New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

Posts

Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#1

Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

Bill Tindall

This stuff works so long as the protein molecules are not chopped up into smaller pieces by microbial or chemical reaction. If the microbes get at it it will smell bad. Chemical degradation can not be detected by smell but there are other tests that will detect any kind of degradation.

To be an effective adhesive the cured adhesive must be tough and strong. These properties result from the adhesive molecules, in this case protein, being very long such that the molecules can entangle with one another like a plate of mixed up spaghetti. Hence, a test to determine whether the molecules have gotten chopped into smaller pieces must test if the molecules are long enough to tangle.

Test 1 A common test is to rub some glue between thumb and finger until it begins to tack and then pull the thumb and finger apart. To be able to pull long "strings" the molecules must be tangled, so if the partially dry adhesive pulls strings it is ok to use. While this test is quick it is less sensitive than Test 2.

Test 2 This test is recommended by Franklin glue company. Dry a film of glue on some paper. When it is dry flex and pull the dried film. To be tough and flexible the molecules must not be degraded. If the film is tough and flexible so will the glue in the cured joint be tough and flexible. If the molecules are degraded the film will be brittle.

Test 3- When in doubt prepare a lap joint, cure it and bash it apart. If there is substantial wood failure then your technique and glue are good.

So how long can we expect the glue to remain usable? The advertised shelf life is one year. Stored cool the shelf life can be many years, according to a reliable source.

I tested some Franklin hide glue that was bought in 2009 and it tested just fine by Test 1 &2.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#2

I'm always left wondering...

John in NM

Why not use dry hide glue and cease worrying about shelf life :D

Stuff is super easy to mix as needed, and I kind of like the smell of a hot glue pot too :D

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#3

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

david weaver

dangit...I just dumped two half full bottles from early 2011 into the trash.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#4

If you glue...

McKay

If you glue every day, then cooking your own makes sense. However, I can go a week without touching the glue bottle because I may be cutting the joints that will use the glue. As far the smell....I certainly do not care for it.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#5

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

TomD

Bashing joints apart is a very poor test of properties, unless of course you are building those chairs for western sets that get broken apart over extras heads. I would not consider that definitive of say the properties required to stop a bridge being torn off a guitar, which is a slow and steady pull that fails many glues. If you want to be scientific you have to use protocols that have something to do with actual patterns of use, and bashing joints is very rarely the use. If one is using glue for serious purposes and intends to offer warranties, best to always use fresh stuff. So I buy fresh bottles of titebond as required and give the surplus to the kids to mess with on craft projects. That isn't to say that the same surplus glue might not be wonderful for a range of uses in even a serious project, but then glue doesn't cost much either.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#6

False economy, or who cares about shelf life?

wilbur

The subject of the shelf life of liquid hide glue comes up every so often, and is sometimes used as a point against liquid hide glue vs. dry hide glue or PVA glues. Titebond liquid hide glue goes for $10 for an 8 oz. bottle, and $15 for a 16 oz. bottle, based on a quick internet search that I just did.

So if there's any question about the state of the glue I was using, I'd just go get a new bottle. I mean, we're talking about the stuff that's going to hold your (presumably) heirloom project together. It seems a bit silly to not spend a little money for fresh glue, if there's any question about it. You're going to blow away at least $10-15 in scrap wood by the time you finish your project.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#7

Re: False economy, or who cares about shelf life?

TomD

Being in Canada, the supply of titebond 1 has been an on again off again thing. Currently I have a supplier about a mile from home, so I am solidly in the chuck-it camp. But at times I had to order it, or LMII, from the US, only in season, pay duty and postage, etc... So I might have been interested in pushing it at one time. One hopes the supply continues to be accessible. And then again the hot stuff is so much better for a lot of stuff anyway, I am not likely to worry too long about the supply of the wet HG.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#8

Quantity is the key...

