We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Sgian Dubh
Bill, I'm not sure I really understand what's driving you on this. Is it perhaps just an urge to get to grips with the subject for the sake of it, or is there a practical application you're looking for at the end?
In my case I don't find a need to investigate abrasive much.
A sharpening stone will sharpen my plane irons and chisels, and abrasive paper wrapped around a cork block sands the wood. Files cut metal, and rasps tear up wood.
None of it causes me much angst and so far in life the products I can buy off the shelf are effective enough to keep me planing, chiselling and sanding wood as fast as I need to. Other people have done the work required to supply me with abrading tools-- I just buy them and use them as needed. Slainte.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
Mark Hennebury
It can all get very complicated and carried away, but It would seem to me that friction is the main cause of wear on cutting edges. The easiest solution would seem to be design cutting tools with highly polished sharp cutting tips with the lowest rake angles to reduce friction, and to cut into the wood fibres from the direction that requires the least amount of effort, and yields the best result.
Better Tool design, in my opinion seems to be the easiest solution.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
I emailed Bill the other day to apologize for the things I was thinking when he originally brought up the topic of cap irons. I had no idea where he was going with it.
When I emailed him I was in the middle of planing some pretty mild walnut... but with the properly tuned cap iron I was planing against the grain, over crotch grain, etc, and the results were all the same: excellent. So, I'm convinced, as are many others, obviously. The ability to plane without having to pay as much attention to grain direction and figure will enable me to plane more surfaces, instead of relying on sanders, which I'm excited about.
Being able to plane more easily, without having to sharpen as often would be a real game-changer for me.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
Is quantifiable metal loss confirmed by weight (Not that I think that is possible.)? I don't know of any attempts to do this.
or just shape of object.
IE is the blade deformed showing less material or is material really missing? I believe it's inferred by the registration of the camera to a minute mark or recognizable feature on the blade, and overlaying the successive images. Maybe Steve can help here. Kato and Kawai likewise have made photographic registration and measurement, though surely using more expensive gear. On the face of it, then, I suppose you could say, 'well, maybe the steel compressed, since no weight comparisons were made, or spalled-off particles collected'. On the other hand, steel is a crystalline lattice, through and through, and I don't believe density differences have been detected after rolling under great pressure--the rolling just results in elongation, not compression to higher density. However, I'm only reporting what I've read, and don't know any more than you, and could easily know less.
If it is missing where did it go? Dunno.
Did metal particles get found in the planing/chiseling? Dunno.
Wiley
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
"As much as wear is an interesting subject, and one that has a nice scientific character, what are the real chancs of getting enough out of it to get an answer, then find a steel, then get some sufficient results to topple current preferences."
My assessment is slim, which is why the topic was never of great interest. But, I had some time in the library, there was the book, so I seized the opportunity to learn a bit about the topic. There are so many variables that affect abrasive wear and the special case of abrasive-oxidative wear ( a possibility for cutting edges) that doing anything useful with the information in woodworking seems remote.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
So Bill, is the adhesive mechanism that something first bonds to the edge, and that thing has higher tensile strength, so it then pulls some part of the edge off? And some plastics are strong enough to do that to steel?........The examples in the book where there is adhesive wear between a metal and a polymer the metal pulls polymer from the bulk polymer and transfers either a layer (teflon) or particles to the metal. Wood is a composite of three polymers- cellulose, hemicellulose and lignin. So the wood situation would not appear to be any different than the other polymers studied.
By the way, isn't adhesion the non-chemical stickiness? well....... there is mingling but maybe not chemical bonds like what hold teflon together. So you would in many cases not only not have something with the tensile strength to pull away steel, but also the bond would not be strong enough, most materials aren't higher tensile strength than steel......correct
The form of adhesive dulling I most often see is deposition related. A cutting tool looses it's edge when crud builds up, virtually welding itself to the edge. This is common with machine tools, but it isn't abrasive. So it isn't what you are looking for. ....this is an excellent example of adhesive wear. A judgement rendered by a 3 hour "expert" in the field!
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
In each profile test (that is, when I was looking for how the shape of the worn edge changed) the blade was held in a jig under the microscope to keep it at exactly the same angle. The images were then "stacked" in Photoshop and moved one pixel at a time to align the portions of the blade that were not affected by wear. Finally, the profile shape at each stage was extracted using a "find edges" tool in Photoshop.
