New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed bench

Posts

sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed bench

#1

sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed bench

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

It's been a long time since I posted here, but I'm finally building a few things again instead of just thinking about it. With two kids often asleep when I want to work, and a basement shop, I'm suddenly finding quiet a lot more necessary. I'm shifting over to hand tools as much as I can.

One challenge in this - which was also a challenge in power tools - is that I'm left-handed. I'm reasonably ambidextrous, mostly winding up lousy at a variety of tasks with both hands.

With the power tools there weren't a lot of opportunities to choose alternative tools or setups. With hand tools, it seems like I have a chance - at least before I set vises up with a workbench or buy tools beyond the basics - to choose which way to go.

My guess is that the path of least resistance is to go with a right-handed bench, so I don't have to mirror setups. I'll have to practice more to get things done that way, and resist the occasional urge to switch hands, but the tools and instruction are easier to find.

Anyone have an opinion? Especially lefties with a left-handed bench? Or righties who somehow wound up with a left-handed bench?

Thanks!

Re: sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed bench

#2

I like my left-handed bench

Steve Elliott

When I was taking a cabinetmaking course in the late 1970s I built a left-handed cabinetmaker's bench (i.e. with the front vise and tail vise reversed). I like that arrangement because it means I can stand in front of the bench instead of out past the end when I'm working at the front vise. (Yes, I'm left-handed.)

For a while a right-handed friend used the bench and didn't have any problem with it so I'm not sure how big an issue it is.

The only real problem I've had with right-handed tools is the style of veneer saw that has to be used in the right hand. Luckily there are other styles.

Re: sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed bench

#3

Re: sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed b

roger lance

First of all, I'd recommend that you build your own bench....second, build it to suit you....after all, you'll be the one using it.

Re: sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed bench

#4

Re: sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed b

TomD

First thing to decide is whether your bench will be against a wall or not. Best set-up is a bench away from a wall. and better still is a bench with a right and left side that is away from the wall. even though I have a good sized shop, I have always ended up with the bench against the wall. As such, I end up using the right hand side of the bench as a right hander. I guess another option would be 10 or more feet of bench and a vise at both ends. As a right hander I prefer a left hand bench for Japanese tools.

If you use regular western tools, and you put a deep board in your left side vise and support the tail in a stand or stool, then the right hand vise location (left side) is what you want. Otherwise you will have all the vise junk at your hip when you start the planing stroke. Also the board will get less stable as you follow it which is contrary to what you want also. This alone would preclude me using a left handed bench with western tools as a righty.

Re: sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed bench

#5

Re: sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed b

William Duffield

I'm left handed, and have suffered the restrictions of many right handed benches for years. Some day, I'll rebuild my bench top and put the vises in their proper places. In the meantime, I do lots of things from the back of the bench, or do it right handed, or do it less efficiently than I could.

Some examples of things that a properly oriented bench makes a lot easier and more efficient. when jointing and shooting moldings on long boards, you will want to plane from left to right. If your end vise is on the left end, the force of the plane is against the sturdy bench dog in the bench top, not against the bench dog in the more fragile vise. The vise just keeps the back end of the board from swinging around.

When cross cutting on a pair of bench hooks, on a long board, both hooks and the board are to the right of the saw. You don't want the shoulder vise in front of you when you're sawing.

When marking out and cutting joinery, the work is often held in the shoulder vise, and most of the tools, most of the time are in your left hand, when they are not on the bench top. When it is time to swap tools, they go directly between the left hand and the bench top. If the shoulder vise is on the left end, then you have to swap the tool to the right hand to set it down, and swap the next tool when you pick it up, because there's no bench surface to the left of your work. Also, the work held in the vise tends to block your view of the tools on the bench top.

Note that there are lots of planes that are designed for right handed use, especially side escapement molding planes, rabbet planes and plough planes. They can be used left handed, but you have more problems clearing the shavings. In the case of some planes with skewed blades, you have to use them right handed because you push down and forward with your right hand, and sideways into the bench with the left hand. Moldings made with these planes are often planed in a sticking board against a flat head wood screw, and you can hold the sticking board in place with a holdfast instead of putting additional pressure against your tail vise hardware. Bench planes, shoulder planes and modern metallic rabbet planes in general are ambidextrous. Lee Valley now makes rabbet and plough planes specifically for left handed use.

There are some handed planes, e.g., side rabbet planes and skew rabbet block planes, that are skewed to match grain direction, not your handedness, and you might want a pair of them, and learn to use one with each hand. Of course, that is not as difficult for left handers who have learned to live in a world strongly biased against us, as it is for right handers, who seldom have need to learn to do anything left handed, until they want to learn to carve.

Re: sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed bench

#7

Re: sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed b

Patrick Gibbons

I'm a lefty. I've used right-handed benches and left-handed benches and a left-handed bench is the best way to go. Notice I didn't say only way to go. William covered the bases in his post. I built my bench ten years ago and oriented it for left-handed use. I've never regretted that. The things I want to change have nothing to do with it being left-handed. I think to do your best work requires using your dominant hand. At least that's the best way to go about it.

Re: sort of a lefty contemplating a right-handed bench

#8

Thanks, everyone!

Simon St.Laurent - Dryden, NY

I'm leaning slightly further toward going with the left-handed bench. It definitely sounds like it would help me take better advantage of the (pretty slight) dominance of my left hand.

It's great to hear the shared experience!