New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

Posts

Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#1

Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

James Watriss

I don't use it much, but when I do, I find the handles on my large (27.5" blade) bowsaw to be really uncomfortable, and to require a serious death grip. Given the frequency of use, I'm sure some of it is a technique issue, but in any event...

Has anyone here managed to build a bowsaw that feels comfortable in use? Did you use a pattern that's readily available, or make it up? Are there aspects of the design that you feel are more important than others?

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#2

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

John Pappas

I have a large bow saw (Ulmia) that I modified. Talking about the vertical handle, not the knob. I modified it so it has some slope relative to the blade (like most saw handles do) by carving away some of the handle where my "thumb web" rests and also carving some of the handle that make contact with my fingers. The handle isn't wide enough to carve away as much as I would have liked, but I think the small amount I was able to remove made a difference.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#3

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

Frank D. in Montreal

I know this isn't what you asked for, but I started using my large bowsaw a lot more when I held it by the frame, maybe three or four inches above the handle. It cuts a lot faster now, is easier to control, and I use it quite a lot now. I'd say give that a try first, if you haven't already.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#4

Depending on the work...

Bob Hackett

I find a frame saw more comfortable to use than a big bow saw. I can power it with two hands instead of one and it`s far easier for me to maintain horizontal with two hands than vertical with one.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#5

Clarification... Think I meant frame saw.

James Watriss

I get the two mixed up sometimes.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#6

Re: Clarification... Think I meant frame saw. *LINK*

William Duffield

I don't have plans for a frame saw, but a few years ago, I built one from scrap 1x2 red oak, and documented it in the archives. After I had it build and operational, I decided it was uncomfortable, so I added some pads made from 1/4" thick scrap mahogany. These increased the comfort immensely. If you are sawing a horizontal kerf, then the grips on the arms are important. If you are using it in two person mode, then you need grips on both arms. If you are sawing a vertical kerf, then the grips on the stretchers are important.

Here's an enlarged photo of the grips from the article, to give you an idea of the amount of shaping that I found necessary.


If you are working the saw alone, then the weight of the saw is even more important that the grips. Unlike a bow saw, a heavy frame saw works better than a light one. You will want to cut on the push stroke, with the angle of the blade approximately horizontal. You can always move your hands closer together or farther apart to get the right angle on your wrists.

Also, reference plate and commentary on Roubo by Don Williams in the Lost Art Press blog titled "Sawing the Roubo Way".

http://blog.lostartpress.com/2011/05/23/sawing-the-roubo-way/


Constructing a Frame Saw

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#7

Nope... Definitely bow saw. (Hangs head in shame)


Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#8

Re: Nope... Definitely bow saw. (Hangs head in sha

William Duffield

Easy enough to do. I suppose the only reason I don't get them confused anymore is that I've built both kinds. The stresses on the components of bowsaws and frame saws are completely different, as are the stresses on your body, using them.

The most important thing to consider is that the places where you often hold either one are also the places where the saw has the greatest lateral stress. A tough wood, and very straight grain here are important to the saw's survival, so you can't do a lot of shaping to fit your grip, like you would do with a plane tote or backsaw handle, without seriously compromising its strength. I have considered, but have not yet tried, replacing one of the turned handles on a bowsaw with a backsaw shaped handle, but somehow I think a few friends would throw stones at me if I showed up with one. I'd have to make it with an adjustable hang angle.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#9

What exactly is the difference?

Kees

I'm reading this thread, but I'm afraid that my English knowledge is runnung short. How do they look different?

Despite living on mainland Europe I have no experience with these kinds of saws. They look pretty unwieldy to me...

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#10

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: What exactly is the difference?

Jack Guzman from Maine

A frame saw is a square frame with a blade in the center. A bow saw has the blade on one end and a string or bolt on the other to put tension on the blade.---Jack

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#11

Thanks


Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#12

Re: What exactly is the difference?

William Duffield

The link I posted above to Chris Schwarz' blog shows a plate from Roubo showing a frame saw being used to make veneer.

Here is a picture of a bowsaw I built. It is also called a turning saw because it is used to make curved cuts.


There are a couple of other types of less elegant bowsaws (usually used for cutting up firewood) that are also called bucksaws. Search Google Images for examples.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#13

Must defend my buck saw.....

Bill Tindall


Firewood indeed! While it might be true that most of this kind of saw was used for cutting up small firewood and now is used for decorating walls with rustic themes, the occasion saw has found new employment as a cross cut saw in shops. These are wonderful tools for breaking down lumber into manageable pieces because they cut fast and they are easy for a novice to sharpen.

For Mr. Kees- these saws were common in the day when people cut up small limbs and trees for wood for the cook stove. While it is common to see them for sale they often have rusted or otherwise damaged blades that are irretrievable. The teeth typically will be in a pattern of four cutters arranged like an upside down "W" followed by a double raker tooth that rakes on the forward or back stroke- WWMWWMWWMWWM [turn the W upside down and you have the pattern

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#14

After some more digging...