In other tests I've made a scratch with a carbide scribing tool on the blade near enough to the edge that it would appear in the field of view of the microscope. Afterward I aligned the marks in Photoshop or made measurements from the scratch to the worn edge.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
James writes Even with diamonds, D2 is an unmitigated beast that doesn't take finest edge
James (or anyone else) - how you determine the "fineness" of an edge? I ask because I use O1, A2 & D2 and find I can get all of them to an equivalent sharpness, which is when pushed against the edge of a piece of paper, it cuts (which seems a better test than arm hair). Is there a better "shop" test (ie that doesn't use microscopes)?
As an aside, I'm not so sure that this level of sharpness is all that useful as it seems to disappear really quickly. Opinions?
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
David writes ..I've read the discussion with some interest, because I can't otherwise explain why my HSS planes last so many multiples longer
I could be blowing smoke but I believe that HHS is more rust/corrosion resistant than O1 which may possibly be a [probably quite small] factor. The more obvious factor is HSS was designed to be more durable in machining applications (as well as tolerating much higher heat, if heat is a factor).
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
Thanks bill, now I know what is being talked about. All new to me, an example of where one has a sorta image in the mind of what must happen to tools, but in reality no idea at all.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
If you run the shaving through a magnetic field, would there be some kind of disturbance in the field that is measurable. Basically a metal detector kind of deal. Sounds like something the TSA would have a lot of hardware for.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanism
TomD
With metal tools there is a lot of info, and stuff you can do. Wouldn't a tool that uses oil to soften the wood, lubricate the tool, and to flow out the finish be cool. Patent applied for.
My thing about the adhesive deal so far, is that as it has been described so far, it isn't wear so much as deposition. LV and many others have done microphotography of edges and they are worn not rounded over due to deposition. I'm not saying it doesn't happen, just not feeling it yet.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
Take a card scraper that's been burnished on both sides of one edge. Hold it at 90º so that no edge makes contact and rub it on wood. You can rub all day and not generate much heat. Take a shaving and things get hot quickly.
That's because of visco-elastic compression ahead of the cutting edge. Heat is a major factor in visco-elastic compression. Metal, wood, and a lot of other solids react this way.
You can vary the amount of heat from visco-elastic compression by causing less wood deflection. That's one of the things missing in the Kato study, they ignore heat creation and opt for maximum deflection. I don't have to read books or articles about this, the more heat one generates through deflection and visco-elastic compression the shorter the edge life. It's not a straight line curve if graphed. A lot of experience tells me that changing from a 55º cutting angle to 60º generates more heat and a lot shorter edge life than when going from 50º to 55º.
I don't see where introducing more fiber deflection than necessary gains anything but you can lose a lot of edge life.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
"You can vary the amount of heat from visco-elastic compression by causing less wood deflection. That's one of the things missing in the Kato study, they ignore heat creation and opt for maximum deflection. I don't have to read books or articles about this, the more heat one generates through deflection and visco-elastic compression the shorter the edge life. It's not a straight line curve if graphed. A lot of experience tells me that changing from a 55º cutting angle to 60º generates more heat and a lot shorter edge life than when going from 50º to 55º.
I don't see where introducing more fiber deflection than necessary gains anything but you can lose a lot of edge life. "
Your theory isn't supported by the data from the translated Kato paper as you can find on Steve Elliott's page now. The Japanese meassured the force while planing with different capiron setups. The horizontal force is a good meassure for the wear at the edge.
We see that a capiron configuration with more deflection of the shaving (the open triangles, boxes, circles ) start at a higher point on the y-axis. That's logical because deflecting the shaving needs some power input of the user. But after that, all the curves run more or less parallel, which means they wear all at the same rate, independend of the amount of shaving deflection. I would even say in the configuration without capiron at all (the line with little x), the wear is even a bit more then all the capiron configurations.
If you would make a similar graph for different pitches ( say 40 -45 -50 -55 -60 degrees), I suspect the lines would diverge a lot more. Difficult to prove that theory of mine, because I don't have a planing machine with force sensors.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
As Kato and Kawai demonstrated factors that increase shaving pressure promote wear in the high pressure areas. One does not have to conjure different wear mechanisms to explain the different amounts of wear observed at different rake angles relative to the grain orientation. These results can be rationalized by the difference in shaving pressure on the blade tip.
and
pressure creates heat. One only has to hold a card scraper (high rake angle) long enough to experience this.
The question is whether this is relevant, and if so, how does this heat create wear?
just a small correction, pressure is static
what we are dealing with plane blades and scrapers working wood is friction
the action of dragging a cutting edge through wood is resisted by a combination of friction between the cutting edge and the wood and the mechanical interlock of the wood fibres, overcoming these forces results in the generation of heat at the cutting edge.
