New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Nails

Posts

Nails

#1

Nails

ron in kokomo

Many years ago, I was taught that a real furniture maker did not use nails. Nails were for carpenters. I am reading stuff that would indicate that there is a lot more to this discussion than I had been taught. I could not find much on this site. I know that The Schwarz is a nail user. What about the rest of you? Can we talk about this a little?

Thanks

Ron

Re: Nails

#2

Re: Nails

Schtoo

I use nails when I'm too lazy to cut joinery (or don't have the time!).

I'll also use them to hold down ship lapped boards and to hold beading for glass, although I prefer to use small screws because glass can and will get broken and easy replacement should be 'easy'. I've nailed together more boxes than I've 'joined', not all of those boxes were for tools either.

If it works and is appropriate I'll use them. Anyone who gets upset about it isn't worth getting upset over. ;)

And my 6 year old loves nails. It lets him make his boats and airplanes without waiting for dad to 'do it properly'. :)

Stu.

Re: Nails

#3

Re: Nails

John in NM

That may be true of framing nails, but finish nails and brads definitely have their place in furniture work. I suppose some eschew them for various reasons, but I've never seen much reason to do so. I believe you'll also find a lot of them used on antique pieces, though I've not made the study of antiques that Stephen or Bill has done.

Rather than justifying their use, I believe I would ask those who think they are always taboo to explain their thoughts.

Re: Nails

#4

I am not sure but....

ron in Kokomo

I always got the impression that the thought was that nails were a substitute for a skill that I should have. They didn't think much of screws either.

Re: Nails

#5

Re: Nails

david weaver

I would rather pin drawers together with nails than have screws all over everything, though slotted brass screws are OK.

My house is about 60 years old. All of the kitchen drawers are solid wood and held together with nails. None of them have failed yet.

I'm not going to go out of my way looking for a place to put nails in any furniture or tools that I build, though. If I'm looking for quick, so be it, but I'm not going to do something because it shows up in a blog or magazine article.

Re: Nails

#6

Huh??

ron in kokomo

I don't think they blogged in Colonial Williamsburg???

Re: Nails

#7

Stephen Shepherd

Re: Nails

Stephen Shepherd

I am not sure where the 'no nails' thing came from but it is a silly idea. Sure some things like simple stools or chairs can be made with no nails, but some of the finest furniture ever made had nails.

Few drawers have their bottoms pegged on, there is always a nail or two in each. Molding is nailed on in 99% of the instances on old furniture, I have seen one small piece that had the moldings pegged on, but had nails in the hardware. Backs are usually nailed on and some carcase construction is done with nails.

They have had their use since Egyptian times and were common in 19th century furniture. When and where appropriate they should be used without any fear.

Stephen

Re: Nails

#8

Re: Huh??

david weaver

Ah, yeah.. you mention Chris Schwartz (blogger), I reference blogs and magazine articles, and you follow up with a post asserting that I'm referring to CW? That makes no sense. Stop trolling my posts.

Re: Nails

#9

nosir!!

roninkokomo

I meant that I read about the use of nails in Colonial Williamsburg.. Trolling????? In 30 years of being a member of internet forums, I have never had trouble with anyone. Had to be a first time. I am deeply sorry for however I may have offended you. You will NOT hear from me again.

Re: Nails

#10

???

ron in Kokomo

You said "when and where appropriate".. any examples??.. I can see tacking on the back of a cabinet and, the use of brads for moldings. What am I missing? maybe toenailing dadoed shelves??

Ron

Re: Nails

#11

All very well on the internet...

John in NM

But I've noticed that in the real world expediency often trumps all. While there are exceptions, those who have built furniture for decades and build true masterpieces, the vast majority of us are, for whatever reason, interested in results first.

Now that is not to discourage anyone who wishes to hone their skills to the point where they need no brads. Rather the idea is to keep the expectations of novices and skilled amateurs - most of us are one or the other - within the limits of practical reality.

In cases where those advocating a nail-less approach also post pictures of their work, I am genuinely impressed. With no examples, I often wonder if the fella actually builds much of anything, or if he's just a pervasive reader/recycler of theory and practice :D

Re: Nails

#12

Follow up Question

ron in Kokomo

Could the anti nail bias have some from the Guild system?? Cabinet makers did not use them and joiners did??

Ron

Re: Nails

#13

I agree wholeheartedly

ron in kokomo

There are lots of experts on the net.. Nuff said.....

Re: Nails

#14

Honestly, I think its much more recent...

John in NM

I think a lot of us amateurs see pro's doing fancy stuff like moldings held on with dovetail strips and heaven knows what else, and assume that this is the bar for "quality" workmanship. Whether that bar is appropriate or not is something I feel best left to the individual furniture maker. What I've read of period builders is more in line with what Stephen outlines - an historical git'r'done attitude if you will :D

Re: Nails

#15

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Nails

Jack Guzman from Maine

I use nails. It just depends on whether they are the proper fastening for the application. For example,recently I built a small case to hold spice jars horizontally. The outside is four 1/2" thick cherry boards 5" wide. To join the corners I thought dovetails would be overkill so I rabetted the side pieces and nailed the top and bottom in using square cut brads. The heads show as a tiny black dot that looks great against the cherry. When building clock cases I will nail the moldings on when glue alone isn't enough to hold it or in a cross grain situation. I don't plan on using nails but I end up using them alot more than I expected.In my experience most old clock cases were nailed together.

