New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

wood drying

Posts

Re: wood drying

#26

a comment about the crust and taste

Bill Tindall

The problem with a lot of pizza is that nothing has been done to develop the flavor of the crust. A good pizza crust should taste as good as a baguette or loaf of Italian bread from a "real" bakery. I taught a friend to make pizza. Previously his kids never ate the crust edges. Commonly they taste similar to paper. Now they eat every scrap of crust. I purposefully make a large edge to provide more crust. It is like having a loaf of Italian bread to accompany the meal.

Re: wood drying

#27

Re: a comment about the crust and taste

Kees

Thanks Bill, I learned a couple new tricks from your description. My next pizza's should taste a lot better.

Re: wood drying

#28

back to your problem.....

Bill Tindall

I don't know anything about drying green spindles. But we got the pizza cooked and eaten.

If you dry the spindles too fast they will fracture. I have no idea what too fast is for something that looks different than a stack of 4/4 lumber. However, 120 F is not hot enough to get to 7% moisture content unless the outside humidity is very low. Might work in the winter. Where I live I need to get up around 140 to 150 F to reach 7%.

The final moisture content of the wood only depends on the humidity at the temperature of the air around the spindle.

Re: wood drying

#29

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: back to your problem.....

Jack Guzman from Maine

I don't mind getting off subject for that one. That is a yummy looking pizza.

I only want to dry the spindles enough so the tenons won't shrink and loosen up. The reason for the scale is that when I dry them I have very little clue of what's going on.I guess on time. They get thinner,feel lighter,seem dry but I don't really know. I figure a scale will give me something I can gauge.I think the temp is more than that maybe 150. I don't remember.It is the highest setting on the thermal switch. I use 450 watts of light and it gets pretty warm in there before the switch trips off.

Do you deliver? Just kidding,the pizza would probably cool before I got it.---Jack

Re: wood drying

#30

Re: back to your problem.....

Bill Tindall

If you get something as tiny as a spindle to 150 degree and it don't crack the tenon ends are going to be as dry as the prevailing humidity allows in hours, not days. Moisture is going to come screaming out the ends of the spindle as soon as the spindle reaches temperature.

Re: wood drying

#31

Re: back to your problem.....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I would question why you want to do the turnings green. I have often done rough turning green, then let the cylinders sit and dry for six months or more before doing the fine turning. Green turnings will fuzz up and lose crispness and smoothness when they dry.

I sit in a 200 year old Windsor every day . I can't imagine the maker was weighing spindles, putting tenons in hot sand, burning light bulbs, or the like.

Re: wood drying

#32

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: back to your problem.....

Jack Guzman from Maine

Warren I have turned them totally dry. I even made a chair with legs I got out of my firewood stack.The only stock I have on hand right now is green. My neighbor cut down the tree for me a little over a week ago. I do want to try one though where I insert dry tenons into green mortises but that's not what I'm working on right now. Just want to learn more about drying wood.---Jack

Re: wood drying

#33

In this case you are not correct

Bill Tindall

Arguably the best chair maker in the US turns his maple spindles green because they turn vastly easier that way and that is straight from the "horses mouth", well Curtis's mouth. His turnings are unmatched in crispness. Curtis has a freezer to store his green maple so it doesn't mold.

Re: wood drying

#34

Re: In this case you are not correct

TomD

There are three different ways of going green, one is how you source your materials; two is how you process you materials, turning green wood in this case, or splitting wood out from logs; three is playing games with differential shrinkage to make your joints more permanent. There are probably more but those come to mind.

Re: wood drying

#35

Documentation?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Curtis is a very good chair maker. It is a really wonderful set a videos he has made. I think more helpful than a class. But just because he lives in Tennessee does not make him the best chair maker in the U.S. However helpful his techniques are, without historical evidence they are speculative. I am having trouble picturing a freezer full of maple in a chair factory in 18th century Philadelphia. Or tenon kilns. I have seen finer turnings on both historical and new work.

