New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

The Kato wear study *LINK*

Posts

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#26

Re: what's to sharpen?

Steve Elliott

Reviewing the study images and data, I get these figures for the sharpening strategies you mention:

After the relatively large amount of use studied (200 meters cutting length) up to 8 or 9 microns would have to be removed from the blade back. This is just over 1/3 of a thousandth of an inch.

Working only the bevel side, 2 to 3 thousandths would have to be removed to restore the original geometry. This side of the blade can easily be ground, so this is not difficult.

My own experience has convinced me that using a back bevel does not result in a "growing back bevel problem."

Most woodworkers remove steel from both surfaces of the cutting edge when sharpening, the proportion from each being a matter of personal preference.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#27

Re: what's to sharpen?

Marhk

Thanks, I find this discussion the very essence of the approach to sharpening. I will need to think about the back bevel thing a bit more. Several years ago, when I had just read Charlesworth, I tried it. It worked quite well the first time I tried it - but on repeat sharpening, not so well. Maybe I was doing too much.

Now as to removing the scooped area as noted in this current paper: "proportion" (back vs. front) is not effective. If you think about it in order to correct the geometry it all has to be done one side or the other. Interesting because I'm not sure that even with the Sellers technique (starting on a coarse stone) that I remove 3 thou from a bevel and I know that I personally don't polish the back ½ thou. So as I said originally, what we need is a series of EM studies to follow a blade through repeated sharpenings so as to see what happens to that scooped area + and - a back bevel.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#28

Ruler trick bevel does not grow.

David Charlesworth

What tends to be forgotten is that the blade length is shortened with every sharpening.

I get a decent wire edge on an 800grit stone every time, (no faffing about trying to resharpen on a polishing stone).

Hence the growth in width of the polished, ruler back bevel, is balanced by the shortening of the blade.

I find that the back bevel does not grow in width and remains at less than 3/64" .

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#29

Re: Ruler trick bevel does not grow.

Marhk

I can’t help but dwell on the wear data presented. That scooped area is an epiphany which explains a lot of the sharpening problems encountered especially rehoning between grindings. To sharpen this blade to a true edge either the bevel or the back has to be fully ground back to the parallel red line so as to remove the scooped area. (note that partial removal of both surfaces won’t work to remove the scoop.) That is approximately 1/2 thou from the back or as much as 3 thou from the bevel.

It seems especially important to note that the bevel could be sharpened to a palpable burr that would probably break off when the back is polished but still not become a true intersecting plane and thus not as sharp as it could be.


img

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#30

One thing about the wear in the back..

david weaver

..I don't know that most people will plane that much before they resharpen, and I also don't know that people will often set their cap irons close enough for a relative thickness shaving to get that kind of wear.

I would bet, if I was going to bet money on such a thing, that the wear is actually between zero and what's shown on average for a user.

Of course, we know it's not zero, but i'm just giving a range and i'm not about to stick my neck out and make some numeric figure for a minimum the wear could be.

I do know that with a decent polish stone, I have not had trouble removing all of the wear on the back of an iron (it is very easy to see to the edge, especially if you confirm your looks with a loupe) as long as I'm using a decent stone.

As bill points out, as long as something has not become a defect (i.e., chips or scratches in the back of the iron), I don't know how much terminal performance is added by that back polishing to that level, but I do it, anyway. If I didn't, probably nobody would be able to tell in my work, but it takes about 10-15 seconds more to dedicate yourself to really wiping out all of the wear on the back of a flat iron.

But, anyway, I wouldn't get hung up on a half thousandth of wear in depth, because I doubt too many people actually put that much wear on an iron before they go back to the stones.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#31

Re: Ruler trick bevel does not grow.

Steve Elliott

The Kato study found that without a cap iron the wear depth on the back of the blade was 2-1/2 microns after 200 meters of planing, which is less than one eighth of a thousandth of an inch. The average depth with a cap iron was around 6 microns, or 1/4 thousandth. If a truly sharp blade is needed for the task at hand the blade would probably be rehoned before planing 200 meters, so the amount to be removed from the back would be a few microns, not one half thousandth of an inch.

