Re: precision in woodowrking
TomD
"used to cut and assemble these sorts of things with the table saw and hollow chisel mortiser. Once I "inserted a hand tool "fitting step" into the procedure the quality took a leap forward."
HCMs are pretty clean and accurate, they just need to be set up properly. Normally wall roughness assuming quality tools are in use are either due to: the chisel isn't tuned for rotation; the indexing of the part is off (often because of dust); or the drill is not at the correct projection.
- To tune for rotation, it is usually faster to cut some trials and just rotate until the walls are smooth, rather than agonizing over machinist's squares etc...
- Indexing either, clean all the time and keep the part in contact with the fence whenever possible, or get a machine with a vise and X/Y table movement.
- Basically tune the drill for minimal projection that does not burn. Depending on the chuck, I either use chuck set back to spit the drill back the right amount, or I use a gage in the HC shoulder to set a given projection. This should be done before setting wall smoothness in 1 above.
As far as fitting, for one offs, I do it thus: HCM the mortises, bandsaw the tenons, then pass the tenons over a router table. The only hand work is going after the last 1/8 of wood on the faces with a chisel (saves risking shoulder contact with the bit, though that is not terribly likely), which is not really necesarry, but works out faster than the set-up time. at least for me. This method allows tuning as readily as using a shoulder plane and is a lot faster.
This is basically Kelly Meher's method. Not saying one should do it this way, but if one only has a few joints and wants to have perfect results, and use power tools, it is easily doable. I also like this method because it minimizes noise and dust for a machine method.