Re: wood drying

#36

Re: Documentation?

Bob Hackett

I bought a freezer (cheap) made in the 1700`s when an old chair mill (water powered) went into foreclosure and had to be auctioned off recently. Before we could move it we had to unload all the frozen maple out of it. Luckily the auctioneer threw in several pairs of brain tanned beaver skin mittens so we didn`t get frostbite.

All the spindles were dated and we got the purchase date of the freezer from the mill ledger. Good enough documentation for ya? ;)

Re: wood drying

#37

Seriously

Bob Hackett

Until the middle of the last century there was a type of craftsmen called "Bodgers" in the UK who were effectively subcontractors to the mills that mass produced the chairs and tables. These people lived in the groves and turned chair parts on springpole lathes. They cut the wood, split the billets and turned the spindles from green wood. When they had depleted the suitable material from a grove they moved on and set up camp in the next grove.

My Conover lathe is patterned after what was originally a bodger`s lathe from the High Wycombe area of England.

There is a whole lot of history on both sides of the ocean to back green turning of chair parts Warren. Freezers aren`t the only way to keep billets green, all it takes is water. Water contained in a bucket, tub or pond. Even free running water like a creek or stream will do if you don`t have a bucket or tub (or a freezer) handy.

Re: wood drying

#38

For your viewing pleasure (link)

Bob Hackett

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KCkc7Qp1vho

Anyone who has ever used a sping pole (or other human powered) lathe can tell you that it`s a real bear to turn using dry wood. As you can see, all the smart bodgers turned green. Easier on the legs, tools and the lungs. Far faster too, a very real consideration when you`re a subcontractor and being paid by the spindle.

Re: wood drying

#39

And here I thought...

John in NM

that "bodger" meant something else entirely :D

That's what I get for learning my Brit slang from Junkyard Wars :D

Re: wood drying

#40

However.......

Bill Tindall

You can't turn green spindles with amateur technique. The shavings must be sliced through the cells cleanly like what is done in the best planing- a skew to slice the convex parts and gouge for the concave parts.

At the rate a professional could turn spindles, Curtis does one in tens of seconds not many minutes, the billets from a log section would soon be turned into spindles. A modern professional turner doesn't even slow the lather between spindles, mounting them at speed to save time. Long before the wood became damaged even in hot weather the tree would be consumed and the spindles drying.

The modern occasional chair maker adapts methods to suit their situation and what was done in 1740 is irrelevant. Celebrate their accomplishment and don't fuss about how they got there, its irrelevant too.

Re: wood drying

#41

Re: However.......

TomD

"You can't turn green spindles with amateur technique. The shavings must be sliced through the cells cleanly like what is done in the best planing- a skew to slice the convex parts and gouge for the concave parts."

What are amateur techniques? Skew and gouge are what everyone uses. There are more pros out there hacking up wood, or using tools that may be associated with amateurs unfairly like scrapers, than there are amateurs. Even Curtis is only a part time one trick pony turner. I know a guy who makes windsor chairs for a living, and he turns dry wood I think, not that it matters. He was not a particularly enthusiastic turner. He spent monday mornings turning. So a few hours a week. There are a lot of amateur turners who exceed that level of turning many times over

"The modern occasional chair maker adapts methods to suit their situation and what was done in 1740 is irrelevant. Celebrate their accomplishment and don't fuss about how they got there, its irrelevant too."

How is it irrelevant if people are interested. For a long time it was hoped that one would untangle the secret to chairs that lasted hundreds of years by following best practices from the old days. I think that is still the hope of some, though I am not sure it is how the best work is actually being done. It's not for sure that lasting many centuries was really the objective of early turners. Nobody in history has really been able to hope for that outcome for their work on any kind of reliable basis. But it is the objective of some working today.

Re: wood drying

#42

Re: And here I thought...