I find it easier to understand this by just trying out different sharpening techniques to see what it takes to get a really sharp edge.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#32

Re: Ruler trick bevel does not grow.

david weaver

That's exactly what my previous comment was about (or maybe it was yesterday to kees) - if you can get a polish to the edge with the sharpening method you already have, there's no reason to retool with nuclear diamond fission stones and loose grit to try to remove a dip that a study says is there - when you've already managed to remove it.

All you need to do is do the job correctly. If you're doing that already, then the details of the study don't really affect much.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#33

Re: Ruler trick bevel does not grow.

Marhk

There are even more variables on the head of this pin! This picture shows a 3 degree back bevel is required to reach the tip of the scoop (associated with bevel honing). Note how wide the back bevel becomes. Now, the real question is what happens next? We reapply the cap iron and plane some more. On the second or third honing what is the geometry? We at this point can only speculate. Someone needs to do that study with EM’s.

Another factor is what is the real back bevel angle? Mr. Charlesworth’s technique (movement 1 and movement 2) causes a hollow to the blade back - this reduces the back bevel and I suspect makes the scoop less deep. Mr. Weaver’s approach is to put pressure on the edge when polishing the back - thus, it would seem, creating a hump and a back bevel. Mr. Sellers strops and probably causes a small hump and back bevel by dubbing (as was noted before). Mr. Elliott tries to keep the back flat and at the end applies a "couple" degree back bevel. I have no doubt all end up with a workable edge. Some may be sharper than others but it’s really the HOW of it that interests me.


img

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#34

Some perspective...

Schtoo

I don't want to spoil the party here, but are you all fully aware of how much planing 200 metres entails?

I have a plane sitting on my shelf that will plane just over 300 lineal metres of clear softwood (or it might be the same stuff used in this study), and maintain a shaving thickness of 5 microns for that full distance.

To do that it's powder metal cobalt high speed steel somewhere in the high HRC 60 range.

Your average plane blade isn't going to plane 200 metres of wood before you (or I) decide that it needs sharpening because us ham fisted humans suffer an affliction known as 'muscle fatigue' which tells us that when the plane is too hard to push, it's time to stop and sharpen the blade.

The largest single surface I've ever planed myself was 2.4m x 1m, and that was well behaved and not too hard beech. I did it without needed to sharpen up the blade, because even if I planed every square millimetre twice, it's still only 100 lineal metres of planing, based on a shaving width of 5 cm. The blade isn't anything spectacular, but it's decent at least.

Simply put, 200 lineal metres equals A LOT of wood and a mountain of shavings. I'd bet that few folks who care about this kind of thing are actually going to heap such abuse on their blades, and are equally unlikely to need to remove such divots from their blades.

I'd also think that the higher planing speeds of a human being pushing/pulling the plane likely change what's happening, but not by so much that we need to remove craters from our blades.

Just to keep things in perspective is all.

But I might be wrong...

Stu.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#35

Re: Some perspective...

david weaver

My point exactly. Too much discussion of how to solve the problem in the picture when we don't have any proof that such deep wear exists on any iron used in a hand plane. I haven't had trouble polishing the wear off, so i'm inclined to side with the assumption that our planing will rarely rarely create that level of wear - which would require a close set chipbreaker and a thick bulling shaving relative to the set.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#36

Re: The Kato wear study

Marhk

Thanks to all !

Entirely an interesting discussion. Angels, heads of pins, etc..

But, what is actually happening when we sharpen and how that blade wears over repeated sharpenings is surely worth looking at. I agree this machine-driven data is the extreme but is probably relevant to some degree to hand planing. That's why we are all talking about it in the first place.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#37

question

Bill Tindall

what is the perceived problem of leaving some hollowed place on the blade back? The shaving wear has left this area polished so there is no problem creating a sharp edge. Granted, the rake angle will change a tiny amount but I don't see that as anything to worry about.

You are not going to plane 600' before sharpening so the amounts of metal to be removed are likely much less that you are concluding from the Kato and Kawai data.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#38

Re: Some perspective...

Kees

Yes, like you two say, I don't think we realy have a problem to solve. Sharpening the iron isn't much of an issue after using the capiron to good effect. It might take a bit more time, hard to say because it is rather subjective.

Anyway, compared to the huge gains the capiron delivers, a bit more time on the sharpening stone isn't such a bad deal.