New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

Posts

Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#1

Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

Bruce McCrory

I bought a thickness planer and used it today.

Why should I even look at handplanes, ready to go, with an electronic beaver in the corner?

Why do I feel cheap and dirty? Even when my bad shoulders feel better after doing three times the surface area a hand plane could do; and better, to-boot?

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#2

I sure wouldn't feel guilty.  I never do,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

At least about using a tailed thickness planer. I have way too many things to feel guilty about, and that doesn't EVEN make the list. Save your energy and tools for finished surfaces where they really count. I buy all my lumber rough sawn, and I'd never get projects done if I had to thickness everything by hand.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#3

Guilt Free

James Watriss

If nothing ever needed to be done after you pulled it out of that planer, it would be different. But machines were made for doing bulk, dirty work. And depending on what you have for a jointer, you may find yourself planing the initial reference surface by hand anyway. I do.

But considering how much work remains after the boards are all to thickness, ye gads... You've only made your life easier, not easy.

I took a class with Brian Boggs in 2007. His general philosophy seemed to be that all tools should be used to their most efficient purpose, to contribute whatever value they added to the piece. Sure, he started out with very little, except for a bag of hand tools. But now, my impression is that he uses them mainly for finishing strokes, as they add more to the aesthetics of his designs than they add efficiency to his shop at this point.

Whatever provides the best results in the end is what counts. How you get there is less important in the end product. Of course, if you have your own reasons to do the work in a certain way, that's good too... But just remember that the guilt here is in YOUR eyes, not in the eyes of others.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#4

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

eliot d

I have some DVD's by David Charlesworth, who contributes here on occasion, and is without question a master with hand tools. Yet in one of his videos he advocates doing the rough work with power tools, saying, "I'm not a Nearanderthal, even if I look like one". He then goes on to show how to finish up to accuracies of about two thousandths inch with a hand plane. ( And to be fair he doesn't look anything like a Neanderthal -- just lots of hair!)

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#5

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

Bruce McCrory

You convinced me. After heavy thought--I dwell on inconsequential--I realized it's my Scotch upbringing: cheap, cheap...

Boy, they work just like in videos and on TV. Zzzip, and smooth as glass. I do have to fix the house electric, though. Built in '85, everything is 20 Amp.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#6

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bruce and all,

Following onto what James said about doing the first reference surface by hand.....

It all depends. Is the board flat and straight to begin with? Or does it have cup, bow, or twist? Will that stick be structurally unconstrained in the finished project, like a rail or stile say, or will it be forced straight by constraining members? Are you trying to retain all the thickness you can in the finished stock? Is the machine leaving a perfect surface on the wood, or is there a little tearout where the grain reverses?

I don't six-square and thickness every stick of a project by hand, either. But there are very few hardwood boards (that I have seen, especially figured ones) that don't benefit from having at least the first side done by hand, to remove the cup, bow, or twist--then that becomes your 'down' side to go through the machine. If the board is thick enough, then you can machine out cup. But if thinner, the machine will press out the cup, and it springs right back to life as you pull your (now thinner) board out of the machine. Bow and twist have to be removed by hand IME, from one side at least. If you're trying to save thickness in a board which is bowed, you can sometimes do that by working the convex side first (in the middle)--cutting the fibers in the middle may let the board give up a little bow, so you don't have to mill a 1/4" from the middle of one side and from the two ends of the other side to get a straight board. Thickness also saved by rough cutting to approx. length, once you know where every board is going to go in the project.

What James said.

Wiley

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#7

Re:Boggs

TomD

"But now, my impression is that he uses them mainly for finishing strokes, as they add more to the aesthetics of his designs than they add efficiency to his shop at this point. "

He really put in the time astride the horse. As a result most of his chair designs look, organic... But if he had started wanting to make basically the same kind of chair, but in a production shop with a pantograph, and dowel machine, etc... They probably would not have developed as they have. Once you have a great product you have sweated over for a long time, powering up some of the steps is not really the same issue, as designing from the machines in the first place.

Though, I was just thinking about my attempts to cut my own chairwood from my oak trees. It is hard to get clean enough stock for hand tools. So often a log looked perfect, only to turn out to have some nearly invisible feature that would tear out. That wood would easily saw out, and then turn on a lathe. I'm guessing one could probably get a finishing cut on it due to the barrel shape of a lot of his parts, and the fact one could use a special tool for finishing. Anyway, he has great wood resources. Just musing.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#8

Re:Boggs

James Watriss

Oh, clearly. I got to see him demonstrate with drawknife and spoke shave... Ye gads, he knows what he's doing.