TomD

A bodge job is one that has been messed up. Not sure if the root is the same. Modern day adoration aside, it is possible that vagrant woodworkers living in the woods where not at the top of the craft pyramid.

Reminds me of the thread on peat. One can imagine people prattling on about green energy workers today, while in another context one can enjoy an endless selection of bogman jokes.

Here are some pros bodging it up in a fine little song from the sixties that I was brought up on:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mOA_SUKEZRE

Re: wood drying

#43

Re: Seriously

Sgian Dubh

Bob, here's a bit of information from a text I've written. It supplements your contribution. I have a reference somewhere that discusses Windsor chairmaking around the High Wycombe area of southern England, but can't locate it at the moment. Slainte.

"There is a long history of traditional basket making and the fabrication of hurdles and gates using wet timber harvested from coppiced woodlands of hazel, willow, oak, ash or elm. The flexibility of the wet wood is an advantage. After construction the wood dries and shrinks, but in this case wood stability is not a major concern.

Similarly the ancient craft of chair bodging required the craftsman to go out into the woods with a pole lathe and turn spindles and legs for Windsor chairs. The Chiltern Hills of England were a focal point for the industry due to there being plentiful beech woodlands. The work could continue all year and for some workers bodging was a full-time occupation. Chair parts were turned from wet freshly felled small beech trees and coppiced parts. Some accounts estimate that in the early 1900s a pair of skilled bodgers could produce 350 or so leg and framing parts for Windsor chairs in a 5-1/2 day work week of 12 hours a day. Once turned the parts would be stacked for seasoning and finally delivered to local chair making factories in and around High Wycombe.

In both these examples green, or wet wood is utilised for a purpose. Turning green wood is much easier than turning dry wood. The air dried turned leg and spindle parts received thorough drying near a stove in the chair factory. Construction required inserting the extremely dry spindle parts into holes or mortices bored into comparatively damp air dried seats. The seats, and their bored mortises, would shrink and the legs would swell after assembly making the joints tighter."

Re: wood drying

#44

Curtis does this on Youtube


Re: wood drying

#45

Bodgers

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The term bodger originated in the early 20th century and was used a for relatively small number of turners, all in the High Wycombe area. The High Wycombe District became a center for chair manufacture in the mid 19th century. In the 19th century turners were called turners. In the 18th, 17th,... 13th centuries they were called turners. Most prints from the 18th century and earlier show turners working inside or in sheds.

I have used a pole lathe for professional work for more than 30 years. Some techniques that work for an electric lathe do not work well for a pole lathe or for a treadle lathe.

Re: wood drying

#46

David Barnett

(Message Deleted by Poster)


Re: wood drying

#47

Re: more details

TomD

Bill:

1) How do you find cooking at 550 works. I haven't just tried that for 7 minutes, but my oven starts to seem too hot at the upper range for more prolonged heats. I recall people used to say back in the 60s that you couldn't make pizza at home because one did not have the right kind of oven (not hot enough). Obviously you can't tell me about my oven, just wondering what you have observed or heard from others.

2) Any tip for French bread?

Re: wood drying

#48

Re: more details

Bill Tindall

I have no problem at all doing the pizza at 550. It does take 1/2 hour to get there and equilibrate the quarry tiles. Again, the placement of the tiles vertically needs to be where the crust is medium brown just as the cheese starts to develop some browning . (there is often a vertical temperature gradient in ovens)

French Bread....still working on that one. I get OK shaped loaves and excellent flavor but still can't develop big holes. There are dozens of procedures out there and they often are in conflict. I hope to visit a French bakery and get some pointers.

Re: wood drying

#50

More on the pizza

Bill Tindall

I thought everyone in the world has a good local pizza place except me. I had no idea my quest for "made at home pizza" would be useful to others.

After its rest in the frig the dough can be frozen and kept frozen for a few weeks. Same drill, except now its thaw, warm to room temperature to wake up the yeasties and carry on. I just make a ball and freeze in a freezer zip lock bag.