The Kato wear study *LINK*
Kees
During the long traintrips between home and work I have been thinking a bit about the Kato study to wear, as has been published recently on Steve Elliott's site.
http://planetuning.infillplane.com/html/review_of_cap_iron_study.htmlWhen I first read that piece I didn't really understand it much. I think I have gained a little bit of understanding now. I am very curious to the thoughts of others.
There are two parts. The first about what kind of wear was observed when planing with or without capiron over a distance of 200 meters. The second part is about what influence the grain direction has on the wear pattern.
The first part has an interesting graph. The researchers had two force sensors in the setup to meassure horizontal and vertical force.

The line with little crosses is without capiron. The closed figures are with the capiron 0.2mm from the edge. The open figures 0.1 from the edge. The circles are with a capiron with 40 degree frontbevel. Triangles is 50 degrees and squares is 60 degrees.
When we look at the horizontal force, we can say that this represents the wear off the edge. The starting point of each capiron configuration isn't the same, this represents how strongly the shaving is deflected. Deflection costs energy of course. During the 200 meter planing session we see how the force increasses almost linear. All curves run almost parallel, but there is a bit of a difference. I calculated how much the force increased during this planing session.
no capiron______: 0.52 kgf
40 degree, 0.2mm: 0.31 kgf
50 degree, 0.2mm: 0.42 kgf
60 degree, 0.2mm: 0.47 kgf
40 degree, 0.1mm: 0.57 kgf
50 degree, 0.1mm: 0.52 kgf
60 degree, 0.1mm: 0.31 kgf
As you can see, they are close together, but the capiron numbers tend to be a little bit better then the no-capiron number.
When we look at the vertical force, we see how the force is first negative, but later, when the wear on the bevelside of the iron becomes larger then the relief angle, the force becomes positive. In other words, first the blade is pulled into the wood, later it is pushed out of the wood. When the blade isn't pulled into the wood any longer, planing becomes much more cumbersome.
The zeroline is crossed after about 90 meter when no capiron is fitted. The result is much better with the capiron at 0.2 mm or with the capiron 0.1mm with the 40 degree bevel. It is worse with the capiron at 0.1mm and a bevel of 50 or 60 degrees.
We could conclude from this graph that the capiron effect doesn't increase the wear as the user feels it, in fact it is slighty better overall. In the vertical graph we can see that the capiron lets the blade pulling into the wood longer, as long as the capiron effect isn't too strong for the type of wood at hand.
All very nice, but there is no free lunch!
The first graph of the paper describes the wear pattern. How does the wear look like and how deep is it?
Here we see how the capiron causes deeper, but a little shorter wear on the faceside of the blade then the situation without capiron. I roughly calculated the multiplication of depth and length of the wear spot.
no capiron______: 250um2
40 degree, 0.2mm: 550um2
50 degree, 0.2mm: 600um2
60 degree, 0.2mm: 600um2
40 degree, 0.1mm: 490um2
50 degree, 0.1mm: 510um2
60 degree, 0.1mm: 400um2
So we can see, when the wear as meassured by the force, is positively influenced by the capiron, the wear pattern on the face of the blade is actually worse. More metal is being removed during planing. This is I think the self sharpening effect Kato is writing about. The wear is worse when you look at the blade, but because of the shape of the wearspot, it keeps the blade sharp. Of course this is going to haunt us when we must resharpen the blade. We must remove more metal to get a perfect edge again.
Of course all these numbers are not absolute. The second part of the article describes the influence of the grain direction of the wood on the wear patterns. this effect is huge, so each piece of wood will behave differently. But I suppose the relative effect will be the same.
Another conclusion. Just looking at the edge with a microscope isn't going to tell us much about how bad the wear of the blade influences the planing force. The selfsharpening effect makes that impossible.
I am very curious if somebody still understands what the heck I am talking about, and what your ideas are about this paper.
Kato study