How much heat will depend on many factors, but it's not unreasonable to surmise that heat on the very tip of the cutting edge softens the edge and allows it to fold over. For a given rake angle and timber, the friction and hence heating should be relatively constant regardless of what steel the blade is made from
In part this surmise would explain the observed improved edge holding ability of HS steel compared to plain carbon steel when planing particularly abrasive timbers
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
Yeah, heat tolerance is probably the biggest day to day change.
But it's uncanny when you get something cocobolo that is really bad in terms of silica content, it can dull a carbon steel plane in 10 strokes. I can get 100 or more out of an HSS planes.
But what those numbers look like with something like cherry, is probably more like a factor of two to three, and vs. A2 in cherry, maybe a factor of 2 or a little less.
But in cocobolo that is really nasty with silica, A2 and HCS are hard to use.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
Kato and kawai used a rake angle of 40 degrees, 5 degrees lower than our common planes. Friction, compression or whatever going on at the cap iron is not going to affect edge life for the tip of the blade is remote from where this work is occurring.
The objective of Kato and Kawai's work (as reported in the papers not the video) was to investigate edge life. You will find a trove of data in the paper we have translated.
Some of the work on coated blades is in English. I can send these papers if you wish.
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
I've used O1, A2, M2, W1 (Lie-Nielsen pre-A2) D2, S53( MUCH worse than D2) old laminated Stanley sweetheart irons...
Slicing paper is better than arm hair, for sure. I used paper towels for a while, too.
I gauge by surface quality at this point. My surfaces typically look clean and almost burnished. Held up to the light, I can see edge issues reflected in the streaks left by the blade in passing. First passes are always clean. And soon the iron will settle into 'working sharp.' This is what I call the state the iron settles into after those virgin swipes. Some steels with coarser grain still cut just fine, but there's a degrade in surface quality. I find that HC/O1/W1 (variations of HC) and old SW irons leave a cleaner surface for longer. And they take a lot less time to re-sharpen, so the working time to sharpening tiLme ratio is a lot higher to maintain that kind of edge quality. Using diamonds, M2 is also really good.
Some woods or grain patterns are simply brutal, and you're not going to get that kind of experience. So, D2, A2, etc, feel more appropriate, because they'll tolerate the rougher treatment by the wood.
This whole line of obsessiveness has to be tempered by the observation that the surface won't always be immaculate, nor does it need to be. These are just my observations of the performance of certain steels, as evidenced by the results I see in the wood.
As for S53... It's a 2" aftermarket Holtey iron, mounted in my L-N 50 degree #4. When I get to the point where I can sharpen it reliably, I'll let you know if it was worth it. I think I'm gonna have to abandon hand-sharpening on that one. Ye gads...
Re: Revisiting various abrasion(dulling) mechanisms
The biggest factor in tip dulling is the effort required to cut. Using the same piece of wood; Easier to cut, the tip will last longer, harder to cut tip dull sooner.
This effort is determined by rake angle, skew angle and the approach to the wood fibres.
Whatever the combination of things that actually remove the metal from the tip weather it is abrasion, adhesion, visco-elastic compression or Zombies makes no difference to me.
Tool edge life can be best extended by efficient tool design and the best wood fibre approach.
Highest rake angles and cutting against the grain: requires the most effort, distresses the wood fibres and dulls the blade quickest.
Lowest rake angles cutting with the grain: requires less effort, gives better surface quality and dulls the tool less.
Lowest rake angles with a high skew, cutting with the grain requires the least amount of effort, gives the best surface and dulls the tool the least.
The most important to understand from a practical standpoint is simple tool geometry and cutting approach to the wood fibres.
If you made two very fine chisel tips out of glass and used one as a scraper and a the other as a paring chisel
I would expect the scraper would dull the fastest, and I would attribute that to higher friction at the tip, and lack of structural support of the tip due to the high rake angle.
A high rake angle and fine tip offers very little support to the tip material, as the force is perpendicular to the blade.
A low rake angle offers more support as the tip material is fully backed up by the bulk of the blade. As the force is inline with the blade and pushing into the blade.
The only thing that I am concerned with in all of my tools is that that are designed to be the most efficient: to give the best finish with the least amount of effort, and there are big gains to be had with better tool geometry.
Take a card scraper that's been burnished on both sides of one edge. Hold it at 90º so that no edge makes contact and rub it on wood. You can rub all day and not generate much heat. Take a shaving and things get hot quickly.
Rubbing metal against wood creates a lot of heat, try running table saw with no side relief on the teeth. Not cutting anything, just rubbing but will fill your shop with smoke in no time at all and can even catch fire.