New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

Posts

Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#1

Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

Bruce McCrory

The following is how far I went to avoid using my pristine, 20-year-old Stanley smoothing plane:

I have owned or used family hand planes most of my life. And I used them just about as many times as I am old in years, with mostly the same results. They were horrid, brutal, cantankerous monsters. When I discovered belt sanders is about the last time my blue, made-in-usa Stanley #4 had the chance to tear up a piece of wood.

A few months ago I decided to replace cedar yard furniture that my son and I made twenty years ago. Some pieces would be made from a redwood picnic set that belonged to my wife’s grandparents and we salvaged wood from after using it ourselves for 20 years.

Now, anyone who has tried to strip up to an eighth-inch of weathered redwood using 40-grit on a belt sander—and is sensitive to the Western US durable woods, redwood and cedar—will know why I paused and reconsidered the choice of tool after washing a few pounds of dust down the shower drain.

Why avoid hand planes?

Simply answered ... They don’t do what they are intended to do. 90-percent of the time one spends fiddling. However, the other 10-percent can be nirvana for a rank neophyte. It’s like raising children. We forget the trauma, and laugh about him/her fingering the policeman from a school bus window.

Second, the experts use shop tools costing thousands of dollars, then “knock-off” the planer marks with the boutique hand tool. What we poor schleps see on YouTube is the final “knock-off”, after the furniture maker has run to the deli next door for a cold one, and to achieve a sweaty t-shirt.

Finally, and only because this will turn into a book should I keep going. Any Stanley—I know nothing of the Other Brands—will require a machine shop to finish what the factory didn’t do. My blue made-in-usa Stanley No. 4 has everything mated at cast and painted metal; or, cast metal to ground iron. A few people finished their investment. The rest, the vast majority, parked Freddie in the dark where he stayed until eBay found him.

What’s wrong with hand planes? The 90-percent factor?

Answer(s):

Sharp. Sharp, sharp, and sharper! Years ago, we had Norton two-tone grinding stones. Maybe, an Arkansas stone. Dad attached a wheel to an old refrigerator motor and we were the grinding kings of the neighborhood. Today, every mail-order catalog sells more sharpening systems and stones than planes. That is where the profits are. Experts like to talk about sharpening. Me, too.

Adjustment. (Tuning.) Those who use hand planes like a challenge. Or like to tinker. I got Crabby Blue adjusted, eventually, and used him along with a morphodite Millers Falls low angle block plane to polish the cedar pieces for the new chairs. They both worked until I tried to shift cutting depth. Experts don’t tell you how many turns of the adjustment screw are required for lash.

Planes do not stay adjusted. My Stanley, Crabby Blue, rocks at the frog and everywhere else. I don’t have a machine shop—don’t bring up files-- so chips sneak into cracks and, like wedges, fix the factory made problems, causing other problems. To fix this entails dismantling, cleaning and re-adjusting. That is about a half-hour fiddle. It takes 30-seconds for a chip to re-wedge the iron.

After a couple days of this hassle, I said “Enough!!” and drove up to the only place I knew in a metro-plex of 3 million people that had any brand other than Stanley. I came home with a Wood River No. 4. It glistened, glittered down to the throat. I knew this guy would work!

Again, hand planes do not stay adjusted! The only thing keeping a hand plane iron in one place is friction. Oh, there are levers that drag it up and down the throat. And, one that swings (kicks) it sideways. But all these motions rely on the plane iron slipping properly. Irons do not slip properly. Crabby Blue had rough iron and paint for friction.

Woodie nearly did me in. But after a couple hours, I went back and did something no expert has ever mentioned. I needed a cheater bar on the screw driver, but after chasing the iron and herding it into position, I reefed the cap-lock screw into its sole stud. To adjust this plane requires relieving the lock screw first, before popping the cam. Then, reefing it back once the iron is adjusted.

That’s my story. And, I’m staying with it.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#2

That's a new one to me

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Your particular concern - the adjustment not holding - is one I've not encountered. I wonder if you've got planes that need adjustments. It is true that the later Stanley planes were often seriously lacking in quality; the same is true of many other makers from the 60s on (and not just in hand tools). I gave away my first plane, a Craftsman jack plane, when I realized that the mouth was so hollow that I'd never get it to work right (I will not here mention to whom I gave it; let it be enough to say that he is someone for whom the possession of the tool is challenge enough, and the use of it far beyond what he wants really to do).

