New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

Posts

Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#1

Michael Donaldson

Sharpening, I finally did it.   *LINK*

Michael Donaldson

I need to make a confession: I have been using my hand tools for over a year now, and last night was the first time I sharpened any of them. There were so many different methods and theories about sharpening, that I really didn't know where to start. I actually bought a new plane iron once to avoid sharpening the old one (shame on me). I am now in the middle of building a few boxes and ALL of my planes and chisels were dull, so I had to bite the bullet and sharpen them (Can't afford to just buy new ones ;) ). I have detailed my process and results at the link below.

If anyone has any suggestions on how I could be doing this better or more efficiently, please let me know.


http://thatwoodwork.blogspot.com/

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#2

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it.

CStan

I think there are some steel manufacturers that will want to test the edge tools you've been using for a year without sharpening. It's hard to imagine that they would make a cut in balsa wood, much less anything else.

The average Stanley/Record blade is good for about thirty minutes of work, max, before needing a touch up. You've managed to go a whole year? Pretty amazing.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#3

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it.

TomD

It is an amazing world were a person can own all those tools, and have a profesional blog, and not know the first thing about woodworking. But you are not alone, the knife collecting and using hobby has people in it who send their knives from Canada back to the US to be sharpened.

The ruler deal is so you don't have to flatten the back, it is basically a shortcut that many prefer. The only other thing I saw from skimming is that 1200 to 8K is a big jump and I doubt you are getting that worked out. I would have a 4 or 6K stone in there depending on how all the stones are cutting. I find I need 3 stones to get back to 8K, generally, and I don't need the coarser ones. Of course if you are getting the correct results, and using micro bevels you may be fine.

Check out the way they check razors it does not require cutting anything and particularly when you have large jobs and are learning you will look less patchwork in the hair department.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#4

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it.

William Duffield

patchwork in the hair department?

We're all grown-ups here. No need to obfuscate or strive for political correctness. Call it what it is:

Neanderthal Pattern Baldness

And Rogaine can't cure it.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#5

Ellis Walentine

Welcome to the sharpening club

Ellis

You've mastered the essence already: know what sharp is and pick a way to get there. I started on oil stones in the 50s, moved up to waterstones when they became widespread in the 70s, and stuck with them ever since. Along the way, I've tried just about every other method we've ever discussed here. There are no right or wrong ways. The important thing is to get the edge you need and get back to work.

Nice blog, by the way. You're an accomplished writer and storyteller.

Ellis

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#6

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it.

Patrick Gibbons

Michael, You're a brave man to admit your delay to finally begin sharpening. DAMHIKT but I'm sure we all could make an admission of some sort concerning our woodworking journey that is similar to yours. I think you found all the information out there to be confusing. Years ago I took a course with Paul Sellers when he was in Texas and learned to sharpen there. Like a lot of other aspects of woodworking, I read what other experts had to say about sharpening and became curious about other methods. I tried a lot of other methods much to the consternation of my wallet. Recently I've gone back to Paul's method because of its speed, simplicity and effectiveness. I watched Paul's YouTube video on sharpening and started to understand that a convex bevel achieved the same results as a micro bevel for the first time. Plus it's just easier. You're correct in saying that everyone feels strongly about the correctness of their way of sharpening and there are many ways to get to a sharp edge. I think the best piece of advice I can give you is to get to sharpening freehand as soon as possible. Once the training wheels are gone the ride is a lot more fun.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#7

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#8

Re: Oh... My... God...

TomD

It is the difference between fundamentals, the stuff without which you don't get the desired result, and preferences, that we all have, including not sharpening at all. There is nothing wrong with defending a set of preferences, particularly when someone asks one to.

On the positive, this thread has the potential to go to the moon, ruler trick, Paul Sellers, sharpening, duffers with blogs (I'm pro), there is no limit!

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#9

Michael Donaldson

Re: Oh... My... God...

Michael Donaldson

I really need to find a way to streamline the process. One of the things that kept me from sharpening was the water stones, they were my dad's and are what I have, I can't afford diamond stones or a tormek (spent all my money on new blades ;) ), but the water stones were messy, and required a lot of set up. Plus, here in the south, a tool left unattended for a few hours will start to rust, so covering it in water seemed counter-intuitive. I really need to find a way that I can sharpen IN my shop quickly while in the middle of a project. After I sharpened my tools, I was finally ale to feel like a little less of a fraud, maybe starting to become a real woodworker...

By the way, I was able to go a year by cheating. I would plane my boards, then sand them smooth, or occasionally relapse into power tools. Someone needs to make a rehab clinic for recovering power tool users.

Thanks for the insights and observations. Now, to go look up this Sellers fellow...

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#10

Re: Oh... My... God...

CStan

I have a vintage "No. 1" Washita stone that will raise a burr, i.e. remove bluntness ('make sharp') on regular high carbon steel and do it in five or fewer passes down the stone. Waterstones ARE NOT faster and by the time you pussyfoot around trying not to give everything in the shop a bath and generally schlepping them in and out of the water they are probably slower. They need a dedicated station. And they need flattening, often.

