New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

The Kato wear study *LINK*

Posts

The Kato wear study *LINK*

#1

The Kato wear study *LINK*

Kees

During the long traintrips between home and work I have been thinking a bit about the Kato study to wear, as has been published recently on Steve Elliott's site.

http://planetuning.infillplane.com/html/review_of_cap_iron_study.htmlWhen I first read that piece I didn't really understand it much. I think I have gained a little bit of understanding now. I am very curious to the thoughts of others.

There are two parts. The first about what kind of wear was observed when planing with or without capiron over a distance of 200 meters. The second part is about what influence the grain direction has on the wear pattern.

The first part has an interesting graph. The researchers had two force sensors in the setup to meassure horizontal and vertical force.


The line with little crosses is without capiron. The closed figures are with the capiron 0.2mm from the edge. The open figures 0.1 from the edge. The circles are with a capiron with 40 degree frontbevel. Triangles is 50 degrees and squares is 60 degrees.

When we look at the horizontal force, we can say that this represents the wear off the edge. The starting point of each capiron configuration isn't the same, this represents how strongly the shaving is deflected. Deflection costs energy of course. During the 200 meter planing session we see how the force increasses almost linear. All curves run almost parallel, but there is a bit of a difference. I calculated how much the force increased during this planing session.

no capiron______: 0.52 kgf

40 degree, 0.2mm: 0.31 kgf

50 degree, 0.2mm: 0.42 kgf

60 degree, 0.2mm: 0.47 kgf

40 degree, 0.1mm: 0.57 kgf

50 degree, 0.1mm: 0.52 kgf

60 degree, 0.1mm: 0.31 kgf

As you can see, they are close together, but the capiron numbers tend to be a little bit better then the no-capiron number.

When we look at the vertical force, we see how the force is first negative, but later, when the wear on the bevelside of the iron becomes larger then the relief angle, the force becomes positive. In other words, first the blade is pulled into the wood, later it is pushed out of the wood. When the blade isn't pulled into the wood any longer, planing becomes much more cumbersome.

The zeroline is crossed after about 90 meter when no capiron is fitted. The result is much better with the capiron at 0.2 mm or with the capiron 0.1mm with the 40 degree bevel. It is worse with the capiron at 0.1mm and a bevel of 50 or 60 degrees.

We could conclude from this graph that the capiron effect doesn't increase the wear as the user feels it, in fact it is slighty better overall. In the vertical graph we can see that the capiron lets the blade pulling into the wood longer, as long as the capiron effect isn't too strong for the type of wood at hand.

All very nice, but there is no free lunch!


The first graph of the paper describes the wear pattern. How does the wear look like and how deep is it?


Here we see how the capiron causes deeper, but a little shorter wear on the faceside of the blade then the situation without capiron. I roughly calculated the multiplication of depth and length of the wear spot.

no capiron______: 250um2

40 degree, 0.2mm: 550um2

50 degree, 0.2mm: 600um2

60 degree, 0.2mm: 600um2

40 degree, 0.1mm: 490um2

50 degree, 0.1mm: 510um2

60 degree, 0.1mm: 400um2

So we can see, when the wear as meassured by the force, is positively influenced by the capiron, the wear pattern on the face of the blade is actually worse. More metal is being removed during planing. This is I think the self sharpening effect Kato is writing about. The wear is worse when you look at the blade, but because of the shape of the wearspot, it keeps the blade sharp. Of course this is going to haunt us when we must resharpen the blade. We must remove more metal to get a perfect edge again.

Of course all these numbers are not absolute. The second part of the article describes the influence of the grain direction of the wood on the wear patterns. this effect is huge, so each piece of wood will behave differently. But I suppose the relative effect will be the same.

Another conclusion. Just looking at the edge with a microscope isn't going to tell us much about how bad the wear of the blade influences the planing force. The selfsharpening effect makes that impossible.

I am very curious if somebody still understands what the heck I am talking about, and what your ideas are about this paper.


