New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

Posts

Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#1

Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

James Watriss

This is a design borrowed from a French chair builder who did a demo at North Bennet, several years back. All it does is cut the tenon shoulder, the cheeks must still be cut by hand, but given that the shoulder is such a critical point, and is the most visible part of the joint, I figured this was a fixture that was worth building.

It's taken me 6 years to get around to making it, but I think it's going to get a lot of use.


img

More here.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#2

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders

William Duffield

Brilliant!

Since, like me, you are not averse to slaughtering a few electrons with a Domino, why go to the extra trouble of double wedged through tenons? It is just a shop fixture. I think four 10x50 Dominos per joint should be ample to keep it plumb and square.

I assume you have an unrevealed gauge block set to the height of the saw kerf to align the shoulder layout lines with the fixture?

In your example photo, I notice you have only made three shoulder cuts. It seems that if the chamfer below the blade were at a higher angle, say 45°, you could make the fourth cut.

I like the handle on your saw. It's a lot more elegant than the ones I make for push sticks, etc. To attach my handles, I use a Domino. Would your saw work better if you twisted the handle a few degrees clockwise?

IIRC, you're left handed, like me. I can't imagine using your saw right handed, unless you have another blade hidden on the other side. Of course, a second blade would mean you wouldn't have to walk all the way around the end of the vise to make the second cut.

Is it an adaptation of an M. C. Escher stair saw? :)


img

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#3

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders

TomD

Very interesting. Seems like something one might do with various existing vises, on a bench. And an application for a flush cut saw. But it is knew to me and cool.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#4

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders

James Watriss

-Why the over-build? Eh, I felt like it. Yes, it's just a shop fixture, but it's for my home (hand tool) shop), and I felt like going overboard. Wedged through tenons, drawbore pins on the underside... Yeah.

-The blade is simply clamped in the block. I could re-clamp with more blade projection if the design demanded.

-Yes, there's a gauge stick. I'm mildly right handed, meaning I write and throw right handed, but played lacrosse and shoot a bow lefty. I've cultivated ambidextrous sawing skill, so I can always see the line, regardless of which side I'm cutting on.

I'm happy with the saw handle, too. The clamp is hard maple. The saw is beech, and the plan is to burnish it with a beef bone per Andrew Lunn's blog suggestion.

And no, no Escher influences... Yet. :-)

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#5

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders

James Watriss

I thought about that for a while. It would require a really stout chop to cut both sides, and a religiously maintained work surface to be able to make it reliable. At the shop, the jaws on my Emmert wouldn't work for this, and the screw and alignment bars on my end vise would get in the way. At home, the vise chop isn't thick enough.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#6

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders

William Duffield

I understand. I also have a tendency to over-engineer and over-build. If someone calls me on it, i just tell them I'm practicing for the real thing.

If you are carving or turning, being ambidextrous is a distinct advantage.

For burnishing, Don Williams offers these broomcorn burnishers, right out of Roubo. I use them either straight or charged with beeswax.


Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#7

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders

James Watriss

I try to keep practicing for the real thing, too. I've found that it's too easy to rely on quick and dirty methods, and lately I've been missing the quiet sustained focus that high end work requires.

So, it's for my own satisfaction more than anything else.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#8

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders

CStan

Interesting. Seems like wood movement in the jig parts themselves could be an issue.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#9

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders

CStan

The woodworking in the jig itself is pretty breathtaking. Really nice.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#10

Ellis Walentine

Couple questions

Ellis Walentine

First, thanks for showing us this excellent jig. Second, it seems to me that to get the kind of accuracy you're after (100% coplanar shoulders, not to mention perfect 45º angles or whatever), a) you need to strike very accurate layout lines on the workpiece, and b) you need to line those up very accurately with the gauge block. With my eyesight, that would seem to be a tall order. I wonder if there's a good way (e.g., a little miter square type angle setting block) that could work with a height-setting contrivance to reference off the corner of the eventual tenon that would eliminate the need for layout lines or a gauge block?

Also, I wonder if there is an acceptable saw filing pattern that would work equally well when sawing uphill or downhill on the grain, maybe like a veneer saw?

Ellis

Nifty jig.

Ellis

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#11

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders

Stephen Shepherd

Here is the one I made a few years back. Works great, I did whet the teeth on the down side of the blade and it produces a very clean cut.

Since this picture was taken I have modified the clamp with an external tongue for clamping to the bench.

Stephen


img

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#12

Kudos and a challenge

Ron in Kokomo

What a great piece of gear.. Now............ how do we figure out a similar aid for the cheek cuts??

Ron

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#13

For Saws from the east

Ron in Kokomo

Found this on Close Grain. Really looks like it would work great for tenons in the center of the thickness.

http://www.closegrain.com/2010/03/ryoba-tenon-cheeks.html

Ron

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#14

Re: Couple questions

James Watriss

It can take a bit of work to make sure that everything lines up properly. It gets easier with practice, but one of the virtues of the jig is that yes, you can add auxiliary padding to help. The chop and the back of the vise are drilled to accept 3/8" dowels to allow me to use auxiliary pads or set up blocks to help. I'm sure that there are ways to mount some sort of production stops to the thing, too, but I'm not there yet.

