New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Mortises Chopped

Posts

Mortises Chopped

#1

Mortises Chopped

Bill Tindall


Now its on to molding the edges and coping in the rails.


For these short deep mortises I found it easiest to drill an undersized hole near one end and chop from there to the other end of the mortise. The hole provides a depth target and clearance for chips. The mortises turned out to be more precise in width and have much smoother walls than when I use a hollow chisel mortiser. These advantages will become beneficial when fitting the tenons.

It took me 10 min to do one mortise. Bulk excavation went quickly but diddling with the ends of the mortise took most of the time.

My chisel is home made from a piece of tool steel bar stock. It was trivial to grind out. The bevel is 28 degrees and I found a bevel of about this size to be advantageous for levering out chips. For my level of experience I doubt that a more refined chisel would have offered a significant advantage.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#2

Re: One thing that would've been a benefit..

david weaver

Would've been grinding a taper on the thickness of the chisel along its length (ebay item 370623753649 )

(that is by no means an endorsement of that seller at all, just the picture I wanted)

And a more modern version:

http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com//Merchant/merchant.mvc?Screen=PROD&Store_Code=toolshop&Product_Code=MS-MORT.XX&Category_Code=TBMC

Re: Mortises Chopped

#3

Why?

Bill Tindall

The taper can be easily added, but why? How does the taper help. Never seen it on any of the limited number of mortise chisels I have seen.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#4

Re: Why?

david weaver

Because the chisel doesn't need to be as thick at the business end, it does make it a little harder to work with in small mortises.

The edge of the chisel is really what takes the beating, and its held up at the handle, so there's no great need for balance to be pointed toward the end, it might be a detriment if anything.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#5

Re: One thing that would've been a benefit..

William Duffield

…and if you read Joel's article, you will find the following endorsement:

"The best chisel I have ever used." - Paul Sellers

…ducking and running!

What I really don't understand is why Lie-Nielsen doesn't taper grind their mortise chisels.

Bill, if you taper your handle, I think you'll find it a bit easier to use.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#6

Re: One thing that would've been a benefit..

david weaver

I'll agree with paul's statement, though I'd say one of the best.

And not because it's made with die makers steel or something, but because the profile is very nice and it's just comfortable.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#7

Re: One thing that would've been a benefit..

William Duffield

I would definitely have a few from Joel and Ray Iles if I hadn't already found what I need in a bucket-o-rust at PATINA. All are cast steel, but only the Butcher is oval bolster. The F Colm and the James Swan are socketed. Of course, they all needed to be rehandled and depatinated. One handle is purpleheart, and the other two are "Flying Dragon".

During the recent discussions, one of the old engravings turned on a light bulb. I can't find it now, but it showed a mortise chisel that was considerably thicker where the bevel met the front (narrow) face of the chisel and immediately narrowed again towards the handle. After thinking about it, I realized it made sense if it were hand forged and steel were expensive (an oft heard argument), since it wasn't going to break any easier than one with a thick body all the way back into the handle. The important point is that the thickness of the mortise chisel moves the fulcrum when prying away from the edge, but unlike a bench chisel, not all the way to the top of the mortise. This allows you to rake the sides clean with the sharp edges of the back, even if your mallet blow has driven the chisel in farther than the length of the bevel. It's the long lever arm between the edge and the top of the mortise when you are working down at the bottom of the deep mortise that breaks the bench chisel or even the sash mortise chisel.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#8

precision in woodowrking

Bill Tindall

The need for precision is often dismissed in woodworking. After all, it's wood and wood doesn't lend itself to precision.

Indeed, if the size of this chest of drawers comes out 3/8 "too" big, who cares, or would notice. But when it comes to joinery the required precision approaches that of machining metal. I have been making the tenons to fit in the mortises. If they are off center 0.005" it shows at the joint. If they are too big by 0.005" they won't fit. If the baseline of the tenon wanders less than 0.005" the gaps would be obvious (thankfully I don't have any, but I used to ). It gets fiddly getting all these things just right, especially when one doesn't do it regularly. But it is satisfying when all the fiddling comes together in a crisp joint.

