New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Split top workbench

Posts

Split top workbench

#1

Michael Donaldson

Split top workbench

Michael Donaldson

So I need a real workbench and intend to build it, but I will use designs someone else came up with that I know work. One very popular one is the split top Roubo. It seems nice, but I can't for the life of me figure out why anyone would want the bench top split. What is the split for? Does it act like a vice? If so, how useful is a vice in the middle of the bench?

Re: Split top workbench

#2

Re: Split top workbench

James Watriss

I haven't seen a split top Roubo. I did see a split top bench in PWW a year or 2 back.

Merit of the design? Bridging panels could alternately provide flat surfaces or tool trays, and the narrow dimensions of each half of the top would fit through a bench top planer.

Re: Split top workbench

#3

Re: Split top workbench

Patrick Gibbons, Katy, TX

I've seen this split top Roubo you're talking about and there is what appears to be a very thin split between the two parts. I can't see any benefit except in the building of it.

Re: Split top workbench

#4

Re: Split top workbench *LINK*

Dean J in MN

I have no idea how a split top Roubo is still a Roubo, but we'll leave that debate for another day.

As for a split in the top in general, here are my and Mike Siemsen's observations:


Nicholson Bench, How Does It Work?

Re: Split top workbench

#5

Re: Split top workbench

Chuck Nickerson

I built a split-top Roubo from the BenchCrafted plans 20 months ago.

Advantages: clamping through middle of the nench, easier to build, and much easier to move. The second point is important to me, as two or three times a year I take it to do WW demos. I can single-handedly move the STR, granted with some grunting.

Disadvantage: perhaps harder to flatten. At this point I can still flatten with shims when needed.

Re: Split top workbench

#6

Re: Split top workbench

Curt Putnam

I am considering a split top for several reasons:

* 2 12" sections can fit through my lunchbox planer.

* I can probably handle a 12" section by myself

* There is the possibility of using two different species; i.e., hard maple for the front and poplar for the rear

* The split can be set up with removable, task specific tool holding modules

* Split can be used for clamping

* back side can be set to butt up against front side for panel planing and then moved back (not sure about the feasibility of this one.) Alternatively split can accept a module to provide continuous level surface.

* Bob Lang has found the split to be very useful for some sawing operations.

Since folks tend to like what they have/are used to, I hope there will be a real good and dispassionate analysis of the strengths & weaknesses of a split top.

Re: Split top workbench

#7

Re: Split top workbench

Dean J in MN

I encourage you to think about using poplar for both the front and rear of the split top (or just a solid top of poplar for those building solid tops).

I had a massive 4" think hard maple top bench-- and I grew to dislike it. It is hard, crazy heavy, and more importantly -- slippery! My current bench is all poplar, and I love it. No issues with a slippery top, and it is more than stiff enough. With 8/4 as the top boards of a English style bench I'm quite sure I could park my truck on it without it moving. And a mortal can move the bench yet it stays in place in use.

Re: Split top workbench

#8

Re: Split top workbench

Curt Putnam

I like the idea of poplar, but how is it in terms of denting?

Re: Split top workbench

#9

Re: Split top workbench

Dean J in MN

Much better to dent a bench than the piece you are working on!

That said, my bench looks fine after nearly 2 years. And the construction lumber nicholsons we've built are holding up just fine after being abused (in and out of vans/trailers for demos) for several years.

Re: Split top workbench

#10

Michael Donaldson

Re: Split top workbench

Michael Donaldson

Thanks for the input. Here are some pics of the split top Roubo:



There are some things I do and don't like about it, but I want to give the design a fair shake. I am really in love with the Lie Nielson Improved workbench found here:

http://www.lie-nielsen.com/catalog.php?sku=1-B-LNA

I only wish it had round dog holes, which work better for holdfasts. I am pretty sure the only one who makes the perfect workbench for me is me.

I like the idea of making the bench out of poplar, mostly because I could build it with far less expense than hard maple which is important. Thanks for the input.

Re: Split top workbench

#11

Re: Split top workbench *LINK*

William Duffield

Bob Rozaieski has five episodes on his Logan Cabinet Shoppe video podcast, discussing work bench design and construction of a Nicholson (English) bench. This is the type of bench used at Colonial Williamsburg, and I believe used by Dean J and Mike Siemsen up in the frozen north woods. The Nicholson bench has a split top, and Bob discusses its use.

These episodes are well worth watching. Note that Bob uses only traditional hand tools in his woodworking.


http://www.logancabinetshoppe.com/podcast-the-workbench.php