John in NM

I mix small amounts as needed using a copper pipe cap for 1 1/2" pipe on a coffee warmer hot plate. Mixing it full is enough for 4-6 average size M-T's, mix just a bit in the bottom is not even enough to do a small project. I tinned the inside of the cap with solder, but that's probably not necessary.

Pre-mixed is fine if its what you like, I've just never seen the point to it.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#9

shelf life of most glues

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I've always thought that glue was the least costly of any part of my projects.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#10

I'll answer that

Bill Tindall

Since almost everyone making furniture from home shop to factory uses some variety of "yellow glue" there must be some reasons for this choice. A more obvious question is other than to be period correct why would anyone consider hot hide glue for edge and typical joint joinery?

Yellow glue is:

1. It is cheap

2. available everywhere

3. shelf life is years

4. contrary to myth it is reversible

5. it makes a bond stronger than the wood

6. 10 minutes open joint time and another 10 minutes of closed joint time under typical conditions.

7. Quick tack in edge joining(can be a disadvantage in closed joints)

8. No preparation time to use it

9. High moisture resistance, especially compared to hide glue

10. Almost no learning curve to use it.

11. Can be used at less than optimum temperatures if your shop is cold.

12. no equipment required to use it

13. contrary to myth it can be "rub joined"

14. tests have shown it is significantly stronger in less than perfect mortise and tenon joinery than hide glue

15 no animals are sacrificed ( I had to stretch to make 15 reasons)

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#11

Re: I'll answer that

wilbur

Liquid hide glue is:

1. It is cheap

2. available everywhere thanks to Woodcraft and Rockler

3. shelf life is years

4. reversible

5. it makes a bond stronger than the wood

6. 10 minutes open joint time and another 10 minutes of closed joint time under typical conditions.*

7. Quick tack in edge joining(can be a disadvantage in closed joints)

8. No preparation time to use it

9. Reasonable moisture resistance.

10. Almost no learning curve to use it.

11. Same operating temperature as PVA glues*

12. no equipment required to use it

13. can be "rub joined"

14. tests have shown it is strong enough in less than perfect mortise and tenon joinery

15 no animals are sacrificed solely for the purpose of making hide glue. :D

* based on data from the Titebond website.

:D :D :D

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#12

But that is not what I asked

John in NM

I don't get why anyone would use liquid hide glue, as in pre-mixed. Your original post was concerning liquid hide glue, not yellow glue.

Yellow glue is great stuff and I use it too.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#13

Re: But that is not what I asked

wilbur

Why use liquid hide glue over dry hide glue? For me, it's convenience. No glue pot to warm up.

The shelf life of liquid hide glue, as I mentioned before, really isn't an issue to my mind.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#14

Re: I'll answer that

GolfSteve in Calgary

This is drifting away from the original question, but you missed one of the best reasons to use hide glue (liquid or otherwise) instead of PVA, and that is clean-up and stainability. A PVA glue spot shows up like a sore thumb under a finish, but liquid or hot hide glue is much less visible.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#15

Re: I'll answer that

William Duffield

You missed one salient point, Wilbur: Simple bench dog cleanup of squeeze-out and drips on glue bottle, bench, floor, fingers and shoes.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#16

Re: I'll answer that

TomD

1. It is cheap

So is hide glue

2. available everywhere

This works against the diamonds you know. CPv whatever, etc...

3. shelf life is years

Indefinite on the hot, but you probably have me on the cold

4. contrary to myth it is reversible

But not as easily.

5. it makes a bond stronger than the wood, your lack of specificity

But creeps badly in many instances. Again, your failure paradigm lacks specificity and relevance.

6. 10 minutes open joint time and another 10 minutes of closed joint time under typical conditions.

Are you saying this is fast or slow, I guess it is fairly optimal for average uses, which with 1.70 will get you a cup of coffee.

7. Quick tack in edge joining(can be a disadvantage in closed joints)

Yeah, I like this, though it isn't enough in most cases and is too little in others.