I don't know where you are, but there might be a woodworking club in your area; and, if so, one of the hand tool using members might be willing to spend a Saturday afternoon doing show and tell on how to set one up.

I won't try to convince you that hand tools are The Answer - it sounds like you're convinced they're not, unless your post was a cry for help. I will say that I've found them to solve problems that power tools can't easily solve, and, if you can get comfortable with them, you'll find them valuable either alone or as adjuncts to your power tools.

Power tools need tuning/adjusting, too; it's just that the electric motors allow you to overpower a lot of the tuning/adjusting problems, rather than addressing them, right up to when they fail to help you at all.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#3

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

Jerry Nicholson

My first experiences with planes involved Craftsman and Dunlap, the Craftsman probably made in the early 50s and the Dunlap in the early 60s. The conclusion I drew was that planes were useful only for hacking excess height from doors. On these two planes, the frog does not extend downward from its seat and the blade is unsupported for 3/4 inch or so, unless the frog can be moved back enough to jam the edge of the blade against the sole. Almost as bad as a transitional woodie. Then a few years ago I bought a rusty Stanley #8 in an antique shop in Eureka Springs. After I filed the rust lumps off the sole and sharpened the blade, I was actually able to use the plane! This monster was far better than the Craftsman and Dunlap! Then I decided I should have a #4. A #5. A #5 1/4. A #6. A #7. Now I have over 30 Stanley planes and about that many more woodies, transitionals, etc. What do I actually use? Veritas bevel-up planes of course. I keep the old Craftsman around because it belonged to my dad but I wouldn't even consider using it.

Jerry

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#4

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

Ronald Dean

Your problem is that the planes you are using are…well there’s no nice way to put it…they are excrement of the first degree! Your blue plane is from the era well past the point at which Stanley forgot how to manufacture quality (or even usable) woodworking products. The Woodcraft plane is a cheap Chinese knock-off and isn’t even worthy of being a boat anchor.

Wood is a very complex material. Woodworking planes are deceptively complex devices. They can work amazingly well, but they have to be manufactured by companies who intimately understand how they work and how wood behaves.

There are those who will advise you to buy a vintage Stanley on e-Bay and then learn how to tune it up…. to which I’d reply, don’t waste your time and money. You obviously want to cut wood so; find the closest wood working show you can and visit either the Lie-Nielsen booth or the Lee Valley booth.

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/

http://www.leevalley.com/us/?c=2

These two companies are the pre-eminent manufacturers of woodworking hand tools and both will have experts in their booths that can show you how a plane should work. Both companies are more than willing to make sure you know how to get good results out of their products before you buy. Both companies design and manufacture exclusively in North America, so the people you buy from actually make the product. There’s a good chance you’ll actually meet Tom Lie-Nielsen or Rob Lee in their respective booths.

Finally, both have pretty much iron clad satisfaction guarantees…so the whole thing is risk free on your part.

Yup, it’s gonna cost more, but a cheap tool that doesn’t work is worse than useless. An expensive tool that works flawlessly is priceless.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#5

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

Bruce McCrory

Thanks to all of your comments. I hope that you have entertaining experiences, also. The post was principally for laughs. I look at the experience as a rite of passage. A pretty long one, so far.

I really should have gone for the low angle BU from Lee Valley. I suppose it can still happen, since I am exclusively using a Bailey Jack now. Even for the finish smoothing. I will probably save the iron and chip breaker from Crabby Blue; then recycle the rest. The Wood River runs just like the Stanley (blue), and lighter No. 3. Mass has advantages.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#6

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

TomD

You could make a wooden plane in less time than you could participate in this thread. About 45 minutes with an existing blade, in a well equipped power tool shop. You can buy some nice blades out there from the same guys who sell the multi hundred dollar planes, and who in the LV case, wrote the book on wooden planes. Snap! As the kids say.

Typically, one does not get the sense that the average responder actually read you RFP, and they have drifted off to that happy place where they do minimal heavy lifting, and dream of diaphanous shavings from their BU planes. Hogging off 1/8" of cedar, let alone the paint is not something I read about in the LV BU brochure, you want a big mouth, a well blue printed blade retention system, a sharp heavily cambered blade, and some serious lung protection, even if you hand plane it. Sounds like a scrub or jack plane to me.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#7

Wood is good

John in NM

I have a wood scrub plane I made, and I like it a lot, enough that I keep meaning to make more wood planes instead of buying metal ones. Trouble is I keep hanging around forums rather than spending the time to make the planes :D

Seriously though, Tom has it right about the time - if you have a decent chop saw and table saw you can make a perfectly serviceable wood plane in a very short time. Mine took a bit longer as I didn't want the glued up sides, and I fully concede that this is my version of the anti-nail prejudice :D --> there is really nothing wrong with glued sides, I just don't like them.

