New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

data point for lapping/sharpening

Posts

data point for lapping/sharpening

#1

data point for lapping/sharpening

bugbear

I was reading Cassell's Encyclopædia of Mechanics, 1908, which is mainly a compilation from "Work" from earlier years.

In a short article on polishing Carnelians, it recommends using emery (in various grits) on sheets of lead as part of the sequence.

Sounds like classic lapping - hard workpiece, (even) harder abrasive, soft substrate.

BugBear

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#2

relevance to sharpening steel

Bill Tindall

I had access to some copper plated circuit boards. I thought these would be an ideal substrate for diamonds to be used in sharpening our tools. They were not. Copper, and likely other softer metals, of course embedded the diamond nicely. But as soon as some grinding grunge began to form the copper turned into contact cement. It became difficult to move the steel about the copper surface. I think the problem was that the grinding grunge stuck to the copper rather than floating away as it does with cast iron.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#3

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

CStan

That's great, but why not now use emery paper (rather than loose grit) on a hard flat substrate? Would there be any real difference?

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#4

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

david weaver

Only in the rate of birth defects.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#5

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

CStan

Loose grits sink ships.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#6

What I've read, not experienced

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Some folks report "bubbles" under the paper that makes the sandpaper less than totally flat.

Also, it seems to be more expensive than loose grits.

At any rate, where do you find emery paper anymore? My local hardware store hasn't had it for years, and it's a pretty comprehensive place as hardware stores go.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#7

"Emery paper" is easy to find

Bill Tindall

It's now called aluminum oxide.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#8

Yes big difference

Bill Tindall

It costs a lot to apply grits to paper. When the paper grits wear out new expensive paper is required. Alternatively if the worn grits can be replaced by sprinkling some fresh cheap grits on some substrate the cost is much less.

In the case of diamonds the cost of the diamond is cents per caret as the powder and dollars a caret when bought already applied to a film of metal plate.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#9

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#10

Re: "Emery paper" is easy to find

CStan

HD still sell something called emery cloth and it does have a more substantial backing. That's the product I had in mind.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#11

Re: Yes big difference

CStan

Wikipedia:

Emery is a very hard rock type used to make abrasive powder. It largely consists of the mineral corundum (aluminium oxide), mixed with other species such as the iron-bearing spinels hercynite and magnetite, and also rutile (titania). Industrial emery may contain a variety of other minerals and synthetic compounds such as magnesia, mullite, and silica.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#12

Re: Yes big difference

CStan

Here's a source for relatively large quantities. It's apparently used in the dental industry:

http://www.dentallabproducts.com/index.php?cat=3

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#13

Re: Yes big difference

CStan

It is black or dark gray in colour, less dense than translucent-brown corundum with a specific gravity of between 3.5 and 3.8. Because it can be a mixture of minerals, no definite Mohs hardness can be assigned: the hardness of corundum is 9 and that of some spinel-group minerals is near 8, but the hardness of others such as magnetite is near 6.

Crushed or naturally eroded emery (known as black sand) is used as an abrasive — for example, on an emery board, as a traction enhancer in asphalt and tarmac mixtures, or as used in mechanical engineering as emery cloth.

The Greek island of Naxos used to be the main source of this industrially important rock type. It has been mined on the eastern side of Naxos for well over two thousand years until recent times. However, demand for emery has decreased with the development of sintered carbide and oxide materials as abrasives.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#14

According to Dana....

Bill Tindall

Never thought I would be locking horns on this topic.

According to Dana, Textbook of Mineralogy page 482 under the mineral heading Corundum chemical composition, Al2O3.....

"Emery- Includes granular corundum and contains magnetite or hematite (neither of which are much of an abrasive compared to corundum but they may provide some beneficial fracture to the hard corundum). Sometimes associated with iron spinel or hercynite. "

It is my understanding that "Emory Paper", at least the generic stuff that comes in rolls and used in machine shops, is just natural corundum. Given the limited locations where what is called "emery" is located I always thought the generic name of emery got applied to any corundum abrasive.

I suspect that in the context of abrading steel that synthetic aluminum oxide is an acceptable substitute.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#15

emery cloth....

roger lance

was it located with other abrasives or in plumbing section ??....use to employ emery cloth to clean ends of copper pipe before soldering.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#16

Re: emery cloth....

david weaver

Still commonly requested in car repair guides, too. Guessing that's a holdover from older texts.

Re: data point for lapping/sharpening

#17

David Barnett

To set the record straight

David Barnett

Bill's right. I'm wrong.

Emery should be considered mostly naturally occurring corundum (Al203) and not spinel (MgAl2O4) and hematite, both according to Dana and a world-class mineralogist-gemologist who confirmed this over the phone. Now I know better.

Bill is gracious enough to set me straight in email but I wouldn't wish to propogate any misinformation so am posting my error. Sometimes I learn, sometimes re-learn.

Thanks, Bill.