New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

Posts

Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#1

Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

James Watriss

Peter Follansbee just put up a link to a video that he shot at L-N, showing how to chop mortises.

I was impressed, and felt like sharing.


Follansbee's blog

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#2

Re: Awesome video on mortising

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks James!

I like the method of starting with a deep V in the center, and using a long thin bevel on the mortise chisel to get to depth quickly.

Excellent video!!

Wiley

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#3

your going to hate me for this *LINK*

Mark Hennebury




Mortise video

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#4

Re: your going to hate me for this

cstan

Bitchin'

Cleanest mortise I've ever seen.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Excellent video

Jack Guzman from Maine

That is a great teaching aid. For someone just learning to chop mortises that video would be a great help. I got something from it and I have chopped alot of mortises.

That old saying "a picture is worth a thousand words" has taken on new meaning since the onset of woodworking videos.---Jack

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#6

Nothing Awesome about it at all!

Mark Hennebury

Everything isnt awesome.

It isn't awesome just because someone made a video of it.

Are we in kindergarten where everyone gets a star so they wont feel bad.

Surely to rate being awesome, it should be something special, above average, better than we are used to seeing.

There was nothing special about the way he cut the mortice, it in fact was pretty bad.

He didn't cut a full V instead it was flat bottomed and he used his chisel like a crowbar to lever the middle out, which is bad for chisel tip and can break it. Using the top ends of the mortise as a fulcrum crushes the wood. He didnt even have straight, square or parallel ends to the mortise. The mortise was pretty sloppy.

So, it doesnt rate an awesome, nor a great, not even a good. the most that you could say and be honest is: its a video of a guy chopping a mortise, with a piece of glass on the side so that you can see what he's doing.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#7

I would be impressed...

John in NM

If I didn't already know how those were cut :D

They're certainly the best machines ever made for the job, and I would own one if I could, but you're comparing apples and oranges. Poorly grown apples perhaps, but the mechanized, fertilized oranges don't make them look any worse than they would on their own.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#8

New ripping tool

Ron in Kokomo

I understand they even have a new tool for ripping. Some kind of round blade in a table, powered by a motor? I hear it even has a fence to keep the cut straight.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#9

Re: Prying

TomD

He kept talking about prying. For the most part though, I would call that mortise cut, a word he also used. If the wood is cut out, lifting the chips free with the chisel is not my idea of prying. Even splitting wood out is not really prying, if all the fibers have been cut. He did drag the edge more than I would, but on the whole he cut it.

When one sees confused amateurs at it, they over hammer the chisel and pry it to effect the "cut", to cut through or tear out the fibers. Or they start out cutting, but run out of geometry and just start a cascade of bad things happening.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#10

Re: Nothing Awesome about it at all!

TomD

Your problem Mark, might be that you do not have a program, and as such are not in possession of the team roster, or know who the home team is, or the start players.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#11

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Nothing Awesome about it at all!

Jack Guzman from Maine

Mark,

It is awesome to me because It shows how do do something rather than explain the process in writing,which was all that was available before now. It is a leap ahead in teaching. It reminds me of the first time I saw an ant farm. You can actually see what happens inside the wood.---Jack

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#12

Re: The prying part..

david weaver

I don't know what chisels he uses, but I have three sets of mortising chisels. A2 chisels, D2 chisels and some blue steel chisels.

I have never pried on the blue steel chisels, but the amount of prying he did would never touch the D2 chisels. They can be pulled 4 times on a polish stone after each mortise and never need anything else.

I don't know what's awesome or not, that's for other people to determine. If I were a beginner, I would probably appreciate that video more. As it is here, I've cut mortises before, so it's sort of like watching the neighbor mow the lawn.

If it encourages people to work wood, that's awesome. A lot of us here don't really have any interest in machines, it's not what we do for a living or we don't find machine setup and use interesting. The only machine I find remotely interesting that doesn't carry a martin name is a simple band saw.

Well, I don't mind a ported chainsaw, either.

