New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Question for Bill Tindall.....

Posts

Question for Bill Tindall.....

#1

Question for Bill Tindall.....

roger lance

Bill....I know you are/have built chests that are "Chester County" chests....would you elaborate on just what this is ??....is this a design school of furniture like Shaker ??....or designs that came from a county years ago ??.....I've just not heard of it or wasn't paying attention but this is new to me and perhaps others.

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#2

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

CStan

http://thehuntmagazine.com/antiques/2010/12/chester-county-furniture/#axzz20EVU0WeJ

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#3

Re: Question for Bill Tindall..... *LINK*

William Duffield

These are in the "Pennsylvania Dutch" (German, e.g., Amish, Mennonite and Moravian) traditions. A typical form is a "Pennsylvania Spice Chest" with the door decorated with an inlay style called "Line and Berry." Of course, the Germans settled in more counties of Pennsylvania than just Chester, and I suppose not all spice chests they built originated in Chester county. A major proponent of this form and style of decoration is Steve Latta (who also does Federal Period inlay). Google image searches on any of these text strings should give you a good idea of what might be included in this type of furniture.

Here is a link to a Pennsylvania Spice Chest disassembled for finishing, revealing its anatomy. The door, in addition to the line and berry, also has a conch-shell paterae, which is atypical of the style.


http://sapfmvachapterfinishingretreat.shutterfly.com/pictures/215

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#4

Examples of what I like from Chester Co

Bill Tindall

I am making a piece like this except with frame and panel sides and bun feet.

The following is something I made a while ago.


I find Chester County furniture more refined than say Shaker, yet not to pretentious for my life style and farm house.

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#5

Chester County

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In colonial days Chester County, Pennsylvania was the land west of Philadelphia and (after a 1729 division) east of Lancaster County. It was settled largely by Quakers, especially Welsh Quakers. The furniture we admire is very much in the Philadelphia tradition, but everything is a bit understated and restrained. I think that is what Bill likes about it. The Quakers were a plain dress sect and though they were prosperous, did not like ostentation or too much display. One odd thing is that some chests of drawers were made without brasses, no pulls at all. Some had brasses put on later, but I have seen at least one which never had holes made in the drawer fronts. In colonial times, many rural or outlying areas often had furniture with a quaintness or quirkiness about them, but Chester County had its own style without the peculiarities.

The line and berry design is apparently a Welsh import, I think mostly seen in the southern part of the county, maybe not really very many makers originally.

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#6

if there is more interest....

Bill Tindall

I recommend the book

Furniture and Its Makers of Chester County, PA by Margaret Schiffer

To see some

Chester County Museum and Winterthur.

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#7

Re: Chester County

William Duffield

Thank you for the clarification, Warren. And thank you for the book recommendation, Bill. The Del-Val Chapter of SAPFM is preparing to do a group build of a Chester County Spice Chest, and I'm considering getting involved with the group, so I guess I've got a lot to learn in a hurry about Chester County.

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#8

Spice boxes

Bill Tindall

Suggest you get loan of the book written about spice boxes.....I think the author is Shiffer. When I made some I shrank them from their traditional size to something better for a jewelry box that could sit on a chest of drawers. I put the traditional "secret" compartment in the top behind the top molding. I would not do that again as in my mind it makes the box look top heavy.

Are you all going to do line and berry? Chester Co museum has a bunch of boxes.

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#9

Re: Spice boxes *LINK*

William Duffield

We're just getting started with organizing the group build, and I don't know who all is going to be participating, much less whether they will decide to do line-and-berry decorations. I'll try to keep y'all posted on this forum as things progress. The articles that were passed out to interested parties at the last meeting all had line-and-berry doors, and there is lots of expertise on the art form in this area. However, there's always the possibility that someone will have a stunning piece of walnut burl and will decide to use it for their door panel as well as their drawer fronts.

I've already ordered the Chester County book by Margaret Schiffer. Thanks again for the recommendation. Searching the SAPFM archives, I find that Jeff Saylor and Steve Latta recommend books and dissertations on Line and Berry by Lee Ellen Griffith.

http://www.sapfm.org/forum/index.php?topic=947.0;wap2

Jeff gave a demonstration of Line and Berry (and the specialty tools he built that are required to make it) at the SAPFM booth at the Lie-Nielsen event at Hearne Hardwoods last fall. (Lie-Nielsen also builds a set of very elegant tools to this purpose.) Chuck Bender of Acanthus Workshops is also active in our chapter, and is adept at this style. The book by Griffith is not currently available on Amazon, ABEBooks, or Google Books. The link below is to the copy of her dissertation in the Penn library.

Is the Chester County Museum to which you refer the Chester County Historical Society Museum in West Chester? I only ask because I figure there is an outside chance you might be referring to another other museum in West Chester, but only if your interests are akin to those of Adam when he's wearing something other than his poofy shirt and not chopping mortises (without a mallet). :)


http://repository.upenn.edu/dissertations/AAI8824743/

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#10

Re: Spice boxes

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Lee Ellen Griffith also wrote the Spice Box Book (1986). It has notes on history and construction and also pictures and descriptions of 58 chests. I think it is worth paying a premium for on the used market. My book is falling apart; I would still buy one in poor condition.

There have been two good articles in Fine Woodworking on Spice Boxes, one by Krutsky #72 1988 and a recent one by Latta#196 2008. Of these I think the older article is more period construction oriented.

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#11

line and berry disertation...

Bill Tindall

I have a copy of the line and berry dissertation. Should anyone need it email me off line.

The museum I speak of is Chester County Historical Society Museum. Good restaurants nearby.

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#12

Re: and I thought the spices were expensive! *LINK*

William Duffield

I have copies of both the Krutsky and Latta articles.

Amazon lists two used copies of The Pennsylvania Spice Box: Paneled Doors and Secret Drawers, by Lee Ellen or Lee E. Griffith (I couldn't find it previously because I searched for "Lee Ellen Griffith") at $245 and $423. Ouch! Lthat's a lot of money, but I suppose I should look at it philosophically: I'd spend a lot more than that for the wood, or for the complete set of string inlay tools from Lie-Nielsen.


http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?cat=549

Re: Question for Bill Tindall.....

#13

Alternate opinion of book

Bill Tindall

I sought out a copy at the Winterthur library. By this time I had spent the day seeing spice boxes in person at Winterthur and the large and vastly more accessible collection of boxes at Chester Co museum. I was interested in inspiration for making a box. I didn't get additional inspiration from the book. In fact I thought most were not attractive to a modern taste. Had I been searching out historical information it would have been a different story. But if you are just looking for inspiration for something to make I don't think the book is worth anything close to the price.

I think Latta's boxes are the most practical to make and use in a modern home. One could not go wrong just making something like he shows in this LN video on line and berry.