I used to cut and assemble these sorts of things with the table saw and hollow chisel mortiser. Once I "inserted a hand tool "fitting step" into the procedure the quality took a leap forward.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#9

Re: If I'd have been able to find good ..

david weaver

...classic cast steel mortise chisels locally, I likely would not have any RI chisels.

i haven't been that luck. There's a guy local to my parents who still doesn't deal on ebay or anything, so his prices are lower than you'd expect. I always manage to find a couple cast steel chisels in his piles of stuff, but never mortisers.

But I do like the RIs and don't regret spending the money (i think I may have gotten two of them used on discount).

I have a couple of old socket mortisers -big oens, and as George Wilson always says, not all of the old tools are good. They are soft, i almost wonder if they were intended for greener and softer wood than cabinetmakers would use (I have only ever used anything that large to excavate waste from a wooden plane body).

Re: Mortises Chopped

#10

Re: precision in woodowrking

John in NM

I did a lot of production work in a shop for a couple years, all power sawn and mortised joints. Being a hair off center was common for whatever reason. Most pieces were G&G, with the rails set back from the posts, so you never noticed, but on the few flush jointed piece we made, I just swiped the joint a few times with a plane after glue up. Sloppy perhaps, sure to cause fits of heebie jeebies on internet forums, but sure as heck worked fine :D

Re: Mortises Chopped

#11

18th century

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In the early 18th century the taper went the other way, smaller toward the bolster. Later in the century, the mortise chisel was pretty flat for a while before becoming thicker at the bolster. I guess the Chester County makers were able to deal with these tools.

I think Bill did a rather presentable job for a guy who was thinking about giving up on the mortise chisel just a few days ago.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#12

Ellis Walentine

Nice job!

Ellis Walentine

Your studious approach is paying dividends.

Hand-sawn tenons next?

Ellis

Re: Mortises Chopped

#13

Re: 18th century

William Duffield

I like the handle smaller towards the bolster. (I think Adam prefers this configuration as well.) Less chance of it becoming a this little piggy went to market sticker. Any idea why they decided to change the design?

Re: Mortises Chopped

#14

precision vs accuracy

Chris Friesen

I would suggest that handtool woodworking may involve high levels of precision but not necessarily accuracy. The tenon must fit the mortise, but it doesn't matter if the shoulder on one side is a few thou wider than the shoulder on the other side, or if it doesn't fit the *other* mortise.

Basically you pick your show faces, cut one side of the joint (with some degree of slop in the accuracy), then cut the other side and tweak it such that everything fits and looks good.

As has already been said, if you're aiming for flush joints it's often quicker to flush things up after with a hand plane. If you design such that things are intentionally not flush you have more leeway.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#15

Re: Mortises Chopped

CStan

The ultimate test is whether the assembly goes together without twist which can be cause by chopping twist into the mortise, sawing a little twist into the tenons (or both, or offsetting errors in both).

Let us know how it goes, or went, together.

Once there is twist, you have to pare the 'hard side' either the mortise or the tenon (usually the tenon) and by definition there will be slop at that point. It's practically unavoidable if twist is introduced once the joints are cut.

I tend to agree with Joel (and I think David Weaver mentioned this as well), namely, that your craftsman-made chisel probably lacks the subtle geometry needed to make that style chisel work effectively day in and day out.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#16

Re: 18th century

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I think when the bolster is large enough the handle has to lose its taper.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#17

I agree

david weaver

>>I think Bill did a rather presentable job for a guy who was thinking about giving up on the mortise chisel just a few days ago. <<

I agree.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#18

correction

Bill Tindall

"that your craftsman-made chisel". When I made the chisel I had never worked a piece of metal before.....so I would correct to say "hacker made". But, it cost me $10 not $70.

The chisel reminds me of my rifles. For all their shortcomings they all shoot better than I do, which is good enough. The same could be said of the chisel. The $70 chisel would lessen my retirement account for no significant benefit.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#19

Mortising Chisel???

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

Gosh Bill,

After an earlier post I sharpened my blue chips and relegated my Tasai mortising chisels to paint can openers. Did I act in haste?

