New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

Posts

Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#1

Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

Bill Tindall

Many will be grinding your new steel. How sensitive is it to being heated? Because A2 and O1 steels are tempered at relatively low temperature we must be vigilant about not getting the edge hot while grinding or the hardness is lost. M2 and the like are tempered in the neighborhood of 1000 degrees and hence are more tolerant of heat from grinding. Where does this new steel stand in this important property?

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#2

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

John Pappas

Bill, I am curious. Given a safe temperature, how would you know during grinding if you were within, or outside, that safe temperature? Don't we strive for a good technique that gets the job done without going past a moderately warm iron?

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#3

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

Bill Tindall

I am not sure I understand the question. Some common steels like M2, M4 CPM 3V are tempered at such a high temperature that one doesn't need to worry about being careful grinding. For all practical purposes you can't get them so hot that they will soften. On the other hand, it takes some experience to grind a Stanley blade at 3600 rpm. It would certainly be a marketing advantage if this new steel was grinding heat immune. It would be yet another significant advantage over A2.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#4

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

John Pappas

The point I was trying to make is that by developing a sound grinding technique one should be able to grind all the tools in the shop without being concerned about what temperature to avoid. Even though LV might have a steel that is fool proof, we still have other blades and chisels that aren't fool proof. One needs to have a good technique that works for all their tools.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#5

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

david weaver

I guess the point where I'd depart from the kind of grinding that I do on a carbon steel tool is when grinding something like HSS. If you use a two or three bevel setup on a mujingfang iron, and you use diamonds, the grinding time on a 46 grit wheel is fairly substantial to get it out and the iron grinds maybe 1/3rd as fast. As you go up from there, like M4, if you needed to chase the primary back a significant amount, it could take a matter of several minutes to grind it.

With HSS, as bill says, I worry less about the temperature of the metal for tempering purposes, and more about the temperature for the purpose of not burning myself when I get back to the stones. (on carbon steel, I always use my palm to cool the edge, so I don't always have water handy)

As well as LV's metal worked in MDF, I'd expect it will challenge a standard gray or white grinding wheel a bit more than A2.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#6

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#7

Re: Sound grinding technique?

John Pappas

Obviously there is more involved than I realize. Thanks to both Davids for the insight.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#8

David Barnett

Never hurts to play it safe, ...

David Barnett

... especially when you have an unidentified steel. Didn't mean to imply that approaching each steel cautiously isn't "sound grinding technique" -- it is, but once you know what you're working with, you can grind however's best. A quick, aggressive grind on some tools works really well. On carbon steels I'm gentle and let the abrasive do the work. On tougher HSS tools I'll lean into it when grinding freehand to get the profile I need with the least variation and get my hands off the tool before I sizzle.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#9

Agree but that is not the point

Bill Tindall

Without question everything you said is correct.

I teach sharpening classes. The stress when a beginner goes to the grinder with a Stanley blade is high, as it should be. Would you rather teach or learn to use a grinder on a blade that can be damaged at 350 degrees or one that will withstand turning red with no damage. From a marketing perspective don't you think a blade that will stand red heat would be an advantage over A2? No low speed grinder to buy. No getting a second mortgage to buy a Tormek. Etc.

What you say is correct but getting there is stress free with something like M2. I was terrified of grinding a Stanley blade till I developed my skill on the heat tolerant steels.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#10

look at sharpening data

Bill Tindall

This new steel abrades with abrasive grits about like A2. Look at the sharpening data.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#11

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

TomD

It isn't normally a problem to grind any metal if the wheel is clean, and the touch is light. The art is in knowing how hard you can push it.

My trick to keeping from overheating delicate and valuable steel is to dip it in some water, and grind it until the water evaporates from the edge, dip and keep at it again. Sometimes it gets too warm, in which case I just set it aside for a while. Mostly because if the heat gets too great in the hand the cycle time between dips gets to tight.

These days one can buy laser thermos on ebay for 15 bucks, so that is another option.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#12

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

TomD

I had kinda been thinking it was a HSS steel. There are specific things that hss are good for. Heavy regrinds. If you need to cut up the blade into smaller blades, then you have the option of just slashing it with a disc, and you won't do it any harm. And also you can then construct cutters by silver soldering chunks onto cheaper blades. So you could probably get 6 - 12 hollows and rounds out of a single blade.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#13

Re: Agree but that is not the point

TomD

I think you should rig up a stub as a thermocouple, so they can grind on it an watch the real time temp develop. Or mount a laser, so it can can be read that way. All rights reserved.

What people don't probably need is to learn to grind like they need fire to survive. They would gain the same kind of confidence one gets from learning to drive bumper cars prior to going out in traffic.

Another option is to show them how easy it is to heat treat a simple steel, then they know they don't have to worry about getting the hardness back. That won't be viable in all cases, but one can with certain tools.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#14

Question not answered despite the back and forth

North of the Border

A simple question about the new steel to Rob Lee of LV could turn into a lengthy discussion that sheds little light on the original question. For this thread, we only need Bill's question and Rob's answer (forthcoming, I believe). I am seeing more and more of this in various forums whereby people cloud a topic with their own observations, ideas or further but less-related questions or points.

Not every one feels the way I do about forum discussions, I prefer straight-to-the-point and stick-to-the-topic exchanges.

There's a difference between "having something to say" and "having to say something.”

