(Message Deleted by Poster)
(Message Deleted by Poster)
#1
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: A curious narrow workbench
wilbur
The description says that it was used to make skis. Don't know how true that is, though.
On the pictures of the top, it does look like there are holes that were subsequently plugged, in locations that could be used as planing stops or where i would put them for holdfasts.
Re: A curious narrow workbench
Patrick Gibbons
The plugged holes appear to me to be where the top is connected to the base. I don't see any use of holdfasts or plane stop. Making skis is plausible. I wonder why there is a board secured underneath the end opposite from the vise. It doesn't appear to be a structural use (keeping the top flat) so it makes me wonder if it served a function having to do with clamping work.
Re: A curious narrow workbench
William Duffield
Patrick, I see pegs for holding the top to the base, but also other pegs that do not intersect the case frame, that are probably plugged holes for uses such as David describes.
Another clue to the function of the supporting member under the end of the bench is the two heavy metal nuts or bolts used to attach it to the top. Perhaps it had something to do with bending the front tips of the skis? This is pure speculation, as I have no experience in this craft.
Also in both ends can be seen the spline used to keep the two top boards aligned.
Re: A curious narrow workbench
William Duffield
The vise appears to be machined steel, not cast iron.
The mortise and tenon holding the bottom right side rail to the right front leg also appear to be machine made. Curious…it has round m&t ends but square pegs holding the joints together.
The saw kerfs in the vise jaw, ends and top face of the top and the leg posts are of a regularity that would indicate they were cut on a bandsaw.
The refinishing job done by the antique dealer has very shamefully obliterated most of the marks made by the craftsman that would provide evidence of the methods used in making the skis, not to mention hiding the warm colors that makes chestnut so charming.
More clues to the work process are the two areas on the top where there are numerous deep dents, or gouges: the right rear, and across the top just to the right of the vise location. Again the dealer's work probably has completely obliterated evidence of what tools or materials made those marks.
In the U. S., to be called an antique, it should be at least a century old. This one may be pushing the limit.
Re: A curious narrow workbench
roger lance
All speculation.....the top looks too thin for holdfasts but there may have been reinforcements under some of the holes for holdfasts with these reinforcements now removed.....it is also possible that the holes in the top were for steam bending skis.....the top being, in effect, a steam bending form or jig.....that's quite a price for the old girl!
Re: A curious narrow workbench
William Duffield
I don't think it's too thin. From the photos, I would guess it's at least 8/4, and probably 10/4. I use holdfasts effectively in 5/4 white oak and 7/4 rock maple.

The first two photos show holding work against the front surface of my Loxiliary meta-bench. It is even narrower than the ski bench, about 9".

Of course, chestnut is not as durable as oak or maple, and my modern Gramercy holdfasts are sized properly for my dog holes. The bigger problem would be the damage done by the holdfast to the tools kept in the chest below the bench top.
OTOH, Steve Latta's (shown below), which is about 6/4 bubinga, is reinforced under the dog holes with a strip of 3/4 BB ply. I don't know how he gets away with figure-8 tabletop fasteners to hold the top to the trestles, but evidently it works for the work he does on it.

(Message Deleted by Poster)
Re: You're good, William
William Duffield
From what I can see of the grain and figure, and the heavily dinged work surface, it could very easily be chestnut, much more likely than harder oak (no ray fleck on the QS surfaces) or ash, which might superficially resemble it.
Nothing about it shouts out at me that it's form has been significantly altered, except for plugging dog holes. My guess is that it could have been built in the closing decades of the 19th Century, or the early decades of the 20th. I don't have much in the way of old toolmonger catalogs, especially European, so I'm only guessing about dates when M&T machines that would produce that type of joint were developed, and when vise hardware of that design were offered for sale.
Re: A curious narrow workbench
Patrick Gibbons
We can't assume the dealer refinished the bench but I would doubt seriously the original owner finished it to the degree it is now. I now see plugged holes in locations that could indicate the use of a holdfast. The spline indicates it was made before the use of improved modern glues (or the maker was trained prior to this time).
Re: You're good, William
Patrick Gibbons
The m&t could have been made with a brace or auger. Certainly an easy way to make a joint this big. drill the two ends and saw out the waste. Shaping the tenon is easier than squaring the mortise.
Re: A curious narrow workbench
TomD
William do you have more pictures of this joinery bench. For scale purposes, are the HFs 5/8 stock or thicker.
Re: A curious narrow workbench *LINK*
William Duffield
I have lots of pictures of the meta-bench: construction details, construction and use of accessories for it, installation using holdfasts or F- or K-clamps, Moxon vise construction and attachment, etc. What are you interested in seeing? Or, where would you like to start?
I don't have the exact dimensions of the Gramercy Tools holdfasts, but they are just under 3/4" diameter, to work in 3/4" round dogholes. I have cut about an inch and a half of the ends of one pair so I can use them in the dog holes in the bench legs. Joel doesn't provide dimensions on the linked website, so I'll get back to you with the particulars. Also, there is this review by Bob Lang at Popular Woodworking. http://www.popularwoodworking.com/tools/gramercy-holdfasts-the-real-story
Also, I can go take measurements of just about any part of the bench you are interested in, with the caveat lignarius that I do not recommend you build your meta-bench from a set of measured drawings, but instead from the bench you are going to install it on top of, the measurements of your body, the vise you are going to use, and the materials you have on hand.
I do have partial measurements of Steve Latta's meta-bench (the one in the last photo) that I could share with you, if you are a galoot,
but I'm a bit reluctant to post them on a public website, as I'm not sure of their copyright status. The measurements were made by another galoot at the January, 2009 Woodworking in the 18th Century conference at Colonial Williamsburg, where Steve was demonstrating, and where I got the inspiration for building mine.
I also have many insightful observations about the sizes and materials I used to build mine, and what I might do differently next time, that I would be glad to discuss on this forum. There are also a few other photos I have posted here, on other threads, over the last several weeks, but I think it might be better to start at the top.
Every-so-often, I drag the thing out to hand tool woodworking events in the Mid-Atantic region, so people can take their own pictures and measurements, and try it out for themselves, and decide what features they might want to "steal" for their own use.
Gramercy Holdfasts
Re: A curious narrow workbench
William Duffield
Near as I can measure, the holdfast shafts are 23/32" diameter.