently, the tree trimming firm and the crane operators had a little trouble with schedules; but Saturday, a mere eight days or so after the trees got scalped, the crane operators were out holding up tree chunks while the tree guys cut them off. Makes sense; it's a busy street, and the trees were very close to the building, and the buildings on adjacent, small lots.

35 years ago, even 30 years ago, I'd have been over there, on the far side of the street, in company with one son or another, watching it happen.