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#15

Re: Question not answered despite the back and for

david weaver

It's very easy to read Bill's question, and then read Rob's answer and ignore the rest of the posts.

And that doesn't even involve suggesting anyone else change their behavior to make the forum less like they like it and more like you like it. Most people don't find a lot of favor in that.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#16

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

CStan

That's an incisive question and especially relevant for chumps like me running an old Craftsman 6" high speed (one speed) grinder.

Is everybody going to have to buy a water-cooled slow-speed grinder to use these 'new' steels or risk ruining them even though the operator is relatively skilled at the grinder?

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#17

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

CStan

FWIW, ECE sells HSS plane irons and so do Kunz. Not cheap, but they're available. ECE also has a little insert jobby for plane irons. Just slap a new insert in.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#18

Re: Agree but that is not the point

CStan

I let my plain O1 stuff sit in ice water before I even turn on the grinder. Then I dunk in ice water. I've heard this can (or does) cause microfractures but I haven't gotten around to buying a microscope powerful enough to check.

I keep my forefinger right behind the edge and I never let it get even close to uncomfortably hot before it goes back into the ice water.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#19

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

david weaver

Yeah, ECE wants the moon for theirs. Last I checked, they were around $100.

For that kind of money, someone could figure out how to put a mujingfang iron in a bench plane..

.. well, if someone would bother to sell them over here consistently. The two irons in my continental smoothers are as tough as any irons I've seen (I haven't used any space steels, like M4, though), and when the planes were being sold over here, the replacement irons were $10.

edit:

http://woodworker.com/9-34-euro-smoothing-plane-mssu-131-795.asp

Woodworker's supply has them, they've gone up in price a little and switched to a bland wood vs. the ebony they used to have. But the large smoother has a near 2" iron in it that is what I'm talking about. They don't sell the iron separately, though - too bad.

Funny that they call it "carbon steel", they called it that when I ordered mine - it is not remotely close to carbon steel, though I guess along with lots of other stuff, it has carbon in it.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#20

Re: Question not answered despite the back and for

John Pappas

Since I was the first to comment on Bill's original post, I would like to respond to your remarks. I asked Bill a sincere question relative to his question to Rob Lee. David Weaver and David Barnett offered intelligent information to my question that I found to be enllightening and made me see that even though I consider my grinding technique to be quite good that I really lack some knowledge that is pertinent to the overall topic. As I see it, I asked a sincere question, and received some intelligent information. I learned something from this exchange and I would wager that others also gained some insight. All the comments in this thread are pertinent and related to Bill's question in one way or other. A good thread, I would say.

Regards,

John

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#21

Based on no real knowledge at all...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I would guess that your old Craftsman is probably in the same league as my old Delta one-speed (3450) and that if we can grind a stock Stanley blade without killing it, we can probably grind a new LV blade.

I'd still like to see Rob's answer to Bill's question, but I'll bet Rob is on vacation or some such thing or we would have seen that answer already.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#22

David Barnett

Enantiodromia much?

David Barnett

Not every one feels the way I do about forum discussions, I prefer straight-to-the-point and stick-to-the-topic exchanges.

Isn't that funny? Free-ranging discourse is what I like best about Wood Central. Where else would I have learned to make better pizza when I didn't even know I wanted to make better pizza?

There's a difference between "having something to say" and "having to say something.”

Yes. Yes, there is, and one could even argue you've just demonstrated that very principle.

:)

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#23

Re: Based on no real knowledge at all...

CStan

Oh, I've drawn the temper on more than one blade.... it's been a while though.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#24

Re: It's the reverse

TomD

"Is everybody going to have to buy a water-cooled slow-speed grinder to use these 'new' steels or risk ruining them even though the operator is relatively skilled at the grinder?"

It's actually the reverse. The old steels can be tempered at low heat, domestic oven heat. This means it is easy to over-heat them and end up with a softer tool that the manufacturer intended, though if you love soft tools, no biggie. The flip side is that you can reharden them at home because they are easily heat treated with workshop gear, the main limitation most people face being a tempering oven that will operate at high temp, but isn't needed for plain steel.

The other thing is that certain jobs will heat the tool so much they draw the temper. Since tool steel is generally more about making cars than say milking stools, this can easily happen. So we have HSS which is designed to work at any heat, pretty much, worst case it just gets harder.

So the "new" HSS steels are the easy to grind without worry steels, the old steels are the worrisome ones. Though skill will conquer all.

When I bought my original grinder it was an 8" 1800 model, and it is still chugging. When I much later got into metal working heavy iron, I think I figured out the whole 6", 3600 rpm, gray green wheel thing. Those are designed to burn out with friction lathe bits, etc... in HSS. Or with different wheels grind carbide. Those should probably never make it into a woodworking shop, though they do work with a light touch. But to me they are designed to burn off the metal with friction, they are capable of 4x the heat. And the extra speed makes them 4x as dangerous if a wheel blows.

Re: Calling Mr. Lee of Lee Valley..steel question

#25

Re:Canada Day

TomD

Canada day long weekend. The rich people have cottages or are helping out in soup kitchens. I saw a rock band play last year's number one hit song, Not In Love, to a free crowd of about 400. Sounds Canadian to me.

Further extrapolation:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mWQf13B8epw&list=PLF75BF93B25B21521&index=1&feature=plcp