Back to topic at hand, this is why I see no guilt in power planing... It's just finding a more efficient way to do something the OP already knows how to do.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#9

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

William Duffield

If you have a power jointer, too, then you can often use that for the purposes Wiley describes, with a couple exceptions. It would be really tricky to remove the cup by starting with the convex surface, because you are apt to put in as much twist as the cup you take out. Working with a board wider than a bit less than twice the width of the jointer, you have to fall back on the try plane and a flat workbench, but probably by that size, it wouldn't fit through your power planer either. In general taking out twist can be tricky with a jointer, and especially problematical for boards wider than the jointer, depending on whether the twist is clockwise or counterclockwise.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#10

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

James Watriss

Very true.

That said, here are two examples in recent memory of why I still like the hand-plane in conjunction with machines:

-I had a highly figured slab top recently that was about 20" wide. Our jointer is 8". Yes, there are techniques to make do, but I've had to chase those around before, losing 1/4" or more. I've had them work, too, but this was some wildly curly maple. 10 minutes with a high angle smoother had the bottom dead flat AND tear-out free, so I could take it to the drum sander.

-A chair base that I just finished was posing some serious issues. 4 saber legs meet in the middle. All blanks meet at 90 degrees in plan view, and at 30 degrees to vertical. The first opposing pair comes together in a doweled butt joint. The second pair comes in at 90 to that. More dowels, and it locks everything together. But, the joints are 50/50 butt/miter joints. (see photo, words fail me.) And the surfaces involved were large, and had to be gap-less.

The relevant point here is that to cut the reference surfaces that would then register for cut, everything had to be just so. One simple nick in the jointer OR planer knives would be bad enough that the blanks wouldn't sit perfectly squarely on the saw table. (Vintage 16" sliding table Oliver table saw.) Without an accurate blank, accurate machines wouldn't matter. 10 minutes per blank to get 2 reference faces perfectly flat and perfectly square.

Our machines are very accurate. But jointers rely on our hands to guide the stock, and even then... they're not milling machines. They're great, and very useful, but when I need it to be just so, I reach for my hand tools.


img

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#11

20 amp is fine -

Bruce, a MN Galoot

the planer is probably 15 amps or so. Just make sure that the cord to your planer isn't really long, and it helps if you have a 12 ga. cord, too. I used to have constant problems tripping the breaker with my tablesaw with a 15 amp motor. It was at the end of a 25' 16 ga extension cord, so I made a new one of multi-strand 12 ga and only half that length, and all the tripping problems went away.

Besides, it's not as easy as it sounds to put in a 30 amp circuit.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#12

Depends on your woodworking goals

Bill Tindall

Do you do woodworking to make stuff or to do woodworking? Planing surfaces can be a rewarding exercise or simply an essential step to get through in the process to achieve a piece of furniture. It should be be a concern what decision you make unless you have a daughter (or other) waiting for a piece of furniture.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#13

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

Bruce McCrory

Beautiful chair leg joints!

Now, I really feel guilty. I can't hand joint a square face for anything. I figure that has to do with what torn ligaments and relocated muscle groups allow.

Anyway, it's just a portable bench-top Dewalt (12.5"). Need two things: The canister vacuum fills in about 30-seconds. I need an intermediate vortex-separator-can [thingy]. Looking for a Vortex got me a reduced price-match for the planer. Bruce, MN mentioned 20A being good, but the DW734 is 18A(?), and the vac. is 5A; and I have to string 25' length cable. Lights had to be turned off, and the startups sequenced to avoid breaker shut-down. I think the stuffed vacuum canister finally drew too much juice, because everything ground down tooo aaa-a-a-a- slow die.

All wood pieces in my initial test were [factory] milled, some hit-and-miss. Some figured maple with bad mill tearout smoothed into a glass-like finish. I think the knives hit 90+ times per inch. All of my passes were under 1/32". There is snipe, which could be my inexperience. Subsequent passes often minimized it. The thin cuts did knock down some convex surfaces; but nothing to brag about.

A negative is several knife edge dings from maybe, 30 surface feet of wood through the planer. These are HSS throw away knives. GRRRRrrr. I'll certainly try honing them first.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#14

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

Bruce, a MN Galoot

For starters, I'll bet that extension cord is light gauge. Try a 12 gauge wire. Then have a qualified electrician take a look at your shop. It will probably be easier to run a heavier cable to your shop, maybe 6-0, and install a subpanel. Then your worries are over. That's what I did in my shop. I also installed a 220 circuit to handle a compressor with an abnormally high amp inrush current.