I can't say as I've had similar problems to those listed in the OP. I can only speculate that its due to one of two reasons - first all my Stanleys are older, 1950's or so. A lot of those troubles could be laid at the door of poor quality control in the particular vintage of manufacturing. Second is that I freely admit to having lower standards than most people who talk a lot about hand planes on the web. I try to avoid chatter and tearout as much as possible, but I also take the accounts of planing nirvana with a fair helping of salt :D Save the big effort for table tops and other fancy surfaces, and don't sweat it if you get some rough finish where no one will see it.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#8

Re: Wood is good

Bruce McCrory

I do have some woodies, but would never consider them in this use. They probably have spent half their lives in storage. People used the things for firewood when I inherited them.

For cedar, I have stripped weathered wood regularly on a substantial deck, and have rehab'd 150 lf of cedar fence for its second 25-years. We in the Pac. NW must do the former and only an eco-masochist would do the latter. I treat myself to the child-like pleasure garden sprinklers provide. Just stay away from the high pressure nozzle.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#9

Please tell me...

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

that you aren't aware of the need to always adjust the depth of cut by extending the blade to the proper adjustment. This always seemed to allow my final adjustment to hold until I needed to remove the blade to resharpen. If you over adjust the blade and back it off to depth there is no contact between the yoke and the cap iron/ chipbreaker. This then leads the blade to back off until the yoke contacts the hole again and thus lose the dept of cut needed. If this method (final adjustment is OUT) is followed I have never needed ot over tighten the lever cap screw. If you do follow this procedure and the adjustment won't hold see the posts concerning the quality of the planes comments. :D

JR

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#10

Strongly disagree

Neal in San Jose

I own three of the WoodCraft planes and find them to be fine workers, and in fact they worked well out of the box with very little fettling. In my part-time role as a hand plane instructor, I found it difficult to recommend that a rookie hand plane user commit many hundreds of dollars to one or more LN or LV planes until s/he was comfortable that was the direction they wanted to go. I was happy when WoodCraft came out with their Bedrock copies at an affordable price.

I use them on a daily basis in my shop, and let students use them side-by-side with LN and LV and others including classic Stanley Bedrock planes so they can get a feel for them, and appreciate the difference between a well designed and manufactured plane such as the WoodCraft, LN and LV, and a current production Stanley, Anant, et al.

My only complaint is that WoodCraft isn't currently making any bevel up planes (well, except for the block).

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#11

Michael Donaldson

Re: Strongly disagree

Michael Donaldson

I have a LN #3, and a Woodriver #4, the rest of my planes are vintage Stanley's (all pre-WWII), or vintage woodies. My experience with the woodriver plane has been pleasant. The feel, fit, and finish may not be quite as nice as the LN, but functionally, I see little to no difference.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#12

Plane and Simple Facts, Bill?


Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#13

That was a cutting remark!   


Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#14

Re: Wood is good

TomD

"glued up sides, and I fully concede that this is my version of the anti-nail prejudice :D --> there is really nothing wrong with glued sides, I just don't like them."

We are pretty much on the same page on that one. I would not cheat a wooden plane in say Japanese style, or English style if it could be made just as well without the glue up. Sometimes glue-ups are not successful over the longer haul. There are certain planes or effects that only gluing up will provide, but that is a different thing. I did make a Japanese plane with glued up sides, just to see how I liked it. And the answer was it worked fine, but I did not like the glue lines running through the plane. :) My experience so far is that glued side outlast the first owner.

And example of a detail that requires a glue up is the Krenov plane where the carved cross pin would require access to at least one side or something tricky, but then that feature is not necessarily the best part of the Krenov plane.

Another example is when glue lines, or lamination are used to construct a more stable plane.

Most of the planes I see myself making going forward are likely of the mortised type.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#15

Ease of build???

Ron in Kokomo

Isn't that the reason for the laminated planes??. I have never made a mortised plane, but It would seem to me that a good bit more skill and time is required??

Ron a Kokomo Galoot who has one week left till retirement.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#16

Re: Please tell me...