Kato study

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#2

Re: The Kato wear study

Bill Tindall

good job. the vertical force data were most provocative

when resharpening the "hollow grind" from the shaving wear does not have to be removed, but the flat on the blade bottom does need to be removed. the hollow means less material to remove to get the bottom flat removed, at the expense of slightly increasing the bevel angle

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#3

Chris Scholz

Re: The Kato wear study

Chris Scholz

The first thing that comes to mind when looking at the graph that shows the evolution of the vertical force P_v over planing distance is that you don't need to push the plane down as long as the iron is sharp. Just push the plane forward (i.e. provide P_h plus the force to overcome friction from the plane body) Physics will take care of the rest and pull the blade into the wood. How cool is that?

This also means that all the pretty super heavy solid bronze sided infill planes that are all the rage...snake-oil. If you need that kind of plane your blade is dull! (Of course "need" can be defined in non-technical terms).

Are these results real, in tune with your own observation?

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#4

Re: The Kato wear study

Kees

That's a very sharp observation Bill! I didn't think about that. It's kind of like a Japanese plane iron with the hollow back, just on a tiny scale.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#5

Re: The Kato wear study

Kees

Yes that vertical force pulling the blade down into the wood is very real. You can feel it better with a wooden smoother. Somehow I have now the feeling that I can surf the plane on the wood. Ride the bevel, so to speak. Reminds me of my wide powderboards after a snowstorm in the Swiss Alps. :D

I can't really say if the blade stays sharp for longer when I use the capiron effect. That's a very subjective thing of course. I certainly don't have the impression the sharpness is leaving me any sooner then in the past.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#6

Re: The Kato wear study

david weaver

Two parts -

1) one of the first mistakes amateurs probably make with metal planes is that when they want to take a heavier cut, they push down hard on the plane instead of forward into the cut, increasing friction.

2) infill planes and heavy planes aren't snake oil in woods where a lighter plane is a rough ride, especially if you're doing something fairly coarse.

I don't understand the huge sentiment lately on here of various folks to find something that is generally accepted as good quality and try to bust it down. Chris, I know you weren't involved in the other things, but there seems to be a pattern lately of huckster accusations, but I don't get the sense that the accusations come from much familiarity with the criticized goods, or better yet much experience in using them in the trenches.

I will work large panels sometimes in a heavy cut with a wooden plane. And sometimes I will pull out a panel plane that is almost 9 pounds to do the same. Same depth of cut, the panel plane is easier to be more accurate and much smoother in the heavy cut. It's like a vacation.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#7

Re: The Kato wear study

Marhk

Perhaps someone could take this a practical step further and discuss the implications of re-sharpening this blade. During sharpening the bevel is ground on successive stones and the flat side (I call this the back) is finished on the finest stone. If no ruler trick is used then from these photos the actual cutting edge may not be touched by the stone - just the burr is bent off. Using a ruler trick successively seems to lead to the same effect- but this is harder to visualize. So, several questions: Does this mean that the entire scooped-out area has to be removed when the bevel is sharpened? How else can the geometry of 2 intersecting planes be reestablished - unless of course the entire flat side is refinished each time. I wonder if this effect explains enthusiasm for bevel-up planes? The near lack of development of this scooped out area with a BU plane (and the fact that it now occurs on the bevel side) makes them easier to sharpen? What we really need is a series of electron micrographs of a blade tip and cap iron showing wear after use AND after successive sharpenings. The evolution of the blade tip and especially our carefully prepared backs (flat side) would be interesting.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#8

Re: The Kato wear study

david weaver

There really aren't any implications - the wear that occurs in this case over 200 meters of planing is only a couple of microns deep and perhaps 90 microns back from the edge (90 is in the range of about 4 thousandths). If the depth of the wear at an extreme amount of planing (200 meters of a 4 thousandths shaving is a lot) is 8 microns, then it's in the range of 4 ten thousandths of an inch, give or take one.

You still do the same thing, polish the back with a polish stone (however you'd like to do it)until the polish goes to the edge, and hone and polish the bevel side of the iron. I haven't actually noticed any issue because the depth of the hollow is maybe a bit overemphasized by the picture.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#9

Re: The Kato wear study

Kees

My feeling too. The wearbevel seems to be a bit more visual. You can clearly see a light line along the edge on the face side. But it's no trouble to remove it on the 8000 stone. And as Bill wrote, a bit of a hollow in the face doesn't really matter.