Of all of the instructors around, I like peter a lot. I'll probably never make anything like peter makes (with green wood or in that style) but I appreciate that the bug that peter appears to have is the woodworking bug and not the huckster bug like a lot of the "instructors" do. (and I don't include our david charlesworth in that group, I have a lot of respect for david).

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#13

Re: your going to hate me for this

joel moskowitz

I would hate you for it except that everytime one compares late 18th century production times to a modern cabinetmaker using modern electric tools you find that the 18th century cabinemaker could more than keep up, and in most cases was a little faster. The reasons are pretty complex but with a little practice chopping a mortise by hand is very very fast. Machines like yours are really cool in a production environment, but at the same token it's why furniture today is so homogenized. IF you have the capital to get lots of really tech machines you can make cookie cutter furniture very efficiently. If on the other hand you do one-offs it is so much faster, and so much easier, and requires so little capital to just chop the mortise.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#14

Re: your going to hate me for this

Mark Hennebury

I posted the video to show what to me is an awesome mortise video: that is something above and beyond normal, a level of speed accuracy and precision to aspire to.

I have been using these machine for twenty years, and they still blow me away.

I wish that i could cut mortises that clean and accurate by hand and have tried, a lot.

I worked for many years exclusively with hand tools and I am quite familiar with cutting mortises by hand, and occasionally still do, if I have only one or two to do.

If on the other hand I was making a dining room table and chairs, you would be into hundreds of mortises, and there is no way that you can compete with that machine, not in speed , not in accuracy, not in cleanliness of cut.

So it is at that point we diverge, I see no reason to cut them by hand, taking a longer time, a lot more effort and ending up with a lower quality job, for what purpose? If its a hobby and you just want to try it fine, I enjoy handtool work myself, though It would seem that that is more about how it makes me feel then about getting the job done.

In terms of capital cost, if your time is worth nothing them cut everything by hand, to whatever extreme you want to take that. If you are a studio furniture maker with a family and mortgage, it would make sense to do the best work as fast and efficiently as possible. Someone has to pay for how long you take to build a piece, either your family or your customer.

I was a studio furniture maker for most of my life, I never did any production work or "cookie cutter" furniture.

I did a lot of mortise and tenon work, clean , precise tight fitting mortises made on a wide range of machines, which gave me more time to concentrate on other operations.

Machines are just tools to be used to achieve a goal... well made furniture.

So I would disagree with you, it is not easier, faster or cheaper to cut mortises by hand and it certainly isn't better. But it can be enjoyable to a degree.

Furniture is not well made just because someone made it by "hand" and it is not poorly made because someone used machines. It is either well made or not, regardless of what method used.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#15

Re: your going to hate me for this

joel moskowitz

Mark,

I studied with Maurice Frasier, and if I could not cut a series of through mortises as least as clean as your machine in hardwood (and matching piston fit tenons) I would have to do it over. I won't tell you how many do overs I did. But once I learned it's not a big deal, it's mostly about paying attention and accurate layout (he taught the same technique Moxon describes). When I am practiced up under two minutes a mortise is a reasonable pace.

I wasn't kidding about the 18th century speeds. If you do custom work doing it by hand in many cases is a lot faster and certainly less expensive in total outlay, but you need good training and practice. If I want to duplicate a factory your machine would be perfect. Heck, Stickley used chain mortisers for everything - nothing wrong with that.

For normal professional woodworkers, wanting to do lots of production work a biscuit joiner or a domino is a far more appropriate tool.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#16

That's a pretty snazzy machine, BUT...

Bruce, a MN Galoot

The cost of that one machine alone is more than all the machines and tools in my shop combined, including my 1981 Goldwing (which I include because it occupies more than half of my shop space). So, I could either swap everything in my shop plus raid my retirement funds to get a machine to make mortises in wood I could no longer afford to buy, OR I could learn to use my cheap but effective Narex mortising chisels better.

It really is that simple.