Bruce McCrory

Joe, the nib does stay in its assigned recepticle. However, all the planes I have used with adjusters possess the bit of wiggle room that causes lash. And in the case of the Wood River, a very noticeable slip.

When re-adjusting the Wood River, "slip" feels like maneuvering a vehicle with rear wheel turning, i.e., my reference to herding in a previous post . I suspect slip is in all planes with adjusters. The variables of junky or no flattening, nor smooth, well mated surfaces hide the slipping action in the other planes .

For my part, the ravages of age and indigence probably influence the amount of tension in the cap-iron cam, which led to the slipped disks. The fix entailed releasing and then, reefing down the cap-iron screw after fiddling with iron adjustment.

I actually had trouble removing the iron from the Wood River plane because it would seal to the frog by vacuum suction. In this instance, I credit Woodcraft with good quality control of manufacturing. Gochnour's critique and gripe about frog level was slightly less wet in my sample.

The OP still stands....

Re; the wood plane construction: I have a Hock, Krenov style kit--to build. I like the looks of traditional mortice construction method better.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#17

Yep, definitely quicker and easier...

John in NM

And for that reason alone I wouldn't discourage anyone from building one that way. Even if the glue fails one day, the owner will likely get years of productive use out of a tool that took very little time to make. The plane one has handy will get a lot more use than the one they're going to build one day soon :D

I just seem to like solid wood ones, maybe for the challenge, maybe for the look.... purely aesthetic either way. Nice to have the luxury of aesthetic preferences :D

Tom is quite correct too, that this kind of design also has advantages in design details, maximizing stability, and of course you could use a very durable sole material without having to make the whole thing out of it.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#18

on my list

ron in Kokomo

Is a smoother with curly maple body and a lignum vitae sole.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#19

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

CStan

Send it to me. I'll have it working fine in twenty minutes.

Re: Hand plane stinkers experts don’t talk about

#20

Re: Ease of build???

TomD

"Isn't that the reason for the laminated planes??. I have never made a mortised plane, but It would seem to me that a good bit more skill and time is required?? "

It depends on a lot of factors. One would be whether one is making a plane that can be cut to final dimensions in the lamination or not. Classic planes and Japanese planes are often fit somewhat, so that means the any lamination is really only offsetting the rough out. In the case of classic planes the fitting with floats is easy, and removes predictable amounts of material, which means that extreme accuracy in mortising is not really required, or some of the faces are made with a saw. In the case of Japanese planes the blade needs very precise fitting, and this will require hand work whether the rough out was done with lamination or mortising.

Second there is the whole power tool thing. Power tools require a lot of skill in their use. it is often the case that when people come to hand tools, they have already been through power tools. I rarely ever meet an all hand tool woodworker, though I think recent trends make this more common. So:

1) Power tools require skill

2) There are power tools to do the mortising, so in that case the mortising speed and skill thing is a wash with laminated

3) If a person was a hand tool only worker, they would have to do a lot of time consuming work to make an authentic Krenov style laminated plane by hand.

So as I addressed a few days back, there is not that much mortising work that has to be done to make a mortised plane. I mentioned it was about the same to make a Jack as was excavated in the Sellers mortising video, 8 minutes on the long side. That compares favourably to resawing planing, pinning, gluing and clamping, cleaning up, re-squaring, etc...

However, there are sawn planes that are worked to nearly the final dimensions, and are simple in form, the Krenov planes being an example. These are extremely fast to make. It is normally fairly easy to get them cutting if your general plane skills are good. It can be difficult to get them to expel shavings to maximum potential, it might take a few iterations, though I would say that keeping absolutely to the dimensions in the book, or better, is a pretty good bet.

I'm guessing wood also makes a pretty big difference. I once made a full Mac Ebony plane, and that would be very hard to mortise, and very toxic to saw out on a table saw. There is also the aesthetics.

Sounds like you hunger after a bit of a tourist plane there, which is understandable. I think Birdseye will come out a lot nicer when mortised since it will not have the figure interrupted by the lam lines. Some woods hide that better than others. Soles are all pretty much silly on bench planes, and display a lack of knowledge, ATMO. Though they have a place on molding, or other high wear planes, though even there, few people are actually going to get the miles in to wear a plane. And if one can make a plane, it is child's play to fix it. Though in thirty years, only one of my planes has required a rebuild. The more you get into experimentation and collection of different planes, the less you will need any one plane to last all that long. And I am pretty sure it is all for beep when I am gone.