We shouldn't forget, the single iron plane in this study has a bedding angle of 40 degrees. That isn't an angle we would choose to fight tearout. Against tearout a 55 degree Single iron plane is more usefull. Such steep pitches have defenitely a faster wear rate. And we don't know whether these have a self sharpening effect like the double iron planes.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#10

Re: The Kato wear study

Kees

The self sharpening has another funny effect. When planing against the grain the wear is less then planing with the grain! This is all documented in the 2nd part of the study. To be honest the implications of that second part are still far from clear to me.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#11

Re: The Kato wear study

david weaver

I noticed that, too, when bill was passing the docs around initially, I think I noticed it because bill told me about it.

Against the grain is less wear, but it does make some sense, I suppose, at least that the length of the wear bevel might be a little bit less.

I have noticed one thing, the obvious - the wear bevel stops at the cap iron, as opposed to seeing a series of small lines of wear on an un-capped iron.

The self sharpening effect is probably what we notice (maybe you have noticed, too) in that as the iron is dulling, the surface still seems to stay nice, as long as the iron isn't defective and chippy. i don't know what this is attributed to in reality, though, whether it's self sharpening, or whether it's just the cap iron affording the ability to continue to smooth something nicely with an iron that is less sharp. I notice lack of sharpness more in my single iron planes, but by how much, I don't know, because I rarely drive those to the point that they don't cut, especially if they are used for finish work.

I think a lot of the wear principles are more applicable to machine work where running for more linear feet is something someone would notice in a production environment. I'm pleased that the effect in the end is that you can carry on sharpening as you always would, and there's no real "penalty" to the extra wear depth.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#12

Re: The Kato wear study

Marhk

From the paper table 1: Maybe my math is wrong, but at the extreme of Tw = 100 microns (4 thou) then T eta (depth of scooped area) is about 13 microns (½ thou). So in order to reach the goal of 2 intersecting flat planes either ½ thou from the flat side or 4 thou from the bevel side has to be removed.

I wonder, when we polish the flat back are we removing ½ thou? Perhaps.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#13

Re: The Kato wear study

david weaver

I suppose I was looking at somehwere around 8 microns being the wear, but we're in the same ballpark. I probably should've read the chart closer.

I don't know if we see this much wear on our plane irons, because we don't generally smooth with 200 meters worth of 4 thousandth shavings.

But if we do see this much wear, we must be removing it. I'd be curious about how much iron length is removed each time an iron is sharpened, but I guess I've never been curious enough to actually figure it out.

One thing that I'm careful to do (and I'm sure others have gotten to this) is to apply my finger pressure very close to the edge when lapping the wear out of the back on a polish stone. If for no other reason, then just because I want to do as little work as possible and polish the part that isn't shiny. So if we're taking off 1/2 of a thousandth there even in the heaviest used scenario, it's likely that we're just putting a very gradual bevel over a length of the back that might be 1/2 inch, and we chase that up the iron as we go. It never will outpace what we remove from the bevel, though, or we'd see thin short older plane irons with their laminations worn through.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#14

Removing wear from the blade back

Steve Elliott

"I wonder, when we polish the flat back are we removing ½ thou? Perhaps."

When I was testing plane blades I polished the backs of quite a number of them and sometimes kept track of how much I removed using a micrometer. (It was such a slow task I wanted to see some sign of progress.) I'd say that the amount of polishing done on the flat side of a blade during ordinary sharpening is not more than one ten thousandth of an inch (2.5 micons). That's on a plane blade, not a 1/4" chisel or something, and not lifting the back of the blade either using a ruler or just by eye. This means that often wear is left on the flat side of the blade unless the bevel is worked quite a bit.

One of the reasons stropping has advocates is that it dubs the edge a little and polishes the cutting edge even though the entire worn area has not been removed. It's like the ruler trick in that it concentrates polishing right at the edge. I don't like the fact that stropping gradually makes the blade back less and less flat.

The bevel can be ground, which removes steel much more quickly. On a blade with a carefully polished flat back, I prefer to leave the back almost untouched and shorten the blade by a couple of thousandths by working the bevel until the worn area is gone. Then I put the back on a fine stone for a few strokes to remove any possible wire edge.