8. No preparation time to use it

There is actually a fair amount of time fritzing about with bottles, pealing scrum, and drilling out, at times. I doubt anyone who is set up for glueing cares one way or another about this since there is good tradecraft for any of it.

9. High moisture resistance, especially compared to hide glue

I'm not too sure that is true, but the real yellow glue on uses is too little for anything wet, so who cares. The new sorta proof glues appear to be a step forward, but when the water flies it is epoxy or nothing around my place.

10. Almost no learning curve to use it.

I don't think that is ever true. Glue is an art. You can squirt it out of a bottle, but if you make a bad part using the wrong stuff, or bad ideas, then how easy was it really.

11. Can be used at less than optimum temperatures if your shop is cold.

Hot glue has the hands down here, it is the thing that was used for most of the time heating was abscent from shops, and doesn't do strange stuff like got white.

12. no equipment required to use it

Not really true, tI have a lot of rollers and specialty bottles. Now that the hot set-up for a lot of guys using hide glue is the Rival crock pot from Walmart, for 9 bucks, there isn't really anything to this.

13. contrary to myth it can be "rub joined"

Where do you get these "Myths"? People rub yellow, or white all the time. In fact there is an art to this where the joint can be rested and it sucks together so perfectly in some grain you can't even find the joint, at all, no mater how hard you look. But the reality is you can't run it the same way people run hide. That's a different animal. You can't veneer large pieces by hand, etc...

14. tests have shown it is significantly stronger in less than perfect mortise and tenon joinery than hide glue

Maybe, but that would be a reason not to use it, since apparently you can be encouraged to make bad parts with it. I have no problem with gappy joints in their place. I have glued wood together with a 1/4" or more gap. But I wouldn't use yellow for that.

15 no animals are sacrificed ( I had to stretch to make 15 reasons)

Right, not slurping the stuff when you get hungry over the bench...

For joinery and butt work there are definitely reasons to use the stuff. And these are serious reasons. Accoustic (not totally proven in my mind); creep, this one is for real; certain rub applications; centuries from now should anything fail. However my problem with this is ensuring that anyone who gets the parts will know what to do with them, so myself, I have a hard time taking that one seriously. But if I was making a piece for the ages, I would use hide glue and document it. I do certain things with hide glue that I can only do with epoxy, but when making musical instruments I make an all natural instrument, and

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#17

No. 1 Reason

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The number one reason for using liquid hide glue is that people who are used to yellow glue or white glue can use it without learning new skills or new routines. It fits their concept of what glue is supposed to do and the advantages of the hot glue are not apparent to them. Some could argue the merits of the tricycle.

The use of yellow glue can easily double the cost restoration work. When you tell this to furniture makers who use yellow glue they just shrug their shoulders and say "That's not my concern."

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#18

I agree 100%

Ron in Sterling, CT

I totally agree with you. I was reluctant to get involved with hot hide glue due to lack of experience with it. However, as you infer, learning how to use liquid hide glue was fairly quick and easy. Now both liquid hide glue, and yellow glue share space in my shop and each is used depending on the application.

Ron

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#19

Contrary data

Bill Tindall

You have often repeated the claim that yellow glue will double the repair cost. There is a local craftsman with an impressive pedigree of apprentice and experience including Colonial Williamsburg who does mostly repair and restoration. I asked him if in his experience the use of yellow glue doubled the cost of repair. He response was that the only glue that caused him any significant increase in repair cost was epoxy. He demonstrated that a joint assembled with yellow glue came apart with the same technique and effort as hide. Frankly, I was surprised. It could well be that someone experienced in dealing with the various glues in repair and restoration has developed the experience where it doesn't matter.

