New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

Posts

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#26

Re: Considering Various Saws and Grips

William Duffield

I've looked at the pictures of Frank's grip on the large saws and also Warren's, and have decided that whoever built the saws had no respect for their users. Otherwise, they would have put a smooth ball grip at the end of the arm. The Highland saw is even worse, as it puts a wingnut and a piece of threaded rod where you would want to grip it. The Highland saw, in contrast to Frank's illustration of using the smaller saw for dovetails, emphasizes something else important. The large saws are not intended to be pushed and pulled by the knobs, but the smaller saws are. The large saws have too much weight in the stretcher (even if made from light weight cedar) and in the arms to be counteracted by the hand and wrist holding the knob when sawing other than vertically. Therefore, as Highland has done, the knobs can be made much smaller, and used only for adjusting the angle of the blade w.r.t. the frame. Using a smaller saw (with a 12" blade), I sometimes hold it by the close knob and the distant arm, or by the close arm if I'm cutting on the pull stroke. Holding either the far arm or the far knob of course is not practical with a 27" blade. I have recently begun to suspect that the far knob on smaller, pushed saws could be improved if it were even shorter and fatter, but further experimentation is needed.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#27

Re: And Now for Something Completely Different

William Duffield

Specifically, a coping saw. Unlike the saw suggested by the picture in my previous post, which was obviously in humor, this is completely serious. It uses standard 6-1/2" coping saw blades.

This one is walnut, bloodwood, black cherry, red oak, European beech and brass.

I've got to stop using bloodwood where it is totally inappropriate. The stretcher is under compressive forces only, so a wood that is much lighter, and easier to carve would make a lot more sense.


Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#29

Re: That begs the question:

William Duffield

Since you have real world experience, and I've just been speculating based on using other saws, and looking at pictures: Do you hold it in the manner Warren describes, and do you find that the sharp wingnut and threaded rod get in the way of using it with a natural grip?

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#30

question begging time

Bruce, a MN Galoot

My real-world experience is unbelievably limited: roughly a half-dozen times spaced over nearly 30 years. I wanted to pace myself. :D

I suspect that had I used a grip similar to what you describe, my experience would have been vastly better. One of the things I didn't like about it was having to balance the whole of the saw's weight above the cut with just one hand. After all, that was how Frid was pictured in the FWW article, and maybe in one of his books. I just recall that he introduced it to all his students and said that most of them had adopted it. The blade is very thin, and that part is good, and so is the tension. I just never felt I had control over it.

Now you've done it; I'll have to drag it off the hooks and give your method a try.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#31

Re: question begging time

William Duffield

Not my method! I'm just sitting here looking at pictures of the way the experts (Klaus, Frid, Roubo, et. al.) do it and asking questions. BTW, there is something seriously wrong with the perspective shown in Warren's picture from Roubo, although the grip looks reasonable. I don't have a large bowsaw like the one James is seeking. My framesaw is on that order of magnitude, but I don't use it very often, and frame saws are inherently balanced, while bow saws are inherently off balance. When it comes down to sawing wood in large dimensions, my proclivity is to roll out my 18" bandsaurus and mercilessly start slaughtering electrons.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#32

this one time, at band camp

Bruce, a MN Galoot

well, actually, the oldtools list, I gave my bandsaw the nickname of neanderbuddy, because it seemed to be the only tailed apprentice that everyone had and tacitly sanctioned. I figure that if God had wanted me to use a bowsaw or frame saw, He wouldn't have invented the bandsaw.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#33

craigd

Re: And Now for Something Completely Different

craigd

That's a beauty! I really like the shapes and the rounded ends on the stretcher, much nicer than the square ones on mine.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#34

Re: Roubo grip

James Watriss

I'll have to give that one a try...

After replacing the wing nut with some twine.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#35

Re: And Now for Something Completely Different

William Duffield

The rounded joints between the stretcher and the arms was a carefully thought out structural detail. Three are two other options I have seen. The first is square shoulders like yours and most others. Since it is very difficult to control the length of the blade and mounting pins and knobs, it can result in most of the pressure on one point on each arm, which has a small chance of causing the arm to crack. It is still, I think a better alternative to the ones whose ends terminate in a half circle, because the additional material removed from the sides of the mortises in the arms significantly weakens the arms. The range of movement due to inconsistent blade lengths and tightening the twine is not enough to require that huge range of motion. The problem with the joint I build is just that it is a bit fiddly to get the shoulders to fit closely without binding. I use an oscillating spindle sander to shape the concave surface, but first I use the same drum to shape a template that I use to mark both shoulders. The shoulders of the stretcher are not so difficult, and a disk sander or manual sanding block or block plane can be used to match the curve.

The other details of the stretcher, including the hand carved lambs tongues, are purely decorative. A straight stick would work as well, but might weigh a bit more.