My standard sharpening now includes a back bevel of a couple of degrees for just these reasons. The back bevel is kept so narrow (1/64” or less) that I can remove it if I want to go back to a flat back, but for sharpening quickly the narrow back bevel is a big advantage.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#15

Re: Removing wear from the blade back

Marhk

So, if you use a ruler trick (aka; back bevel) you may well be removing the trigonometric equivalent of ½ thou and if you keep it short as Charlesworth notes then it is removed with each bevel sharpening - - - IF - enough metal is removed from the bevel. I don't think polishing a micro-bevel is enough to remove the ruler trick back bevel. So the back bevel will grow until the blade is reground. It is interesting that I'm starting to go back to a no-jig technique that I learned years ago. I have been watching the Sellers convex edge method, which does seems to work for me. A feature of this method that is not emphasized enough is that he always starts at a coarse diamond stone and thus removes more metal than the micro-bevel techniques. So, I wonder if the dubbing (back bevel) from the stropping isn't mostly removed by this more aggressive action.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#16

Re: Removing wear from the blade back

david weaver

I think you'll find with the sellers technique that you don't remove length of an iron any faster. He does, though, work the back with a medium diamond stone (well, medium in terms of other stones - the diamond folks call it fine or something).

You're replacing a grinder with the coarse stones, but I think in reality you'll find that you don't work off too much length of a chisel that way, because it's extra work and you'll tend toward doing enough to make a tool sharp and no more as you've used the method for a while (that is most efficient, after all).

One thing that has changed for me over the years, is that on the polishing stone, I give a lot more attention to the back of an iron than I ever did when I had first started. I leave the back flat, but I put finger pressure right at the edge and I intentionally lap the back for about 20 seconds uninterrupted. That's probably 3 or 4 times more work than I ever did before. I do that until i can't see any wear on the back of an iron.

I believe iterations of this comment have been made several times, and I've seen joel moskowitz mention (i hope I get this right) that japanese craftsmen he's talked to have said that they think the biggest mistake people make sharpening is not spending enough time on a polish stone.

On the backs of irons, I think that's clearly true.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#17

Re: Removing wear from the blade back

Steve Elliott

"I don't think polishing a micro-bevel is enough to remove the ruler trick back bevel."

Honing the bevel isn't intended to remove the back bevel with every sharpening. I hone the bevel enough to remove wear from the bevel and hone the back bevel to remove wear from the back of the blade. By keeping the back bevel very narrow the amount of honing needed to remove wear from the back is kept to a minimum.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#18

Re: The Kato wear study

Kees

Indeed it seems like I can continue working with a not so sharp iron. I still prefer to sharpen often,but laziness often gets the better of me.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#19

Re: Removing wear from the blade back

Marhk

It would seem that the back bevel would slowly grow if your not removing it each time (or it has to get steeper). At some point you, I guess, need to do enough grinding to get the back to flat again (which is part of the microbevel sharpening technique). I'm trying to do it all by hand - no grinding. No risk of softening a blade - different approach.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#20

what's to sharpen?

bill tindall

The wood polishes the top of the blade as well as any stone. The fact that it is concave to the tune of a few microns matters little. There are still two intersecting planes, just at slightly different angles. In other papers Kato and Kawai report good surface finish at 200 meters of planing.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#21

Re: The Kato wear study

bill tindall

Higher rake angles are studied in another paper

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#22

Re: Removing wear from the blade back

Steve Elliott

I've been using my method for a number of years and have been through many cycles of grinding and honing. The back bevel tends to get a little wider between grindings, just like the final microbevel on the bevel side of the blade. I grind all the way to the edge on most blades, and then re-establish a small bevel at the cutting edge. When that is done the back bevel is usually reduced in width but not eliminated.

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#23

Re: what's to sharpen?

Marhk

OK, that explains the durability in use of a sharpened edge - but, the geometry of sharpening is what I'm trying to get at. How do you explain that?

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#24

Re: what's to sharpen?

bill tindall

i don't understand what the question is?

Re: The Kato wear study *LINK*

#25

Re: what's to sharpen?

Marhk

Sorry for being so dense - as you noted the study data supports an in use sharpening effect which prolongs the effective sharpness. But, as I noted before in this discussion, I can't see how the blade can be resharpened with the same geometry unless the entire scooped-out area is totally removed either from the bevel side (potentially 4 thou) or the flat side (potentially ½ thou) — OR, unless the flat back is sharpened with a back bevel. If the back bevel method is used then it seems to me that you have the growing back bevel problem.