I have seen one example of the difficulty of using hot hide glue. A friend hired someone who is arguably one of the top makers of Federal Furniture to hammer veneer two panels. After two days of lots of fiddling and failed effort it was concluded that there was something wrong with the veneer. I acquired the remaining two sheets of this veneer and took it to class at the Mack Headley shop in Winchester where Jeff Headley glued it using white glue and a vacuum press. There was no flattening of the veneer, white glue was slathered on with a paint brush and the whole operation took 5 minutes at most. Because white glue is a "hot melt" when cured it can be restuck with an iron, removed with a heat gun and otherwise repaired little different than hide glue.


The white glue that squoze through the pores of this crotchwood offered no impediment to either staining or finishing this panel.

We (or at least I am) are fortunate that modern materials and techniques enable persons to make fine furniture without the skills and experience that some traditional techniques demand.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#20

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

Tony - Memphis

I've been using a bottle of 2009 vintage as well. I tested it several ways and could find no issues with it. It has been stored in my shop and kept at <78°. I use so little, I hate to throw out a mostly full bottle. I had a bottle of Titebond III that I noticed looked pretty funky. Almost like it had curdled. It wasn't that old and had not been exposed ot any temperature extremes while in my care. No telling what it experienced before it got to me, but it was fine when I bought it. I have really come to appreciate the long working time of liquid hide glue too. I used it to glue the edge veneer of a table I am working on. Cleans up nice too. I have a hard time finding it locally though. We have one woodworking store that carries it and I have found their stock is usually pre-aged!

Tony

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#21

All this begs the question...

John in NM

Did I get sandbagged into providing the opening to shill for pva :D

I've tried the yellow glue iron on method. It does work, but not as well as resin glue and pressure. Both have their gotchas that may frustrate a novice, which is probably part of the reason veneer has the reputation for difficulty that it does - with any veneer gluing method there seem to be more difficulties than gluing up casework.

I have also seen pva + vacuum bag yield bubbles. No idea why it worked well for you and not well for the project I was involved in. Size and open time perhaps. Paper backed veneer on plywood perhaps.

Whenever someone tells me any technique is infallible, I usually figure they just haven't worked enough with it yet, there are always a few mistakes yet to be made :D

I've had best results veneering and laminating using plastic resin glue. I've seen others use 2 hour epoxy with fine results (laminating). While I likely would not use either on casework joints, both seem to be great products for veneer, well worth the time spent on any learning curve.

Hammer veneering is about the one method I've never tried :D

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#22

Nothing beats a class with experienced instructor

Bill Tindall

I learned to bag veneer in the Headley shop as part of a class. I likely didn't realize how much I learned by doing and watching the process. I learned what to worry about (adequate glue and rapid assembly, taping to prevent movement, etc. ) And I suppose things not be be worried about that could get in the way of worrying about the important things.

What was done was simple and I now practice it reliably and effortlessly. But I may well have had a rough learning curve if I had tried to do it on my own. I am a big fan of classes in professional shops.

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#23

Re: Contrary data

Warren in Lancaster, PA

A friend hired someone who is arguably one of the top makers of Federal Furniture to hammer veneer two panels. After two days of lots of fiddling and failed effort it was concluded that there was something wrong with the veneer.

Something does not smell right here. Lots of Federal furniture has crotch veneer on it. Are we to think that guys in the 1790s would have fooled around for two days and then thrown up their hands and discarded the veneer? My guess is they learned to deal with veneer that was probably less uniform than what is available today.

I can remove old hide glue from a surface with just warm water, or alternatively new glue can stick very nicely to the old. Are you suggesting these techniques work just as well for yellow glue?

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#24

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

Curt Putnam

Does occasional, unintended, exposure to the elements (such as might happen with a traveling tool chest) obviate the use of liquid hide glue?

Re: Shelf life of liquid hide glue-More from IWF

#25

you will need to be more specific

Bill Tindall

Most of the adhesives don't like to be frozen and rethawed. I don't know for sure but I expect liquid hide is more stable, or even immune to this assault, than yellow or white glue. After a few cycles the glue can become useless. Without question any of the glue types exposed to extended heat will suffer a shorter life than when stored cool. What in the traveling part are you concerned about?