New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

Posts

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#26

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

CStan

I have no idea. I thought that's what you were hinting at. If there are any specs, I'm quite sure I can hit them using western tools and generally with a lot less hooray and who shot John than otherwise seems to be involved whenever Japanese tools and Japanese woodworking come up.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#27

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

CStan

Really? You sure about that?

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#28

Re: Breaker pardigm

CStan

Oh gracious me, somewhere in some post recently I predicted all of this - the total overcomplication of it all.

Now it's a selection of four (is it?) mutually exclusive 'paradigms.'

Oy, vey.

Can a chipbreaker setting jig be too far behind? I think not.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#29

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

david weaver

I'm no more sure about anything than you are, but David did pop in on the SMC thread about using the cap iron to mitigate tearout and said he was wrong about it for X years (fill in the blank, I don't know how many years he was talking about).

Take from that what you'd like.

I do think the idea of rounding the corners of one as a visual reference for camber of the iron itself has more functionality than rounding it to break chips at the corners.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#30

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

Jerry Murrey

Many thanks to all of you that took the time to respond to my question. Some answers made me realize that I should have spent more time with how I phrased the question. Based on the positive responses from those that had actually introduced a parallel camber on the chipbreaker, I believe I will try this on smoothers with slight camber intended for flat-panel work. Using the eclipse jig for cambering the breaker as with a blade sounds good to me. (Thanks Mr. Charlesworth) FYI - I have been shooting for a blade exposure of about 1/64" (approx. 0.4 mm) and a gradual camber that approximately 2-3 thosands at the edges (see some light under a straighedge).

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#31

Re: I just round the corners

Gary Roberts

Yup on rounding. A Greek architectural cabinetmaker I worked for around 30 years ago showed me the Secret of the Cap Iron. After cleaning the edge on a sharpening stone, wipe the upper side to remove any burr, which left a hair thin line (what some people are now calling a microbevel). Since there was no need to be careful of any angle, it was really a very slight rounding of the cap iron edge but so slight no shaving would ever catch on it and no shaving ever did.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#32

Re: Breaker pardigm

TomD

"Oh gracious me, somewhere in some post recently I predicted all of this - the total overcomplication of it all.

Now it's a selection of four (is it?) mutually exclusive 'paradigms.'"

1) three of them seem to be on a continuum, with the stiffening on being tosh, which I always thought it was, or at least less useful as a paradigm. People aren't really discussing this, so it hasn't fouled the waters yet. It is just my contention that there may be a continuum. I put that out there so that people won't dimis the other methods.

2) All this stuff was always around, so there isn't anything new about it. Do you remember that uncomplicated time of your childhood? It was all there then. Life goes on.

3) It's only complicated if you find it so. Some people might not have the capacity to sort all this out in their feeble brains. But in your case I think you are not having any trouble with it at all, you just like to rage against the complexity. The complexity is a sideshow. It's woodworking, you just get rid of any wood you don't need, it's a pretty simple black and white process.

"Oy, vey.

Can a chipbreaker setting jig be too far behind? I think not."

Well I have already laid claim to various forms of mechanically adjustable chip breaker, but a jig is a good idea, you may end up rich.