We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Anybody have any experience with this set? I am about to buy the LN Steve Latta set of tools to do Line and Berry. Looks like this set might do Line and Berry but I would hate to buy it and not have it do the job.
I do a lot of line and berry and teach some workshops on it using everything from user/purpose made tools to the LN Latta tools, which are excellent. I have ordered a set of the LV as I need to make the comparison myself. From all appearances they should be fine for line and berry... At first glance, and without hands on, I would probably give the edge to the LN radius cutter. It is an excellent tool. Verdict is still out on the other comparisons as I await delivery. I will post an update as soon as I get the tools. Should be by this weekend. Right now (warning, stealth gloat... ) I am on a bus into Boston's North end for day two of my two year journey at North Bennet Street School in their full time furniture program...so weekdays are just a bit busy now!
We are eagerly anticipating the results of your comparative analysis. The L-N tools for this purpose certainly seem to be well designed and well constructed. Their circle cutter is a work of art as well as a competent performer.
The new Lee Valley stringing scraping tool immediately opens a Pandora's Box of questions, since its physical form is so different from the L-N tool that, I think, is designed to perform analogous functions.What's up with this?
Latta and the LN product essentially saws a groove in the wood using a "few toothed" saw blade. The LV cutter is identical in design as what was demonstrated by Steve Hamilton (Mack Headley and Sons Shop Winchester VA) in a class I took. It is basically two sharp "wings" formed by a vee grind that score the fibers and the throat of the vee that rakes out the waste. Both designs work, at least in competent hands.
The potential short coming of the LV design is that they have provided no means of resharpening it. This seems a fatal flaw. The obvious strength of the LV design is that one tool does straight and curved grooves, resulting in a considerable savings for those of us that are cheap.
I have only had a brief chance to use the tools since they arrived on Saturday, and I emailed Bill some early impressions.
I have used the LN tools for aome time, and before that, my own user built tools. I also like and use many LV products. That said, I think there are several shortcomings on the LV compared to the LN, but this is only a first impression.
Some general thoughts...
The LV seem to cut much slower. Both LV and LN are capable of clean cuts when sharp. LN is easier to sharpen, in my opinion.
LV uses a common base for both straight and radius...while well built, there are many (most) times when I swap back and forth between straight and radius when working on a piece...i don't want to change the radius setting every time I need to make a straight cut.
The free hand cutter and chisel were both unimpressive...had a cheap feel to them.
More comments later....bus has arrived...time for school
I have only had a brief chance to use the tools since they arrived on Saturday, and I emailed Bill some early impressions.
I have used the LN tools for aome time, and before that, my own user built tools. I also like and use many LV products. That said, I think there are several shortcomings on the LV compared to the LN, but this is only a first impression.
Some general thoughts...
The LV seem to cut much slower. Both LV and LN are capable of clean cuts when sharp. LN is easier to sharpen, in my opinion.
LV uses a common base for both straight and radius...while well built, there are many (most) times when I swap back and forth between straight and radius when working on a piece...i don't want to change the radius setting every time I need to make a straight cut.
The free hand cutter and chisel were both unimpressive...had a cheap feel to them.
I can't envision using the pencil holder forthe same reason... i do layout with a compass and/or dividers.
The quality of the cutting tool is very good...feels solid, but I don't care for the blade ( at least at this time ), and to have to use the same tool for straight cuts, slicing string, and radius cuts is not a practical solution for me.
I will continue to use them, and my opinion may change some, and I will have them for people to try when I do workshops.
I'm still a strong supporter of LV, but in this case, I prefer the LN inlay tools.