Re: Considering Various Saws and Grips
William Duffield
I've looked at the pictures of Frank's grip on the large saws and also Warren's, and have decided that whoever built the saws had no respect for their users. Otherwise, they would have put a smooth ball grip at the end of the arm. The Highland saw is even worse, as it puts a wingnut and a piece of threaded rod where you would want to grip it. The Highland saw, in contrast to Frank's illustration of using the smaller saw for dovetails, emphasizes something else important. The large saws are not intended to be pushed and pulled by the knobs, but the smaller saws are. The large saws have too much weight in the stretcher (even if made from light weight cedar) and in the arms to be counteracted by the hand and wrist holding the knob when sawing other than vertically. Therefore, as Highland has done, the knobs can be made much smaller, and used only for adjusting the angle of the blade w.r.t. the frame. Using a smaller saw (with a 12" blade), I sometimes hold it by the close knob and the distant arm, or by the close arm if I'm cutting on the pull stroke. Holding either the far arm or the far knob of course is not practical with a 27" blade. I have recently begun to suspect that the far knob on smaller, pushed saws could be improved if it were even shorter and fatter, but further experimentation is needed.





