New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Lamination question

Posts

Lamination question

#1

Lamination question

Edward in Vancouver

Looks like one of my projects this winter will be a complete re-make/remodel of my bench.

I want to save and re-use my top. It is 72" x 20" and made from 2 salvaged maple baker's tables. It's currently at 1 1/2" thick and swiss cheesed with holes on a 6" grid. Of course, I'd like to make it thicker, say at 4" thick and also deeper, at 24". Problem is money....

I'd like to make the extra 4" deep chunk to deepen my bench from 2x8 fir or spruce. I imagine I could rip the lumber down the middle giving me about 31/2" width, glue on a "veneer" of, oh, say 3/4" to 1" of solid Eastern maple to each strip, then glue the whole assembly together, and glue this assembly to my existing top.

I'd also like to do the same treatment to my existing top--make an assembly of common softwood and glue this to the underside of the top to beef up the thickness.

However I am not very knowledgeable about wood movement, and especially with different species of wood.

The bench is in my garage which is insulated but not heated. I have very little--if any rust problems with my tools.

Would this work?

Edward

Re: Lamination question

#2

Re: Lamination question

TomD

You might well get away with it, but you are definitely setting up an uneven condition and you could get dramatic cupping. I would not do it myself. The fact there are a lot of people who may have got away with it does not mean it is a good idea. If one was looking to avoid things that might cause a movement type problem, that would be near the head of my list. The fact something is a bad practice does not mean you actually suffer from it if your conditions are benign enough, and you never move. If you do try it, at least be sure both woods are at the same ambient humidity before you start. I would let those stocks sit together for a good long while before I joined them.

Re: Lamination question

#3

My bet is that it will cup

Bill Tindall

The radial and tangential shrinkage values for loss/gain of moisture from fir and maple are different. The softwood will have a different response to moisture coming and going than the maple so one side of the bench will shrink/expand more or less than the other as the humidity changes. The result will be like veneering one side of a panel.

6' x 4" of hard maple is not going to be a lot of money to spend expanding the top. I would think that you could trade a dish of brownies with some shop for such a piece. It would work for me.

What would be the benefit of thickening the top?

Re: Lamination question

#4

Re: My bet is that it will cup

Edward in Vancouver

Thickening the top? Is 1/12" not too thin? One of the reasons I want it thicker is because I made a fine mess installing the LV twin screw the first time around; installation would be easier with a thicker top.

I guess I can look into how much eastern maple is per bd ft, maybe I can glue on 1 1/2" strips directly to the existing top.

Edward

Re: Lamination question

#5

Re: My bet is that it will cup

TomD

In Ontario it is about 6 bucks. So that would be about 120. One can get it a lot cheaper, but not all served up. I usually figure 2 bucks a bft, and then there is the whole cut it yourself thing. But for six bucks you might get a pen with their name on it around here.

Re: Lamination question

#6

Alternative

Bill Tindall

The only reason to have such a thick top is weight, if you need it. There are alternatives to adding weight. As far as the vise, just add thickness to the area where the vise attaches. I have done this on several benches. If you want it to look cool and manly just add a thickening strip around the edges.

Re: Lamination question

#7

Build a new top.


Re: Lamination question

#8

Agree


Re: Lamination question

#9

Re: My bet is that it will cup

James Watriss

I installed my twin screw on a 2" top. No problems. I agree with Bill, I'd only thicken where you need to. If it's currently a mess, patch where necessary, and do over.

Everybody wants a bigger bench. I say the bench needs to be proportional to shop size. There is such a thing as a bench too big. There's too small, too, but yours is not too small. Your bench is a workable size, provided it's not being used to store project parts and 'junk.' Instead, it should be kept clear to do work.

Assuming you have a place to store your tools already, my suggestion is wall shelves . As long as you keep the shelves clear of anything except parts for whatever your project you're working on, and don't give in to the instinct to immediately fill them with tools, screws, junk, etc, they should give you plenty of extra horizontal space to move things to, instead of just moving them down the bench. I think you'll find you have more bench than you believed.

Re: Lamination question

#10

Re: My bet is that it will cup

Edward in Vancouver

I think that would be the route to go, slap on a 4" chunk of maple, and forget about the thickness of the rest.

I have only one shelf on the bench, about 5" from the ground. This is made up from scraps of 2" thick "mystery wood" (from pallets and bed posts), and is bolted on to stretchers. I have my lunchbox thickness planer on it as well as a few bench appliances. This does add a bit of weight. All of my w'working tools are kept in a toolchest (Yes, the anarchist's toolchest) to my immediate left.

