New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Fast and affordable laser cutting – so you can make the parts you can’t find anywhere else

Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

Posts

Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#1

Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

Jerry Murrey

Been following the chipbreaker discussion with great interest and have done some experimenting with setting the breaker close as possible to the blade edge - I like what I'm seeing. Assuming that the blade is sharpened straight across for a plane for jointing edges, the close setting appears straightforward.

Now my question deals with blades sharpened with a very slight camber, as I try to do for the blades used in the planes I use for smoothing. The camber will prevent the center from being a close as I might like as the breaker appears to get dangerously close to the edge. Has anyone tried to introduce a parallel (?) camber on the chipbreaker when modifying (tuning) it for better performance?

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#2

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

david weaver

You shouldn't have that much camber on a smoother iron, just a few thousandths. Even if your camber is, say, 4 or 5 thousandths, set your chipbreaker right at zero (or maybe even just the tiniest bit back) at the edges where the camber is, and the iron will protrude from the chipbreaker then in the middle exactly the amount of the camber. I think you'll find even this is too close.

If that's confusing because you have no iron projection at the corner, it's no worry because the camber is there to keep the corner from cutting to begin with.

The remainder of the protruding edge will take a cut of varying thickness, and where the shaving is thick, the cap iron will be farther from the edge.

It'll work just fine.

Every iron I have used so far after getting into this in the last couple of months has had at least some gradual camber on it.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#3

Ellis Walentine

My 2¢

Ellis Walentine

I generally try to keep my camber on smoothing planes to about .002" or less. What I've found so far in my not-too-clinical trials of the chipbreaker effect is that a difference of a couple thousandths in the setback isn't critical, so a straight-ground chipbreaker would perform effectively as well as a slightly rounded one. That said, a swat with a very fine mill file or stone would give you a matching camber. Assuming you use that particular plane with the same camber all the time, I would see no harm in matching the breaker to it.

Ellis

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#4

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

david weaver

By the way, don't try to produce variable camber on the chipbreaker - you have the chance of ruining something, and it's not necessary to begin with because you're assuming if you do that, that the shaving will be uniform thickness (to need to have an identical set from corner to corner), and it will not be - it will be thicker in the middle of the cut.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#5

Ellis Walentine

Aha! Of course. Good point.


Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#6

I just round the corners

James Watriss

On my smoothers I don't camber the whole thing, just the corners. It's easier to do, and it keeps the shaving flat, with tapering edges.

I keep the cambering for rougher work, where the chip breaker thing isn't such an issue.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#7

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

TomD

Keep in mind you need 44% more camber than cut on a 45 degree bedded plane.

I'm not all that fussed with camber on smoothing planes. Should be I guess, I have some work arounds. Certainly when I read Odates approach I felt a whole lot better about just putting that off as a detail I would get to fully later. Of course one has to do something to keep edges dead straight, so I am letting camber happen, but I haven`t gone all crazy on it.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#8

Re: Aha! Of course. Good point.

david weaver

Sorry about that, Ellis - I didn't know it would go directly opposite of your post - it all occurred at the same time.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#9

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

CStan

Put a profile on the chipbreaker and shape the cutter to fit.....easiest way to 'keep track' of the camber you like on the cutter.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#10

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

David Charlesworth

I have worked with cambered chipbreakers for years.

The curve is created in exactly the same way as the cambered edge on the blade. i.e. in an Eclipse type guide with the breaker set at 45 degrees.

I would not begin to claim that these curves were exactly the same, but it feels good to have gone some way towards addressing the issue!!

best wishes,

David Charlesworth

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#11

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

TomD

In theory. The problem Odate addressed was let's say you want a shaving of 3 tens, so you camber would be north of 4 tens, less than 1/2 thou spread over the width of the iron, if it was a plain curve. Then as David says your breaker needs to be a larger arc to accomodate for the fading cut size. And you have to not only arrive at this shape but polish it out perfectly through amazingly fine grits. I suppose at the lower ends you don't need a breaker. It isn't a trivial task.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#12

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

TomD

The question would be which breaker paradigm are you working with. We know in the case of some, maybe most Japanese chraftsmen that they were working with the tight set paradigm. I'm not sure Odate was though.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#13

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

CStan

Right on, brother.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#14

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

CStan

I guess I should have read this thread before I cambered my chipbreaker so I would have known how tough a job it is to do right. I think it took three or four minutes at the grinder and another couple of minutes with some 400 grit.