Tom

Re: Mortises Chopped

#20

Re: correction

TomD

I've spent more than 70 on mortising chisels, but one doesn't have to. I paid about 5 bucks for classic pigstickers without the handles. So I don't think cost is going to keep anyone out of it.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#21

Re: precision vs accuracy

TomD

I agree that sometimes a little guile will save one a lot of unecesarry work. But wood is worked to the same tolerances as metal when it comes to fits, or even the overall pieces. What is different is how it is laid out. Even metal working did not have 100% parts interchangeability for most of the time. That came later.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#22

Re: precision in woodowrking

TomD

"used to cut and assemble these sorts of things with the table saw and hollow chisel mortiser. Once I "inserted a hand tool "fitting step" into the procedure the quality took a leap forward."

HCMs are pretty clean and accurate, they just need to be set up properly. Normally wall roughness assuming quality tools are in use are either due to: the chisel isn't tuned for rotation; the indexing of the part is off (often because of dust); or the drill is not at the correct projection.

- To tune for rotation, it is usually faster to cut some trials and just rotate until the walls are smooth, rather than agonizing over machinist's squares etc...

- Indexing either, clean all the time and keep the part in contact with the fence whenever possible, or get a machine with a vise and X/Y table movement.

- Basically tune the drill for minimal projection that does not burn. Depending on the chuck, I either use chuck set back to spit the drill back the right amount, or I use a gage in the HC shoulder to set a given projection. This should be done before setting wall smoothness in 1 above.

As far as fitting, for one offs, I do it thus: HCM the mortises, bandsaw the tenons, then pass the tenons over a router table. The only hand work is going after the last 1/8 of wood on the faces with a chisel (saves risking shoulder contact with the bit, though that is not terribly likely), which is not really necesarry, but works out faster than the set-up time. at least for me. This method allows tuning as readily as using a shoulder plane and is a lot faster.

This is basically Kelly Meher's method. Not saying one should do it this way, but if one only has a few joints and wants to have perfect results, and use power tools, it is easily doable. I also like this method because it minimizes noise and dust for a machine method.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#23

Re: precision in woodowrking

TomD

"used to cut and assemble these sorts of things with the table saw and hollow chisel mortiser. Once I "inserted a hand tool "fitting step" into the procedure the quality took a leap forward."

HCMs are pretty clean and accurate, they just need to be set up properly. Normally wall roughness assuming quality tools are in use are either due to: the chisel isn't tuned for rotation; the indexing of the part is off (often because of dust); or the drill is not at the correct projection.

- To tune for rotation, it is usually faster to cut some trials and just rotate until the walls are smooth, rather than agonizing over machinist's squares etc...

- Indexing either, clean all the time and keep the part in contact with the fence whenever possible, or get a machine with a vise and X/Y table movement.

- Basically tune the drill for minimal projection that does not burn. Depending on the chuck, I either use chuck set back to spit the drill back the right amount, or I use a gage in the HC shoulder to set a given projection. This should be done before setting wall smoothness in 1 above.

As far as fitting, for one offs, I do it thus: HCM the mortises, bandsaw the tenons, then pass the tenons over a router table. The only hand work is going after the last 1/8 of wood on the faces with a chisel (saves risking shoulder contact with the bit, though that is not terribly likely), which is not really necesarry, but works out faster than the set-up time. at least for me. This method allows tuning as readily as using a shoulder plane and is a lot faster.

This is basically Kelly Meher's method. Not saying one should do it this way, but if one only has a few joints and wants to have perfect results, and use power tools, it is easily doable. I also like this method because it minimizes noise and dust for a machine method.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#24

Agree with Tom that....

roger lance

power tools are like hand tools in that very few give perfect optimum performance out of the box....you have to adjust, fiddle, tune and massage the settings on a power tool like a HCM to get best performance.....but if its a good tool to begin with, that high level of performance can be had.

Re: Mortises Chopped

#25

Re: Mortising Chisel???

James Watriss

Not at all.

I've been opening a lot of paint cans lately, and the cheapo paint can/ bottle opener has finally worn out... I'll give ya $5 for those Tasai chisels, I'm sure they'll hold up better...