Junk table............... About 30" behind my bench stands the end of my t.s. which is equipped with a 32" extension. About 5 years ago I "stuffed" the gap of the extension with a cheapie aluminum router table. I have not made friends with the router yet,( and probably never will) but the table comes in very handy for glue ups, (scrapes off easily) general assembly, fixing bikes, and other stuff.

I'll be giving the remake of the bench a lot of serious thought, probably won't get around to it untill after Christmas.

Edward

Re: Lamination question

#11

Re: What!? You live in a forest!

Bruce McCrory

Jeesh! You got the world of Western woods all around you, and you're looking to tack some outrageously priced eastern wood onto a salvage job? There are wood suppliers comming out of your ears in BC. Convert the swiss cheese table into a glue-up table, using threaded rod and cauls.

Look in the yellow pages. Start hunting for small scavenger mills.

Thumb Chris, and his tree-in-the-basement preaching, off. At BigBox I bought two boards of DF (2x12x12, 2x10x10); ripped them with an antique circular saw, and glued them into a four-foot bench. There might be a third board, but that's because the 12' literally exploded after a day in the sun, having concealed pitch pockets. All for under $30. What's that Canadian? For $50, I'll have yours, and more.

You have a planer. I beat my shoulders and blistered my paws on a jack plane.

Oops, forgot two 3/4" pipe clamps. They were cheaper than scrap 2x4s and twisted rope for clamping. A pound of Titebond, and 3" screws I am reusing for other projects took care of the leg and stretcher laminations.

Start fresh. You will feel a lot better. Trust me, it will cost less too. Some guys here spent more time in the 1930s Depression than me (Parent Schooling).

BTW, I don't have room for a proper bench.

Re: Lamination question

#12

Re: My bet is that it will cup

James Watriss

I tried having a junk table. It clogged up work flow. I tried using my wall shelves for storage of 'stuff.' I have a lot of stuff. In the end, with a junk table, or with wall shelves, using them that way contributed nothing to the productivity factor. Because everything on the shelves was pretty static, there was no room for new stuff, like legs, stretchers, drawer parts... Basically, no room for a project in motion. So all that stuff ended up on the floor, getting dented or dirty, or (more likely) on the bench, until the project was done. That's a fast way to make the bench effectively smaller.

I built a storage cabinet for 'junk,' and moved it to a back corner. I made storage elsewhere for supplies. And legs, stretchers, drawer parts, etc, go on the shelves that are next to the bench til they're needed... And now I have my entire bench to work on.

Much cheaper and easier than a whole new top, or a whole new bench, and more effective.

I feel a little disingenuous, my bench is 8' x 2'. But when it was clogged up with stuff, it was effectively smaller than yours.

Re: Lamination question

#13

Re: What!? You live in a forest!

Edward in Vancouver

Actually I'm a big fan of "reclaimed" wood. I haven't gone the route of starting off with whole trees or parts of them, but I do keep an eye out for "processed wood" My bench is almost 100% reclaimed, with the top from two baker's tables, and the legs from soft (western) maple from shipping palettes. Most of my shop "furniture" is made from palettes or shipping crates.(Those expensive commercial baker's ovens form Germany come in fancy/schmancy pine shipping crates...)

This is augumented with "selected" hardwoods that the neighbors throw out: Birch beds, flatsawn oak cofeetables, and Ikea. Don't snort, Ikea has provided me with enough beech to make a bowsaw, a mallet, and other sundries--they do actually use real wood now and then....

Re: Lamination question

#14

Re: What!? You live in a forest!

Bruce McCrory

I made several tools using Ikea parts. We're both scroungers--the new name: galoots(?).

My $30 bench has mistakes, one being a 1.25" DF top, face grain. It needs to be 3" thick--I am used to working over a concrete slab. I will replace that part with a new top.

The intent of my *outburst* was, at some point we need to choose a pristine material for a key element (the top) and quit ticky-tacking odds-and-ends to it.

Re: Lamination question

#15

Re: My bet is that it will cup

TomD

Stout fellow! My bench is 8x2 also, and the last time I saw it was when the last coat of finish was polished up.

I feel this is the appropriate time to bring out a few snaps from the back file in 2010:




A little small, just 7' by 4 inch, Canadian beech

Re: Lamination question

#16

Re: What!? You live in a forest!

Edward in Vancouver

Long Live the Ikea "Poang" Footstool!!! It has supplied me with many solid bits and pieces of beech.

I think my bench might go through a few more metamorphises before I splurge on virgin lumber for the final design. Good thing my Vise can be swapped out, over and over, and over again.....