Toshio Odate would probably fire me on the first day before the first morning break on whatever temple building job we were working on.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#15

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

david weaver

You can do whatever you want, but if the wood looks the same either way, and you're trying to undercut the back of the chipbreaker to begin with, why would you want to run anything off the corners of it?

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#16

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

CStan

I mainly did it in order to be able to repeat the camber I wanted on the iron. I wasn't looking for any particular chipbreaker effect at the time to be perfectly honest. I needed the iron profile to be more or less the same as time went by. It made sense to me to profile the breaker that went with the iron rather than make some sort of template that needed to be dragged out constantly.

Otherwise, you question might be better put to David Charlesworth who apparently cambers his breakers as well. For once, it seems, I'm in good company and in a better neighborhood so to speak.

I never gave it another moment's thought until this thread came up.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#17

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

CStan

"Breaker paradigm?"

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#18

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

CStan

One of these days I'm going to make Shoji with my crappy old set of tools (and gettin' crappier by the hour) to see if all the bleedin' fuss is really necessary.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#19

Re: Breaker pardigm

TomD

ie, is the breaker there to break the chip, stabilize the blade, or set really close to hold the chip back. The first two don't require a close set, so the issues around fit don't mater. The no breaker plane doesn't need one. So in 3 out of 4 paradigms, the issues don't come up. In one, it's either going to be rough or maybe it will all work out fine because of David's claim.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#20

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

TomD

Well as Clinton would say "depends what you mean by "necesarry"".

If you plane pine with a good plane you can read a book in the reflection, and it looks like polished bone, and it is easier to clean. So if you want that business, you need to hand plane the finish. And the joinery has a right and wrong way. But if you ever look at what hits the windows of a lot of sushi places, yikes, see prettier packing crates.

The thing is that making nice stuff is about finding justifiable distinctions. These niceties may or may not be necessary, but they are observable. It is worth considering whether you're in the right game if you just want to dismiss them all out of hand. It's like being a lawyer, finding distinctions that create pain for your opponents is part of the job. If you just want to reduce everything to the lowest common denominator where nothing you say ads any value to your clients life, might be the wrong career. try taking an aw shucks guitar to a guitar show. The standard is incredibly high, as it could be in a juried show.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#21

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

CStan

Well, of course the point I was making is that technically correct Shoji can certainly be made with an average, decent set of Western hand tools. If you think otherwise, then your consumption of the Kool Aid is not in any doubt. The work could get done without all of the Eastern Mysticism and incense burning in the background.

It's the copping of the whole 'aura' from certain quarters that gets my goat. It would be like me faking a British accent when I was running a Record plane. What a hokie bunch 'o crap that would be don't you think?

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#22

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

david weaver

David hasn't used it to control tearout until very recently.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#23

And, anyway,

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Since the chipbreaker (at least the classic Stanley Bailey* chipbreaker) has only so much "length" as it curls down onto the cutting iron at the edge, if you try to camber the chipbreaker, you stand a chance of making a gap between breaker and cutting iron, something you don't want, as it will catch shavings.

*And Bailey clones by other makers after the patents expired.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#24

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

TomD

It's not the difficulty of cambering the breaker, it is the difficulty of maintaining the cambered blade that he addressed. Most people don't seem to have followed his lead, but any time you would like to prove your planes take a precisely tapering shaving from a max depth of 3 tens, I am sure someone will be interested in hearing about it.

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

#25

Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion

TomD

"Well, of course the point I was making is that technically correct Shoji can certainly be made with an average, decent set of Western hand tools. If you think otherwise, then your consumption of the Kool Aid is not in any doubt."

What is a technically correct shoji. Do you have a set of specifications, or do you simply mean you can make one that you will like. Most men like their wives, but they wouldn't get much money for them as runway models in Paris. The place where they use Shoji is in Japan, and if you want to spend time making them with hand tools you should get a standard from that exercise that is commensurate with the effort put in. You will fail if you don't finish to the expected standard, and the western kit of tools does not include several specialized tools designed for making the joints in the technically correct way.

"The work could get done without all of the Eastern Mysticism and incense burning in the background."

Could you kindly indicate where anything I said relied on eastern mysticism, or incense. I said you need to surface the wood to the expected level. That is just an obsevable fact that you can read in the reflection of hand planed pine.

"It's the copping of the whole 'aura' from certain quarters that gets my goat. It would be like me faking a British accent when I was running a Record plane. What a hokie bunch 'o crap that would be don't you think?"

BS, nobody is saying you have to fake it as a Japanese carpenter, I'm saying you have to make it to that standard. I've heard enough of your faking it already. Make the stuff, prepare and use the tools. Commit to something and get good at it, then put in 30 years.