Awesome skills work much better for me than awesome machines. Because of the recent discussions on cap irons, inter alia, I can continue using my existing tool set and amp up my skill set. Works for me. That's what this forum is all about.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#17

Ellis didnt send me the program

Mark Hennebury

This way I am just commenting on the work.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#18

Sure it is...

John in NM

I generally don't use the term "awesome" myself, however I do think it is a good video - if for no other reason than it clearly illustrates what it intends to illustrate, and will likely get more than a few people to try it. Nothing mystical about chopping a mortise, but it still seems to intimidate a lot of people, though perhaps not so much as dovetails seem to do.

The other thing I like about that vid, is I was not distracted by the usual huge number of "ummms" and "uhhhs" in the commentary. Whatever criticism of the mortising technique may be appropriate, I will give the video an A+ for production values when sooooo many others strike me as amatuerish and in need of heavy editing.

I was really expecting a pretty bad video from your commentary, but was in fact pleasantly surprised. I didn't find the prying action to be excessive personally, but then I'm no expert. If I may be completely honest, I think there is a bit of finding fault with the video simply because you don't care for the enthusiastic description of it. No need to take the jam out of all our donuts.

I'll definitely give ya credit though, you got me to go watch the video, which normally I don't do :D

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#19

What's the name of ths message board?


Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#20

Re: Awesome video on mortising

Brian Anderson Gunsmith

While this video was clearly superior as a teaching tool, I don't think the term "awesome" is useful.

I think the term "awesome" is dramatically overused.

I wonder if a complete rookie mortise chopper could make a mortise just by watching this video.

(I think one would have to be shown how to lay it out first.)

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#21

don't get too worked up about the use of "awesome"

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I think it's a generational thing. Mr. Watriss appears to be about the same age as my kids, and they use "awesome" in pretty much the same way. In my frame of reference, awesome only refers to things like the Grand Canyon or the redwood forest.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#22

Dude... Mr. Watriss is my Father...

James Watriss

I'm 38. I grew up (if you can call it that) just north of Boston, 'Awesome,' is pretty frequently and casually used. And I figured 'wicked pissa' would be lost on most of you.

Why did I like the video so much? Because the prying part is actually pretty minimal. Starting in the center the way he does makes more sense than most of the other methods I've seen and tried. And by chopping off short-grain chunks as he does, the bulk of the structural connection to the rest of the wood is eliminated. So the prying action has more of a scooping function than anything else, and he's actually minimizing abuse to the tool.

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#23

Re: Dude... Mr. Watriss is my Father...

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks James! My thoughts exactly. The big problem in mortising is to create a place for the waste to go. The center-V method immediately creates clearance for the waste all the way to the bottom, and as you say, when the end grain is shaved off in 1/8" vertical slices, it has no holding strength and can be virtually 'scooped' out.

In the 'typewriter method", you have to create new waste clearance as you start each new horizontal course.

I thought it was a wicked pissa too, because you can see what's happening in the wood (as everyone else has already said).

Wiley

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#24

So you don't find it awe inducing.

AlanWS

Goals differ. Follansbee is as much a historian as woodworker, and is interested in replicating the methods and results of earlier workers. His video very clearly shows how he chops mortises. You can ask him exactly when the techniques shown were common.

One of the things he demonstrates is that some of the expectation of the appearance of a mortise for example, is completely unnecessary for the unglued drawbored joinery he demonstrates, and comes from machining methods that are useful in their place but not in his work. For your work his mortise may be poor, but that does not mean it's not an excellent mortise for its intended purpose. (No, I don't know the intended role of this particular mortise, and I'm not claiming that a drawbored M&T joint is as strong as a perfectly fit glued one.)

Re: Awesome video on mortising *LINK*

#25

Re: Dude... Mr. Watriss is my Father...

Mike L.

Sheesh James, first you use the word "awesome" without prior approval and now you've included a questionable use of the word "dude." Ellis/Bill, prepare the gallows!

p.s. Thanks for posting the vid. I enjoyed it immensely (oops, I hope the word police don't get me for that).