The saw blade is a Japanese style blade, made to fit a frame saw. It's a little grabby at first, but the knife-like shape does a very good job of scribing its own lines on the back-stroke. At some point, I may get around to installing a western style blade, but this one's been working well so far.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#15

Cool!

James Watriss

Rather than a tongue, I just added a third cross-piece.

I was one the fence about adding the turned handle on the saw. Have you found it to be helpful?

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#16

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders

James Watriss

Thanks!

Re- Movement, I chose rift sawn hard maple, figuring it would be stable enough, along with the beech body for the saw. I'm sure it will need to be touched up once in a while, but also that small movements in this context won't be so dramatically noticeable in the end product as they would be in something like a wooden plane. And those seem to work just fine. :-)

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#17

I'm skeptical

Bill Tindall

It certainly is an elegant potential solution to the problem of precise shoulders and yours is elegantly executed.

I can think of several "theoretical" reasons it won't continue to deliver precise shoulder lines. If you will humor my skepticism, tell us a year from now how it worked out.

Once scribed, a shoulder line can be whacked approximately with a band saw, or hand saw if you must, and then chiseled to the scribe line in what seems to me to be no more time than this sawing arrangement. For softer woods a single paring cut suffices and these can be made along the base line quickly. I find the scribe and pare to be the only reliably way I can get tight shoulders and many others use it. I never was successful cutting them reliably on a table saw.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#18

craigd

Re: Kudos and a challenge

craigd

how do we figure out a similar aid for the cheek cuts??

Use the vise as a shoot board with your #10 rabbit plane?

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#19

Skeptics welcome

James Watriss

I've seen lots of simple production methods that work, Bill. Particularly for square or simple angled shoulders. This seemed to me to be a good solution for more involved shoulders with compound angles ... But we'll see how it goes.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#20

for example?

Bill Tindall

"I've seen lots of simple production methods that work, Bill. Particularly for square" ......I have yet to try one that delivered precision shoulders. What have you used that works?

Scribing the length off a square end and paring to this scribe line is the only technique that has delivered shoulders reliably in the same plane for me. I see enough professional shops using this ap0proach that I presumed it was the only way that was quick and reliable. But I would be delighted to try something different if you will recommend it.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#21

Re: for example?

James Watriss

-Cross-cutting with a dado stack, using a push block to back up the cut is an easy favorite for me. The whole shebang is slid down the fence, which sets the length of tenon. First pass cuts shoulder and cheek, subsequent passes cut the rest of the cheek.

-Store-bought Delta tenon jig for the table saw has also treated me well. The threaded adjustment points allow for pretty precise dialing-in. I use the Freud box cutting blades with this, or a dado stack.

-cross-cutting with a sliding compound miter blade leaves a clean surface. Because I do this BEFORE cutting cheeks, I use the crosscut bar with the fence.

I've cut square shoulders this way, and simple angled ones. Compound angles required a lot of tweaking and jiggery that I don't clearly remember.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#22

Re: Challenge accepted *LINK*

William Duffield

Well, there's this one, by Jeff Miller, for cutting tenon cheeks with a backsaw.

It's also described in detail in the June 2012 issue of Popular Woodworking.

And, there's a reply to Chris' blog entry with a link to another design that is over a century old [see pg. 90].


http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/chris-schwarz-blog/jeff-miller’s-incredible-tenon-jig

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#23

questions

Bill Tindall

-Cross-cutting with a dado stack, using a push block to back up the cut is an easy favorite for me. ...This approach has never worked reliably for me or others I know that have tried it. Do three shoulders on a rail and one of them invariably is off a bit. Any suggestions for making the approach reliable? Another shortcoming is that the lumber must be of precise thickness, like to +/-0.005" or less because the tenon is not cut from one reference side. Hence any variability in lumber thickness shows up as a tenon thickness.

-Store-bought Delta tenon jig for the table saw has also treated me well. The threaded adjustment points allow for pretty precise dialing-in. ...I have a tenon jig and I use it for cheeks. But how do you arrange shoulders with it?

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#24

Re: questions

James Watriss

Well, these are machine methods... If you have thickness variation, your planer has issues. And if you're getting uneven shoulders, the cut isn't square.

The tenon jig, I scribe the shoulders with a knife to cut back on blowout, and once I get a good test piece, all other tenons get cut.

Re: Vise for cutting tenon shoulders *LINK*

#25

Production tenoning

Steve Elliott

The best method I've seen for small-shop production of tenons combines power and hand tool use. To cut the shoulders, the rails are laid flat and trimmed using a carefully squared-up crosscut table on the table saw and a stop block that references off a point near the center of the rail end. For the short cuts (with the rail standing on its side) the stop block is adjusted to leave just a little extra material, which is then trimmed using a sharp chisel. This takes care of the few thousandths of an inch of misalignment where the different cuts meet.

For the tenon cheeks a tenoning jig on the table saw that references off the same face for both cuts will produce precisely dimensioned tenons in spite of variations in stock thickness.

As for planers, I don't trust them to be precise enough to let the fit of my joint depend on them.