Nails are neither evil or great,they're just another tool.---Jack

Re: Nails

#16

Re: Nails

joel moskowitz

In the current Work Magazine Reprint Project - where we are reprinting all the work magazine issues from 123 years ago there is an ongoing series on building furniture with nails. The series isn't about building furniture with nails but just about all the projects are nailed together. I am starting to plan about building the screen secretary desk in issue 10 and part of me says no nails, but structurally I can't think of a reason why not and it's a lot less work. Also cut nails hold better than wire nails so I could see nailing falling out of favor in the 20th century.

I don't think nails are specifically downmarket, but I do think that they are inappropriately used so many times that they are today commonly associated with downmarket furniture. But the association isn't entirely fair.

Re: Nails

#17

Re: Nails

TomD

I like nailing frames together, it's like golf, physical, and you can slice and hook them. I have a collection of framing hammers. Modest though it is.

On furniture, the discussion is meaningless without context. I too have lived in a house were the kitchen was held together with nails, and it did not come apart. In fact, when we took down the upper corner assembly, that had hundreds of pounds of weight in it, it turned out to be held up with two framing nails, only. So let me try a few categories:

Heavy utilitarian furniture held together with nails;

Very light weight furniture held together with joints, because nails might not have sufficient bearing.

Furniture that has applied stuff like moldings held on with nails, these to cover the "fine" hand cut joinery. So "made with nails", but not avoiding joinery due to a skills shortage, or for other reasons.

Furniture that has hidden elements nailed in place. Could be dust panels, or drawer runners. Could be very strong.

Furniture that used nails somehow, and these were a basis for failure.

Bad repairs made with nails and hope.

Nails used without an understanding of their excellence in shear, and weakness in retention.

Etc...

Aesthetically...

There is a long standing practice of using design to elevate the quality of a piece. So a very simple piece like a Krenov might use no nails because it would drag the level of such a piece down. The aesthetic of revealed structure/exposed joinery is naturally going to lead to the idea that say dovetails are at a higher level than a nailed together crate. Because of the paradigm in play. A crate is pretty awesome if you love the structural cleverness of the nail.

A complex piece like a highboy might use nails to apply ornament, or even hide exposed joinery that would drag that piece down. The paradigm is different for this piece.

Re: Nails

#18

Re: Nails

TomD

I built a version of Roy Underhill's tool box from a recent series. I didn't have one, and travel to the farm every year, and had never made a Roy piece. He very sternly told us that we should not dovetail the case, that nails were the way to go. I dovetailed it anyway. Take that!

Not really worth a picture, but there it is in the upper right.


Re: Nails

#19

Re: Nails

TomD

You hit the nail on the head. It did not used to be a cheap method due to the cost of nails. Now the cost of making nails has never been lower, and what do they do, flood the market with bad nails. So it's a twofer. A shortcut, with junk.

Of course we know we can get cut nails, or we can use wire nails within their intended limits.

Re: Nails

#20

Re: Nails

Bob Lang

Just before Chris Schwarz got "nail happy" I looked for anti-nail references, and the oldest I came across was in "Encyclopedia of Furniture Making". I don't have the original version, so I'm not sure if it was Ernest Joyce or Alan Peters that turned their nose up at the use of nails.

I didn't dig that deep and someone geekier than me can likely find something earlier, but I believe it is a 20th century prejudice that really took hold in the 1970s or so. It seems that the earlier you look, the more nails you find, along with no desire to apologize or hide them.

Bob Lang

Re: Nails

#21

Repairs...

John in NM

That reminds me that these days drywall screws often fit that bill...

Failed joint, silicone, drywall screw, and hope :D

Re: Nails

#22

Re: Nails

joel moskowitz

I have the earlier edition. (1970)

"Apart from panel and veneer pins the furnituremaker has little use for nails except for softwood fixings...."

then he goes on a bit. Seems to dislike using nails but doesn't mention them in the context of construction of furniture. He does not mention cut nails.

Re: Nails

#23

Jack Guzman from Maine

Nails in chairs

Jack Guzman from Maine

On the other hand,nails should not be used in chair repair. I repair chairs regularly and when I see nail heads at the joints I groan. I have only run into one instance where a nail made sense in a chair. I've seen a few similar.The seat is woven rattan with the four seat frame pieces held together with dowels. Front legs tenoned into the underside of the seat. The back legs are part of the chair back and have a cutout to rest the seat in. This joint is nailed with one large square nail going from the outside of the rear leg into the seat back.---Jack

Re: Nails

#24

Re: Nails

Bob Lang

That's the quote.

Bob Lang

Re: Nails

#25

Re: Nails

Patrick Gibbons

I'm building some nailed furniture right now for Xmas presents. I'm using nails because they're quicker. I chose projects that were appropriate for nailing. When this heat dissipates I'll get back in the garage and finish them. I'll post some pictures when I'm through.