Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about
Bruce McCrory
The following is how far I went to avoid using my pristine, 20-year-old Stanley smoothing plane:
I have owned or used family hand planes most of my life. And I used them just about as many times as I am old in years, with mostly the same results. They were horrid, brutal, cantankerous monsters. When I discovered belt sanders is about the last time my blue, made-in-usa Stanley #4 had the chance to tear up a piece of wood.
A few months ago I decided to replace cedar yard furniture that my son and I made twenty years ago. Some pieces would be made from a redwood picnic set that belonged to my wife’s grandparents and we salvaged wood from after using it ourselves for 20 years.
Now, anyone who has tried to strip up to an eighth-inch of weathered redwood using 40-grit on a belt sander—and is sensitive to the Western US durable woods, redwood and cedar—will know why I paused and reconsidered the choice of tool after washing a few pounds of dust down the shower drain.
Why avoid hand planes?
Simply answered ... They don’t do what they are intended to do. 90-percent of the time one spends fiddling. However, the other 10-percent can be nirvana for a rank neophyte. It’s like raising children. We forget the trauma, and laugh about him/her fingering the policeman from a school bus window.
Second, the experts use shop tools costing thousands of dollars, then “knock-off” the planer marks with the boutique hand tool. What we poor schleps see on YouTube is the final “knock-off”, after the furniture maker has run to the deli next door for a cold one, and to achieve a sweaty t-shirt.
Finally, and only because this will turn into a book should I keep going. Any Stanley—I know nothing of the Other Brands—will require a machine shop to finish what the factory didn’t do. My blue made-in-usa Stanley No. 4 has everything mated at cast and painted metal; or, cast metal to ground iron. A few people finished their investment. The rest, the vast majority, parked Freddie in the dark where he stayed until eBay found him.
What’s wrong with hand planes? The 90-percent factor?
Answer(s):
Sharp. Sharp, sharp, and sharper! Years ago, we had Norton two-tone grinding stones. Maybe, an Arkansas stone. Dad attached a wheel to an old refrigerator motor and we were the grinding kings of the neighborhood. Today, every mail-order catalog sells more sharpening systems and stones than planes. That is where the profits are. Experts like to talk about sharpening. Me, too.
Adjustment. (Tuning.) Those who use hand planes like a challenge. Or like to tinker. I got Crabby Blue adjusted, eventually, and used him along with a morphodite Millers Falls low angle block plane to polish the cedar pieces for the new chairs. They both worked until I tried to shift cutting depth. Experts don’t tell you how many turns of the adjustment screw are required for lash.
Planes do not stay adjusted. My Stanley, Crabby Blue, rocks at the frog and everywhere else. I don’t have a machine shop—don’t bring up files-- so chips sneak into cracks and, like wedges, fix the factory made problems, causing other problems. To fix this entails dismantling, cleaning and re-adjusting. That is about a half-hour fiddle. It takes 30-seconds for a chip to re-wedge the iron.
After a couple days of this hassle, I said “Enough!!” and drove up to the only place I knew in a metro-plex of 3 million people that had any brand other than Stanley. I came home with a Wood River No. 4. It glistened, glittered down to the throat. I knew this guy would work!
Again, hand planes do not stay adjusted! The only thing keeping a hand plane iron in one place is friction. Oh, there are levers that drag it up and down the throat. And, one that swings (kicks) it sideways. But all these motions rely on the plane iron slipping properly. Irons do not slip properly. Crabby Blue had rough iron and paint for friction.
Woodie nearly did me in. But after a couple hours, I went back and did something no expert has ever mentioned. I needed a cheater bar on the screw driver, but after chasing the iron and herding it into position, I reefed the cap-lock screw into its sole stud. To adjust this plane requires relieving the lock screw first, before popping the cam. Then, reefing it back once the iron is adjusted.
That’s my story. And, I’m staying with it.

My experience so far is that glued side outlast the first owner.