A 30-amp circuit isn't just 10 amps more. I initally wanted a 30-amp circuit for my tablesaw, but my inspector wouldn't let me have one. It requires 10-gauge wire, a 30-amp breaker PLUS different outlets and plugs to make sure that nothing else can be plugged into it. Plus, there can't be any other branches off that wire at all for any reason. The inspector said that that circuit could serve only that one outlet. At least that's what he told me. The wire going to that particular outlet in my garage is 10 gauge, and the electrician told me there were no branches off it, but even though the inspector knew that electrician, he wouldn't approve it because he had not inspected the house when it was being built. I'm just repeating my experience with it.

As for snipe, it's hard to avoid with a lunchbox planer, although some are better than others. Mine is one of the first Deltas, and snipe with that bugger can be bad. Here are a few hints:

1. Get used to it and cut off the sniped ends of the boards. Plan your planing order so that the crappy end takes the snipe.

2. Run a sacrificial chunk of board through first and butt the good board immediately against the sacrificial board. Run all of your boards end to end with no space between them.

3. Make a much longer false bed for your planer. Mine is 3' long. That makes it much easier to ensure that you keep the board flat as it's going through the planer.

4. Make sure that you take all the slack out of the planer's adjustment gearing.

Good luck.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#15

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

rononkokomo

Guilt should not be a part of the conversation. As Bill suggests, one needs to decide why he went to the shop. That will dictate how he/ she spends the time there. I am not a pure hand tool woodworker. Sometimes I wish I were. Yes, I certainly can take a bunch of rough timber and using only handtools, make a chest, or a chair. Most of the time, I will use a planer to thickness wood, or buy it already planed to thickness. Joinery is all by hand, and surface prep is with planes and scrapers almost all the time. I ready do believe that there are some functions that are demonstrably done better with hand tools, regardless of your preference. The most obvious is edge jointing, but there are several other places where handtools are the boss.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#16

Re: Guilt?-- None!

Bruce McCrory

I have been placated, thanks to the reprimands and reasons you all have provided.

Thanks,

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#17

Re: Guilt?--More juice! (more cow bell!!)

Bruce McCrory

Bruce Galoot, Thanks for saving me from Big Brother Citations. I was simply going to check the Romex size for compatability and switch breakers. Also, new band saw will require 220. The saw has been a problem for years.

However, the biggest motivation is the incompatability of Mom's hair drier/clothes iron and the microwave oven. Well, she will be the incentive, and the others will be "while the electrician is here."

In the mean time, I will check for a bigger extension chord. An upgrade will be a while....

SNIPE: Wow! I am going to print and laminate your recommendations to the planer. And to think, I thought this was all continuation of the snipe hunt joke.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#18

Re: Guilt?......why???

roger lance

If God had said in one of his commandments, "Thou shalt not use power tools", and you did, then feel guilty. But since power tools did not make the list, I'd save my guilt for something that mattered.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#19

Re:Boggs

TomD

No doubt, my point though was about design, not his hand skills.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#20

Re: Wide boards and cup

TomD

I usually do use hand tools to get a start on wider boards, however, the jointer will deal with cup and extra wide boards, though you are still limited to the planer width, which is normally something like 16 inches in a small shop. That is about the widest board I get before glue up. And after glue up a belt sander will deal with whatever one needs done. I just hate dust.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#21

Re: Daughters and integrity.

TomD

I have three daughters and I never let them influence anything that goes on in the shop. I sense they might like you better.

I do think that certain power tools are too unpleasant, and certain others tend to take over the process. This is perhaps why I like the planer and the bandsaw. I can't think of anything too much that they do that would adversely affect my output. If I need to take 1/4" off a board, and it is large and hard, it just makes life a lot easier. Never pushes my design around. Same thing with the bandsaw. It opens up resaws I probably would not do on a regular basis by hand. It allows cuts there is no practical way to do by hand, and it does cuts that are essentially the same as some one would do by hand. Neither of these tools ever seems to lead to compromises. And both are relatively safe if used with any sense at all. And both are easy to keep the dust under control. They are also fairly vertical tools that do not take up a huge amount of space, or have greedy infeed and outfeed needs.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#22

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

TomD

One trick that works on some small planers is to offset the knives so the ding is not in line. This is possible with some knives, I can't say whether it would work with yours.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#23

Re: Snipe

TomD

There are tons of online hacks for that. If you do make an extension table, be aware a lot of people have been injured when their fingers get between a board and a gap in the roller extensions. So either design a smooth continuity, or just be careful.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#24

Re:Thickness Planer knife dings

Bruce McCrory

I need to check that. My DeWalt replacement knives have some slightly slotted holes. What I have are only hairline reveals, fixed by one swipe of a scraper.

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

#25

Re: Guilt?--Thickness Planer (electric)

William Duffield

I never fully grasped this concept. Instead of a ridge that is very visible, you get two or three rows of bumps, but almost as much wood to sand or scrape off later.