Re: Question not answered despite the back and for
TomD
One thing that would help would be to change titles so people can spot a digression at a distance. Also depends how you are set up to view. The option I have does not require me to load each post, which would be annoying if they then go all over the place. Sad thing about that option, at least the way I have it, is that it is chrono, so it is sometimes hard to follow the order and sense of responses.
If it is any consolation, my sense is that if there isn't a volume of posts then the place quiets down to a fatal degree. Ongoing somewhat off topic posts are the lifeblood of a place like this. If you aren't posting and keeping fresh content, you are free-riding.
If there was more moderation, and micro payment system to pay content providers for just sticking to someone else's agenda, it might work. But volunteers are going to gab.
I also suspect that a disorderly progress is the key to anything new coming up. If people don't feel free to say anything that is within the bounds of good taste, then how do you know they won't self-sensor discussions that could really end up going somewhere, and advance knowledge. The academic model is designed to channel new research and keep things efficient. But again, people are getting paid not to talk out of turn there. If you look at something like the loose diamonds stuff, that came from what? Lapidary side hobby, tool rooms? All off topic stuff initially.
). I sometimes don't even read them until there's a bunch of posts and it's clear that it is an active discussion with some interesting side paths.