James Watriss

I found a PWW blog post by Frank Klausz. ("Bowsaw Basics") and got a better look at his saws, how they're shaped, and how he holds them in use. He also makes some good points about their speed and subsequent usefulness in a modern shop... Which I suspected already. The frames aren't markedly different from mine, but his technique is. So, I have some practicing to do.

AND, Highland has frames, too. Subtly different from Frank's, but not impressive enough to warrant buying one when I have ample means for making one. I'd forgotten about their 700mm Japanese crosscut blades though. I have a 400, the 700 will be worth thinking about later, I think.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#15

Re: Must defend my buck saw.....

William Duffield

I have one with the tubular steel open C-shaped frame with a blade with the tooth pattern you describe. Because I'm usually using it on green wood, bark on, outdoors, and I leave it hanging on my garden cart, it also needs sharpening and setting often. It is good practice, especially for exercising your brain, since the sharpening pattern isn't as easy as a rip saw.

My bowsaw is often used a bit unconventionally. I put a hacksaw blade in it, and use it for sawing up steel for tools. I find the hacksaw blade works better on the pull stroke with the blade reversed.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#16

Buck saw

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think you are using the buck saw for its designed use: rough cross cutting. The bow saws that James is interested in are much more like precision instruments. They are designed to cut tenons right on the line, to rip to width following a gauge line closely enough that there is little planing, accurate cross cutting, and scroll work. I don't think your buck saw is used in these situations.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#17

my saw is better than your saw......`

Bill Tindall

Apologies for the title but I could not think of anything better to describe this response. Buck saws of all kinds are a passion with me. I own many and use them regularly and even build some for firewood cutting and wood working.

The tubular metal-framed saws employ a thin, narrow blade with one of two tooth patterns. If you can find a Sandvick blade they are best by a good measure. These blades don't have the raker. The typical "hardware store" replacement blades with raker are poorly ground and often too hard to refile. All of them are too wiggly for accurate cross cutting of lumber, but more ideal for firewood due to reduced drag. Before chain saws were prevalent the larger versions were used to cut pulp wood.

The blade in the saw pictured is thicker and wider and it is made of steel to be sharpened with a triangular file. Because the blade is wider and thicker it tracks accurately across a board, as well as a hand saw in my hands and much quicker because of the large teeth. For hardwood I use minimal set.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#18

Amen

James Watriss

But, they seem to be pretty hard to find. The blades I have came from Woodcraft, I think, made by "Putsch," (currently available at Highland as the 'continental frame saw) and while it's possible that I'll be able to sort them out and make them work more accurately in the future, for now they seem a lot rougher than what I had in mind.

So... frame first, possibly new blades later.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#19

Re: Amen

William Duffield

Mine was built from BugBear's plans, that you can find here:

http://www.tooltrip.com/tooltrip9/woodworking/bowsaw1.pdf

I have "reverse engineered" the plans back into the Imperial units used by the builder of the original saw that Paul reproduced. If you want them in numbers you can work with, in a jpg file, e-mail me. I also have plans for my fancy windlass.

Also, visit Joel Moskowitz' ToolsforWorkingWood site for lots more useful information on the Grammercy bowsaw and how to build and use one from their kit.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#20

Looking for something a bit bigger *LINK*

James Watriss

Have a gander at the kind of thing I have in mind...

He also has smaller versions, like you're talking about, but I'm after something to hold a 700mm blade. (27.5")


Klausz on Bow Saws

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#21

Re: After some more digging...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

would you mind posting a pic of what you have, James? Early in the 80's, there was an article by Frid in FWW wherein he advocated the use of bowsaws. (After all, he was shown using a Makita router, so those must be the best and I bought one of those, too) So I had just learned of Garrett Wade and bought one of theirs. I bet I haven't used it a half dozen times in the nearly 30 years since then. Maybe, like you, my problem is technique.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#22

Re: Looking for something a bit bigger

William Duffield

That's a huge saw, and the blade he is using you would have a hard time salvaging from a broken bandsaw blade in most small shops. Maybe we could start with one of these? :D


I have a Putch blade in my frame saw that looks about the size of the one Frank is using, but it cuts rather coarsely. Of course it could be improved by fiddling with the rake, fleam and set, if I were better at sharpening.

I know Frank is kinda set in his ways, and of course Disston hand saws probably weren't available behind the iron curtain when he was growing up and learning the craft. Of course, bow saw blades require a lot less steel than a hand saw blade, and there is a lot less that can go wrong with a blade being used under tension.

On examining his grip, I can appreciate how you are having problems with operating it comfortably. Looking for a more comfortable grip is a valid goal.

(The pictured bandsaw blades are at Hearne Hardwoods.)

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#23

Re: After some more digging...  *LINK*


Look here...

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#24

Roubo grip

Warren in Lancaster, PA

How does this Roubo grip grab you, James? I sometimes put my left hand just above the cross piece. Some have trouble learning to work with their hands far apart (like in turning or sharpening) but in general spreading the hands gives more control.

Re: Good pattern for a large bowsaw?

#25

Works for me

Bill Tindall

that is how I grip the buck saw. It feels like I have better control with this grip and a more fluid motion.