Re: Question re Chipbreaker Discussion
TomD
"Well, of course the point I was making is that technically correct Shoji can certainly be made with an average, decent set of Western hand tools. If you think otherwise, then your consumption of the Kool Aid is not in any doubt."
What is a technically correct shoji. Do you have a set of specifications, or do you simply mean you can make one that you will like. Most men like their wives, but they wouldn't get much money for them as runway models in Paris. The place where they use Shoji is in Japan, and if you want to spend time making them with hand tools you should get a standard from that exercise that is commensurate with the effort put in. You will fail if you don't finish to the expected standard, and the western kit of tools does not include several specialized tools designed for making the joints in the technically correct way.
"The work could get done without all of the Eastern Mysticism and incense burning in the background."
Could you kindly indicate where anything I said relied on eastern mysticism, or incense. I said you need to surface the wood to the expected level. That is just an obsevable fact that you can read in the reflection of hand planed pine.
"It's the copping of the whole 'aura' from certain quarters that gets my goat. It would be like me faking a British accent when I was running a Record plane. What a hokie bunch 'o crap that would be don't you think?"
BS, nobody is saying you have to fake it as a Japanese carpenter, I'm saying you have to make it to that standard. I've heard enough of your faking it already. Make the stuff, prepare and use the tools. Commit to something and get good at it, then put in 30 years.