After that, burr removal takes about the same number of alternating front/back passes on a black Arky or just let the wood remove the burr which it is most anxious to do for you. You can also just stay on the Washita and give the burr a flex (I rarely remove it completely on the stones) and not worry about the black Ark. You can run it down a strop if you want, this is so quick it doesn't even count really.

From the time I put the plane down and start removing the iron to the time I start planing again with the freshly honed iron is two minutes, tops, if I'm in a hurry.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#11

Michael Donaldson

Re: Oh... My... God...

Michael Donaldson

I have been looking at Arkansas stones a lot lately. For some reason, they seem less mysterious to me. I will have to start saving up for them...now that my tools are sharpened for the year.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#12

Michael Donaldson

Re: Welcome to the sharpening club

Michael Donaldson

Thanks, Ellis. I have a pretty good time making fun of myself online.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#13

Re: Oh... My... God...

David Weaver

You should actually get some exposure to modern stones before you run around making errant statements.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#14

Michael Donaldson

Re: Oh... My... God...

Michael Donaldson

I would love some exposure to modern stones, as long as you aren't throwing them at me. What should I be looking for?

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#15

Re: Oh... My... God...

david weaver

Any stones are fine, including oil stones. They're pretty much all the same speed if used properly.

I am partial to using two shapton stones, a 1k (which is easily as fast as a washita) and a 15k (which is faster and finer than any finishing oilstone), they are not cheap but nothing good is. A decent black or translucent arkansas will also cost a bunch of money.

They translate to what charles is conveying (raise a burr with a few strokes on the coarse stone, chase it off with the finer stone), except the edge is better, and they work well for a wider variety of steels.

I have seen george wilson mention many times that he uses a medium diamond stone and a spyderco UF stone, after trying gobs of stones at the expense of colonial williamsburg. The spydercos are nice, not sensitive to the type of steel, and quite a bit harder than oilstones.

But for right now, if you dad left you a set of stones to use, even if they're the old style waterstones (that are soft messy) i would stick with them. You're likely to find out that as you get used to using them, you make less mess and work faster.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#16

Re: Oh... My... God...

mark Hennebury

You don't have to use water on water stones;

I quite often soak my "water stones" in solvents such as paint thinners, Varsol, mineral spirits, and sometimes WD40

I use my "watestones" to lap cast iron surfaces like jointer tables or tablesaw tops from time to time to clean them up and also to flatten the stones, this way i don't have to worry about the metal going rusty.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#17

Re: Oh... My... God...

david weaver

shapton professionals, that is. I can't see any reason at all that anyone would ever want to buy the glasstones.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#18

Re: Scary Sharp

TomD

That is an interesting option, but I would never do it in a regular shop environment.

One of the best methods for sharpening your tools is the Scary Sharp method. I started using it for demos where if I wasn't demoing sharpening, I just needed a safety blanket of sharpeners, and I started carrying a piece of wood with some 360, and a fine capable of a razor edge. Eventually it was all I used for a bunch of years. I even used the same piece for an unimaginable period of time.

It seems to have fallen out of favour, due to the fact that there are so many new things coming on. But there is no wet, it is very fast, and the results are good. The only real technical difference is you sharpen side to side. Look up Micahel Dunbar and SS. In my case though I use pieces about the size of playing cards.

Diamond paste is like SS, but a little more difficult to outfit.

I use water stones when it is warm.

Basically find something and stick to it till you are proficient. The two reasons why the competent find all this so easy, are that we have 1) found something that works for the stuff we have, and have stuck with it long enough to have confidence in it. Just having a different make of tools could make my choices less optimal for you. I'm sure I could go into your shop, take your stones and sharpen your tools, but it might take me a while to get stuff the way I like it. 2) We are starting with sharp tools, that were sharpened using our method. So returning to do a refresh is a sure thing, starting from a condition of only slightly dull for the most part. I can start from a raw piece of steel and make a blade, but that is a whole other thing. But when I sharpen, I have a tool that was just sharpened using the same method, it has only gone off from some work, and I just give it the short back and sides treatment, and get back to it.

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it. *LINK*

#19

Re: Sharpening, I finally did it.

Bruce McCrory

Ummm ... my first post here....

Just for the record, putting dull woodworking tools on balsa is called "bludgeoning." In fact, anything duller than a #11 Exacto blade will mangle balsa.

Anyway, I too had my "wow" sharpening moments a few days ago. While my new grinding/sharpening kit floats down the Columbia from Canada--conjecture--after de-railing between North Carolina and "Why-n-th-world?", Montana, I decided to sharpen some plane blades.

I have a series of metalworking sand-paper grits, a glass plate, and a blade-holder-roller thingy from Sears. I got brave and hit the 4" belt sander to fix a block plane iron from its skewed last sharpen before I inherited it. The next iron was done over 100 grit on the glass; I skated the iron holder thingy over the glass.

Memo: glue sandpaper over a coffee can to achieve the desired hollow grind ... Bad pun... I don't own a bench grinder.

Keeping Stanley blades sharp for a year is simple. Mr. ? (Yikes, no reference message post--must be doing this reply wrong...) Mr. ? rarely uses his Made in US, post WWII Stanley tools. Mine stayed sharp for probably 20 years. This is why I have an abundance of sandpaper.

There is more to this story. Much more. But it is Mr. ?'s moment.

Mr. Donaldson! (I just registered.)