New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Is this a Union bench plane? *LINK*

Posts

Is this a Union bench plane? *LINK*

#1

Is this a Union bench plane? *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Union brand planes are not very common around here; I guess whoever had the local franchise wasn't very enthusiastic.

Yesterday, I picked up a No. 4-1/2-sized bench plane, with free rust at no extra charge. Walt Quadrato's quick bench plane maker ID page indicates that this is probably a Union plane (see linky below). There are no markings on the plane body, and the iron is an E.A. Berg, probably aftermarket (as I haven't found any indication that Berg made metal bench planes). The lever cap has a casting mark of "418."

Now, it doesn't much matter to me, really; if, when I clean it up and get a new iron (existing one has about 1/4" of usefulness left) and chip-bender (existing one is nearly flat), it works well, that's enough. Still, it'd be nice to know. Can anyone more knowledgeable tell from the photos below whether this is a Union plane?






Walt Quadrato's bench plane ID page

Re: Is this a Union bench plane? *LINK*

#2

Re: Is this a Union bench plane?

Bob Hackett

Most of the Union planes I have have "Union" cast in raised letters on them somewhere just like a Stanley plane does. I have been told that both companies (and folks like Miller`s Falls as well) were known to have made planes for other distributors/sellers such as large hardware store chains and Sears/Craftsman. These secondary distributors many times only marked the irons of these planes and that Berg iron in yours is not a factory part I`ll bet.

Over on a blacksmithing forum I`m a member of there are MANY (some of us feel too many) posts asking to identify the maker of an anvil , post vice, or forge. There is usually at least one reply stating something to the effect of "if you can work hot iron with it then it`s the perfect brand for you, if not send it to me".

Nobody is making parts for it anymore, why is the brand name important if it works? Looks like a potentially nice user plane BTW and if the edge of that Berg iron doesn`t need too much grinding to bring it back to serviceable condition then 1/4 inch of good steel should last you and whoever you will it to two lifetimes.

I love my 4 1/2, on the days I`m able to push it. My brother also favors the one I rehabbed for him as well. No doubt you`ll be clearing a place of honor for this one after you rub the rust off of it. Nice find.

Re: Is this a Union bench plane? *LINK*

#3

Jack Guzman from Maine

well used

Jack Guzman from Maine

No idea about the identification but that plane was a favorite. It reminds me of the thumb hole rip saw I found that was sharpened down so far that it came to a point. It was sharpened so many times you know it had to be well used.

Didn't stanley put out some planes with no markings? I thought I heard that somewhere.---Jack

Re: Is this a Union bench plane? *LINK*

#4

Re: Is this a Union bench plane?

Robin Corell in Atascadero CA

My E.A. Berg chisels are better than most all of the others in my tool box. I would not be so eager to replace that iron, particularly if it is laminated.

Re: Is this a Union bench plane? *LINK*

#5

Re: Is this a Union bench plane?

Don Evans

Best way to handle rust (this is my opinion only and I'm sticking with it) is to get some phosphoric acid at the hardware store. Put it in a spray bottle and spray all the rusted steel with it. It will take about 2 or 3 minutes and all the rust will turn BLACK.

I actually brush off loose rust with a nylon brush first then spray.

After the acid bath, rinse really well with water then dry with paper towels, then very important blow it dry as possible with compressed air. This will get all the moisture out of cracks crevices etc.

I cannot remember what the name of the after product is called but it chemically changes the rust oxide and stops the rusting process.

Try on a piece of scrape iron first, the more completely rusted it is, hopefully without pitting, the better it will look.

RUST AWAY sold at woodworking suppliers is same acid, sold to use on on rusting cast iron tool tops like table saws etc.

Don