New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Portable Sawmill & Tree Service – Abingdon, VA

Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

Posts

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#26

Re: Question not answered despite the back and for

TomD

One thing that would help would be to change titles so people can spot a digression at a distance. Also depends how you are set up to view. The option I have does not require me to load each post, which would be annoying if they then go all over the place. Sad thing about that option, at least the way I have it, is that it is chrono, so it is sometimes hard to follow the order and sense of responses.

If it is any consolation, my sense is that if there isn't a volume of posts then the place quiets down to a fatal degree. Ongoing somewhat off topic posts are the lifeblood of a place like this. If you aren't posting and keeping fresh content, you are free-riding.

If there was more moderation, and micro payment system to pay content providers for just sticking to someone else's agenda, it might work. But volunteers are going to gab.

I also suspect that a disorderly progress is the key to anything new coming up. If people don't feel free to say anything that is within the bounds of good taste, then how do you know they won't self-sensor discussions that could really end up going somewhere, and advance knowledge. The academic model is designed to channel new research and keep things efficient. But again, people are getting paid not to talk out of turn there. If you look at something like the loose diamonds stuff, that came from what? Lapidary side hobby, tool rooms? All off topic stuff initially.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#27

It's funny...

John in NM

I prefer these long threads that progress with disorder (thanks Tom, that's perfect :D ). I sometimes don't even read them until there's a bunch of posts and it's clear that it is an active discussion with some interesting side paths.

I think I would find a strictly Q&A format pretty dull really, sorry but there it is.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#28

I'll hand it to you David...

John in NM

You sure know a lot of words I've never heard before :D :D :D

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#29

Re: New Steels

TomD

HSS is a 19th century technology. So HSS came out about 35 years after the first Stanley planes. All this well over 100 years ago. The metal plane and the tools to cut metal are much the same technology. However, they also spelled the end of serious woodworking over the decades that followed. Or the transition to industrial woodworking.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#30

Re: Enantiodromia much?

North of the Border

"Yes. Yes, there is, and one could even argue you've just demonstrated that very principle."

One can argue anything but to demonstrate something calls for more than that. Reread my post and please show me where and how it has demonstrated what you think it has. All my post has demonstrated, if any, is that I have a different preference, one that's different from that of some other forum members.

My opinion that the thread is off topic a bit from the question posed is as good as yours and others who don't think so. I was trying to read through every post but found none who offered what could answer Bill's inquiry. That's all I pointed out, nothing more.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#31

I've burned my share of blades, too,

Bruce, a MN Galoot

and probably your share as well. Anyway, that's how I learned a light touch.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#32

Re: Enantiodromia much?

david weaver

Again, given that this is pretty much the character of this board, to examine excrutiating details and go off on tangents, why not then just restrict yourself to reading bill's first post, and then checking for a second post from Rob Lee, and otherwise ignoring every other response?

When you tell other people what to do, and it's different than what they're already doing (and what they're doing isn't against the rules), you can't be surprised that people are either going to react negatively or have some fun with your post at your expense.

Most of us moved away from our mother for a reason.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#33

Negatively yes, but not surprised nor at my expens

North of the Border

"react negatively or have some fun with your post at your expense. "

If I had worried about the negativity which was well expected given the nature of internet forums, I would not have posted my opinion.

When a member makes a statement about my post, he or she shouldn't be surprised that he or she would get a response or a request for clarification from me.

Move on? Yes.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#34

Ellis Walentine

Couple thoughts on this

Ellis Walentine

This little meta-conversation we're having here about the nature of forum discussions is of great interest to me. I've long held that the value of the forum format is its very diversity of answers and opinions, which may or may not entirely agree with each other, but which, taken as a whole, give greater perspective to any given issue than you would get with a one-sided answer. The caveat that goes with this benefit is that you have to choose to believe whatever combination of opinions seems most compelling to you or whichever expert you give the most credence to.

Just like members of a real-world community, forum visitors vary widely in intelligence, experience, temperament, social skills and communications ability. Everyone's level of understanding is different, and no question is too dumb to ask. The pursuant discussions often lead into greater depth and clarity on a given topic.

The original question here was directed to Robin Lee, and he's the only one who can give us an authoritative answer -- at least until the new chisels are available, so anyone else's answer is either conjecture or just constructive chatter -- "gab" as Tom would say. Tangents are not unwelcome, though their relevance can vary considerably. That's okay with me.

Ellis

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#35

David Barnett

Enantiodromia more?

David Barnett

"One can argue anything but to demonstrate something calls for more than that."

Yes. You're right. And to that end I quote you:

"I recall someone blasting another guy in another forum because the discussion got sidetracked into a religious matter. I think we are being too uptight about just everything."

http://tinyurl.com/BeingPCWillMean

Only this week I addressed another thread that divagated from the original question.

http://tinyurl.com/ForumMisnamed

It's an imperfect system, and our opinions will differ as to relevant content and topic segregation, but we should endeavor to tolerate others' explorations of paths they deem promising even if we might find them less germane or even disturbing, especially in light of our own personal inconsistencies.

Incidentally, I absolutely respect your right to have and state your opinion. My distaste arose from your sanctimonious and churlish expression of it.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#36

Re: New Steels

CStan

Oh yes,,,, both Record and Stanley sold HSS cutters to the Australian and New Zealand market decades ago.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#37

Re: Enantiodromia more?

TomD

Well without getting personal, it literally is a digression to talk about digressions in a thread on steel. I think that is the logical falsehood some may feel has been exposed by means of a cunning semantic subterfuge.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#38

Re: New Steels

TomD

It's like the car that runs on water - They won't let us have it!

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#39

O Canada!

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I don't know the appropriate greeting for Canada Day, but whatever it is, that's what I wish for you and your countrymen. I do absolutely love your national anthem.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#40

Re: O Canada!

TomD

Aw, shucks! I'm as red over pasty white as the flag...

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#41

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

Rob Lee

Hi Bill,

Holiday up here...spent 3 days stripping, sanding, and staining a deck...not really a holiday after all....

Was an excuse to buy a RO 150 though..... :D

Short answer is ...treat it as you would a high quality O1 steel...it's not a HSS.

Cheers,

Rob

( cleaning up, and heading home.... )

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#42

PS ...

Rob Lee

...for those that do want a HSS, we did run them for the bevel-ups...and have 'em in stock...M2......

Cheers,

Rob

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#43

David Barnett

Let me say it another way

David Barnett

I get prickly when peers advocate to restrict others or tell them how to behave. Remember the Saw Stop thread?

"To those who responded to my last call that the SAW stop feature should be made mandatory ... legislation is a powerful and effective tool to move builders and makers towards better (if not) practices. This applies to almost all industries: oil & gas, hospitals, and whatnot. I'm not for legislation per se but when people say that legislation is a bad thing, I'd tell them to find out why they need their gov't (or Congress in the case of my friends south of the border)."

Perhaps it's a clash of personality types, psychological needs and philosophies. I prefer less-restrictive, freer approaches to things and don't see any need to belittle others for participating in the open discourse of this forum.

I avoid threads such as the one I quoted, but when it comes to a thread where I participated in an appropriate and germane manner, it's fair that I should express my differences.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#45

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

david weaver

Haha...the deck. Otherwise known as the leisure area that takes all of your leisure time to take care of. If we all had sense, we'd have a small house, and a big shop and a shade tree for leisure.