New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Help with Spiers Infill needed

Posts

Help with Spiers Infill needed

#1

Help with Spiers Infill needed

Ron in Kokomo

I cannot tighten my iron to the bed. The brass piece that holds the knurled screw is pivoting on two pins. I don't think it is supposed to be loose?

I tried to post a pic and failed.

Thanks for any help

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Ron,

Is the lever cap able to pivot on the pins without wobbling? Have you checked the threads on the hold down screw to make sure they are clean? With out a picture I am thinking you may have a loose pivot pin or debris under the iron.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#3

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

Ron in Kokomo

No wobble. But if it pivots at all, how can it hold? Do I need to delicately peen the pins?

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#4

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Ron,

There should only be two contact points with the lever cap, the right and left side via the pin (small screw in this image), the cap has two contact points with the iron, the large screw and the edge of the lever cap. I would not do a thing till you can show us a picture please.

Take care,

Jim


img

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#5

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

Ron in Kokomo

Jim the best I can do right now is e mail you a photo

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#6

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Ron,

Send it and I will post it for you my friend,

Take care,

Jim

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#7

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

Ron in Kokomo

I need your e mail address

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

The Picture is here...

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.


Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#9

Question for Ron *LINK*

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Ron,

Beautiful plane! But not sure what is happening, even after looking at the photo Jim published. Yes, the lever cap is supposed to pivot.

I wonder do you have the correct iron and chip breaker? Attached is a link showing a Spiers NO. 7, complete with iron and chip breaker. Does your plane look like this, when it is all together?

Wiley


Infill Planes Showcase, showing Spiers No. 7

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#10

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Question for Ron

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Wiley,

I think he's missing the chip breaker, great link.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#11

Re: Question for Ron

Ron in Kokomo

Yes Wiley that is what I have

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#12

Re: Question for Ron

Ron in Kokomo

No Jim mine looks like what Wiley posted exactly

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#13

Let us try this

Ron in Kokomo

As you see, I do have the breaker. Yes I know it needs cleaned. When I tighten the screw, the brass piece pivots up and the screw is then not tight enough against the breaker to hold fast.


img

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#15

Getting closer

roninkokomo

At least you can see I have the iron and breaker, and that the breaker needs cleaned. BTW. This problem is very new. It used to work just peachy. :D

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#16

Better pic

roninkokomo

Note screw tightened all the way. Iron assembly still loose


img

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#17

Re: Better pic

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Ron,

One of the lever cap pins must have sheared off. It used to work, now it doesn't, what else could have happened? If you remove the iron/chipbreaker assembly, and examine the lever's attachment, is there play in the lever cap's attachment to one side or the other of the plane's side?

Wiley

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#18

No play at all

roninkokomo

No movement side to side. Slow movement up and down or front to back

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#19

Re: No play at all

TomD

One thing is whether that is the right levercap for the plane. Is it possible an LC from another plane was combined to make a plane that is not original. Same relative to the bladeset, though normally there is less variance possible there.

Does the LC just rotate around the axis of the pin, there is no movement off that point on either side.

If so, how thick a blade would be required to get the LC you have to function within the middle of it's range. Try some shims just to know. Anything being held has to be under the forward end and the screw to be held, as you know. This would be basically a test of whether it is the right LC.

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#20

Re: No play at all

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I'm wondering if Ron should try some shims, see if that works, and then permanently shim the bed for the iron with some appropriately fine hardwood, bringing the iron/breaker* closer to the lever cap and thus permitting the screw to clamp down before it runs out of travel.

*Chip curler? Can't recall what term we agreed upon :D

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#21

Re: No play at all

roninkokomo

Another question occurs.... Remember this plane worked fantastically well for the first five years I used it. I have been out of the shop for 9 years and recently decided to hone it to polish some cherry. What could have caused the change? And. The chip breaker is so far from the cutting edge... Can it be doing any good?

If I move it closer to the edge, it misses the screw.

Ron

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#22

One more complication

roninkokomo

The mouth is already extremely tight. Shimming will cause trouble. How about a longer screw?.

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#23

Re: Let us try this

GolfSteve in Calgary

Hi Ron, judging from the rusty imprint on the cap iron, it looks like the chip breaker used to be much lower in the plane than it is now.

Do you have the chip breaker in the right spot? I've never seen an infill in real life, but I think the lever cap should be riding on the chip breaker. It looks like you might have the lever cap riding on the plane blade because the chip breaker is set too high.

Just a wild guess.

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#24

Possible explanaton and solution

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Ron

It appears that all the attention has been focussed on the screw, that it may be too short. However, as you pointed out, the plane was used successfully for 5 years.

I suspect the problem lies at the other end. The lever cap is a fulcrum and the screw is one end of a lever. The other end is where the pressure is exterted, and this is too low for the screw. So, either the shape of the chipbreaker must change (create more if a bulge/dome - think of the Stanley chipbreaker), or the lever cap needs to be bent a little downward (which is an extreme solution - my money is on the chipbreaker).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Help with Spiers Infill needed

#25

A little more ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Here is a picture of the blade and chipbreaker on the Spier I restored...


(incidentally, I am using an iPad - viz your other question - however I have copied this image from my website)

While this combination looks quite "normal"' I discovered in the resto that the chipbreaker was uneven in height, and that this affected the stability with which the blade was held by the leading edge of the lever cap. I hammered the chip breaker to an even height, and all has been well ever since.

The entry is at the end of the article (long):

http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ToolRestorations/Renovating%20an%20Infill%20Smoother1.html

Regards from Perth

Derek